Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Choosing a sperm donor

64 replies

Tropicaliyes · 24/03/2022 19:11

Hello,

I would like to know if you was in a SS relationship and TTC would the donors race matter to you?

If you are for example both identifying with one race would it be an option for you to get a donor that is the opposite and not going to reflect you both as a couple?

If you both had completely different ideas on what you wanted out of the donor racially how would you meet half way?

Apparently I’m being unreasonable not wanting a specific race and am lessening our chances because that maybe all the bank has (I don’t know any bank that only has one race to have to settle with what you don’t want).

Am I being unreasonable for wanting a specific race even though many couples choose a donor based on more than just race like eye and hair colour and I don’t care for that, just the race?

Just need some opinions because I’m tired of having the same argument and being made to feel like I’m in the wrong non stop to the point where it makes me want to not bother full stop.

TIA

OP posts:
Coldilox · 24/03/2022 21:21

Good luck with Manchester Fertility, my wife and I had our son with them. He’s 7 now. They really are fantastic.

MaryGubbins · 24/03/2022 21:02

Partner not parent I meant

MaryGubbins · 24/03/2022 21:02

Ignore me, cross post.

Do you think they might have a mixed heritage Caribbean and white donor? It’s not like that’s in common?

MaryGubbins · 24/03/2022 21:00

I think if you are not using the same donor for both potential kids you choose a donor who mirrors the non genetic mum. You say your parent is dark but a black donor would lead to a child who wouldn’t look like your colouring. But that would be the case for a true genetic mix of you and your partner too?

Tropicaliyes · 24/03/2022 20:58

@ReeseWitherfork yes we was planning to have them be half siblings so same donor.

OP posts:
Tropicaliyes · 24/03/2022 20:57

Right I read it wrong, I thought it said they that’s what they advised however it said they would question it if they chose the opposite, my bad

OP posts:
ReeseWitherfork · 24/03/2022 20:53

Will you use the same sperm donor for both?

MyDcAreMarvel · 24/03/2022 20:52

@Tropicaliyes I honestly don’t understand how the councillor can advise you both go with having a black donor when you are both white and honestly if it is not something that you both want then you both should dispute it! the counsellor did not advise them to use a black donor. Did you read the post?

Tropicaliyes · 24/03/2022 20:48

Hi all and thanks for replying..

So we are both Caribbean, my partner was born in Jamaica with a partially Chinese dad (the Chinese features came out a lot in her and her brother). I was born in England with a St. Lucian mum and a white English Dad (I came out with more white features than black).

Trying to find someone that can give us a child to reflect us both is already incredibly hard however I feel choosing a Chinese person can reflect my partners Chinese features while giving it a lighter skin tone that could potentially pass as both of our child.. If we choose a black donor or a white donor is will swing either way as neither of us are fully one race.

@DuvetHugger I honestly don’t understand how the councillor can advise you both go with having a black donor when you are both white and honestly if it is not something that you both want then you both should dispute it!

What they have not taken not consideration is cultural differences, potentially raising a child with let’s say a hair type you might not know how to manage, even your surroundings, if you live in a predominantly white area it might not reflect well having a child not of the same race and not to mention the child not being able to reflect you both..

Like @Easymeasy said it does seem incredibly strange when seeing couples choose donors of a completely different race, I mean everyone has their right to choose what they want but it does leave a lot to be questioned.

We are planning to use both of us however I’m to be used first, if you mix a white donor with me it will make the child more white than black (my partner is more black than Chinese or even white).. we have the same issue with using a black donor and her (it wouldn’t reflect me at all)..

We have decided to contact Manchester fertility clinic as they said they have more diverse ethnic groups to choose from (not too far from us in London) to see what our options are.

OP posts:
Twizbe · 24/03/2022 20:01

It's not unreasonable to want a donor that reflects the racial make up of you as a couple. You want your child to feel like the belong. Choosing something that will mark them out so obviously as not being biologically related to both of you seems a bit cruel tbh.

Laiste · 24/03/2022 19:57

YANBU to want your donor to reflect your own race IMO.

DuvetHugger · 24/03/2022 19:45

When me and my wife were choosing a donor, we also had fertility counselling. They advised that of we chose a black donor (we are both white) they would question why. Would we be able to discuss their culture and ethnic origins that kind of thing.

Ad it happens, we wanted a white donor. What are the reasons for choosing a black donor?

Easymeasy · 24/03/2022 19:22

It depends. If you are white and partner is black for example and you wanted a white donor (if you were carrying the baby) or vice versa if she was carrying the baby.

I personally think the baby should reflect the parents.
A white couple choosing a black donor or a black couple choosing a white donor because they want a mixed baby is extremely strange to me.

There are lots of variables.

ReeseWitherfork · 24/03/2022 19:14

I think there was a case recently which caused a bit of outrage because the white couple used the egg of a black woman. Or something to that effect. I feel like if you're paying for sperm you can pick whatever the hell you want. Else surely they'd make it all random and you'd just get the pot at the front of the shelf.

Swipe left for the next trending thread