Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Dogs… To think it doesn’t matter whether it’s a legal breed or not?!

633 replies

MsWalterMitty · 24/03/2022 19:44

Just read about the recent child death in St Helen’s. It’s so awful!

The breed of dog has been released and it turns out it’s not an illegal breed. It’s called an American Bully XL, never heard of it so I googled it, even though I had an idea what it might look like due to its name.

Surely, whether it’s legal or not, this dog seems like a really stupid choice for a family!

OP posts:
Thread gallery
13
tabulahrasa · 25/03/2022 09:55

“For me it's all 3, I would much rather a fight with a Bichon than a pit bull 🤷🏻‍♀️“

But if breeders didn’t breed badly and owners were responsible - you wouldn’t have to fight either.

If we banned every breed but bichons I bet you someone would manage to breed killer ones.

Weekendtobegin · 25/03/2022 09:53

Yanbu, it doesn't matter at all if it a banned breed.

The parents should be prosecuted. It was a terrible, irresponsible and neglectful thing to bring a strong powerful and unknown dog into their home around their small defenceless children.

Any dog can bite, but with a dog like this one you might as well climb into a lions den for all the chance you'd have against it if it turns on you.

They didn't want it as a loving family pet they wanted it to breed and for status, as with a lot of owners of these type of dogs.

Sick of reading claptrap on here about not blaming the dogs, not all dog owners bla bla. Take some fucking responsibility. There is no excuse whatsoever to bring a potentially dangerous animal into your home around your children.

I grew up with lots of pets including large dogs the fact is it's way too easy for any idiot to squire a dog and children are paying the price.

freedaym · 25/03/2022 09:51

So if you believe breed matters more than what breeders or owners do because some breeds are inherently going to behave more dangerously it should matter hugely what’s actually in those dogs.

For me it's all 3, I would much rather a fight with a Bichon than a pit bull 🤷🏻‍♀️

tabulahrasa · 25/03/2022 09:48

“Well quite. Nobody is mixing up pitbulls and poodles, are they?!”

Lol

But cross a lab, pointer or Dalmatian for example with anything with a broad head and people will misidentify it as a pitbull or staffie.

With the types of dog that are most commonly identified they are by definition mixed breeds in this country.

It just doesn’t even make sense to insist that breed is the issue when it isn’t one breed, but a mix.

What would absolutely work on lowering dog attacks would be controls over breeding dogs and owning dogs, of any breed.

JuvenileGreyFox · 25/03/2022 09:45

It is also a massive red flag when you see these types of breeds being 'sold' as adults. There is a reason.

SlashBeef · 25/03/2022 09:43

Cannot understand why anyone would want one of the horrible looking things. Well I can actually, it's so they can look intimidating. I cross the road when I see one. Wouldn't let my kids anywhere near them.

MotherIveys · 25/03/2022 09:39

Owning a dog is a privilege, not a right and because of the minority that should not be allowed to own a goldfish let alone a dog, decent dog owners will be the ones that pay the price with shoddy legislation that won't make any difference.

it's clear something needs to be done but it does sadden me that because of 'the few', the same type of 'few', over and over again, decent responsible owners will be the ones to pay the price, not the idiots who don't care for law and responsibility anyway.

There is no place in society for these types of dogs (or people IMO) but currently breeding and selling these monsters is lucrative. Selling for thousands and thousands of pounds and they're generally being passed between the type of people already engaged in illegal or dodgy activity. They've become big, business and they're not shy about it. To open your eyes, take a look at the Facebook groups for these XL Bullies, bred down from and still bred to pit bulls. I recently heard of a £5000 stud fee. These not are not recognised by any registration body and pedigree dog prices don't even come close to people are charging for these things.

I'm utterly fed up of hearing breed not deed because more likely than not, if a child is killed, it is by this type of dog. Bull breeds, any dogs that have been bred to fight are wired differently, stop suggesting otherwise. Yes any dog can have temperament issues but anyone who has real dog experience knows full well what I mean by 'the head going'. Bull is often put into lurchers too, to make them harder and more effective killers.

Sadly I think the time has come to some severe restriction on dog ownership , a blanket ban on breeding of many more breeds of dogs and perhaps even the type of home you allowed to own a dog. This would affect me (we have a Rottweiler) and most of my responsible friends, including my best friend, but something needs to be done.

