Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To say that It feels like there's no effort to reduce train stress.

188 replies

hockeysticks89 · 24/03/2022 16:26

I'm sitting at Euston, having missed my hourly train by seconds. When I approached it (running, which is not an attractive look for me) at its proper departure time a guy blew a whistle at me and said no. He saw me coming but gave the lock doors command as I approached.

Fair enough but I know from experience that they only put the station up on the board for my Crewe train around five minutes before it departs, at which point everyone literally charges like crazed animals. If you're slightly infirm you're screwed, it's a health and safety nightmare.

There are more platforms than there are trains. Guards know in advance which station it's going from.

AIBU to state that there appears to be no desire to reduce the stress of train travel in this situation? Grrrrr

OP posts:
DdraigGoch · 24/03/2022 23:25

@Joinedforthis2021

When a train arrives, passengers get off, the preparations are done for the next journey, its announced on the board and passengers have up to 2 minutes to board before boarding closes and the train departs.
@Joinedforthis2021 two minutes?

You do realise that the minimum connection time at Euston (a "large interchange") is fifteen minutes?

saraclara · 24/03/2022 23:25

Euston must also be a horrible place to work. It's stuffy, gloomy and dreary as well as having the worst concourse information and boarding system that I've ever come across. St Pancras and Kings Cross are incredibly airy and calm places in comparison.

No wonder the staff at Euston are grumpy. They have to spend all day every working day amid the tension and yellowy gloom.

HardbackWriter · 24/03/2022 23:13

@DdraigGoch

In fact, I wonder if there is a case to be made on age and disability discrimination for this practice of late posting of platforms and changing them around.

Very likely. Legal action is the only thing that will make management listen. Perhaps the Association of British Commuters might take it up.

By the way, it's only the London terminals which do this. Glasgow Central gives at least 30 mins notice, pretty much everywhere else I've been to gives up to two hours notice.

Or a serious accident, but legal action would obviously be greatly preferable!
HardbackWriter · 24/03/2022 23:12

@Joinedforthis2021

Wonder if it's to do with the layout of the station?

I don't use the other large major London stations so cannot make a comparison.

Possibly - maybe they think it's more problematic to have people hanging around near their platform at Euston than elsewhere? I do think it's really dangerous, though, to encourage the stampede as it does.
lakeswimmer · 24/03/2022 23:10

I'm glad it's not just me. For years I've wondered why the trains I get from Euston (usually to Glasgow) have the platform announced so late. I thought it was something to do with that specific train service. I never had those problems from Kings Cross.

DdraigGoch · 24/03/2022 23:10

In fact, I wonder if there is a case to be made on age and disability discrimination for this practice of late posting of platforms and changing them around.

Very likely. Legal action is the only thing that will make management listen. Perhaps the Association of British Commuters might take it up.

By the way, it's only the London terminals which do this. Glasgow Central gives at least 30 mins notice, pretty much everywhere else I've been to gives up to two hours notice.

OnTheBoardwalk · 24/03/2022 23:08

I’m thinking a lot of people on this thread have never got a train from Euston. Get there on time, check an app, none of this applies at Euston

The Euston stampede is actually quite frightening and you get caught up in it trying to get the train or just stood on the concourse

The 1st class lounge (just saying and for anyone who’s been knows it’s nothing to brag about) give you an indication of the platform but half the time it changed based on the other trains wanting to get in the station

I think it’s very dangerous

ClafoutisSurprise · 24/03/2022 23:04

Ah, I can go to bed happy now @SoulofEuston. Counting platform numbers to get to sleep...

saraclara · 24/03/2022 23:00

@Joinedforthis2021

Wonder if it's to do with the layout of the station?

I don't use the other large major London stations so cannot make a comparison.

St Pancras has different areas of the station for different train companies. So you always know roughly where your train will leave from. And the display boards are all over the station, so there's not just one big board like there is at Euston, that everyone has to crowd around.

But the platforms are decided way before the train comes in. I have never had to wait and watch for the platform to be announced at StP, and I'm one of those people who gets to transport hubs way, way earlier than they need to. The information has always been there half an hour before.

SoulofEuston · 24/03/2022 22:55
Grin
ClafoutisSurprise · 24/03/2022 22:53

@Joinedforthis2021

Soul of Euston Grin that's made me laugh I may change my username to that.

I promise I don't work at Euston, I travel in and out of Euston A LOT and just from knowledge and observations.

Do it! It would make my day if I inspired a username.

Although you’ve broken the spell now, as don’t see Euston as having much of a sense of humour Grin

ouchmyfeet · 24/03/2022 22:52

Agree that Euston is terrible for this. You need this app OP, it has never let me down. Yesterday I waited by the platform for 10 minutes before my train actually came up on the board. When it did I strolled onto the platform and was first on the train.

apps.apple.com/gb/app/london-platforms/id1044591401

Joinedforthis2021 · 24/03/2022 22:51

Wonder if it's to do with the layout of the station?

