Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Dogs… To think it doesn’t matter whether it’s a legal breed or not?!

633 replies

MsWalterMitty · 24/03/2022 19:44

Just read about the recent child death in St Helen’s. It’s so awful!

The breed of dog has been released and it turns out it’s not an illegal breed. It’s called an American Bully XL, never heard of it so I googled it, even though I had an idea what it might look like due to its name.

Surely, whether it’s legal or not, this dog seems like a really stupid choice for a family!

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Thread gallery
13
edenhills · 31/07/2022 10:42

Nobody should own a dog that they couldn't physically restrain themselves if they had to. I think that would mean the majority of people couldn't own an XL bully.

iilikerustyspooons · 31/07/2022 05:32

Anyone who has young children and a dog that is a known dangerous breed, that's capable of killing or causing serious injuries is an idiot.

Time and time again these stories hit the news and ifs always the same type of dog, and the same naive people that say 'my dog wouldn't hurt a fly'.

All dogs are capable of causing harm, even the tiny ones, but those that are able to completely over power a human are just fucking dangerous to have in your home, and I can't understand people who have them when they have children.

skimper · 31/07/2022 04:51

I'm on the fence. I have an American bulldog he's huge soft beautiful but so so strong. That weigh could smother a child if he climbed in bed on top of them by being so loving. You have to be cautious of that potential. I would also never get a rescue dog same as mine, as potential past trauma could make them bite I just couldn't trust it. They're descendants from the dogo Argentina which is a banned breed aswel.

Firefly1987 · 30/07/2022 21:33

Perplexed0522 · 30/07/2022 08:41

I read a news article last week where an American Bully mauled and killed its own owner (a middle aged woman).

It terrified me to think if they can do it to an adult then what hope do small children have?

And if the dog can turn on its owner and kill them…..well that’s terrifying too.

Yes when I heard about that poor woman I thought "bet it was a bully XL" before I even read about it. Same as the one who killed that 10 year old. Normally I wouldn't be scared of any particular breed but they are fast getting a terrible rep. The woman's mother couldn't come up with any reason why he'd suddenly attack bar it being because of the excessive heat that week. She'd also come back from a night out so had been drinking-no idea if this could've been a factor why it suddenly turned on it's owner. Her partner was also severely hurt trying to save her.

Confrontayshunme · 30/07/2022 09:46

We raised a safeguarding concern over some children in our school whose father got an American bully XL. They had scratches and numerous bruises and head bumps from being knocked over by it. I grew up with all sorts of dogs, but I have never felt fear like I feel seeing them being dragged around by it as it alarm barks at every child on the school run. It is not well controlled, and I am waiting for it to hurt someone.

Perplexed0522 · 30/07/2022 08:41

I read a news article last week where an American Bully mauled and killed its own owner (a middle aged woman).

It terrified me to think if they can do it to an adult then what hope do small children have?

And if the dog can turn on its owner and kill them…..well that’s terrifying too.

lightisnotwhite · 30/07/2022 08:17

Nobodycarestakeitelsewhere · 24/03/2022 20:10

American bullies and xl bullies should be banned. They've been the culprits in every recent high profile attack on children. They're poorly bred, and the focus is absolutely not on temperament, just on breeding them bigger and stronger. Invariably they have names like Tank, Beast, Machete, Monster and Demon. One dog that killed a child recently had been bred from and had at least 10 puppies out there, passing on its genetics. They're the canine personification of toxic masculinity. They serve no real purpose apart from a status dog, they're not safe to be in society and should be banned.

Agree with this. There’s no point to owning them aside from effectively wanting to own a weapon.

Leonberger · 30/07/2022 08:09

To be fair I have giant breeds and even I can see that there’s a huge difference between a little breed running around snapping and barking compared to something that’s 80kg or something double the size of a standard dog built out of pure muscle with a high prey drive.

As the owner of such large dogs (and a vilified breed like a GSD) it’s up to me to make sure my dogs are the perfect examples of the breed that they can be and embarrass the hell out of people who can’t even train a tiny dog right.

Sadly, lots of people owning bullies at the minute seem more bothered about the size and look of them than anything else.

skimper · 30/07/2022 04:05

EmeraldShamrock1 · 28/07/2022 11:31

There has been a huge increase in large breed attacks.
We mainly hear about the fatalities.

Equally little dogs run around and can snap at big dogs to cause issues.

EmeraldShamrock1 · 28/07/2022 11:31

There has been a huge increase in large breed attacks.
We mainly hear about the fatalities.

clarebeau2 · 28/07/2022 11:17

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

Gerriden · 31/03/2022 18:11

Exactly Headnorth, this is the point that so many are missing. A bit like comparing a gerbil to a wolf.

HeadNorth · 31/03/2022 14:52

If you encounter a vicious chihuahua you can punt the little shit six foot in the air. Rather different to being at the mercy of a big dog that could kill you.

XenoBitch · 30/03/2022 23:45

@StrawberryStarfish

Labradors can be bastards. My dog has been attacked by two different Labradors in two separate incidents
My mum's dog nearly died after being bitten by a lab. My own dog got admitted to emergency vets after being bitten by a collie. The most vicious dogs I have personally met have been chihuahuas. "Oh, they are small, so can't hurt you"... so they don't train out the bad behaviours.
Cherropea · 30/03/2022 20:15

user3837313202

My DH is a farmer, we have three working collies. Doesn't change my opinion.

user3837313202 · 30/03/2022 20:11

Dogs are a luxury not a necessity before people start comparing them with cars 🙄

Try telling a farmer his working dogs are a luxury.

