Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Choosing a sperm donor

64 replies

Tropicaliyes · 24/03/2022 19:11

Hello,

I would like to know if you was in a SS relationship and TTC would the donors race matter to you?

If you are for example both identifying with one race would it be an option for you to get a donor that is the opposite and not going to reflect you both as a couple?

If you both had completely different ideas on what you wanted out of the donor racially how would you meet half way?

Apparently I’m being unreasonable not wanting a specific race and am lessening our chances because that maybe all the bank has (I don’t know any bank that only has one race to have to settle with what you don’t want).

Am I being unreasonable for wanting a specific race even though many couples choose a donor based on more than just race like eye and hair colour and I don’t care for that, just the race?

Just need some opinions because I’m tired of having the same argument and being made to feel like I’m in the wrong non stop to the point where it makes me want to not bother full stop.

TIA

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Biglad90 · 01/04/2022 13:10

They are trying to say now that they don’t have to contractually give me a 12 week scan photo that I’m suppose to take their word that they are pregnant. I mean she hasn’t even been to the doctors to confirm the pregnancy

juneybean · 01/04/2022 12:51

I can't imagine there's any way to prove they are indeed having an early scan. You will have to see if anything materialises at 12 weeks and if not, remind them of their contractual duties.

Biglad90 · 31/03/2022 08:52

The end goal was to help them conceive with contact with child when 18, we drew up a friendly contract which stated they would give me updates and scan photos etc. They gave me the option of seeing a early scan photo just for peace of mind that it is happening and when I went to take them up on it they then said they aren’t now doing a early scan. But will update me on the 12 week scan

juneybean · 31/03/2022 08:41

What's your issue? What was your end goal?

Biglad90 · 30/03/2022 19:30

Hi can you please give me some advice, I’ve been helping two women to conceive and they have recently sent me a photo of a positive test, they said they are going to pay for a early scan but when I asked about seeing a photo with a update after they have it done they suddenly said they aren’t now going to have a early scan done. There is so much going through my head that I don’t know where to turn

underneaththeash · 26/03/2022 20:42

Most Caribbean people are quite mixed though and genetics of additive genes are complex and random. I'd not overthink it and just go for someone who is from one of the Winward Islands or Jamaican.

One of my exs is St Lucian and his 9 siblings varied from white to black even though his parents had similar colouring.

Clymene · 26/03/2022 20:12

I really recommend you get in touch with the donor conception network. Your children should know how they were conceived from the moment you are able to have those conversations with them. It shouldn't be something you do a big reveal on when they get older; it should be something they have always known about themselves.

The DC network has some very helpful resources to help you have those conversations. They also have a forum where you might find other mixed race couples having similar conversations.

Tropicaliyes · 26/03/2022 19:50

No like others have stated if they are white/black/mixed etc. couples they would like a similar donors, as it would ethnically be the same or similar as both and so we have the same requirements as others had stated. The children will know where they came from when they got older which is why them being related is also important to us.

Features are not something we worry about however coming from a similar background is something we would like us all to have similarities, not exacts.. but that’s all really. I have a half brother and a full sister and we were many years apart from our half brother however if it was back when we were younger I cannot imagine the questions that would have arisen, nonetheless we are prepared for any eventuality and I’m grateful to hear peoples opinions and journeys as it makes me feel a lot better about our journey going forward..

Thanks again everyone ☺️

OP posts:
Clymene · 26/03/2022 17:22

@BloodyloveGeorge

‘ This is in AIBU, so fair game for anyone to have an opinion’

That’s not an opinion - it’s a statement of ‘facts’ which are wrong.

My children are donor conceived and are teenagers. How many donor conceived children do you have and how old are they?
Clymene · 26/03/2022 17:21

@BloodyloveGeorge

‘ Clymene The issue with using sperm from overseas is that your child can never get in touch with their donor when they're an adult. The law to remove anonymity in the U.K. was changed for a reason - because it's better for the children conceived using donor gametes.

Remember that the most important person in the process is the child, not the parent.’

That’s not true- perhaps if you haven’t experienced donor conception, or tried to find a donor, you shouldn’t be giving out advice?

