Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To Make DS do something he vehemently doesn’t want to?

259 replies

UserOfManyMonickers · 24/03/2022 19:22

So DS (11) is a complete tech addict. It’s good in one way as he can write his own code and watches a lot of science based stuff. He can tell you all about Nuclear Fusion if you’re interested!

He’s doing excellently at secondary school. In fact I’ve had calls from teachers telling what a pleasure he is to teach and how he’s acing everything. One teacher told me this this week. he’s never taught anybody like him (not a stealth boast but background!).

BUT he won’t go out. He’s not interested in meet-up with friends. Won’t do any excercise, he’s 5ft 8 and reasonably slim so not overweight. He just doesn’t want to exert himself, waste of energy!

Anyway I enrolled him in Scouts last year as a way to do stuff outdoors. He was OK initially but said it was quite boring and the other boys are immature and doesn’t seem to have made friends there. He’s always on the periphery.

For the last few weeks he has insisted he’s not doing it. I’ve said he is.

He has a 2 night camp tomorrow and lots more over the rest of the year. I’ve shelled out a lot for kit and he’s just had a massive tantrum that he’s not going. Tears, shouting everything. He hates me.

WIBU to force him?

My older boys were similar and I gave up with making them do stuff like this. I’m don’t want to do the same with him!

OP posts:
XenoBitch · 24/03/2022 22:03

If he is into tech, and if he sees his friends online.. maybe look into getting a VR headset. A lot of games and apps now can get you moving.
Gaming is no longer just sitting in front of a console and moving only your thumbs.

Donra · 24/03/2022 22:02

It’s not reasonable to make him go if he doesn’t want to. There are lots of other types of exercise he could do. Maybe he would like gardening or jogging or another solo activity. Not everyone enjoys group activities.

XenoBitch · 24/03/2022 22:01

see though you can make a child take swimming lessons but you cannot make them learn to swim...I am living proof of this

Same here. Am in my 40s and can't swim. I hate being wet, and I hate being in water. My memories of being taught to swim by my parents was of me crying and saying I was terrified.

They also forced me to do Judo for years. I hated it, and as a result was utter shit at it too. They still drove me all over to do competitions. The only time I took a trophy home was if there was only 3 people in my weight group. I was a pre-teen/teen at the time. Having a boy my age, or even a grown man lay on top of me in a hold makes me feel sick even now.

axolotlfloof · 24/03/2022 22:00

Would he sleep in the garden this weekend, and cook all his meals on a campfire?
No screens at all, so he's getting the break from tech but no scout camp?
He has to choose a family outdoor activity this weekend (eg walk, bike ride, run, orienteering, geocaching etc).
I think you are right to want this for him, but he needs to take the lead in some way.
At 11 does he have a screen time limit?
My boys are older and no screen time limits as long as they do plenty of exercise (they like sport) join in family activities and do h/w.

aveline161 · 24/03/2022 21:59

Exercise is really not the be all and end all it’s a modern fad, you’ve said he’s slim, if he eats ok he doesn’t need forced organised exercise

fairylightsandwaxmelts · 24/03/2022 21:58

So instead of just saying he doesn't have to go, you're giving him a "choice" but punishing him if he chooses to stay home? Hmm

I was that kid who was forced into awful group activities and I hated every minute of it. I'm autistic and as an adult I work in a job that means I'm on my feet outdoors all day and I ride. It just took my years to find what I liked doing.

Please don't force him.

caringcarer · 24/03/2022 21:56

Could you not find him a Science camp or something instead?

SlashBeef · 24/03/2022 21:52

Poor child. So now the siblings are ganging up on him too!
He's doing great at school, he isn't overweight, he walks to school. Christ on a bike leave the kid alone!

reluctantbrit · 24/03/2022 21:51

DD is an Explorer and loved being a Scout. So i do understand where you are coming from.

But - you need to positive about it to enjoy it. DH is the chair of our Scouts and does see the changes from Cubs to Scouts and then during the Scouts, lot of them leave because they don't enjoy it anymore, develop different interests and the leaders themselve say, nothing is worse than a Scout who doesn't want to be there.

Scouting brings a lot but only if you want to do it.

There are other ways to be active, I hate any kind of team sport, camping is the one thing I hate to do but I found my own ways to exercise. Maybe he prefers singular activities, running, weights, martial arts, yoga.

I think it is good to have a decent amount of exercise as a teen but forcing is not doing any good.

Beautifulmonster87 · 24/03/2022 21:45

Don’t force him to do that but definitely limit time be spends staring at a screen. He has to go out and get some exercise even a little walk or bike ride? Football in the garden or park?

sunisblinding · 24/03/2022 21:39

@TatianaBis

camping? fuck that

Camping is ace when you’re 11.

Not if you're an autistic bookworm that needs a lot of personal space.
FarangGirl · 24/03/2022 21:37

I would strongly encourage him, even with gentle bribery, to give it a go. He did agree to sign up for it to begin with I guess or did you do it for him? I do push my kids to follow through when they have made a commitment to something (eg my DD signed up for DofE award but then decided she didn't want to do the expedition - I did push her to do it since she had made that commitment) but not if it wasn't their decision to begin with as that's not fair. He may surprise himself and find he does like it. Obviously, if he goes and doesn't like it then totally fine not to do it again, at least he's tried.

