Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To Make DS do something he vehemently doesn’t want to?

259 replies

UserOfManyMonickers · 24/03/2022 19:22

So DS (11) is a complete tech addict. It’s good in one way as he can write his own code and watches a lot of science based stuff. He can tell you all about Nuclear Fusion if you’re interested!

He’s doing excellently at secondary school. In fact I’ve had calls from teachers telling what a pleasure he is to teach and how he’s acing everything. One teacher told me this this week. he’s never taught anybody like him (not a stealth boast but background!).

BUT he won’t go out. He’s not interested in meet-up with friends. Won’t do any excercise, he’s 5ft 8 and reasonably slim so not overweight. He just doesn’t want to exert himself, waste of energy!

Anyway I enrolled him in Scouts last year as a way to do stuff outdoors. He was OK initially but said it was quite boring and the other boys are immature and doesn’t seem to have made friends there. He’s always on the periphery.

For the last few weeks he has insisted he’s not doing it. I’ve said he is.

He has a 2 night camp tomorrow and lots more over the rest of the year. I’ve shelled out a lot for kit and he’s just had a massive tantrum that he’s not going. Tears, shouting everything. He hates me.

WIBU to force him?

My older boys were similar and I gave up with making them do stuff like this. I’m don’t want to do the same with him!

OP posts:
thatsgotit · 25/03/2022 12:06

YABU. I get where you're coming from re exercise/getting outdoors etc, but pushing him into an activity he dislikes to the point of tears is cruel imo. Give the poor kid a break, there are other ways to encourage him to exercise and be outside more.

pawcontrol · 25/03/2022 11:46

I'm on the fence here. Sometimes it is nerves that stops them doing things and a little push helps. But I have the same issue with my DS and football, he never wants to go to training once he's there he's smiling and laughing.He'd stay home on his games too.

User310 · 25/03/2022 11:40

Op, just for a bit of reassurance my husband was the child you have. Textbook computer nerd, learned coding himself as a child, never went out ect.

He is now a computer nerd who builds games and earns 80k a year. He is very introverted, but married to an extrovert that forces him to get out and about, we have lovely children to run after also.

My advice would be to stop worrying, don’t force scouts and buy him a computer coding textbook (thank you husbands mum for doing this!) instead.

SartresSoul · 25/03/2022 11:30

Too old to be forced into extra curricular stuff he doesn’t enjoy. DS chose to end cubs when it was about to switch over to scouts, he felt too old for it already at that age.

You wouldn’t be unreasonable to get him off games and outside every so often though, I think that’s good for his health. Everyone needs to exercise and fresh air too.

Mischance · 25/03/2022 11:26

Why would you try and force him? He is himself - respect him.

incognitoforthisone · 25/03/2022 11:16

I was very, very like your son when I was his age. Not with tech, because I'm old and it wasn't really much of a thing when I was a kid, but I just wanted to spend all my time reading, writing, drawing, watching weird films and generally obsessing over my various, largely sedentary, interests. I was very academic and very articulate. And I hated exercise and group activities. I insisted on ditching Guides when I was the same age as your son because I hated it, and I didn't replace it with any other extra curricular stuff. I just wanted to do my own thing instead. I also hated exercise (although I loved watching sports).

Please don't force your son to do activities that he hates because you think he needs fixing in some way. He's probably a textbook introvert and, after a day at school with his friends, really values time alone in the evenings to recharge his batteries. Scouts is great for some kids, but absolutely not for everyone. It's not enjoyable for him. You're expecting him to do a social activity that to him is a massive, miserable, draining, anxiety-inducing ordeal.

Regarding exercise, presumably he does PE at school. In an ideal world, yes, he'd be a bit more active in his spare time, but he's clearly someone who isn't going to thrive unless it happens naturally (which it might when he's older and has got the hang of his own height a bit more). But I speak from my own experience when I say that forcing a kid who hates exercise to do scheduled, organised exercise is a surefire way to put them off any kind of exercise for life. When I left school, I did pretty much zero exercise for the next 20 years and when I did start exercising in my late 30s, I struggled massively to overcome a huge mental block and anxiety about it because I was carrying so much psychological baggage from being nagged and pushed towards it when I was a kid.

