Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Asking a friend back for the money I lent her

192 replies

Hazbot · 24/03/2022 16:47

I lent my friend £1000 last March to help with her debts that her husband didn’t know about. She was saying at the time that it was causing her great anxiety and stress and didn’t know how to pay it off as he wanted to buy a house soon.

She had already borrowed money from her husband’s friend and had a payment plan to pay that money back and so this was £1000 that her husband didn’t know about.

We never wrote a formal payment plan back and I did believe that she had every intention to pay it back.

Fast forward to august where we had a huge fall out because she thought I was flirting with her husband. We eventually made up where she apologised because she was extremely drunk but our relationship has never been the same since.

She’s mentioned a few times about paying it back but nothing ever materialises.

During all this, she has tried to move house, gone through 2 bouts of IVF and has her dad repeatedly in hospital so I know she’s going through it.

But I’m wondering how I can ask her if she has a payment plan for the £1000 I lent her and when the best time to ask her.

She’s currently going through ivf again and so I know it’s stressful for her.

Any advice would be greatly appreciated

OP posts:
Onthetoadagain · 25/03/2022 17:18

Nice one OP. Don't be shy to remind her if she doesn't pay up, but hopefully she won't mess you about.

cushioncovers · 25/03/2022 12:56

Well done for messaging her op. Although I still think it will start off well then she'll stop. But fingers crossed I'm wrong and you get your money back.

Gonnagetgoing · 25/03/2022 12:14

That seems a really good outcome OP but definitely ensure she sticks to her payment plan.

PurpleDaisies · 25/03/2022 11:55

I guess whether she did forget or not, it seems like she wants to put it right and hold on to your friendship. Hope it works out.

Hazbot · 25/03/2022 11:54

So she has sent over £100 this morning and then has said £100 for the next 2 months and then will pay back the rest in one go. She apologised that she hasn’t thought about it sooner (I believe she was hoping to get away with it) but I’m genuinely surprised at how she hasn’t used her circumstances or anything else against me

OP posts:
Gazelda · 25/03/2022 11:37

@Hazbot

Thank you to everyone for all the comments and advice!

I’ve messaged her this morning and she was actually really nice about it all and said of course and has set up a payment plan. I’m still a little cynical as to whether it will all be paid but it’s a start!

How much is she paying each month? How many months will it take her to pay you back?
RonSwansonsChair · 25/03/2022 11:30

That's good OP. But don't be afraid to follow up if she doesn't stick to the agreed plan.

Hazbot · 25/03/2022 10:06

Thank you to everyone for all the comments and advice!

I’ve messaged her this morning and she was actually really nice about it all and said of course and has set up a payment plan. I’m still a little cynical as to whether it will all be paid but it’s a start!

OP posts:
Lurking9to5 · 25/03/2022 07:58

Some people have the ability to reframe debt. I realised one saturday i forgot to give my colleague €3.50 for the lotto and i was cringing about it! I dont have revolut.
How do people not care that they owe you 2 weeks net wages (well averagely speaking)

TheMarvelousMrsMaisel · 25/03/2022 07:54

I would just go directly to her husband and show him the evidence.
She doesn't care, IVF is expensive and if she really cared she'd of made sure you was paid back before spending thousands on it.

RonSwansonsChair · 25/03/2022 07:50

Ask her once if you don't get the money go straight to her husband. I'd bet she's borrowed money from a fair few people.

timeisnotaline · 25/03/2022 00:14

@Ohyesiam

Slightly surprised at people a attitudes here. In the last year I’ve lent two good friends £1000 each , one paid it back within weeks as arranged, the other is up to date with her payment plan. I asked her to make sure she kept records of what her debt was as I don’t want to have to keep tabs on it, and she sends me updates. I’m surprised people are anti helping a friend in need.
But they are paying it back. This woman isn’t. I’d ask her for it and say i need it back so I’m afraid I’ll have to ask if you don’t get back to me on this.
Shockedmama · 25/03/2022 00:10

You shouldn’t have to ask her. She should be bringing it up! No matter what is happening in her life

expat101 · 25/03/2022 00:02

Her name isn't Vicky is it?

Funny I had completely forgotten about this until I read the thread..

NumberTheory · 24/03/2022 23:58

@ECN73

It’s a tough lesson but I think you’ll struggle to get that back. My dad told me never to lend money to anyone that I needed back. So I have always loaned thinking it was gone. I’ve been pleasantly surprised that money has always come back to me but if it hadn’t thats ok too.

