Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To say that It feels like there's no effort to reduce train stress.

188 replies

hockeysticks89 · 24/03/2022 16:26

I'm sitting at Euston, having missed my hourly train by seconds. When I approached it (running, which is not an attractive look for me) at its proper departure time a guy blew a whistle at me and said no. He saw me coming but gave the lock doors command as I approached.

Fair enough but I know from experience that they only put the station up on the board for my Crewe train around five minutes before it departs, at which point everyone literally charges like crazed animals. If you're slightly infirm you're screwed, it's a health and safety nightmare.

There are more platforms than there are trains. Guards know in advance which station it's going from.

AIBU to state that there appears to be no desire to reduce the stress of train travel in this situation? Grrrrr

OP posts:
santapaws12 · 25/03/2022 07:29

People who don’t regularly travel to London don’t know about this ridiculous situation and will assume Euston is like any other reasonably sane train station. My mum, aged 79, catches trains no problem most of the time and is very independent and it wouldn't occur to her that she’d need assistance to get to the platform (although she’d be outrun by miles and possibly knocked over at Euston Sad )

Noseylittlemoo · 25/03/2022 06:40

My bugbear tbf not exclusive to Euston is other passengers who are oblivious that at a train station people have trains to catch! On the weekends especially there are people in groups who insist in standing in a group on the escalator / put their case next to them on the escalator so you can't get past. People stopping to regroup right at the entrance of a tube platform. I once missed the train as someone refused to move aside to let me pass on the escalator so I was slower to arrive on the concourse, "luckily" the platform I needed was straight ahead so I sprinted down with 2 min to spare and the guards smugly pulled one of those yellow barriers across. There was me and one more person so it would have taken literally seconds for them to let us on. And I know from experience that the trains often make up time it they leave late. (Altho this one wouldn't have even been late). It happened about 3 months ago but I've still got the rage about it!!

Noseylittlemoo · 25/03/2022 06:29

I commute in and out of Euston 5 days a week so I am familiar with this scenario.
I didn't know about the app. But I usually look at the arrivals board which seems to display the trains coming in up to about an hour ahead and shows which platform they come in to.
If the train to Milton Keynes that i want to get is leaving in 15 min but they haven't announced the platform I look at the arrival board and often there is a train arriving from MK in eg 10 min so I'm confident that's the platform.

TottersBlankly · 25/03/2022 05:37

If other stations can do it, there really is no excuse. I travel between Manchester Piccadilly and Euston fairly frequently; the concourse screen gazing and sprint only happens at one end.

Absolutely. Getting on at the Manchester end is just so luxuriously relaxed. Correct platform might be shown an hour in advance, giving one the peaceful confidence to amble around the station shops, preen in the loos, buy a coffee and then amble onto your sunlit train at your leisure. By comparison, it’s bliss.

Circlesandtriangles · 25/03/2022 02:12

OP I know exactly what you mean, I struggled down to the platform one memorable evening when heavily pregnant and the dispatcher could see me coming and I was literally 10 meters from the train door, looking at me. when he gave the ok and the doors closed in my face and the train left.

Full of hormones, my uncharacteristic reaction was to say nothing but burst into tears on the spot. I was in agony with SPD and the next train was a 5 minute walk away (or 15 for me with my pelvic pain) on a different platform. A few people waiting for a train at nearby platform saw what happened and gave him an earful about it which was lovely but I still had to tearfully and painfully limp the way to that other platform. Awful memory!! Was so mortified!!

honeyytoast · 25/03/2022 00:48

I have Euston down to an art now. But yes it’s so stressful

freedaym · 25/03/2022 00:23

I know it can't be boarded before then! But they can put on the noticeboard which platform it will depart from so people can wait nearby instead of having to charge along from the waiting area and miss the train.

I've waited on platforms whilst a train has been cleaned, it's not a big deal.

Wafflesnsniffles · 25/03/2022 00:21

If you think the OP is being unreasonable.......... try going to Euston to wait for the Crewe train. When they finally put the platform details on the board........... the second they put that platform number up........... you make your way to the platform as quickly as you can......but in the crush amongst all the other passengers by the time you make it to the train the guard shuts the doors........ how is that fair?
Ive got that train often op, I totally get the struggle you are referring to.

Chouetted · 25/03/2022 00:19

The Euston Dash is genuinely terrifying - especially if get caught up in it while trying to go the other way.

I believe it's to do with the lack of space on the platforms, and the daft ramps, but there has to be a better way.

Getting the first off-peak train out of London used to feel like dicing with death - and the prize was getting a patch of carpet on the train to sit on, because all the seats had been taken by people who ran faster.

Pinklimey · 25/03/2022 00:15

I went from Marylebone the other day. Very nice, ambled to the train as soon as platform displayed. Lots of people got on last minute, so not sure what happened there.

Comefromaway · 25/03/2022 00:14

Oh god, the London West Midlands train to Crewe from Euston is stuff of nightmares.

Dh has a vestibular disorder and Ds is autistic and it’s dreadful.

freedaym · 25/03/2022 00:12

my memory of King's Cross before it was renovated is a bit dim but I think it was pretty horrible!
as a kid my memory of the whole area was a bit of a dump

SoulofEuston · 25/03/2022 00:04

I doubt you can speak for everyone hence my post.

As mentioned above I have asked the question myself, I do not know the difference between other large London station and Euston so cannot comment on the exact reasoning I can only state from my experience and observations.