Walkingalot · 25/03/2022 09:35

I just showed a pic of the dog to my teenage DS and told him the story. His first response - why didn't they have a muzzle on it, it's not like they know the dog.

Nobodycarestakeitelsewhere · 25/03/2022 09:35

The recent case has identified an American Bully, I can't see the culprit actually being a Bichon Frisé mix but wrongly labelled.

Well quite. Nobody is mixing up pitbulls and poodles, are they?!

Lou98 · 25/03/2022 09:33

This thread is in extremely bad taste - those parents, right or wrong, have just lost their child.

Perhaps try having a little bit of respect, regardless of what you think of them, I'm sure they're blaming themselves enough.

tabulahrasa · 25/03/2022 09:32

“But I think it's disingenuous to say that the generally breeds are wrongly identified. The recent case has identified an American Bully, I can't see the culprit actually being a Bichon Frisé mix but wrongly labelled.”

Well no, I doubt it’s a bichon frise, lol.I don’t think anyone involved would make that big a mistake.

But... my point is, that determining breed in what is by definition a mix breed dog is always basically a bit of guesswork.

But American bullies, pitbulls, “breeds” like that are in this country a mix of a lot of different breeds to get that particular look - some of those breeds in the mix will be breeds people don’t consider dangerous.

So if you believe breed matters more than what breeders or owners do because some breeds are inherently going to behave more dangerously it should matter hugely what’s actually in those dogs.

Pazuzu · 25/03/2022 09:31

@Eeksteek

It IS the breed. Labs and spaniels are bred to like being with people, to listen, to have weak mouths, to enjoy touch. Hundreds of generations of the survival of the soppiest! Fighting breeds were bred to react with aggression, to attack in a frenzy, to be wound up, to hold on with a crushing bite. If a lab snaps (generally out of fear and anxiety because it’s been poorly raised or it’s needs are not met) it snaps, and then runs away to safety, or can be pulled off. It will let go if hurt. It snaps in its own defence, because it doesn’t have hundreds of generations of being bred to strengthen its desire and ability to fight and attack. Fighting breeds have a much higher chance of reacting like this, and a much higher risk of causing terrible injuries if they do. It’s not their fault, and good training and a healthy environment can certainly produce good individual dogs. But that isn’t the same as saying they don’t a higher risk of killing or maiming as a breed.

Genes load the gun. The environment only pulls the trigger. Labs etc come with rubber bullets and safety catches. Fighting breeds are armour piercing rounds with hair triggers. The might not fire, but they kill if they do. All dogs can be dangerous, but big powerful, fighting dogs are the most dangerous, most often. Having one at all is quite a responsibility, but having one around a child is an unacceptable risk snd should absolutely have to consequences to stop other people taking the same risks. It’s what we do with any other child neglect, to deter other parents from making the same poor parenting decisions. The parents would face charges if the child had been accidentally killed or injured by any other weapon, because weapons shouldn’t be near children.

Absolutely spot on. You can't breed these dogs over countless generations and then wring your hands when the breeding kicks in and they do what they're bred to do. You add training and mistreatment into the mix and you're dealing with a weapon.

There is a reason the police use bloody big dogs to bring down people. There is a reason the police use highly excitable dogs to have fun sniffing for things. They are a tool and/or a weapon.

I'm a dog owner of a very small, astonishingly friendly dog, but he's still a dog with a dog's set of reflexes and instincts.

Should owners of any dog that mauls and kills be potentially charged with manslaughter? Absolutely. It's your dog and your responsibility.

Accidents can and always will happen but there is a difference between a genuine accident and someone buying a fighting breed, training it to fight and then wondering why it's gone for a kid.

JuvenileGreyFox · 25/03/2022 09:31

@BobbinHood I am personally against the breeding of dogs. My dogs are mongrel rescues, ex-street dogs. I would never 'buy' a dog.

For me it is an animal welfare issue. So many pedigree dogs have terrible health problems. Humans taking the role of Mother Nature, creating animals with all kinds of physical and temperamental problems.

CounsellorTroi · 25/03/2022 09:29

I love German Shepherds but they often seem to be one man (or women) dogs. Private and keep themselves to themselves, not really interested in having a good romp around the fields. I hate the way they have been bred with the sloping backs.

