Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Is this amount of compensation for distress reasonable?

211 replies

Wotagain · 24/03/2022 15:00

My Darling husband died suddenly just over 5 weeks ago.
As the executor I had to contact our bank, First Direct about our joint accounts, and then of course send them the interim death certificate proving he had died. ( it’s an interim one as there will be an inquest).
This was all done within a few days and immediately after myself receiving the interim death certificate from the coroners office.
Two weeks later I received a letter from First Direct, addressed to the executor of Wotagain’s estate, sending their condolences on my death and asking for my death certificate.
To say I was upset is a complete understatement, I was devastated, tearful, shaking, and then really, really angry.
My view is the bereavement team at First Direct had one job, to get the name and details of the deceased person right first time, and not send such a letter to a widow numb with grief.

AIBU to ask for £500 as compensation for this distress?

First Direct have offered me £150 which amounts to just over 1p per day for the years that my husband and I banked with them.

OP posts:
Wotagain · 24/03/2022 21:56

[quote DesignerRecliner]@Wotagain you've had no 'material loss', you've not had a financial detriment. The trouble and upset occurred on receiving communication in the wrong name - which would absolutely be upsetting. But for purely distress and upset, I would award £100-150, and I've been with FOS for 6 years, so have seen plenty of similar cases [/quote]
Gosh, I’m shocked that you’ve seen plenty of similar cases.
So are you saying that it’s fairly common for financial institutions to write to people who have recently been bereaved, telling the recipient of the letter that they are the dead person?
If that’s the case, what an indictment of the industry, how sloppy.

OP posts:
uggmum · 24/03/2022 21:55

This particular mistake was made by an individual that was working your account. As yours was a joint account they have gone into the wrong id when they have sent the letter. (No excuse but this was a human error)

I would imagine that they feel really bad about it.

I don't think £150 is unreasonable. There will be a limit that they offer before you would get a final response to enable you to pass this to the ombudsman.

You could probably push it a bit. Highlight your long term relationship and distress and decline the £150. That may push them up a bit.

VodselForDinner · 24/03/2022 21:53

I’m very sorry about your husband, it’s a devastating loss.

However, you’re lashing out at people. That’s fine, it’s normal. Anger is part of grief. You’re understandably angry at the bank, but unless they’re fined £5m, it’s not really going to impact them at all. You’re the one who’ll come away feeling exhausted and angry.

Sadly, no amount of compensation will make up for the loss of your husband so please don’t spend more time on this issue than is healthy for you.

ReadyToMoveIt · 24/03/2022 21:52

You’ve nailed it by saying it’s not grabbiness, it’s conveying that customers at their most vulnerable need effective processes that do not cause additional distress

It was human error. It wasn’t ‘the organisation’, it was one person who I am sure is very sorry for the mistake they made.
If £500 will make you feel better, then ask for it. It’s unlikely to be awarded, but you can only ask.

MistressoftheDarkSide · 24/03/2022 21:51

@Wotagain

Tea and cake most appreciated - even the occasional Gin xxxx

It's a horrible club to be in x I wish we both weren't....... hugs.

Darbs76 · 24/03/2022 21:50

I’m sorry for your loss. I don’t understand why £500 would make up for it anymore than £150. An apology is surely sufficient. These things happen in admin and whilst distressing I struggle to see why money would make that easier to bear? It’s done, they apologise, they will definitely do it again, and move on.

HTH1 · 24/03/2022 21:47

Sorry for your loss OP but I don’t think it’s reasonable to ask for/expect money for this admin error. I know you’re hurting (and I understand how difficult it is as I lost both parents, with whom I was extremely close, at a young age) but you are massively projecting onto this company and essentially blaming them for your upset feelings surrounding the bereavement.

It doesn’t seem like it now, but time is a great healer and you should try to let go of things like this which cause you distress at this already very difficult time.