Sorry, what's not true? That the most important person is the child? Confused

That's a bit of a worrying stance to take. Surely all parents want the best for their children.

BloodyloveGeorge · 26/03/2022 15:09

‘ This is in AIBU, so fair game for anyone to have an opinion’

That’s not an opinion - it’s a statement of ‘facts’ which are wrong.

HTH1 · 26/03/2022 15:08

@BloodyloveGeorge

‘ Clymene The issue with using sperm from overseas is that your child can never get in touch with their donor when they're an adult. The law to remove anonymity in the U.K. was changed for a reason - because it's better for the children conceived using donor gametes.

Remember that the most important person in the process is the child, not the parent.’

That’s not true- perhaps if you haven’t experienced donor conception, or tried to find a donor, you shouldn’t be giving out advice?

This is in AIBU, so fair game for anyone to have an opinion

My two cents is that I would go for a pale skinned black donor or mixed black and Chinese/white.

BloodyloveGeorge · 26/03/2022 14:44

‘ Clymene
The issue with using sperm from overseas is that your child can never get in touch with their donor when they're an adult. The law to remove anonymity in the U.K. was changed for a reason - because it's better for the children conceived using donor gametes.

Remember that the most important person in the process is the child, not the parent.’

That’s not true- perhaps if you haven’t experienced donor conception, or tried to find a donor, you shouldn’t be giving out advice?

BloodyloveGeorge · 26/03/2022 14:41

‘ keep hearing that IUI has a low success rate compared to IVF but then it’s so much more expensive doing the IVF i’

That’s true because many couples with fertility issues start with IUI but I know MANY Rainbow Families , ourselves included, who used IUI successfully in a clinic or even at home as they had no fertility issues.
And a clinic will start by running some basic tests to check there’s nothing obvious that might indicate a fertility issue.

BloodyloveGeorge · 26/03/2022 14:33

‘ I'm not sure why you are trying so hard to create a child whose appearance reflects you both, as you are both women and therefore can't expect to be both genetically linked to your child. ’

We picked a donor who had the non- birth parents colouring - should we not have bothered then?
Of course people choose donors based on their heritage, culture, background or what’s important to them - eg education over ‘looks’ etc
Why wouldn’t they?

BloodyloveGeorge · 26/03/2022 14:31

I think if you want your culture and heritage reflected then you think about that. DW and I are both white,
So we used a white donor. Friends used a black donor as the birth mum was white, non birth mum
Was black.

GCMM · 26/03/2022 14:27

I'm not sure why you are trying so hard to create a child whose appearance reflects you both, as you are both women and therefore can't expect to be both genetically linked to your child. For whose benefit is it ? Once the child gets older, they will know that both mums didn't pass on their genes. If it is for you, to somehow feel more connected to the child, I would put those feelings aside. As other people have said, there are no guarantees that your child will look like the donor anyway. I had a child through egg donation and she looks nothing like the donor's description, nor me obviously. I couldn't love her more and we are very close.

Tropicaliyes · 26/03/2022 13:33

Thanks all for the replies, I wanted to say that for us personally we don’t have any specific hair/eye colour or features or anything designer like that, the most we wanted to choose was the ethnicity since there are many things tied up with this as many people have expressed in this one thread through their own personal experiences.

My sister and I have the same parents and are complete opposites… I have all my white fathers features including a lighter skin tone and my sister has all my mothers features including a darker skin tone so I am not expecting a carbon copy of each other however using the same sperm donor but using both my partner and I wouldn’t make copies either and there is no way they would look the same as the genetics are different for both but it would at least secure them as half siblings.

My parents were separated and growing up in the early 90s I had to endure people questioning or even stating I had been stolen from a white couple, I had people ripping me from my mothers hands/arms and was treated extremely different simply because society didn’t accept a light skinned mixed child being born to a black woman.. these things I still remember to this day and it’s such horrible memories I would hate for anyone let alone my own children to go through.. luckily things have changed a lot now but not 100%

Indeed you can choose who you want as a donor from loads of profiles made available to you which contains the donors hobbies, traits, appearance, medical history (to an extent), occupation and other things. There is always the chance things can be withheld and you potentially have a child that has to pay for it, but then that is also a chance in nature as standardly you don’t do genetic testing with a potential partner you will have children with so I think in a way being able to see more info on a person is a plus and if anything is missed it is a risk but one that could have happened anyway, we all just hope that wouldn’t be the case.

