Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Asking a friend back for the money I lent her

192 replies

Hazbot · 24/03/2022 16:47

I lent my friend £1000 last March to help with her debts that her husband didn’t know about. She was saying at the time that it was causing her great anxiety and stress and didn’t know how to pay it off as he wanted to buy a house soon.

She had already borrowed money from her husband’s friend and had a payment plan to pay that money back and so this was £1000 that her husband didn’t know about.

We never wrote a formal payment plan back and I did believe that she had every intention to pay it back.

Fast forward to august where we had a huge fall out because she thought I was flirting with her husband. We eventually made up where she apologised because she was extremely drunk but our relationship has never been the same since.

She’s mentioned a few times about paying it back but nothing ever materialises.

During all this, she has tried to move house, gone through 2 bouts of IVF and has her dad repeatedly in hospital so I know she’s going through it.

But I’m wondering how I can ask her if she has a payment plan for the £1000 I lent her and when the best time to ask her.

She’s currently going through ivf again and so I know it’s stressful for her.

Any advice would be greatly appreciated

OP posts:
winterchills · 24/03/2022 20:53

I would definitely ask her but I agree you probably won't see that money again. No matter what she is going through it's still not on and £1000 is a lot of money!

BanjoKnockers · 24/03/2022 20:43

@Ohyesiam

Slightly surprised at people a attitudes here. In the last year I’ve lent two good friends £1000 each , one paid it back within weeks as arranged, the other is up to date with her payment plan. I asked her to make sure she kept records of what her debt was as I don’t want to have to keep tabs on it, and she sends me updates. I’m surprised people are anti helping a friend in need.
The big question is why couldn't they get an overdraft or otherwise borrow from a commercial lender.

Banks are all set up to lend money and they have proper credit-control systems in place to recover the money if they're not being paid as agreed. And they have a big incentive to lend, because it's their business and how they make money. If, despite all that, the bank won't lend money (essentially because they think they won't get it back) then what chance has the average (slightly gullible and emotionally blackmailed) friend?

2bazookas · 24/03/2022 20:41

Offer her a choice; is she going to repay the money, or should you ask her husband?

gingerbiscuits · 24/03/2022 20:40

If she's got money for IVF, she's got money to pay you back - she's playing you for a fool & taking the piss!! Just ask. Bluntly. And let her know you expect the full £1000 ASAP. The time for gentle, polite reminders has long gone!

loopylou3030 · 24/03/2022 20:36

If you have it in writing either in text or whatever and proof you sent the money. Tell her you want it back (and when you want the first payment). If she makes no attempt to pay it back take her to county court you can file this online on the money claim website it costs £30 and takes 5 minutes. Surely you don't want to keep a friendship like this anyway!

BobLemon · 24/03/2022 20:36

£1k would be too much for me to be able to write off, but that may not be your situation.

I’d ask for a really manageable amount to start with, like £20 a month, asking if it could increase after a year.

I have a friend I lent money to, keeping it secret from their spouse. They’re paying it back now. If they default, my plan is to go straight to their spouse. After that, I’ll go to small claims.

Mrstwiddle · 24/03/2022 20:27

Another one saying Don’t write it off! She’s no friend of yours so you may as well kiss goodbye to the “friendship” and be £1000 richer by going through the small claims court.

WhoKnewWho · 24/03/2022 20:26

Anyone ballsy enough to borrow money of two people while not telling her husband is no way going to pay it back. I hope you can afford to write it off.

Nah. I reckon her husband was in on it.

Therunecaster · 24/03/2022 20:21

Exactly the same thing happened to my DP. He lent her horrible brother and SIL 5k with a repayment plan. After a couple of months they manufactured a falling out with him and haven't spoken to us now for 5 years. Refuse to discuss the repayment. They really are vile, toxic people so whilst the loss of money was a bitter pill, not having to speak to them is a massive bounus.

Ohyesiam · 24/03/2022 20:21

Slightly surprised at people a attitudes here. In the last year I’ve lent two good friends £1000 each , one paid it back within weeks as arranged, the other is up to date with her payment plan. I asked her to make sure she kept records of what her debt was as I don’t want to have to keep tabs on it, and she sends me updates.
I’m surprised people are anti helping a friend in need.

Ohsugarhoneyicetea · 24/03/2022 20:15

And dont ask her and dont warn her you are doing it.

Ohsugarhoneyicetea · 24/03/2022 20:10

Text her DH and tell him you lent her £1k and you really need it back but you are aware she is going through IVF and you dont want to stress or upset her, so you thought it would be better to ask him, to protect her.

silverbubbles · 24/03/2022 20:07

You will only know if you actually ask for the money back!!

