Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To put DD back in nappies after 3 months?

35 replies

Crossfitgirl · 24/03/2022 15:05

DD is 2.5 and we started potty training at Christmas. She did great to start with, a few accidents once we put clothes on her and she went to nursery, but mostly dry if prompted to go.

Then the dribbling started. Dribbling in knickers every single time she needs a wee, she would tell us then run to the potty to do the actual wee - great. This went on for a month or two, I got so fed up of changing knickers I debated putting back in nappies but was advised by nursery not to, she was doing well etc. I went back to pantless at home, tried sticker rewards, and she did seem to respond a bit. Then suddenly she was totally dry for maybe 2-3 weeks.

Now, the dribbling has started again. She is now having some full accidents again too, increasingly refusing to use the potty or toilet, or saying "I don't need a wee" when she's wet herself, tantrums at me trying to get her to use the toilet, always saying no if she needs a wee. I am fed up!!

I have a 7 month old too and it's been great not doing 2 lots of nappies but I just feel SO done with it and I have often lost patience with her which has to be honest probably not helped, but anyway.

Has she come too far to go back to nappies? Should I push on? Should I continue trying with rewards etc? She is SO strong willed and stubborn that I feel like no matter what I do, using the potty and toilet totally depends on her mood, not what approach I use.

It's been 3 months so I almost feel it's a bit unreasonable to go back but I'm also losing the plot with constant battles every day. Would going back to nappies for a bit just make it worse??

Help!!

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Paperyfish · 28/03/2022 22:30

My friend that worked in nurseries used to claim that if you put cotton pants on a toilet training kid then pull ups on top you saved the hassle of clothes changing- but the kid still gets the sensory feedback of the cold damp cotton to reinforce the toilet training message. They’re still in big kid pants- but have a back up. I don’t know though. I must admit I gave up when my boy just didn’t get it after a few weeks. He mastered it quick when he wanted to.

RandomMess · 28/03/2022 22:22

With one of my DC I asked if she liked going to pre-school. when she said "yes" I explained she needed to keep her pants dry then so she did 🤷🏽‍♀️

Another one was dreadful for leaving it as late as possible as she was always immersed in play. I did just remind her that it wasn't ok.

Never did the nagging to go to the toilet they just took themselves.

Anonymous48 · 28/03/2022 21:55

@Crossfitgirl

Just thought I would update, I've put her in pull up nappies. I've carried on prompting her as usual but if she's said she doesn't need it I've just said ok fine and left her alone. She has since happily just taken herself off to the toilet when she's needed to go, with no fuss at all and pretty much kept the nappies dry! Even at nursery today! So long story short, think just taking that pressure off and letting her go on her terms is working and it's an emotional rather than physical thing. Basically if you want your toddler to do something, stop telling them to do it and pretend you don't care and they'll do it 😂
I was going to echo some other posters' suggestion of pull ups, which are a good transitional step between nappies and no protection. It's unfortunate that you started potty training too soon (in hindsight), but going back to nappies probably wouldn't have been helpful. I hope this works for you.

For your next child, don't be in such a hurry!

PurpleNebula84 · 28/03/2022 21:45

If you've got Netflix - episode 9 or 10, Season one of Daniel Tiger's Neighbourhood deals with potty training and has "catchy" song. It might not be the entire answer to potty training issues, but it definitely helped reiterate it to my daughter that when you needed to go, you go and don't hold it in.

RandomMess · 28/03/2022 20:51

That's good progress.

TBH they aren't trained unless you aren't needed!

BrinksmansEntry · 28/03/2022 20:45

My son had accidents once he realised he could hold his wee in. He hated missing out on stuff or being interrupted if he was playing so would hold it in, then dribble once he ws distracted. It was v frustrating as he was dry, just stubborn.

I just reminded him to wee every hour or two. And reminded him he wouldn't miss anything id he went to the toilet. Took blinking months.

Even now at 7 I have to remind him to go to the toilet when he is obviously holding it in.

So I would remind her to go. Often.

Crossfitgirl · 28/03/2022 20:39

Just thought I would update, I've put her in pull up nappies. I've carried on prompting her as usual but if she's said she doesn't need it I've just said ok fine and left her alone. She has since happily just taken herself off to the toilet when she's needed to go, with no fuss at all and pretty much kept the nappies dry! Even at nursery today!
So long story short, think just taking that pressure off and letting her go on her terms is working and it's an emotional rather than physical thing.
Basically if you want your toddler to do something, stop telling them to do it and pretend you don't care and they'll do it 😂

OP posts:
Littlemissprosecco · 24/03/2022 17:16

If she’s refusing nappies then she’s probably able to understand that you don’t want accidents! Try a simple, if you have dry pants by lunchtime we can….. lots of little things, let her chose some. She’ll probably get it quite quickly, then the treats just slowly tail off….. my kids are so embarrassed now when I say do u remember putting a marble in the jar every time pants were dry? Full jar meant as an ice cream, I probably only ever gave them two ice creams!!

Crossfitgirl · 24/03/2022 16:54

I'm gutted as I bought some Mio training pants a few weeks ago, but then she had the really good stint and I thought we'd cracked it so I sold them on. That being said, I only tried them on her and she didn't like them.
She has just got up from her nap a bit ago and wet her pants. I asked her if she wants to put a nappy on, she said flat out NO. So not even sure it'll be another battle trying to get her to wear pull ups! We do already have some - she wears a pull up at bedtime /overnight. I am tempted to just not give her the option tomorrow, put her in pull ups and see how the day goes.