Beautifulmonster87 · 24/03/2022 21:47

@Wotagain

I suppose what is so terribly difficult to convey is how emotionally vulnerable and exhausted I feel, coping with immense grief at a sudden, awful death, and dealing with what to a normal person, ‘not in state of shock’ is a routine admin error.
Sorry for your loss but why would £500 make you feel better? It was clearly a mistake but why would money change how you feel?
Wotagain · 24/03/2022 21:47

[quote MistressoftheDarkSide]@Wotagain

My beloved DP passed on 25th January. I'm posting to say i hear you, completely and utterly. Your world is shattered and what remains of it can't even function efficiently to allow you to the things demanded of you in terms of red tape when you are gritting your teeth, trying to be polite, trying to be as efficient as you can, trying to be mindful of other people and their grief......it goes on and on and there is no way to escape. It's not grabbiness, it's trying to get across to an institution that their customers, at their most vulnerable, require effective administration processes that do not cause additional distress, and sometimes it takes a swift kick to the wallet for them to really take notice. You have been distressed and inconvenienced, due to shoddy processes.

During my "grief journey / process" I have encountered and been told of many such instances - given that many people die every day and processes are pretty standard, attention to detail should be top of the list.

I too have an interim death certificate. When it came through, it had an out of date address by 20 odd years on it. I had corrected it at the first hospital he was at, and the second. And speaking to the coroners office. Multiple times. Getting new certificates with the correct address on delayed release of my DP for burial. Not only that, but the address was incorrect online for the Tell Us Once thing. So I rang the coroners who were going to email me a new reference number. Embroiled with funeral arrangements I chased it up this week. I am still waiting.

I have been transferring direct debits from my DPs account before it gets sorted out. Utilities, that sort of thing. Mostly fine. Except our water supply company won't do it without seeing a death certificate. Which I have emailed to them. Standard response time according to the automatic reply - 10 days, but they are very busy so it might take longer. If I get any grief over lack of payment when his account goes out of action, they'll get the rough end of my tongue.

So, OP rage away. It is part if the grieving process for sure, especially when a loss is out of the blue and sends you reeling. No-one gets to tell anyone else how they "do grief", no-one gets to judge or set time limits or question whether your being rational or proportionate because love and grief have their own kind of madness that has to work itself out in it's own time. Rushing it, suppressing it, hiding it - these things store up problems of their own and can prolong the agony even more.

I send you love OP, and absolute solidarity Flowers[/quote]
Thank you, and I’m so sorry you ‘get it too’, I’m overwhelmed with flowers, can I send you cake and tea instead?

You’ve nailed it by saying it’s not grabbiness, it’s conveying that customers at their most vulnerable need effective processes that do not cause additional distress.

OP posts:
ForeverLooking · 24/03/2022 21:43

[quote MistressoftheDarkSide]@Wotagain

My beloved DP passed on 25th January. I'm posting to say i hear you, completely and utterly. Your world is shattered and what remains of it can't even function efficiently to allow you to the things demanded of you in terms of red tape when you are gritting your teeth, trying to be polite, trying to be as efficient as you can, trying to be mindful of other people and their grief......it goes on and on and there is no way to escape. It's not grabbiness, it's trying to get across to an institution that their customers, at their most vulnerable, require effective administration processes that do not cause additional distress, and sometimes it takes a swift kick to the wallet for them to really take notice. You have been distressed and inconvenienced, due to shoddy processes.

During my "grief journey / process" I have encountered and been told of many such instances - given that many people die every day and processes are pretty standard, attention to detail should be top of the list.

I too have an interim death certificate. When it came through, it had an out of date address by 20 odd years on it. I had corrected it at the first hospital he was at, and the second. And speaking to the coroners office. Multiple times. Getting new certificates with the correct address on delayed release of my DP for burial. Not only that, but the address was incorrect online for the Tell Us Once thing. So I rang the coroners who were going to email me a new reference number. Embroiled with funeral arrangements I chased it up this week. I am still waiting.

I have been transferring direct debits from my DPs account before it gets sorted out. Utilities, that sort of thing. Mostly fine. Except our water supply company won't do it without seeing a death certificate. Which I have emailed to them. Standard response time according to the automatic reply - 10 days, but they are very busy so it might take longer. If I get any grief over lack of payment when his account goes out of action, they'll get the rough end of my tongue.

