Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Is this amount of compensation for distress reasonable?

211 replies

Wotagain · 24/03/2022 15:00

My Darling husband died suddenly just over 5 weeks ago.
As the executor I had to contact our bank, First Direct about our joint accounts, and then of course send them the interim death certificate proving he had died. ( it’s an interim one as there will be an inquest).
This was all done within a few days and immediately after myself receiving the interim death certificate from the coroners office.
Two weeks later I received a letter from First Direct, addressed to the executor of Wotagain’s estate, sending their condolences on my death and asking for my death certificate.
To say I was upset is a complete understatement, I was devastated, tearful, shaking, and then really, really angry.
My view is the bereavement team at First Direct had one job, to get the name and details of the deceased person right first time, and not send such a letter to a widow numb with grief.

AIBU to ask for £500 as compensation for this distress?

First Direct have offered me £150 which amounts to just over 1p per day for the years that my husband and I banked with them.

OP posts:
DrWhoNowww · 24/03/2022 18:27

@girlmom21

I actually think mistakenly asking for your death certificate is much less upsetting than companies insisting on speaking to the deceased - which is much more common.
Second this.

I have a fairly macabre sense of humour so would find it funny that they had written to me to tell me I was dead.

I’m sorry for your loss but I think you’re projecting your feelings of grief on what is simply a clerical error.

AfraidToRun · 24/03/2022 18:24

I've worked in bereavement centres before I found it very difficult. I was constantly in tears because it's such an emotional job. One of the reasons I left. I tried very hard not to make mistakes but it does happen and I found the environment where the consequences for being human meant a lot of suffering for everyone very difficult to manage. I've moved on to pastures new but it is a difficult job if you are an empath.

I wish you well OP and you have my deepest sympathy.

rwalker · 24/03/2022 18:21

I'd take the £150 tbh I'm surprised they offered that much.

It's going to be far more grief and upset to challenge it

CailleachGranda · 24/03/2022 18:21

[quote Wotagain]@MrsCat1
Were you written to, or was your mother written to telling her she had died and asked to send her death certificate when dealing with your father’s estate?

I repeat this is not about letters addressed to my late husband, this was one sent to me, telling me I had died and they needed my death certificate.[/quote]
And you want £500 for that?

2022HereWeCome · 24/03/2022 18:17

What are you going to do with the money OP? Personally I think £150 is reasonable - I can understand you're upset but you are making no allowances here for staff who may be under pressure because they are short-staffed because of Covid, or whatever. To me you are coming across as a bit grabby.

ArtVandalay · 24/03/2022 18:13

I wonder if Mark Twain tried to get compensation 🤔

Anyway, the bereavement team absolutely need to get it right. But expecting £500 compensation is, frankly, disproportionate. I hate this culture of expecting financial recompense when an apology should suffice.

Porcupineintherough · 24/03/2022 18:13

Sometimes in grief we lash out, or fix on something relatively trivial (compared to the loss itself) on which to focus our grief. Do you think that might be the case here?

Ultimately if you think it will help, go for it. But if they say no, will it make you feel worse? And is fighting this going to help, or use up precious energy?

AnneElliott · 24/03/2022 18:06

@LosingTheWill2022

The bereavement team have one job - just one job and they fucked up really badly Do you honestly believe that the bereavement team does nothing other than update a database with the name of the deceased?
No, they obviously have lots of admin jobs involving bereavement and in doing so they need to make doubly sure that mistakes like this don't happen!
TheUndoingProject · 24/03/2022 18:04

I’ve been bereaved several times and wanting £500 for an admin error seems really excessive. Presumably you know damn fine that you’re not dead so I’m surprised you found that so distressing?

ArtVandalay · 24/03/2022 18:03

I actually think mistakenly asking for your death certificate is much less upsetting than companies insisting on speaking to the deceased - which is much more common.

I agree.

Abra1d1 · 24/03/2022 18:02

When my daughter was born the (broadsheet, quality) newspaper put her birth announcement under Deaths instead of Births.

They sent me a bunch of flowers and said sorry. I was obviously pretty hormonal at the time and was very upset, but it was a genuine mistake, they were sorry, they apologised. End of.

Amei · 24/03/2022 18:00

I used to work in the bereavement department of a different bank. I remember once when someone accidentally removed the surviving party from the joint account and left it solely in the deceased name, and then wrote to the deceased person to advice they had removed the surviving party from the account. Mistakes happen but it doesn't take away the upset it has caused.