That said, if you don't get any traction with encouragement and bribery, and he's still vehemently refusing, then pick your battles. It's not worth it.

VivX · 24/03/2022 21:34

Totally sympathise with what you're trying to do.
Exercise is important.
Probably best not to force scouts, though.
As per PP suggestions, keep looking for alternative forms of exercise.
(And thank goodness for the 20min walk home from school)

1910username · 24/03/2022 21:34

Could you maybe find a science/tech podcast he might enjoy listening?

He might be open to go for walks while listening to stuff he’s interested in.

FabFitFifties · 24/03/2022 21:32

I forced my son to go to beavers and cubs. He thought I had to work late, while dad was at football. I justified it, because he always seemed to be having fun when I picked him up. Covid stopped that - he is now Y6 and was offered place in scouts but refuses to go. As PP said - 11 is old enough to choose own interests and square pegs don't fit in round holes. You can, and I think should, however, set time limits for screens, so he is forced to entertain himself in other ways. My son is similar, and I am increasingly aware that he is not NT. He is making his own world smaller and smaller, which is hard to watch. Again, very intelligent boy. He is also very good at sport - but nothing will convince him to join teams, even when his less able friends do. It's very frustrating but you can only encourage, not force.

godmum56 · 24/03/2022 21:30

@Sagegreenvelvet

This thread is fascinating. I am 100% on OPs side but so interesting so see how far in the minority I am in this.
why? what good would it do to force a child and how would you feel if you were the one being forced?
Sagegreenvelvet · 24/03/2022 21:26

This thread is fascinating. I am 100% on OPs side but so interesting so see how far in the minority I am in this.

JohnMcCainsDeathStare · 24/03/2022 21:25

I regret not quitting Scouts earlier since I was like your son. All the team stuff I was always on the perifery off and not really getting on with the other girls - I was ND too.

Really you are more likely to push him away from exercise than encourage him - neither of my boys do or have any wish to do team sports but we take them for walks, we are teaching them to ride bikes, we walk and talk and go swimming, bouldering and do watersports whenever we aren't in the Midlands.

It's more important to get them moving on a daily basis. My boys can stay on their computers for hours at a time but even they will get up and move if I prod them to.

NeverDropYourMooncup · 24/03/2022 21:25

It's the same as having somebody who absolutely loves being outside and physical activity and forcing them to stay in a dark bedroom on the computer for days on end.

The environmental thing could easily be active, outside and physical - when I'm back from the gym or a run, I'm happy, a little achy and relaxed - but when I've spent time clearing sodding Cherry Laurel, pulling Ragwort whilst leaving patches away from livestock for moths, building habitat, strimming brambles to leave space for orchids or removing dangerous branches from 400 year old oaks, I'm so bloody knackered, I can hardly move, despite never getting over walking pace. Standard exercise, whilst I enjoy it, is nowhere near as pleasurable or physically taxing as doing something for good - and there's a massive amount of social interaction that's so much more nuanced and rewarding than 'KICK IT' or 'WHERE'S THE PEG HAMMER' in the pissing rain and wind of a standard camping trip.

hennaoj · 24/03/2022 21:23

Leave the poor soul alone. While you mean well it's bullying him. If you want him to exercise why not offer to go on a bike ride with him? My 13 year old son is very similar to yours (he has asc) but he is quite happy to go on the odd bike ride if not forced to.

WanderlyWagonInWales · 24/03/2022 21:18

I’m saying this kindly, but YAB MASSIVELY U here. Sending a reluctant, unhappy pre-teen off to camp for 2 nights when he has no other close friends in the pack is a recipe for disaster. He will be upset, the leaders will end up having to contact you (no doubt) and it may really damage your relationship with him. Please reconsider.

Hugasauras · 24/03/2022 21:18

YABU. You talk about physical health, but what are you doing to his mental health by forcing him to do something he doesn't want to and is dreading?

wejammin · 24/03/2022 21:18

My autistic 9 year old son is just like this, he would hate scouts, and can't stand team sports (he gets really annoyed when people don't play by the exact rules) but he does do bouldering (he likes the physics/maths of the angles!), parkour, and previously skateboarding and swimming. He will come out for walks if we are geocaching or playing Pokémon Go. He likes camping because he gets to light fires.

I'm sure there will come a point when these are rejected in the teen years and he becomes glued to devices but I don't think that's limited to autistic teens!

DotBall · 24/03/2022 21:17

Don’t know if anyone has suggested it, but bellringing would be an amazing hobby for him. It’s a fab blend of physical skill with a level of pattern in number and permutations that is unlike any other hobby. (I am a musician and don’t understand the number theory behind it but am still an outstanding ringer, so you don’t HAVE to know the concepts behind the patterns (called ‘methods’) but those who do have some of the best minds I’ve come across.

There is a high proportion of high functioning ASD people who are ringers.

DogInATent · 24/03/2022 21:16

You won't achieve anything with brute force, other than resentment.

He's smart, which means you need to be clever. See if you can encourage some techy interests that have outdoor aspects. Amateur radio would be one possibility.

Swipe left for the next trending thread