Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Is this amount of compensation for distress reasonable?

211 replies

Wotagain · 24/03/2022 15:00

My Darling husband died suddenly just over 5 weeks ago.
As the executor I had to contact our bank, First Direct about our joint accounts, and then of course send them the interim death certificate proving he had died. ( it’s an interim one as there will be an inquest).
This was all done within a few days and immediately after myself receiving the interim death certificate from the coroners office.
Two weeks later I received a letter from First Direct, addressed to the executor of Wotagain’s estate, sending their condolences on my death and asking for my death certificate.
To say I was upset is a complete understatement, I was devastated, tearful, shaking, and then really, really angry.
My view is the bereavement team at First Direct had one job, to get the name and details of the deceased person right first time, and not send such a letter to a widow numb with grief.

AIBU to ask for £500 as compensation for this distress?

First Direct have offered me £150 which amounts to just over 1p per day for the years that my husband and I banked with them.

OP posts:
StrangeCondition · 24/03/2022 17:32

[quote Wotagain]@MrsCat1
Were you written to, or was your mother written to telling her she had died and asked to send her death certificate when dealing with your father’s estate?

I repeat this is not about letters addressed to my late husband, this was one sent to me, telling me I had died and they needed my death certificate.[/quote]
It was human error, it wasn't intentionally done to hurt you, people make mistakes. You need to stop being angry, accept the apology and the £150 and let it go now

tomsellecksloverug · 24/03/2022 17:30

[quote Wotagain]@MrsCat1
Were you written to, or was your mother written to telling her she had died and asked to send her death certificate when dealing with your father’s estate?

I repeat this is not about letters addressed to my late husband, this was one sent to me, telling me I had died and they needed my death certificate.[/quote]
Actually this happened to my father years back when his own father died. We actually saw the funny side to it considering he was very much alive and it was a clerical error which happens in every single job in the world. What we didn't do was turn into greedy sods and look for compo.

I cannot believe someone who is so bereft and full of grief would be pursuing the bank for 500 big ones after already being offered 150. You are NOT bloody well dead, ,they made a mistake stop making it about money. Christ Almighty.

Wotagain · 24/03/2022 17:26

@MrsCat1 So, do you when you were helping sort out the estate you were also written to and told you had died and they needed your death certificate?
I didn’t realise it was such a frequent mistake.

OP posts:
MrsCat1 · 24/03/2022 17:22

I was written to. I have POA for my mother's affairs. I received all of the communication I mentioned plus a lot more.

Wotagain · 24/03/2022 17:20

@MrsCat1
Were you written to, or was your mother written to telling her she had died and asked to send her death certificate when dealing with your father’s estate?

I repeat this is not about letters addressed to my late husband, this was one sent to me, telling me I had died and they needed my death certificate.

OP posts:
MrsCat1 · 24/03/2022 17:15

I'm so sorry for your loss.
Personally I don't think this should be about money. I've suffered several bereavements in the last year and have had endless mistakes from HSBC, Lloyds and pension companies. Awful mistakes such as sending me a letter saying that there was no spouse's pension for my mother when my DF died. (There was and if I hadn't queried it we would never have known). I've had loads of letters from the banks addressed to the people who died. Ive battled with bureaucracy and incompetence for months. I've spontaneously been offered £150 compensation thee times but for me it is not about the money and I have told them I don't want their money. I understand you are angry, I know we are all different but for me having the opportunity to tell them about the impact of their mistake and getting a proper apology was far more important. And then move on. There are so many things to do when someone dies. Conserve your energy. 💐

Wotagain · 24/03/2022 17:05

My poor mum received loads of "Dear Mr Zingally" after my dear dad died very unexpectedly. Even now, 4 years on, she still gets the odd bit of post for him. Errors happen

Not what I’m complaining about, I was written to telling me I had died. I was asked to send my death certificate

OP posts:
zingally · 24/03/2022 16:42

YANBU to be upset, but £500 is bonkers. A token £50 and a "whoops, we're very sorry" would be completely acceptable.

My poor mum received loads of "Dear Mr Zingally" after my dear dad died very unexpectedly. Even now, 4 years on, she still gets the odd bit of post for him. Errors happen.

I'm so sorry for your loss. Grief is very hard, and it makes us do and say things we'd never normally do. You are directing your upset in the wrong direction.

CousinKrispy · 24/03/2022 16:34

I'm so sorry for your loss, OP. And I'm so sorry you were hurt by this error.

That said, I'm not sure that it's worth it or appropriate to pursue a higher payment. As a massive international bank, £500 may not make that much more of an impression on them than £150, whereas the fight may be quite draining for you.

You're right that the First Direct team should have got it right and not made the error in the first place. But errors do happen. It's worth thinking through some possibilities ... perhaps the person responsible was suffering through their own bad situation but wasn't able to take adequate time off work. Compassion might be called for all round.

It does seem hideously insensitive though.

ForeverLooking · 24/03/2022 16:33

@ReadyToMoveIt

This is a huge, huge company, that deals in money. My feeling is that only money will talk

For such a huge financial company (I work for one), £500 won’t ‘talk’ any more than £150 will, sadly.

