Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Dogs… To think it doesn’t matter whether it’s a legal breed or not?!

633 replies

MsWalterMitty · 24/03/2022 19:44

Just read about the recent child death in St Helen’s. It’s so awful!

The breed of dog has been released and it turns out it’s not an illegal breed. It’s called an American Bully XL, never heard of it so I googled it, even though I had an idea what it might look like due to its name.

Surely, whether it’s legal or not, this dog seems like a really stupid choice for a family!

OP posts:
Thread gallery
13
Franklin12 · 25/03/2022 09:11

I agree with akitas and huskies. Beautiful but need a specialist to manage them not some big I am man!

I love German Shepherds but they often seem to be one man (or women) dogs. Private and keep themselves to themselves, not really interested in having a good romp around the fields. I hate the way they have been bred with the sloping backs.

I always always ask whether I can say hello to a strange dog. A chap yesterday had a border collie puppy he was holding to get him used to the big wide world outside the supermarket. The dog was absolutely adorable. Seemed very calm and collected as he was in the 'bosses' arms. I suspect that dog will adore this man and tolerated others.

Everyone - always ask whether your dog likes to be touched. I do like those leads that state what personality the dog has. Really helps.

tabulahrasa · 25/03/2022 09:10

“So police shoot the dogs which is what generally happens & seize any others. Often putting down others if they are on the list. And yet all of this is done with no knowledge of what breeds they have actually shot & when they record X death caused by Malamute or Jack Russell cross it's just guesswork?”

Yes

Unless someone’s going, this is a purebred whatever and here’s the paperwork then it’s just based on what they look like.

There isn’t really any accurate way of determining what breed a dog is other than that anyway.

There have been cases of “pitbulls” seized and put to sleep where there was in fact proof they were a different breed or cross - but they measured as pitbulls so that’s that.

toomanytwinkies · 25/03/2022 09:10

Because people expect dog owners to muzzle dogs that are likely to bite. Parents can be very irresponsible but so can dog owners.

I agree but just because a fig owner is being irresponsible doesn’t mean an adult should be too.

It’s hard with Akitas as they look like chunky huskies but I wouldn’t expect a parent to let their child stick their hand around any unknown dog tbh.

freedaym · 25/03/2022 09:09

I love huskies but no way can I have one with my lifestyle. Would adore an Irish wolfhound etc but again not practical. I'm desperate for any dog tbh but at the moment I don't have the capacity for one.

BobbinHood · 25/03/2022 09:08

Yet if my dog snapped, it would be my fault.

Yes, it would be. That’s how it works. You may find it unfair, but if you aren’t prepared for that then you have the option to not have a dog, or to not take your dog places where there will be children. There will always be people who don’t look after their children properly/teach them to interact with dogs properly, it’s shit but you just have to be prepared for it. I keep my DD away from all dogs we don’t know (and half of those we do, tbh) and get accused of teaching my child to fear dogs, by dog owners, so parents can’t win either.

AndAsIfByMagic · 25/03/2022 09:08

@toomanytwinkies

I saw a Japanese Akita at a country fair once and too many children were wanting to stroke it thinking it was a husky, that is not a breed you want your child sticking it’s little hand by, why do parents let their children do this?
Because people expect dog owners to muzzle dogs that are likely to bite. Parents can be very irresponsible but so can dog owners.

And children's safety matters more.

JuvenileGreyFox · 25/03/2022 09:07

Agree with previous posters that a large part of the problem is also people buying breeds that are completely unsuitable for their family and lifestyle. Someone I know, who has mobility problems and difficulty walking has just bought a husky puppy. A dog that needs hours and hours of daily exercise. Because they love the breed.

toomanytwinkies · 25/03/2022 09:07

@JuvenileGreyFox

To me it is not about breeds, it is not really about 'dogs'. In my experience there is a fundamental lack of education/awareness of how humans should interact with dogs, especially children.

How would you react if a stranger, three to four times your size walked directly over to you, uninvited, and reached your hand towards your head. Wouldn't leave you alone, followed you around, chased you. You would call the police.

The amount of times parents have either encouraged (or not stopped) their children from doing this to my dogs.

A lot of dogs, especially if they haven't been brought up around children, are afraid of children. Children are unpredictable.

Yet time and time again, parents allow children to interact with dogs unsupervised. Chase them, reach out to them, crowd them, invade their space. It is no wonder these accidents keep happening.

I have dogs, neither of which have ever shown aggression towards humans. I never allow them to be unsupervised around children. We can be out and children will run over and parents make half hearted, don't annoy the dogs. Yet if my dog snapped, it would be my fault.

