Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Dogs… To think it doesn’t matter whether it’s a legal breed or not?!

633 replies

MsWalterMitty · 24/03/2022 19:44

Just read about the recent child death in St Helen’s. It’s so awful!

The breed of dog has been released and it turns out it’s not an illegal breed. It’s called an American Bully XL, never heard of it so I googled it, even though I had an idea what it might look like due to its name.

Surely, whether it’s legal or not, this dog seems like a really stupid choice for a family!

OP posts:
Thread gallery
13
freedaym · 25/03/2022 08:43

Bill breeds can be lovely. My uncle had a Rottweiler that was a dote. However you never trust an animal 100% particularly around dc & far too many people do not have the experience for dogs.

Thesearmsofmine · 25/03/2022 08:42

That poor baby. It may be awful to say it but the parents are at fault here, they brought this huge powerful, unknown dog into their home with their baby and another young child, they made that stupid choice. I have no doubt they are devastated at their loss but that doesn’t excuse their stupidity.

tabulahrasa · 25/03/2022 08:41

[quote BananaPlants]@tabulahrasa - All dogs can bite, but there is a difference between a non fatal bite from a dog that is resource guarding and an attack where an animal has a strong kill instinct and mauls and shakes a baby to death. That’s not really retriever territory is it?[/quote]
There’s a golden retriever lab mix who killed a child in the US about 10 years ago, I won’t link to it because all the articles are pretty graphic tbh.

Like I said there are absolutely breeds that are not suited to the average pet owner.

But I strongly believe that blaming breed does nothing useful, it creates the fallacy that some breeds are safe and really we should be changing the laws round breeding and ownership.

Gowithme · 25/03/2022 08:41

You can tell people are grasping at straws when they have to pull out a one off case in South Africa as evidence that it's not breed that matters! The child that was killed by the lab (which apparently somehow didn't look like a lab) happened in South Africa FGS.

Now look at the list of killings by dogs in this country and say breed is irrelevant! Bull breeds should be phased out IMO, they can be lovely but when they're not they're deadly and the risk is just too great.
en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_fatal_dog_attacks_in_the_United_Kingdom

user3837313202 · 25/03/2022 08:41

I once spent 3 days as a house guest with a golden retriever that barked at me every time I moved. I'm pretty dog savvy but even I was uncomfortable. The dog has since accepted my existence as the next time I saw her I turned up with a load of high value treats and gave them to her basically I bought her acceptance with dried liver

The same dog however, is great with their 3 year old. Difference is of course that I was seen as an outsider.

Old DDog was attacked on two separate occasions by labradors - on one occasion he needed a lot of stitches on his head. Somewhat to our surprise he retained his sunny disposition.

There's dodgy dogs of every breed tbh. Fatal injuries are the easiest to find statistics on (well, a Wikipedia page) but it's not the only thing that should be considered.

Dachshunds are sometimes reported to be the number 1 breed most likely to bite. Yet I've seen multiple parents actively encourage their child to go and touch dachshunds without even asking the owner first - which is rule number one! My dog prefers not to be touched by people outside his family. It's not like he's going to leap for your jugular if you do touch him, but he just doesn't want to be stroked and will move away. In much the same way, I'll allow my DP to touch me in ways I'd never allow the general public to... and yet I've had lots of people just reach out and start touching my dog without asking either me or him.

Franklin12 · 25/03/2022 08:40

So what are we saying? Ban big dogs, labs unless they are service dogs?

This family have paid the ultimate price and I strongly suspect the man was thinking he was a big tough guy and needed a dog that matched his view of himself. He wanted to show off to his friends.

Where the women was in all of this decision making is another issue but buying a dog like this for buttons and bringing it into the home where there was a young child is completely reckless and stupid.

I have a big dog. Lab who I trust but I dont have young children and do I trust it 100% not to growl or bite if a child gets rough or teases? Nope...

oakleaffy · 25/03/2022 08:38

Sadly there is so much ignorance in dog ownership .
People getting dogs that are grossly unsuitable for them, and people who have zero control.

With a license , It’s likely only the responsible will buy one.

Lessons are never to be learned.
More children will be mauled.

freedaym · 25/03/2022 08:38

I've been bitten by a yorkie as a kid. Getting chased by a pit bull was far scarier!

Nobodycarestakeitelsewhere · 25/03/2022 08:38

It's mad that people will accept a prized border collie has been bred for generations to herd sheep and that genetics are essential to that, but when it comes to dogs that have been bred specifically to fight, it's all "deed not breed" and suddenly genetics don't matter one bit. It's a coincidence that these dogs are killing children and you're just prejudiced if you question whether they make great family pets.

Cheeserton · 25/03/2022 08:37

Cue loads of people arriving to pretend that bull-type breeds aren't grossly over represented in such incidents...

Matleave2022 · 25/03/2022 08:37

the family in question
(typo self spotted)

Matleave2022 · 25/03/2022 08:35

I would go further than criticising private rehoming, and say that I can't understand why anyone would hold onto or acquire any kind of dog (even a good temperament breed from a licensed breeder) if they have a baby or toddler at home. It might be ok if family in question has the space at home to always keep the dog separate from the baby, but that's not true of most homes in the UK.

Supposedly cute videos of small children cuddling up to pet dogs make me wince, as it could go so horribly wrong in an instant.

toomanytwinkies · 25/03/2022 08:33

@BananaPlants finally someone making sense

tabulahrasa · 25/03/2022 08:33

“There are dangerous dog lists for a reason.”

Um, that reason is the media...