OP posts:
emmsyg · 24/03/2022 16:02

Reusable training pants might be an option in the meantime, they'll at least save you having to change full outfits! Bambino mio and several other companies make them, and they just look like pants so no confusion with nappies!

ponkydonkey · 24/03/2022 15:44

Try cheap pull ups... more like pants but not as absorbent as nappies, so she'll feel a bit damp and might prefer to go back to pants after a while?

But I think psychology if she's constantly having accidents she might not be ready yet and find it all a bit too much pressure

Excited101 · 24/03/2022 15:39

I honestly wouldn’t give any option or choice right now. If you’re putting her back in nappies than back off from the whole toilet thing completely- don’t even mention it. If she wants to go on a toilet then of course take her but unless she’s leading it then I would back off entirely. Once you’re clear a few months or whatever, then have a fresh start at it, and when that’s the time you need to commit 100% and see it through. Kids need clear boundaries and expectations, they need to be able to fully rely on you. I think this will all make your life a lot easier.

Gowithme · 24/03/2022 15:33

Yeah I'd go back to pullups for now - she's still quite young and why make it hard for yourself and her? I remember trying so hard to get my son toilet trained at 2.5 - I went to absolutely ridiculous lengths!! If only I'd just left it and waited a bit longer because he did it when he was ready and not a minute before!

Crossfitgirl · 24/03/2022 15:32

@Groomofthestool we have a where's Wally book! And she loves books. This could be a new thing!

OP posts:
Crossfitgirl · 24/03/2022 15:30

I think the sibling jealousy some of you have mentioned definitely could be part of it. She's much better when I can give her my full attention, but often will misbehave while I'm busy with her sister changing a nappy or feeding her or whatever. I try to give her as much praise as possible when she does go, she has stickers for when she uses the loo or potty but I think the novelty has worn off, plus she needs to want to do it all the time, not just for stickers so I'm not sure how effective overall that is.

OP posts:
Mamibaer · 24/03/2022 15:29

We had a very similar situation- potty trained really well at 2.5 then about 4 months later he started having more and more accidents until he was basically back to not being potty trained at all. After a couple of weeks of that we put him in pull-ups as it was just too stressful, but kept encouraging the toilet. Just before he turned 3 he decided he wanted his big boy pants back on and overnight was using the toilet again. So I’d say just be patient and to try again in a couple of months

Crossfitgirl · 24/03/2022 15:27

@GooglyEyeballs she prefers the potty as she can do it herself, but sometimes wants the toilet. Apparently at nursery only one specific toilet with a coloured toddler seat will do, and she waits for it if it's taken. @Excited101 even I don't know what's best, it's just good to sound it out. I think you're right with the physical but not emotional maturity to do it. I think I somehow need to take the pressure off. Maybe an in-between might work, of giving her the option of a nappy or pants on each day.

@TeaAndBrie sooooo strong willed it is unreal. My patience just can't take it some days! Half of me thinks make it easier for myself as I've got to be their mum and look after them at the end of the day and if my soul has been destroyed by daily potty training meltdowns then I can't be the best me, half of me thinks just do the hard work, but it's gruelling!

OP posts:
MadeForThis · 24/03/2022 15:27

Does she get blackcurrant juice at home?

Groomofthestool · 24/03/2022 15:26

I had a few setbacks with my 2.5 year old DD and she started to get resistant to going into the bathroom at all.
In the end we moved 90% of our books into the loo, just dragged in a shelf and had piles of them everywhere. We have a lot of kids books! Kept some in her room for bedtime but the others were only allowed to be read in the loo. She would happily go in and flick through or call for me to read her one while she used the loo. Where's Wally worked best.

Tamarasnotmyname · 24/03/2022 15:22

Hmmm if she’s fine at nursery and with your husband then it might be worth considering if she does it with you to get extra attention? Sometime sibling jealousy can come out in funny ways.

Bunnycat101 · 24/03/2022 15:21

I think it’s quite common to have a regression. For all of the posters on here saying their child never had any accidents once trained, neither of mine were like that. I think it took at least 6 months to a year for them to be fully independent and reliable (ie without me nagging). My 2yo had a terrible regression in January. She’d been doing so well before that and we were tearing our hair out. For a week she had 4 accidents a day. And then she stopped and became reliable again.

gogohm · 24/03/2022 15:20

Dont go back to nappies but consider reusable pull ups

Crossfitgirl · 24/03/2022 15:20

Thanks @Outfoxedbyrabbits I'll check that out.
@SalmonEile at the moment physically it's easier than nappies. She very consistently goes to the toilet for all poos which is way cleaner than changing a pooey nappy that she's sat in. But the battle to actually get her to wee on the potty drives me insane some days and I just think fuck it I should have just let her wet herself or put her a nappy on! Lol. She has been drier at nursery than at home for a fee weeks and now she's not dry at either. X

OP posts:
GooglyEyeballs · 24/03/2022 15:19

*tough not touch

TeaAndBrie · 24/03/2022 15:18

Definitely don’t go backwards.
The fact that she is okay with it at nursery and with your husband means she can control what she is doing.
If you go back to nappies she has got her way and will make it twice as hard to try again as she will repeat the behaviour.
Lots of praise and patience needed.
I know it’s rough, my DD was (and still is) incredibly strong willed but you need to show her you are taking the lead on this.

Swipe left for the next trending thread