Send her a text saying you need the money back as times are tough and would it be easier if she paid in installments of 2x £500 or if its hard then 5 x £200. Then see how she responds.

Myee · 24/03/2022 20:06

All these people borrowing money have credit issues presumably, otherwise they would get an overdraft or borrow it from a bank surely, interest rates are very low right now. That is why I do not believe it when people say they are stuck and I am the only person in the whole wide world that can help them out. Nope.

I would not see anyone hungry or without heat though. So a so called friend asked me for 600 quid to tide her over. I asked what she needed it for, she said bills and food. OK I said, give me the account details for the gas and electric and I'll pay them. Oh and write me a list of food you need and I'll get it delivered from Tesco for you.

Ah no, she said, thanks all the same but the cash will be fine. No I said I do not give cash to anyone but I'll help you out with the bills. I need the cash she said. OK, but if I pay for your bills this month you will have the cash that you would have spent on them. Silence.

Turns out said "friend" was using cash from all angles to fund visits to her toyboy love rat in Turkey. I know, I know. We are both the same age, she is single no kids like me but intended to fund her lifestyle through me. I doubt I would ever have got the cash back. At least if I paid bills etc. I would have been happy to help.

She saw that I saw that she was a No. 1 chancer. We are no longer friends.

I am not perfect, I have many faults and failings, but am usually a good judge of character when it comes down to things like this.

FrancescaContini · 24/03/2022 20:05

@FangsForTheMemory

Are you sure she didn't engineer the row in order not to have to pay you back?

I think you've seen the last of your money tbh.

Yes, this occurred to me, too Shock
Horaceandgus · 24/03/2022 20:01

I had this but a much lower amount-that I couldn’t afford to lose
She got the notes in her grubby mitts,fucked off on holiday and got pregnant
She’s gone on to have the baby and does her best to avoid me if she sees me
I’ve had to write it off

mrsbitaly · 24/03/2022 19:55

I think if you haven't directly asked for it back its not on her priority to repay. If you ask for it then it's more formal, maybe she will pay it back but £1000 is an awful lot not to be repaid even if it is installments of a low amount.

Chloemol · 24/03/2022 19:51

I would contact her and tell her you want relaying, with in full, or at 100pm over the next 10 months

If she doesn’t respond i would say the same again adding I am sorry but if you don’t relay me I will have to speak to your husband to try to get my money back, or possibly take you to small claims court

And do it. Her first priority should have been paying you back, now force the issue

LuluBlakey1 · 24/03/2022 19:44

I wouldn't write £1000 off. Write your own payment plan and send it to her with a start date explaining you really need the money back.
Keep records of everything. As soon as she misses a payment, tell her you will be taking her to the Small Claims Court- my friend did this with an ex-boyfriend and it was really straightforward. Never loan her money again.

Papayamya · 24/03/2022 19:43

I agree she's unlikely to pay it back, sounds like manufacturing the fall out was intentional as well I expect.

BeautifulDragon · 24/03/2022 19:41

Just ask for it back, all of it! Don't go meekly asking if she minds giving you £100 a month.

'It's been a year since I lent you £1000 and I now need it back.

Shall we say end of the month?'

Let her suggest a lower amount, but I would definitely message with the expectation that you'll be getting it all back.

TopCatTheMostEffectual · 24/03/2022 19:37

Not a pleasant series of circumstances OP.

Her row with you is very convenient for keeping you at a distance

You will only get the £1,000 back from the court if you have proof (a series of texts is enough) that she accepted the £1, 000 is a loan.

If no don’t have this evidence, sadly you are probably wasting your time going to court. You might get somewhere by suggesting you’ll approach her husband.

debbrianna · 24/03/2022 19:32

I don't think she thought you were flirting with her husband.sge git scared you would tell her husband. I don't think you will see your money back

EssexLioness · 24/03/2022 19:30

Theoretically we could afford to write £1000 off however I don’t think that is the point. She has completely used you and obviously has a big problem to get into so much secret debt. I also believe she orchestrated the fallout with you to avoid paying what she owed you. That is dreadful behaviour and effectively stealing from you. I wouldn’t let that go and would tell her dh.

Booboobibles · 24/03/2022 19:30

@Babadook76

I don’t get why people are saying you won’t get it back. 1k is way too much for me to write off. I’d be taking her to a small claims court for it. And I’d be telling her husband
That’s what I was going to say. The friendship is over anyway so you may as well get your money back.

Where has all the money for the ivf and attempted house move come from?

Swipe left for the next trending thread