This. Adding £500 to an apology doesn't make it more valid or less hurtful. It won't "punish" a huge company to lose £500 or £5000. The acknowledgement of your hurt and distress and that they were wrong is worth far more. The only thing asking for more is going to do is put you in a situation where you are going back and forwards dealing with with something I would imagine you could really do without right now. You must be absolutely raging at life inside understandably and I'm truly sorry you are going through this. As you've said, you will donate the money. Take the £150 and give it to the charity and give yourself a break.
diddl · 24/03/2022 16:32

"I think £150 is crap. The bereavement team have one job - just one job and they fucked up really badly."

I agree.

So many people excusing it.

Well no wonder such things continue!

Mickarooni · 24/03/2022 16:30

” My feeling is that only money will talk.”

£150 or £500 won’t impact upon the bank. Unfortunately, money can’t and won’t stop future human errors. I appreciate you must be feeling so sad and grief stricken and this was the final straw. I am sorry for your loss and wish you peace and comfort in your memories of your husband. Flowers I am sorry for your added distress at such a tough time for you.

tomsellecksloverug · 24/03/2022 16:30

500 quid, you are demanding 500 quid. That's not anger. That's greed. I can't quite get my head around it to be honest. They made a mistake, they offered you £150 but you think that is not enough.

I suppose what is so terribly difficult to convey is how emotionally vulnerable and exhausted I feel, coping with immense grief at a sudden, awful death, and dealing with what to a normal person, ‘not in state of shock’ is a routine admin error

So there is a monetary value on your grief? 500 quid will make you less emotionally vulnerable?

Someone made a mistake, they are trying to apologise by giving you £150 and you are saying that is not enough???

That's not grief, that's grabby. Grief does not look for compensation for mistakes made. Grabby looks for mistakes made to made for compensation.

Ughhh no.

IncompleteSenten · 24/03/2022 16:26

I'm sorry for your loss.

It's unbelievable that companies make these sort of mistakes, it really is. This is one area they should make damned sure they don't make admin errors. Damned sure.

When my dad died my mum notified people as you do. One company wrote back, saying thank you for sending the death certificate, here's the bill, please pay within 7 days.

Addressed to my dad. His full name. Thanking him for sending them his death certificate.

Mum phoned them again. Very upset. They sent a final reminder. Again addressed to my dad!

I ended up sending them a very sarcastic 3 page letter. One page of which was "he is dead" in a variety of languages. One page of euphemisms for death. I also told them when and where we'd be scattering his ashes if they wanted to serve him or anything and advised them to bring a vacuum cleaner.

They wrote back wiping the debt.

Such incompetence at the most distressing time makes you so angry and I think part of that is that anger is less painful than grief.

No money will make you feel better. A heartfelt apology from them might. Flowers

Siepie · 24/03/2022 16:25

YANBU to ask, but they might say no. Will fighting this help how you feel? It will drag out your dealings with the bank, at a time when you're probably already dealing with lots of different organisations. Every time they write with a refusal or a counteroffer, you're going to be reminded of their mistake. Would it be easier for you just to accept the £150 and draw a line under what the bank has done?

cloverlover · 24/03/2022 16:24

Agree with everyone here. Sorry op.

LakieLady · 24/03/2022 16:24

So sorry for your loss, OP.

I lost my partner very suddenly in late 2020, and I know how very vulnerable it made me feel. The slightest thing would cause me to have a meltdown.

I think for the bereavement team, who should be extra careful, to make an error like this is a damn poor show, and £500 wouldn't be unreasonable, imo.

twinsetandpearl · 24/03/2022 16:24

Why do you need £500? Why isn't an apology enough? If they want to offer it's that's fine but to ask for it just comes across as a bit......grubby sorry

ReadyToMoveIt · 24/03/2022 16:23

This is a huge, huge company, that deals in money. My feeling is that only money will talk

For such a huge financial company (I work for one), £500 won’t ‘talk’ any more than £150 will, sadly.

Babyroobs · 24/03/2022 16:23

@AlmostAJillSandwich

I'm so sorry you're hurting, but someone has made a mistake, i don't think it warrants giving you any money at all. Their offer of £150 sounds very generous to me, why do people expect money for nothing these days?
This.
gogohm · 24/03/2022 16:23

Tbh the fact you are on here asking if £150 is sufficient makes you seem very grabby. It's a case of incorrect drop down menu not some callous act, you trying to justify how emotionally vulnerable you are to an anonymous forum makes you seem exactly the opposite. Accept their sincere apologies and the modest compensation. If they don't correct it now then you have a case for a proper claim.

I have a system with drop down menu's, I've personally not made a mistake but I understand how it happens

JennySpanner · 24/03/2022 16:23

How would £500 help you feel better about that?

Wrinklepicker · 24/03/2022 16:22

I can understand how upset and angry you are but I think they have made a reasonable offer to make amends. No figure compensates for losing your husband, which must be truly awful for you and I’m so sorry for your loss. You have so much to deal with at the moment that I would let this go and try to process all the emotional and practical things you need to go through at this awful time Flowers

CarlCarlson · 24/03/2022 16:21

Sorry for your loss but it’s just an admin error

ArtVandalay · 24/03/2022 16:21

Sorry for your loss, but I think you’re being ridiculous. They made a mistake. Is £500 going to make you feel better?

My dad died recently and I’m the executor. I’ve had a few mistakes made by people making contact, not least the undertaker and the hospital! I accepted apologies and just put it behind me.