I saw a video on YT of a baby pulling at a dogs ear and tail and the parents laughing and filming and I thought there’s an accident waiting to happen.
Crazycatlady83 · 25/03/2022 09:06

Clearly we are a nation of dog lovers and ownership has exploded over lockdown. This creates a lot of people owning dogs who actually you probably wouldn't trust to look after a fillet of fish. But it also creates lots of voters who think their dog has broken the stereotype, is the kindest, gentlest dog in the world who would never do anything so terrible as hurt a person, let alone a child. The government don't want to piss off their voters by coming up with a more robust way of managing "types" of dangerous dogs. Restricting ownership merely to "banned breeds" allows them look like they are doing something, whilst doing nothing. We need legislation because clearly the current law isn't working.

Also, lots of people say their children know how to behave around their animals. But what about people you invite into your home, what about when you go out? All unpredictable times when dogs can and do, serious damage. The bigger the dogs, the stronger the owner will have to be to stop an attack. Looking at these big muscular breeds, some just wouldn't stand a chance.

Posters searching the world desperately trying to find Labs or Collies that have gone rogue and killed really aren't helping. Sadly it's about risk. As a society can we can manage a incident where one dog kills someone (absolutely tragic as that would be) once every 10 years? At the moment it feels like we are having these incidents once every week.

These parents are clearly going through hell right now. But unless we talk about this, now, it will keep happening and more children will die. Clearly some people are incapable of responsible dog ownership and this is the time when government have to step in and take that responsibility away from people to protect them, their family and society generally.

freedaym · 25/03/2022 09:06

Pretty much, yes.

So police shoot the dogs which is what generally happens & seize any others. Often putting down others if they are on the list. And yet all of this is done with no knowledge of what breeds they have actually shot & when they record X death caused by Malamute or Jack Russell cross it's just guesswork?

tabulahrasa · 25/03/2022 09:06

@JuvenileGreyFox

The only reason I am cautious around Staffies is that they have lock jaws so can cause horrendous injuries very quickly. I have met so many gorgeous Staffies with beautiful temperaments so I can totally see why people love the breed.
Their jaws don’t work any differently from any other dog, they’re just strong for their size.
JuvenileGreyFox · 25/03/2022 09:03

The only reason I am cautious around Staffies is that they have lock jaws so can cause horrendous injuries very quickly. I have met so many gorgeous Staffies with beautiful temperaments so I can totally see why people love the breed.

MyDogTails · 25/03/2022 09:00

Dogs I actively avoid in park: akitas and huskies, the latter until the owner says is fine/not fine. We don’t get bull breeds much around here. I don’t get the “deed not breed” argument.

There are quite a few German shepherds but they’re lovely dogs generally. There are companies that train them as guard dogs/family pets and generally they are no trouble although so strong that they’re owners can’t always hold them back, but super well trained and are usually 18 months or older.

tabulahrasa · 25/03/2022 08:58

“So the identified breeds are based on people's made up assumptions?”

Pretty much, yes.

Pitbulls (in this country) American bulldogs and xl bullies are basically a certain shape of mongrel.

Staffies are rarely staffies, bearing in mind actual staffies are often smaller than a cocker spaniel.

Velvian · 25/03/2022 08:54

'macho' men are drawn to specific breeds. The thugs themselves are the main problem, a very real secondary problem is the strength, weight and jaw strength specicific to the breeds dis reputable breeders and owners choose.

JuvenileGreyFox · 25/03/2022 08:53

To me it is not about breeds, it is not really about 'dogs'. In my experience there is a fundamental lack of education/awareness of how humans should interact with dogs, especially children.

How would you react if a stranger, three to four times your size walked directly over to you, uninvited, and reached your hand towards your head. Wouldn't leave you alone, followed you around, chased you. You would call the police.

The amount of times parents have either encouraged (or not stopped) their children from doing this to my dogs.

A lot of dogs, especially if they haven't been brought up around children, are afraid of children. Children are unpredictable.

Yet time and time again, parents allow children to interact with dogs unsupervised. Chase them, reach out to them, crowd them, invade their space. It is no wonder these accidents keep happening.

I have dogs, neither of which have ever shown aggression towards humans. I never allow them to be unsupervised around children. We can be out and children will run over and parents make half hearted, don't annoy the dogs. Yet if my dog snapped, it would be my fault.

freedaym · 25/03/2022 08:53

Because they’re the most common type of dog and because they’re usually not pedigree dogs, it’s people afterwards going... yeah looks like one of those.

So the identified breeds are based on people's made up assumptions? 😆

tabulahrasa · 25/03/2022 08:53

@Nobodycarestakeitelsewhere

It always interests me when people say BSL doesn't work. How many attacks have been prevented due to removing potentially dangerous dogs from society?
You’d never know that, but...