It also really messed with my self-esteem because the fact that people saw my lack of sportiness and non-interest in social activities as a failing made me think there was something wrong with me and that I wasn't good enough. I used to wonder why I was so crap at those things and why I didn't like them like 'normal' kids did.

Your son is extremely clever, popular and friendly, and it sounds like he has a strong social conscience too and a respect for women and girls. Honestly, I would thank your lucky stars for him and stop focusing on his one flaw. No child is perfect.

gannett · 25/03/2022 10:56

I had unpleasant flashbacks to my own childhood here OP.

My parents wanted me to go to youth camps, Guides, outdoorsy stuff that would get me active and make me a team player. They even wanted me to do cadets in school. I was an academic geek who pretty much only wanted to be left alone to read in my spare time. The fight I had with them over Guides was vicious and prolonged. I won it by refusing to take the Guides oath on the basis that I was an atheist and a republican, but in retrospect that was the start of the end of my relationship with my parents, because that was when I realised they only wanted me to be something I wasn't at all.

Funnily enough one of my closest friends now is a gay man who had a similar experience with Scouts. Very traditional, conservative family who wanted him to tick a lot of old-fashioned masculine boxes. He's also estranged from them now.

I wouldn't really worry about making 11-year-olds be active. I was extremely sedentary as a teenager and early 20-something, really hated sport and didn't see the point. In my 20s I discovered exercise and never looked back, and I'm fitter and sportier in my late 30s than ever. In retrospect my dislike of sports was down to 1) I hated all the girls on the sports teams at school, and they hated me, 2) PE is a phenomenally awful way to teach sports, mostly because there's no focus on the kids who actually need to be taught what to do.

Yes, exercise is important but people have to find their own ways to love it. Maybe an individual sport would be up his street - or just get him out for a run or a cycle, 10 minutes to start. That's how I got the bug.

SockFluffInTheBath · 25/03/2022 10:47

@ilovesushi

Wow *@PinaColada123456* you are rude! This is a mum worried about her son trying to do her best!
I disagree, I think it’s what she needs to hear.
ilovesushi · 25/03/2022 10:31

Wow @PinaColada123456 you are rude! This is a mum worried about her son trying to do her best!

PinaColada123456 · 25/03/2022 07:11

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk guidelines.

Ravenglass83 · 25/03/2022 06:29

Just thinking too - I hated (and was terrified of) games like rounders at school. I loved other exercise and social things but if I'd have been forced to play rounders by my family I'd have been miserable, my family was the safe zone away from the few bits of school I didn't like. Definitely agree with those suggesting you help him explore other ways to get active rather than trying to push the Scouts if it's not working for him.

Smorgasbordbaby · 24/03/2022 23:21

My parents tried to force me to go outside and socialise and all it did was make me miserable and resentful. My son has ASD and having it myself has made it easier to support him, he would also happily spend his weekend in his room reading or playing. Team sports, large groups, anything outdoorsy is a big turn-off but a couple of years ago he and I had a long talk about exercise and how it affects both mental and physical health so we started going on walks together, sometimes it's the whole family, sometimes me and him. It's really helped his anxiety and sleep.

I think you need to assess whether an ASD assessment might be appropriate for your son (though I understand they're like hen's teeth at the moment) and also have a conversation with him about this. Explain why you're worried, tell him you understand Scouts isn't his thing but he needs something that gets him out of the house for a short period every weekend. Let him do some thinking and googling about what that might be.

1Dandelion1 · 24/03/2022 23:18

Honestly i wouldn't force him, but maybe you could get him interested in another activity like photography? If you could find a second hand or entry level DSLR camera on offer you could encourage going out to do photography and then editing on his computer after.

notsohippychick · 24/03/2022 23:14

And yes to geocaching. I think this could be good for him but you do it with him. Don’t force him to go with people he doesn’t know.

notsohippychick · 24/03/2022 23:13

This is awful to read.