I don't use the other large major London stations so cannot make a comparison.

DdraigGoch · 24/03/2022 22:51

And maybe so they can switch platforms last minute without people having to go up and down.

The OP's train arrived twenty minutes before departure, so they knew for certain at least that much in advance. I get that they want to allow the cleaners a chance to go through uninterrupted but there is surely a compromise that allows for a comfortable walk to the platform from the concourse.

HardbackWriter · 24/03/2022 22:47

@Joinedforthis2021

"train will have been ready on the platform for ages before it goes on the board"

It has to be cleaned, restocked, train crew boarded and security checks done, only then can it go on the board and board begin.

But this is true of every train station - or at least every major hub/end of line - so why is so noticeably, clearly worse at Euston than at any other station I've ever been to? All the other major London stations manage it much better - you might have the odd last minute platform change and so a mad dash, but it's the exception not the absolute rule like at Euston.
DdraigGoch · 24/03/2022 22:45

@katicomps

I use Euston often and I get what OP means.

There's a big departure hall with the boards up for each train and they only put up what platform it's leaving from at the last minute.
People literally take off running as soon as it appears. I'm fit enough but it's still a stressful few minutes if you're yanking a case along with you, then you get to the train and you don't know wether to get on at the first door and battle all the way down the aisle or walk on the platform and risk getting left behind.
The train will leave within minutes so yeah, if you're a teensy bit late or disabled… Sad

Euston's awful, but most London termini are poor too. Many disabled people avoid Euston for a very different reason - it's notorious for leaving wheelchair users stuck onboard.

If you use the "staff view" function on this site you can see what the staff see.
tiger.worldline.global/home

FangsForTheMemory · 24/03/2022 22:44

I once had a platform be announced three minutes before the train was due to leave. That was at Paddington. At Euston my regular train was moved to a different platform, no announcement and a member of staff stood and watched a couple of dozen people miss it.

Joinedforthis2021 · 24/03/2022 22:44

At no point have I suggested it was the OP fault. I have just be trying to explain the reasoning behind some of the obsticles faced that's all.

Characterisartion · 24/03/2022 22:43

I used to travel a lot with heavy luggage (work kit) on wheels and sometimes missed trains due to physically not being able to lug it quickly enough up stairs, as a fit 20 something. It was horrendous and stressful. And was definitely getting worse.

What happens in situations where people don't have flexible tickets? My situation was rubbish but work always paid for flexible tickets (rebooking would have been more expensive etc) but I wouldn't buy a more expensive flexible ticket personally..?

Joinedforthis2021 · 24/03/2022 22:41

Soul of Euston Grin that's made me laugh I may change my username to that.

I promise I don't work at Euston, I travel in and out of Euston A LOT and just from knowledge and observations.

Justanotherlurker · 24/03/2022 22:40

They are trying to reduce train stress, especially so in the case of OP and the western line with HS2, funnily enough there is a lot of resistance to that.

Euston is a major hub, of course it makes sense that a train can come in at station 5 or 12, you wanting easing of stress on an outward journey would have even more of an impact due to the snowball effect.

Belladonna12 · 24/03/2022 22:38

@Joinedforthis2021

Those that need additional time can either book passengers assistance or speak to a member of staff at the passenger assistance area near the booking hall and they will no doubt try and find out for you.
I don't need assistance to get to the platform. I just need to know what the platform is more than more than 2 minutes before the train leaves. People with reduced mobility shouldn't have to to arrive at the station hours before able-bodied people to book passenger assistance just because Euston can't organise themselves to give details of the platform in good time.
Odilla · 24/03/2022 22:38

Like the OP then?

Euston is bloody awful for this I agree. There are railway stations all over the world where people manage to clean trains and also give more than two minutes' notice as to where a train is. At st pancras just down the road, for one. Maybe they could run courses for Euston staff?

ClafoutisSurprise · 24/03/2022 22:36

[quote lockedinandout]@Joinedforthis2021 do you work for Euston station by any chance? You seem overly invested in defending them.[/quote]
I was wondering this too. Feel almost like the very soul of Euston is speaking to us!

If other stations can do it, there really is no excuse. I travel between Manchester Piccadilly and Euston fairly frequently; the concourse screen gazing and sprint only happens at one end.

lockedinandout · 24/03/2022 22:36

Repeating unhelpful policies whilst suggesting that it's the customers fault they are missing the trainsis rather defensive...

Wouldn't it be better, and more customer focused, if as much advanced warning of the departure platform could be given, as possible? Rather than putting up barriers (or not as the case maybe) to people being able to catch the trains they are paying for. Surely that makes more sense that train users having to use a third party app, or stampede through the station.