Cars meanwhile really are a luxury for most people in urban areas. I didn't have one at all until I was in my late 20s and would happily get rid of my current vehicle if it wasn't a white van necessary for running my business.

If we want to reduce the number of dead children (and I really don't think it matters exactly which violent method they die by), reducing the number of cars on the road, and the speed they travel at, is far more effective than measures tackling dogs.

Doglikeahorse · 30/03/2022 19:55

I agree @Cherropea.
I have GSD, big powerful dogs admittedly.
I am extremely careful with the dogs around children even though I do not for one second believe they could or would be aggressive to a human. I’ve never seen any aggression to people from any of them.

Saying that, if it would save a child somewhere I would happy apply for a license, pay, attend mandatory training classes, test, muzzle, leash my dogs or whatever else it would take to comply. My dogs are not more important than someones child.

Cherropea · 30/03/2022 19:46

*cjpark
*
All dogs can bite, it's the risk of death from the force of the breed's jaws which surely governs the danger level? Ive only ever been bitten by 1 dog - a cockerpoo which ran up to me and latched onto my wrist. It certainly hurt but ultimately the jaws of a cockerpoo are probably not going to be fatal. I wont have a dog with a powerful bite as a pet.

Exactly, it's seriously hurts being bitten by a small dog and that's as an adult human trying to separate two from fighting!! A child has no chance of escaping serious injury from a big dog.

I own a Rottweiler along with other dogs and whilst I believe she has a sound temperament, she is an exceptionally strong dog and I don't think breeds like her are going to have a place in society for much longer. I think the time will come for a lot of breeds to be owned under strict licence only. This will hugely impact responsible dog owning friends of mine but what else can be done?

Too many children are being attacked and killed. Dogs are a luxury not a necessity before people start comparing them with cars 🙄

Alisae · 30/03/2022 19:07

Oh goodness I’m sorry, can see my happy post is entirely inappropriate given the latest posts Sad those poor babies.

Alisae · 30/03/2022 19:06

I don’t think our little 3 kg JR terrier cross (with chihuahua we think, though no one is really sure) couldn’t hurt someone if she tried, except maybe a newborn.

Not that she would, she’s the softest little thing. We had to get her special kibble because the normal was too big for her to chew Grin

But I still will not leave her alone with dc. I have never let them man handle her either and taught them ‘dog etiquette’ early on. Luckily she responds to training well and seems to love everyone and everything.

Dog has currently squished herself between the dc on the sofa. I must admit, looking at them now, that I don’t think I could ever relax with a dog anywhere near them that was so big that I (or even the youngest dc) could not easily overpower if needed. I know there are lots that are absolutely lovely, but the risk would just always be at the front of my mind.

I used to buy into the ‘oh no not a tiny yappy nippy awful dog’ noise but after seeing how fantastic and trainable ddog is I don’t think I’ll ever have/adopt any other kind. Photo included because any excuse Grin

Dogs… To think it doesn’t matter whether it’s a legal breed or not?!
EmeraldShamrock1 · 30/03/2022 19:02

Another DC lost his life today in Worchestershire he suffered cardiac arrest 3 days after an attack by 3 family pets rottweilers.

Menora · 30/03/2022 18:55

I suppose it’s relative to the size of the person being attacked. My 5kg dog could over power a very small child but he has a small jaw and would bite to grip then shake hard and throw rather than the bite itself being harmful (although also depends as in the neck could be fatal)

cjpark · 30/03/2022 18:49

All dogs can bite, it's the risk of death from the force of the breed's jaws which surely governs the danger level? Ive only ever been bitten by 1 dog - a cockerpoo which ran up to me and latched onto my wrist. It certainly hurt but ultimately the jaws of a cockerpoo are probably not going to be fatal. I wont have a dog with a powerful bite as a pet.

Menora · 30/03/2022 18:38

I have a small 5kg terrier dog and I am sure he could easily kill a cat and he can be dog reactive so he’s never off lead. I’ve seen him pretend kill a toy and being a terrier he shakes it really hard and throws it then pounces again, shakes hard, throws. Anyone who ever plays with an excitable dog can see their ‘kill practice’. I do believe some dogs have no interest in this kind of play and maybe just like fetch, or exploring their surroundings but a lot of dogs DO play and they do play kill things and people just think it’s funny and cute. Like all those tough toys in the pet shop made to play tug of war where your massive dog holds onto a huge rope and you can’t get their jaw unclenched from it?

My dog seems to have been bred to not be human aggressive at all, I’ve never seen him do it, but I wouldn’t trust him alone with a child. He is an animal and on instinct chases things and play kills soft toys

HeadNorth · 30/03/2022 18:35

Rottweilers - so no surprise. As I said some pages up, you know it won’t be a cav or a bichon, or a Lhasa, or a shitzu or any of a million smaller breeds that are suitable to be supervised near children. I could not fight of a Rottweiler that attacked a child - or me for that matter. How can people be allowed to own these dangerous weapons.