StrawberrySquash · 25/03/2022 00:01

YANBU, OP. That stupid long ramp and the manual ticket checks at the end of it. Just put an inspector on the train! And Euston is a sad gloomy place, although it has a waiting room, so is doing better than London Bridge. I think it's supposed to get some work with HS2?

Changechangychange · 24/03/2022 23:55

@Joinedforthis2021 we all understand the concept of trains being late thank you.

Why is this a problem at Euston but not at Kings Cross or London Bridge do you think? As presumably Kings Cross trains also need to be cleaned and checked, and can’t set off late. But somehow, magically, the station is announced 10-15 mins before departure time.

ButYouBetterNotTakeItFromMe · 24/03/2022 23:49

There is no justifiable excuse for the situation at Euston. Other stations seem to be able to manage. And as a passenger there is nothing you can really do to avoid it. You can be as early as you like but that doesn't help if you're only going to get 2 or 3 minutes to board anyway.
Booking passenger assistance isn't the answer. Aside from the fact that if everyone who has some degree of mobility issue booked they'd be trying to board an awful lot of people early, it's just not practical or desirable for everyone.
90% of the time I am in London it is for work. I don't always know what time I 'm going to finish and therefore which train I will get home. If I happen to get away early,then just like everyone else would, I will try to make it to the earlier train, not sit around waiting for another hour plus so I can be boarded early on the one I've booked.
I don't think it is unreasonable to think that if you arrive at a station say 15 minutes before a train is due that you should be able to walk at a reasonably leisurely pace to the platform and get on it when it's ready. More often than not my experience at Euston is the stampede and then everyone getting into one of the nearest carriages to ensure that they are actually on board when it leaves, then a scrum of people trying to move through the train to find seats and somewhere to put their luggage as it's pulling out of the station. Particularly given what a peak time ticket costs me (well, my employer ) I think the standard of service is appalling. Putting the onus on passengers to book assistance when it shouldn't be needed is ridiculous
That said, WFH has meant I haven't been for ages and I can't say I miss it. My DH went for a face to face meeting for the first time in 2 years this week and said the train was half empty which made it a bit better. He still had to run to catch it though!

DdraigGoch · 24/03/2022 23:43

[quote saraclara]@DdraigGoch I have never, ever been given platform information 15 minutes in advance at Euston, whether it's been to get a train myself or to meet someone from one. I'd say that five is probably closest to the norm.[/quote]
Well quite. If their own documentation says that it takes fifteen minutes to go platform 1 > concourse > platform 16, then they should be allowing at least 10 minutes for concourse > platform.

Never mind that for intercity services, train travel ought to be a relaxing pleasure, not a fevered dash; so you ought to be able to board at any point within a quarter of an hour before departure. I certainly don't remember any mad dash at Paris Gare de l'Est. On the contrary, a sit-down lunch before ambling to my onward TGV.

nodogz · 24/03/2022 23:41

How weird Euston is. I go in to kings cross very regularly and they are pretty good with platforms.

I expect London trains to leave on time though.

However if they are held up on the way back ooop north, the connecting trains will wait for the London trains. And the conductors will tell you the platforms in advance. It's only good manners isn't it?

daimbarsatemydogsbone · 24/03/2022 23:38

Er, don't call me a liar.
I Didn't
That's what happened. A guy from the offices came onto the train after getting complaints and people were asking him what he was going to do. And he said he was going to walk down the train and see if there was anybody who could drive the train. People were rolling their eyes and muttering because it was a ridiculous thing to say. I've got no reason to lie. They're were a dreadful company and they lost their licence.
So now the story has changed from "he did x" to "he said he was going to do x"
Fair enough it happened then, but it was ridiculous because as I said - driving a train isn't like driving a car, get in and know the controls, job done. You have to have route knowledge - it's part of the training.

TrippinEdBalls · 24/03/2022 23:33

@saraclara

Euston must also be a horrible place to work. It's stuffy, gloomy and dreary as well as having the worst concourse information and boarding system that I've ever come across. St Pancras and Kings Cross are incredibly airy and calm places in comparison.

No wonder the staff at Euston are grumpy. They have to spend all day every working day amid the tension and yellowy gloom.

Tbf St Pancras and Kings Cross have both had much more recent love and care than Euston - my memory of King's Cross before it was renovated is a bit dim but I think it was pretty horrible!
SoulofEuston · 24/03/2022 23:33

@ClafoutisSurprise

Ah, I can go to bed happy now *@SoulofEuston*. Counting platform numbers to get to sleep...
1/2/3/4/5/6/7/8/9/10/11/12/13/14/15/16 sleep Wink
DdraigGoch · 24/03/2022 23:32

@HardbackWriter nah, they've got the potential liability of an accident covered with the "no running" signs. You'd need a good lawyer to argue that not running would make catching a train impossible.

Indirect discrimination litigation is the way to go.

TheElderleyBrothers · 24/03/2022 23:29

So looking forward to my Euston to Crewe experience tomorrow. Luckily it's an open return so I can miss lots of trains. Thanks for the heads up OP.Daffodil

SoulofEuston · 24/03/2022 23:28

Apologies I meant boarding closes 2 mins before the train departs

saraclara · 24/03/2022 23:28

@DdraigGoch I have never, ever been given platform information 15 minutes in advance at Euston, whether it's been to get a train myself or to meet someone from one. I'd say that five is probably closest to the norm.