So, OP rage away. It is part if the grieving process for sure, especially when a loss is out of the blue and sends you reeling. No-one gets to tell anyone else how they "do grief", no-one gets to judge or set time limits or question whether your being rational or proportionate because love and grief have their own kind of madness that has to work itself out in it's own time. Rushing it, suppressing it, hiding it - these things store up problems of their own and can prolong the agony even more.

I send you love OP, and absolute solidarity Flowers[/quote]
Flowers wonderful post which I hope the OP finds comforting.
Much love to you both on your losses.
Op, I don't know if you are on the bereavement board already but you might find some support and understanding there.

WeCouldBeSpearows · 24/03/2022 21:42

@Wotagain

An award of over £300 and up to around £750 might be fair where the impact of a mistake has caused considerable distress, upset and worry
Did you look at the examples given?

The one closest to your circumstances is the one where the bank accidentally closed the bank account of the wrong identical twin. They got between £100 and £300, and imo that's likely to have caused more (non emotional) issues than the circumstances you describe.

The ones that get up to £750 are either repeated issues or ones that cause hardship - fraud not dealt with appropriately or an insurance claim not dealt with correctly.

I think it's incredibly unlikely that an ombudsman would put you in that bracket based on both the website and what you've said.

As I said before, is this fight really a good use of your time right now?

If you are determined to try to get more, maybe you should suggest that instead of compensating you, they donated the £500 that you are looking for to a charity that you choose. They might go for that.

ButtockUp · 24/03/2022 21:39

I'm so sorry for your loss but I do feel that this was a genuine mistake.
I do t believe that it warrants compensation.

DesignerRecliner · 24/03/2022 21:38

@Wotagain you've had no 'material loss', you've not had a financial detriment. The trouble and upset occurred on receiving communication in the wrong name - which would absolutely be upsetting. But for purely distress and upset, I would award £100-150, and I've been with FOS for 6 years, so have seen plenty of similar cases

Fatgalslim · 24/03/2022 21:38

I agree you need to step back now, you asked if YWBU and most people say you are. You've had an apology and an offer of compensation, more money isn't going to make a difference.

MistressoftheDarkSide · 24/03/2022 21:37

@Wotagain

My beloved DP passed on 25th January. I'm posting to say i hear you, completely and utterly. Your world is shattered and what remains of it can't even function efficiently to allow you to the things demanded of you in terms of red tape when you are gritting your teeth, trying to be polite, trying to be as efficient as you can, trying to be mindful of other people and their grief......it goes on and on and there is no way to escape. It's not grabbiness, it's trying to get across to an institution that their customers, at their most vulnerable, require effective administration processes that do not cause additional distress, and sometimes it takes a swift kick to the wallet for them to really take notice. You have been distressed and inconvenienced, due to shoddy processes.

During my "grief journey / process" I have encountered and been told of many such instances - given that many people die every day and processes are pretty standard, attention to detail should be top of the list.

I too have an interim death certificate. When it came through, it had an out of date address by 20 odd years on it. I had corrected it at the first hospital he was at, and the second. And speaking to the coroners office. Multiple times. Getting new certificates with the correct address on delayed release of my DP for burial. Not only that, but the address was incorrect online for the Tell Us Once thing. So I rang the coroners who were going to email me a new reference number. Embroiled with funeral arrangements I chased it up this week. I am still waiting.

I have been transferring direct debits from my DPs account before it gets sorted out. Utilities, that sort of thing. Mostly fine. Except our water supply company won't do it without seeing a death certificate. Which I have emailed to them. Standard response time according to the automatic reply - 10 days, but they are very busy so it might take longer. If I get any grief over lack of payment when his account goes out of action, they'll get the rough end of my tongue.

So, OP rage away. It is part if the grieving process for sure, especially when a loss is out of the blue and sends you reeling. No-one gets to tell anyone else how they "do grief", no-one gets to judge or set time limits or question whether your being rational or proportionate because love and grief have their own kind of madness that has to work itself out in it's own time. Rushing it, suppressing it, hiding it - these things store up problems of their own and can prolong the agony even more.