They are also usually very good at accepting the error though and giving compensation where necessary, I'm just not sure if £500 is too much. They will have limits as to what they can give for the distress caused (like what you have experienced) and the inconvenience caused (if you experienced parking costs whilst been in the bank ect). You could respond saying it's not a sufficient amount for the distress that they have caused, the worst that can happen now is that they say £150 is the most the will give and they will not increase the compensation.

Sorry for your loss xx

bloodywhitecat · 24/03/2022 17:53

My husband died recently, to verify his death we had to call 111 who sent a GP. The next day a text came to his phone (and no, we hadn't used his phone to call 111) asking him to rate the service he'd been given, I was bloody furious. The NHS had let him down from start to finish and now a text when he was dead felt like the final kick in the teeth. I got an apology but no amount of compensation will account for their error. I'd accept the £150 and give it to charity.

Sprig1 · 24/03/2022 17:48

Sorry to hear this happened but I am not sure how you think financial compensation will help? Banks employ humans, humans make mistakes. I think it will be less stressful just to try and forget about it and move on.

Redglitter · 24/03/2022 17:45

Sorry but you are being ridiculous. You're going through a horrible ordeal dealing with your husbands death but your reaction to a genuine admin mistake isn't proportionate. Sounds like you're taking your grief and anger out on this one issue.

The fact they've offered you anything is generous & asking or expecting more imo takes away from the complaint & just makes you look grabby

A similar thing happened when my Dad died, a letter came addressed really badly & upset my Mum enormously. I phoned the bank, spoke to someone in charge, they agreed it was unacceptable and apologised. A few days later my Mum got a very nice letter in the post, an apology & an assurance it had been flagged up to try and prevent it happening again. We felt that was a totally appropriate course of action and that was it

Just accept the £150 & accept it for what it was - an unfortunate human error

notanothertakeaway · 24/03/2022 17:43

@girlmom21

I actually think mistakenly asking for your death certificate is much less upsetting than companies insisting on speaking to the deceased - which is much more common.
Absolutely this

OP, it's a stupid mistake, unacceptable, but £150 sounds quite generous to me

ReadyToMoveIt · 24/03/2022 17:42

[quote Wotagain]@MrsCat1
Were you written to, or was your mother written to telling her she had died and asked to send her death certificate when dealing with your father’s estate?

I repeat this is not about letters addressed to my late husband, this was one sent to me, telling me I had died and they needed my death certificate.[/quote]
I personally don’t see how that is any more distressing than having letters addressed to a dead loved one after the company has been informed of their death. It’s an obvious administrative error (that shouldn’t have been made, but errors happen).

girlmom21 · 24/03/2022 17:41

@Soontobe60 it literally says the OP's name instead of her husbands. They pressed the wrong name on the screen.

Soontobe60 · 24/03/2022 17:40

[quote Wotagain]@MrsCat1
Were you written to, or was your mother written to telling her she had died and asked to send her death certificate when dealing with your father’s estate?

I repeat this is not about letters addressed to my late husband, this was one sent to me, telling me I had died and they needed my death certificate.[/quote]
It doesn’t make sense. Perhaps you could post a redacted copy of the letter?

Soontobe60 · 24/03/2022 17:37

My mother died very suddenly a month ago. I am the executor of her estate. When I rang round everyone who needed to know, several of the companies told me in advance that some mailings may well be despatched inadvertently as the systems they use isn’t completely instant. I understood. I don’t believe any company would knowingly send anything out to a dead person. I think your response is understandable but your desire to get compensation of any amount is not.

StrangeCondition · 24/03/2022 17:36

@girlmom21

I actually think mistakenly asking for your death certificate is much less upsetting than companies insisting on speaking to the deceased - which is much more common.
Agreed
Parky04 · 24/03/2022 17:35

Sorry for your loss.

They don't have to offer you anything so £150 is very reasonable.

LosingTheWill2022 · 24/03/2022 17:34

@Wotagain I think your last couple of posts illustrate how subjective these things can be.
You seem to be saying that receiving a letter requesting your death certificate was more distressing than someone else receiving a letter addressed to their deceased loved one.

These are things that can't be simply measured and quantified.

The errors should not have happened in any of these situations but individuals will react in many and varied ways.

TidyDancer · 24/03/2022 17:34

I'm really sorry for your loss, but I do think they've been reasonable with their offer. I can understand why you're lashing out but I very much doubt additional money would made you feel better even if the situation warranted it. It's a clerical error, it's hurt you and in the circumstances it's obvious why it's done that, but this isn't a deliberate act.

girlmom21 · 24/03/2022 17:33

I actually think mistakenly asking for your death certificate is much less upsetting than companies insisting on speaking to the deceased - which is much more common.