You are forcing a square peg into a round hole because YOU think he should go to scouts. YOU think he should join more clubs. It’s all what YOU think.

Now you are punishing him as he’s having a meltdown and doesn’t wanna go. Because he doesn’t want to go to a camping trip YOU think he should go to.

This isn’t about exercise at all. This is about you thinking you know what’s best for your son. He’s happy and thriving. Leave him alone. All this is just making him feel you don’t accept him. That want to change him.

Plenty of things to try regarding exercise without forcing the poor boy into a trip he’s clearly quite upset about going on.

Concentrate on what he’s doing well. This is an issue of your own making

TheGrinchsDog · 24/03/2022 23:09

Ooh just scrolled up and someone mentioned Geocaching! That's actually something that might work, it's got a bit of everything. Gets you out and about and you need your tech (app on your phone) to find the caches so maybe that would be something he'd enjoy?

godmum56 · 24/03/2022 23:07

@Fcuk38

Massive red flag if he won’t go out. My nephew was like this now in his twenties and doesn’t leave the house at all.
He goes to school, his attendance is good and he is doing very well. Where is the red flag in that?
Fcuk38 · 24/03/2022 23:05

Massive red flag if he won’t go out. My nephew was like this now in his twenties and doesn’t leave the house at all.

TheGrinchsDog · 24/03/2022 23:05

My eldest DN was the same!

Now he's mid 20's and he has a social life away from his computer, holds down a job and does regular exercise taking the dog for a walk. I think he joined a gym at one point but didn't like it.

DN has ADHD and tech stuff was his passion. He's still my go to for anything tech related because he still has an interest but is far less obsessive than he was when he was younger.

I wouldn't force him just now, maybe encourage social life in other ways that would fit around his passion, like a game night with friends at yours or something?

I'm glad you've decided not to make him go, and try not to worry too much. Bet your older two turned out fine right? Flowers

Sixtycats · 24/03/2022 23:03

Get him OUT

He's 11 now, but let him be sedentary his whole life and you're setting him up for obesity and a heart attack before 40. We are supposed to MOVE, this is not normal no matter how normalised it is. Maybe find out why he's so averse to the outdoors?

Regardless of his reasoning, you are not being unreasonable for wanting your child's life to be more than screens and poor health.

11 is not too old to change.

L0stinCyberspace · 24/03/2022 23:00

He sounds like a great young lad. Please don't force him to go to Scout's. He would really like his Mum to "get" him and I understand your worry about being sedentary the whole time, but at 11 maybe try a bargain,? A DS & Mum walk once a week for an hour and a treat afterwards? No Scout's Camp but attend a Techie camp in the summer instead? Try archery / Aikido / Judo in exchange for dropping Scouts? Give him a few options to choose from. Accept the person he is but see can you make exercise a thing he enjoys too.

godmum56 · 24/03/2022 22:59

@Jjjayfee

Why don't you talk to him about what he would like to do to get fitter? At 11 he must hate being ordered to scouts.
who has said he isn't fit?
godmum56 · 24/03/2022 22:58

@axolotlfloof

Would he sleep in the garden this weekend, and cook all his meals on a campfire? No screens at all, so he's getting the break from tech but no scout camp? He has to choose a family outdoor activity this weekend (eg walk, bike ride, run, orienteering, geocaching etc). I think you are right to want this for him, but he needs to take the lead in some way. At 11 does he have a screen time limit? My boys are older and no screen time limits as long as they do plenty of exercise (they like sport) join in family activities and do h/w.
FFS WHY?
Jjjayfee · 24/03/2022 22:58

Why don't you talk to him about what he would like to do to get fitter? At 11 he must hate being ordered to scouts.

slimshady18 · 24/03/2022 22:56

you said you shelled out a lot for the kit but that's completely your fault, he didnt want to do it? not really sure why you're posting

Swipe left for the next trending thread