Lastly I was not saying that because a child doesn’t know their father to tell them ancestry DNA exists and so good luck… I was just pointing out that anonymity is a little harder to keep now days because the likes of ancestry DNA and similar exist and even people that had closed adoptions and donors in the past can benefit from these things even though it was meant to be anonymous. Now you also have the option to know about the donor even if they chose to have no contact with future children.. if I knew they didn’t want any contact I would try to respect their wishes and know that should my children want to find them at 18, it may not go so well as it was already stated they wanted no contact if that makes any sense.

OP posts:
Wordwatcher · 26/03/2022 03:08

I had four children by donor many years ago with my now exH. I had to have ICI at for all four, two were at one clinic and the others at another as we moved. We didn’t get any choice and donor sperm was in shortage as the anonymity laws were on the cusp of change. One of my kids was born with multiple and complex disabilities (hydrocephalus, epilepsy, cerebral palsy etc). As my child shared a sibling with this donor, we informed clinic and donor was withdrawn. We then found out a genetic reason why this donor should have not been selected; in addition to high miscarriage rate and a sadly a stillborn baby. The other two were different donors as there was no supply left two years on after the third child. My convoluted point is that back in mid 90s/2000s, through NHS we had no choice of donor. Came in when ovulation test was positive and I say it was ICI. It was also paid for by us not NHS funded but treatment at NHS. Good luck and all the best on your journey. I suppose I’m interested in fact that nowadays there is a choice whereas before it was difficult sourcing donors and matching to father was really non existent.

Viviennemary · 26/03/2022 02:40

This does sound very designer baby made to order with this level of worrying about skin colour and facial features. But if you are determined to go ahead then take the advice of the prople providing your treatment.

Cattenberg · 26/03/2022 01:28

I honestly wasn’t bothered about the donor’s colouring, and chose a donor who looked different from me. However, in hindsight, I’m glad that DD ended up with the same colouring as my relatives and me, as she can easily see that she “belongs” to our family.

To be honest, I missed out on the first two donors I liked as they “sold out” very quickly. I decided the next time I saw a donor profile I liked, I would go for it. And I did. One one hand, it seems quite random, but on the other hand, it feels as though it was meant to be.

Kanaloa · 26/03/2022 01:25

I would say as well choosing a donor of a certain race won’t necessarily guarantee the child will have a certain skin tone/look. My two oldest kids are the exact same mother and father and yet my daughter is more light skin, light hair and eyes etc. Compared to my son who is darker skin, dark hair and eyes. Like you can’t guarantee the child will reflect the exact way you hope they will.

Sarahcoggles · 26/03/2022 01:24

Wow things must have changed from when I had my donor treatment 14 years ago. There was a 6 month wait to get one donor, and literally no choice at all.

Kanaloa · 26/03/2022 01:22

@juneybean

We are both white, we never considered sperm from another race as felt the child was up against it already having mothers that were same sex without being from another culture as well.
This is how I would feel. I think people should really consider this. My first two children are mixed race (via their father) and it’s a bit of a struggle sometimes because I feel bad that they don’t have any connection to their heritage etc. I try to provide that but obviously it’s not the same, and it can raise awkward questions if the child looks distinctly mixed race. So my kids often are asked. Even simple things like me having to learn to care for dd hair in a different way than I do my own and little dd. The child could feel isolated or conflicted.
LunaAndHerMoonDragons · 26/03/2022 01:01

I don't think you're being unreasonable at all, but it sounds to me like your OH is anxious about this. She might need to know what you're willing to give on in certain scenarios. Maybe she needs to know what you're prepared to do in the scenario where you can't find sperm with the ethnicity you want. Maybe she's feeling anxious by the whole process, chances of success and so on and focusing on this as something you can both actually control. I think trying a couple of clinics would seem reasonable to me, for her that could be too much of a delay. Feelings aren't defined by their reasonableness or not.