Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To say that It feels like there's no effort to reduce train stress.

188 replies

hockeysticks89 · 24/03/2022 16:26

I'm sitting at Euston, having missed my hourly train by seconds. When I approached it (running, which is not an attractive look for me) at its proper departure time a guy blew a whistle at me and said no. He saw me coming but gave the lock doors command as I approached.

Fair enough but I know from experience that they only put the station up on the board for my Crewe train around five minutes before it departs, at which point everyone literally charges like crazed animals. If you're slightly infirm you're screwed, it's a health and safety nightmare.

There are more platforms than there are trains. Guards know in advance which station it's going from.

AIBU to state that there appears to be no desire to reduce the stress of train travel in this situation? Grrrrr

OP posts:
Papayamya · 24/03/2022 19:01

Eurgh I don't miss commuting to London, the platform changed every night for the train I got, and so you had tonnes of people crowded around the screen hedging their bets at which one it would be, before charging forward and pushing people out of the way. The sight of grown men and women rushing past people with crutches, in wheelchairs, people carrying babies etc was absolutely disgraceful, then the bottleneck at the ticket turnstile thing would be another level of savage. There had to be a better way to manage it.

Xiaoxiong · 24/03/2022 18:59

YANBU! Euston is definitely the worst for this, but the old platform 20 at Waterloo used to be like this as well. Platform 14 at Paddington still is bad, platform up with 5 mins to go, you leg it, get to the barrier at platform 12 and think you're there but it's miles away still. It's so horrible for people who are elderly, have kids, have mobility issues etc. Awful.

In fact, I wonder if there is a case to be made on age and disability discrimination for this practice of late posting of platforms and changing them around.

TupilaLilium · 24/03/2022 18:58

Was it to Holyhead? Those are either at the far left or the far right and 5 minutes would be generous. It is so stressful.

hockeysticks89 · 24/03/2022 18:58

Ooh, will definitely check realtimetrains, that would be great if it's ok there

OP posts:
hockeysticks89 · 24/03/2022 18:56

Sorry, the first paragraph was a rant and a bit of a red herring. That was my bad, I arrived probably five seconds before the train was due to pull off and I felt that they could have been more helpful but I accept that it was my fault.

My AIBU was about the late notice of platforms and therefore the mad dash. It's chaotic and potentially dangerous. If avoidable, it's just not a nice way to treat people.

Thanks for your replies.

OP posts:
ButYouBetterNotTakeItFromMe · 24/03/2022 18:53

I've had this too. The trains to my neck of the woods from Euston always go from one of 2 platforms but they are almost as far apart as you can get so you can't risk hanging around the one that you think it might be, as sod's law dictates it would be the other. The stampede one its announced is terrible.

Seleniummillenium · 24/03/2022 18:51

Check out realtimetrains. It gives you advanced notice of what platforms the trains are leaving from.

TillyTopper · 24/03/2022 18:40

I hate Euston for exactly this reason. There is not enough time between announcing the platform and doors being shut - and it's a big station.

freedaym · 24/03/2022 18:36

I've also missed trains that have left 30 seconds or so before their departure time.

TangledUp789 · 24/03/2022 18:32

Some people can't read. The OP is quite clear. This is not about her not getting there early enough to read the board.

I think you might have misread her post actually. She said she ‘knows from experience’ that the board only updates five minutes before departure, which to me suggests she arrived at the station later than that. I could be wrong, but it’s certainly not clear that she arrived with time to spare.

NotJustACigar · 24/03/2022 18:31

I can also confirm, Euston is absolutely shocking and the last minute platform announcements and ensuing stampede for trains is ridiculous. I and DH have written to complain many times but they just don't care.

freedaym · 24/03/2022 18:31

Euston has 16 platforms as well

freedaym · 24/03/2022 18:29

I once tried to outwit the buggers and they used a platform I had never departed from before.

Happened to me too, and was the opposite fecking end so missed it.

Notlabeled · 24/03/2022 18:28

And they wonder why people would rather drive themselves than put up with this nonsense.

freedaym · 24/03/2022 18:28

And I have often wondered what happens if one can’t run.

exactly!

Nightlystroll · 24/03/2022 18:26

@daimbarsatemydogsbone

she got a piece of my mind on how her company was run too. Because everyone knows the frontline staff are actually CEOs and senior managers. I really can't stand people who do this - it's liek the ones who shout at doctor's receptionists as if they are Sajid Javid.
She didn't need to approach me and be patronising, with her have you calmed down grin. No, it was blinking freezing, it was late, I had to wait an hour and I had to pay increased parking fees at the end and increased carers fees. But the company didn't care that I had increased costs because of their mess up. They didn't want to be out of pocket but they were happy with me being. Shutting the door in people's faces was totally unnecessary.
freedaym · 24/03/2022 18:25

The best way to reduce train stress is to get there on time, especially if you know that you'll have to wait an hour for another one! Sorry OP but you know doors close X minutes before departure, if they wait for you they'll have to wait for the person running behind you, and the one behind them, and the one behind them...

You can be an hour early but if you don't know the platform...

Sailorsusan · 24/03/2022 18:25

I can relate to this. And also have had experience of guards seeming to enjoy not letting me through.

Saffy321 · 24/03/2022 18:25

I used to commute on the Thameslink line where it was so packed the people behind you on the platform would be shoving you onto the train so they could also try and squeeze in - also saw a couple of people pass out due to be crammed in so tightly.

cortex10 · 24/03/2022 18:25

There's an app for phones that someone has written (nothing flashy) that notifies the departure platform at Euston as soon as the incoming train is near the station. I used to be a very regular traveller at Euston and found it really reliable - often standing at the ramp 15 or more minutes before anything comes up on the main concourse board. In fact the platform sign on the ramp usually lights up a couple of minutes before the main board so there's plenty of time to walk down and board before the hoardes descend. By sharing this I have probably destroyed the advantage of having the app but I agree that Euston is one of the worst stations for this. Search for London Platforms on the App Store.

freedaym · 24/03/2022 18:24

OMG I was lucky not to get trains too often but why do they do this!!!

Wait until 8:59 to tell you what time the 9am train is leaving from & then the platform is number 500089. 🤬

trailrunner85 · 24/03/2022 18:22

This happened to me. Waiting in the big concourse area, train platform was announced about 5 mins before departure. I got to the train on time - but it was full (presumably from people who knew the platform some other way or who regularly used the service).

Even though I had a booked ticket and reserved seat for that specific train, they wouldn't let me on as the train was full to the point of overcrowding.

I was told to get on the next one (two hours later) and apply for a refund..!

Jules912 · 24/03/2022 18:22

@Nightlystroll I have many issues with our train company but there is at least one nice guard and/or driver who will hold the train if the connecting service was late, well so long as he could see people running across the platforms.

Gizlotsmum · 24/03/2022 18:21

Oh I remember the rush to the platform at Euston as a kid ( so over 30 years ago) never was much notice and a frantic race ( how my mum and dad did it with 2 kids and my grandma I will never know) we used to try to guess which platform it would be…

Nightlystroll · 24/03/2022 18:20

@daimbarsatemydogsbone

A guy from the office came out and walked the length of the train to see if anyone could drive a train! Say what now? Yeah - that didn't happen. Even if you are a driver, you need up to date route knowledge so there's no way that would have worked.
Er, don't call me a liar. That's what happened. A guy from the offices came onto the train after getting complaints and people were asking him what he was going to do. And he said he was going to walk down the train and see if there was anybody who could drive the train. People were rolling their eyes and muttering because it was a ridiculous thing to say. I've got no reason to lie. They're were a dreadful company and they lost their licence.