Knew someone years ago who had a German Shepherd, a police reject. He was an absolute sweetie and loved fuss.

freedaym · 25/03/2022 09:28

I doubt anyone after a fatal attack is particularly trying to prove their dog is a different breed -

My question was specifically talking about fatal attacks though.

freedaym · 25/03/2022 09:26

But the way the law works on pitbulls is that it doesn’t matter what breed they actually are, if they’re reported and fit the description then they’re then pitbulls.

and if you prove otherwise it can be taken into account.

freedaym · 25/03/2022 09:25

It's also been my understanding that professionals also look at the dogs to determine the breed, based on shared characteristics. And of course the owners may have proof of heritage. There will be errors & miscarriages of justice like we get in the human court system. But I think it's disingenuous to say that the generally breeds are wrongly identified. The recent case has identified an American Bully, I can't see the culprit actually being a Bichon Frisé mix but wrongly labelled.

BobbinHood · 25/03/2022 09:24

[quote JuvenileGreyFox]@BobbinHood I agree with you to a certain extent but there has to be an accepting of responsibility on both sides (and I acknowledge that you do this by keeping your child away from dogs)

I love the phrase 'It is easier to put on slippers than carpet the whole world'. Risks exist. Humans have to co-exist with other species. The solution is not to get rid of the other species, they have as much right to exist as you do.[/quote]
There does have to be some acceptance of responsibility on the part of some parents (like ones who bring unknown adult dogs into their homes with toddlers!) but ultimately children’s safety is more important and should be the priority. Dogs have a right to exist but do humans have a right to own and breed them?

LuluBlakey1 · 25/03/2022 09:24

The problem isn't the dog- it's the parents. No parent in their right mind would buy a dog like that with a small child in the house.

abeanbaked · 25/03/2022 09:23

Lots of people who wouldn't have thought about getting a dog 20 years ago, now have dogs. Mainly because dogs have become massively popular and because there are SO many different breeds and traits. But that's an issue when the human gets a dog they cannot physically or verbally control. I worked with someone who had a young family and their partner insisted they get this giant breed dog, big in height but also very very muscular. I had our puppy at the same time and she was constantly asking about toilet training, how it had outgrown the crate, was destructive and too big for the house, how it only listened to her partner and how much it was to insure etc.

I couldn't believe that they hadn't considered these things before getting the dog and that she allowed her partner to bring a dog into the house that she didn't even want. Just because he liked the look of it. They still have it (I'm surprised) and it's always pictured with the child snuggled up, it makes me very very uneasy. As would any image of a baby cuddled up beside a dog.

tabulahrasa · 25/03/2022 09:20

“How did they discover they weren't pit bulls?”

The owners knew the parentage or in one case it had a pedigree.

But the way the law works on pitbulls is that it doesn’t matter what breed they actually are, if they’re reported and fit the description then they’re then pitbulls.

I don’t mean after attacks btw - but because they’re a banned type.

I doubt anyone after a fatal attack is particularly trying to prove their dog is a different breed - tbh I suspect they’ve more on their plate than that.

JuvenileGreyFox · 25/03/2022 09:19

@BobbinHood I agree with you to a certain extent but there has to be an accepting of responsibility on both sides (and I acknowledge that you do this by keeping your child away from dogs)

I love the phrase 'It is easier to put on slippers than carpet the whole world'. Risks exist. Humans have to co-exist with other species. The solution is not to get rid of the other species, they have as much right to exist as you do.

toomanytwinkies · 25/03/2022 09:17

Everyone - always ask whether your dog likes to be touched. I do like those leads that state what personality the dog has. Really helps.

My sister has a ‘nervous’ one and random people have said, “why take it out if it’s nervous!” Like they’re more annoyed their perceived entitlement to stroke a dog trumps everything else, like that dog is there for them! It’s also more for their protection in case he gets scared and reacts! What would they want us do, keep him shut in at home? We’re trying to get him used to people so he’s no longer nervous so move your chubby maulers out of his face, thank yew! 🤣

He’s a greyhound by the way 🥰

freedaym · 25/03/2022 09:15

There have been cases of “pitbulls” seized and put to sleep where there was in fact proof they were a different breed or cross - but they measured as pitbulls so that’s that.

How did they discover they weren't pit bulls?

toomanytwinkies · 25/03/2022 09:11

A dog owner!!!

Lol at the thought of an irresponsible fig owner.

I obviously need to go back to bed!