People who were planning to breed or own those breeds won’t have just gone, hmm, those dogs are real hard to get hold of now, think I’ll not bother having a dog.

But mostly if it had worked dog attacks would have gone down, not up.

toomanytwinkies · 25/03/2022 08:52

Genes load the gun. The environment only pulls the trigger. Labs etc come with rubber bullets and safety catches. Fighting breeds are armour piercing rounds with hair triggers. The might not fire, but they kill if they do. All dogs can be dangerous, but big powerful, fighting dogs are the most dangerous, most often. Having one at all is quite a responsibility, but having one around a child is an unacceptable risk snd should absolutely have to consequences to stop other people taking the same risks. It’s what we do with any other child neglect, to deter other parents from making the same poor parenting decisions. The parents would face charges if the child had been accidentally killed or injured by any other weapon, because weapons shouldn’t be near children.

Very well put

tabulahrasa · 25/03/2022 08:50

“Why do you think UK deaths have weight towards certain breeds?”

Because they’re the most common type of dog and because they’re usually not pedigree dogs, it’s people afterwards going... yeah looks like one of those.

tabulahrasa · 25/03/2022 08:48

@Nobodycarestakeitelsewhere

It's mad that people will accept a prized border collie has been bred for generations to herd sheep and that genetics are essential to that, but when it comes to dogs that have been bred specifically to fight, it's all "deed not breed" and suddenly genetics don't matter one bit. It's a coincidence that these dogs are killing children and you're just prejudiced if you question whether they make great family pets.
They’re bred specifically to fight animals and still be easy to handle by humans, even when injured.

Why would one party of that be relevant if the other isn’t?

But mostly - you don’t get behavioural traits passed on by just looking a certain way, which is how breed is usually assessed after an attack.

Nobodycarestakeitelsewhere · 25/03/2022 08:47

It always interests me when people say BSL doesn't work. How many attacks have been prevented due to removing potentially dangerous dogs from society?

MyDogTails · 25/03/2022 08:46

@Uttoxerley

“Eeksteek

It IS the breed. Labs and spaniels are bred to like being with people, to listen, to have weak mouths, to enjoy touch. Hundreds of generations of the survival of the soppiest! Fighting breeds were bred to react with aggression, to attack in a frenzy, to be wound up, to hold on with a crushing bite. If a lab snaps (generally out of fear and anxiety because it’s been poorly raised or it’s needs are not met) it snaps, and then runs away to safety, or can be pulled off. It will let go if hurt. It snaps in its own defence, because it doesn’t have hundreds of generations of being bred to strengthen its desire and ability to fight and attack. Fighting breeds have a much higher chance of reacting like this, and a much higher risk of causing terrible injuries if they do. It’s not their fault, and good training and a healthy environment can certainly produce good individual dogs. But that isn’t the same as saying they don’t a higher risk of killing or maiming as a breed.

Genes load the gun. The environment only pulls the trigger. Labs etc come with rubber bullets and safety catches. Fighting breeds are armour piercing rounds with hair triggers. The might not fire, but they kill if they do. All dogs can be dangerous, but big powerful, fighting dogs are the most dangerous, most often. Having one at all is quite a responsibility, but having one around a child is an unacceptable risk snd should absolutely have to consequences to stop other people taking the same risks. It’s what we do with any other child neglect, to deter other parents from making the same poor parenting decisions. The parents would face charges if the child had been accidentally killed or injured by any other weapon, because weapons shouldn’t be near children.”

Wholeheartedly agree with this. The “deed not breed” argument dangerously minimises the issue.

Very articulate post, especially the second paragraph with the loaded gun analogy.
freedaym · 25/03/2022 08:46

There’s a golden retriever lab mix who killed a child in the US about 10 years ago, I won’t link to it because all the articles are pretty graphic tbh.

Why do you think UK deaths have weight towards certain breeds?

oakleaffy · 25/03/2022 08:43

@Nobodycarestakeitelsewhere

It's mad that people will accept a prized border collie has been bred for generations to herd sheep and that genetics are essential to that, but when it comes to dogs that have been bred specifically to fight, it's all "deed not breed" and suddenly genetics don't matter one bit. It's a coincidence that these dogs are killing children and you're just prejudiced if you question whether they make great family pets.
Same with Lure Coursing Whippets That genetic drive to chase is evident from a few weeks old.

A series on police dog training on YT showed puppies specially bred being assessed for “Front tooth grip” and calm confidence.
The assessor said of one that failed that it was not to be expected “Of this breeding” ( pup was nervous )
Clearly DNA has a huge input in basic drives.

Swipe left for the next trending thread