Friendship wise though is she really a friend worth keeping? Accusing you of hitting on her husband is pretty harsh.

If the "friend" won't voluntary start repaying, small claims is not that difficult. Since "friend" and husband are planning on buying a house it's unlikely they simply can't pay. I don't think it needs to be a struggle at all.
expat101 · 24/03/2022 23:53

We were owed money by a woman whose Hubby my DH knew. I called her a few times to have it paid, she wasn't returning calls and it was getting frustrating.

Instead of giving up, as I knew a rough time her DH arrived home from work, I left a message on their home answer phone. The funds were in our bank account the following day. I found out afterwards she was well known to owe others as well.

Not long after she was selling her horse truck and stuff and we never saw them again.

Comfortableatlast · 24/03/2022 23:21

My DS lent money to a "friend" in the extended social circle over Christmas, he hasn't had it back, turns out this lad did it to several people in the social circle at the same time.

Now granted it was "only" £100 but a lot when you are on an apprenticeship wage, I said to him you must be raging with him, he said the money would be nice but it was a good life lesson early on in the fact that not everyone is who they appear to be.

I could have bloody hugged him (about all he allows these days Grin) turns out he listens to me more than he pretends.

ECN73 · 24/03/2022 23:04

It’s a tough lesson but I think you’ll struggle to get that back. My dad told me never to lend money to anyone that I needed back. So I have always loaned thinking it was gone. I’ve been pleasantly surprised that money has always come back to me but if it hadn’t thats ok too.

Friendship wise though is she really a friend worth keeping? Accusing you of hitting on her husband is pretty harsh.

wizzywig · 24/03/2022 23:02

Write it off and tell her husband

WeBuiltThisBuffetOnSausageRoll · 24/03/2022 22:22

Banks are all set up to lend money and they have proper credit-control systems in place to recover the money if they're not being paid as agreed. And they have a big incentive to lend, because it's their business and how they make money. If, despite all that, the bank won't lend money (essentially because they think they won't get it back) then what chance has the average (slightly gullible and emotionally blackmailed) friend?

Some people do slip through the cracks with the banks, through no fault of their own, though. Look at how many people are turned down for mortgages that the bank deems 'unaffordable' for them - even when they can prove that they've consistently made significantly higher payments every month for their existing mortgage or rent for many years.

Thinking back to the parallel with the other recent thread, about getting ID'd to buy alcohol at the age of 35, you would assume that shops that sell alcohol would actively want to shift as much stock as they can to customers of a legal age who are wanting to buy it; but it appears that many of them, too, are extremely keen to turn away huge amounts of obviously legitimate and risk-free custom.

Usernameinsponeeded · 24/03/2022 21:35

Just bring it up, tell her you’re struggling right now and need the money. Keep reminding her to set up a payment plan. I wouldn’t let her off the hook. She definitely engineered that argument to get out of repaying you.

Never lend money again that you can’t afford to / don’t want to lose.

Eeksteek · 24/03/2022 21:19

I lent someone a similar amount I doubt I’ll ever see again. She had left her abusive, drug addict husband, and made some stupid life decisions that followed her. The money I ‘lent’ her (which I could easily afford at the time) got her back on her feet and she’s working and has her life together now. She’ll never pay me back - she’s really only just standing on her own two feet as it is. As much as I’m now the one who’s broke, and I could really do it with it right now, I don’t regret it. She doesn’t have it and I’m still in a more privileged position than she is, let alone than she was, and we’ll be ok in the end. It was money well spent, even if it wasn’t well lent.

Hyppogriff · 24/03/2022 21:01

You’re never getting that back

TheOccupier · 24/03/2022 21:00

Is this real? Is anyone really this stupid? Your money's gone... think of it as a gullibility tax.

Gettingthingsdone777 · 24/03/2022 21:00

Unfortunately I think that money is gone one way or another, if you were a bank you probably would not have loaned it to her because she was always going to be high risk with that track record. If you want to keep on good terms with her I recommend you turn it into a gift, and just keep a healthy distance from her generally as it sounds like the friendship might be a bit of a one way street. Better to at least have the social benefit of your generosity I think rather than it being a reason you avoid each other in future. Who knows? If you’re really stuck for money in future, maybe she will return the favour, wouldn’t count on it though

Swipe left for the next trending thread