The dangerous dogs act and the banned breeds were rushed through after a particularly high profile case - those breeds have now been banned for 30 years and yet dog attacks go up all the time, not down.

What would work much more effectively would be legislation about responsible breeding and ownership, but that didn’t make fir great headlines in the way devil dogs does... so...

BananaPlants · 25/03/2022 08:31

@tabulahrasa - All dogs can bite, but there is a difference between a non fatal bite from a dog that is resource guarding and an attack where an animal has a strong kill instinct and mauls and shakes a baby to death. That’s not really retriever territory is it?

toomanytwinkies · 25/03/2022 08:29

Statistically I’d imagine a golden retriever tbh, there are a lot more of them.

Yes statistically but that’s not the case. Out of 100 fatal dog cases there won’t be more goldens than other dangerous dogs. So what does that tell you?

There are dangerous dog lists for a reason.

KimWexlersPonyTail · 25/03/2022 08:28

Switzerland I beleive has compulsory ownership courses. I suspect there would be uproar if it was suggested in U.K

toomanytwinkies · 25/03/2022 08:27

I mean there’s be no point having a dangerous dogs list or a list pet insurers won’t insure if breeds didn’t matter. Yes a badly treated dog is more likely to lash out regardless of breeds but lets not pretend a dachshund and an akita are the same.

tabulahrasa · 25/03/2022 08:25

“I mean sure but what’s more likely to bite, an akita or a golden retriever.”

Statistically I’d imagine a golden retriever tbh, there are a lot more of them.

There’s also a resource guarding issue in lots of lines of golden retrievers, that’s a very tricky problem to deal with and leads to lots of bites.

There are absolutely breeds that are less suited to the average pet owner than others, but there also aren’t “safe” dog breeds.

tabulahrasa · 25/03/2022 08:21

“Why is everyone on this thread talking about breed and not about how they acquired this dog?”

Exactly.

Strictlyfanoftenyears · 25/03/2022 08:20

You only have to read the breeds website to see the problem, they say they make great family pets but reccommend that you use a pronged collar for them.....ffs

toomanytwinkies · 25/03/2022 08:19

@tabulahrasa

“But breed is significant.”

Not when it comes to fatal attacks it’s just not - breed comes way way down the common factors in studies.

Akitas are definitely a tricky breed and one of the few I’d never own, but they’re no more likely to kill someone.

I mean sure but what’s more likely to bite, an akita or a golden retriever.
CounsellorTroi · 25/03/2022 08:18

@Dammitthisisshit

I also think people should have a licence to own a dog and that should involve passing an educational course too.

Yes.
So much poor dog behaviour in general around (before anyone jumps on this I’m not saying all dogs, but far too many dogs) that would be helped by this.

A license to own a dog that you can only get if you’ve done an ownership course. A registration for the dog that is linked to the license and issued once the dog has been through training classes. Registration records DNA.
Anyone mistreating a dog is never allowed a license again.
Only registered breeders or experienced rescue centres allowed to sell dogs (ie no puppy farms).
Any dangerous dog behaviour or repeated antisocial behaviour (like allowing dogs to chase birds on our local ‘dogs on leads only’ nature reserve) loses a license holders right to get any new dogs, or existing dog(s) re-homed/ put down depending on severity.
No high risk breeds allowed: because the same breeds pop up time and time again.
Paid for by fines on any dog poo left lying around which could be DNA tested as it’s all registered.

Why don’t we have this?

I agree with all of this in principle. The reason we don’t have it is cost. Who would administer and enforce it? The police certainly do not have the manpower.
Indoctro · 25/03/2022 08:17

[quote abeanbaked]@Indoctro but labradors aren't bred to bite and kill. That is an issue with how the dog has been raised, potentially in the breeding if it has been dodgy but it is not really in their nature to attack. I have a retriever and her innate instinct is not to kill. When she does come upon a live animal she is unsure how to handle it as she it is in her genes to retrieve shot game with a very soft mouth or flush birds, not handle live game.

She is happy, I can assure you. We do lots of retrieving, steadiness, heel work etc. Infact the full litter went to pet homes, all of which have gotten on fine. The issues that most lab/spaniel/retriever issues will have is harnessing their dogs desire to hunt, this is usually with their noses and flushing out birds or deer, not hunting and attacking humans. Very few will be responsible for fatally injuring children in comparison to XL bull-type dogs.

The issue is a mix of uncontrollably strong dog which is bred for size, strength and its ability to lock on to things and the kind of people that buy them. Sorry, but I really do think it's the breed and the people. [/quote]
I'm fearful of Labs , as twice recently my on the lead staffy has be attacked by off the lead labs and it was horrific. I think a Lab that's worked is a happy well rounded dog, a lab stuck living in a family home with two walks a day and no brain training scare me especially as the owners automatically assume it will be great with kids.

Plus my kids have been growled at by a friends Lab, which I know is good as at least the dog warned them, all they did was walk past.

That said I don't allow my kids to go up to any strange dogs , and I never allow kids to play with my dog when visiting my home, he gets locked away. No one should let there dogs around other peoples kids.

GreenTeaMom · 25/03/2022 08:16

I agree - a lot of people get these ‘status’ dogs that look scary and tough with children in the house - and this unfortunately in a lot of cases is the end result! I know someone that has 2 big staff mixed dogs that tower over their small child and built of muscle - and they video themselves regularly encouraging the dogs to battle over food etc - the safety of their child often plays on my mind because if them 2 dogs ever turned on her there is no way the parents would ever get them off. Beyond stupid and there should be tighter laws on protecting children with animals in the house!

Swipe left for the next trending thread