I send you love OP, and absolute solidarity Flowers

AgathaTrunchbull1 · 24/03/2022 21:35

It seems clear you’re grief at your loss has caused misplaced anger at an admin error from a banking institution and now you want to ‘make them pay’ I don’t think this thread is going to be useful to you as you are not thinking clearly and just getting angry at posters who are pointing this out which can’t be good for you.

ADayAlwaysHasToEnd · 24/03/2022 21:34

I also work for a bank. And £150 would be the sort of offer we would also make. As it was a one of admin error

ChateauxNeufDePoop · 24/03/2022 21:32

@Wotagain

Again, for those hard of reading and comprehension skills: My husband died I sent the requisite information confirming his death The bank contacted me, sending condolences that I had died, and asking for my death certificate I couldn’t see anything laughable in this scenario My ‘grabby’ sense of humour failed to come into play, you know, what with being recently bereaved and all that It is not about the money, it’s the rather awful failure to check basic information and do one job properly

But my arse has been handed to me, and according to MN, IABU for expecting people, I mean a massive international profitable financial institution, to do their one job properly when dealing with customers at the worst time in their life

I'm so sorry for your loss but you come across more and more unreasonable and clueless with each post.

I would imagine, irrespective of the size of the organisation, that this role is fulfilled by regular admin people who will make mistakes. In a milk delivery company they may send someone two pints one day instead of three. In a garage they may book two cars in for an MOT on the same day. In this instance, whilst the ramifications are bigger on an emotional scale it's a genuine human error.

Tohaveandtohold · 24/03/2022 21:30

I’m sorry for your loss OP and your upset.
However if they offer you £150 and you refuse it, If you go to the ombudsman, you’ll certainly not get any more than that. They’ll deem the bank’s stance is fair. They always advice banks on the minimum they can pay for emotional distress and once that’s met, they deem the bank’s stance as fair.
However, from the post, I can see that you’ll keep at it but imo, £500 seems grabby.

Wotagain · 24/03/2022 21:30

An award of over £300 and up to around £750 might be fair where the impact of a mistake has caused considerable distress, upset and worry

OP posts:
Wotagain · 24/03/2022 21:25

@DesignerRecliner

Financial ombudsman investigator here - I would put this at anywhere between £100-200, £500 is not warranted & to award that there would need to be pretty massive impact from the mistake.

I'm sorry for you loss Thanks

Interesting, and massive impact is measured how?
OP posts:
ForeverLooking · 24/03/2022 21:25

I don't think your arse has been handed to you at all. The vast majority of posts have been genuinely sympathetic and concerned for your mental health and wellbeing and the impact on you of pursuing further compensation that might not go your way. It's difficult to compose an answer to such a sad and upsetting post when you disagree as obviously it's going to upset an already distressed person.
You need to do what you feel you need to do. If that's chasing further compensation then do it. The fact that people have a different opinion doesn't have to stop you. Not one person is saying it's OK you have been upset by this and you were not owed an apology. I think it may be best for you to get this deleted as it's upsetting you more and I'm sure this is the last thing you need. Take care of yourself.

Wotagain · 24/03/2022 21:24

@luxxlisbon

I honestly think I would just find it so random/ funny if the letter expressed sympathy for me dying! But I get that it me, and if you were upset then you are absolutely entitled to feel so.

It’s strange to me that an apology and £150 doesn’t help but you think an extra £350 will.

I think you are focusing on the wrong thing here, just leave it, this is not the root cause of your anguish and although it might keep you busy for a few days to chase this complaint I guarantee you won’t even feel better with £500.

So your husband is dead is he?

Yes, I have laughed so much these past few weeks remembering happy times, but this error has not induced mirth.

OP posts:
EinsteinaGogo · 24/03/2022 21:21

It's a really horrible error, OP.

I'm so sorry for your loss.

DesignerRecliner · 24/03/2022 21:20

Financial ombudsman investigator here - I would put this at anywhere between £100-200, £500 is not warranted & to award that there would need to be pretty massive impact from the mistake.

I'm sorry for you loss Thanks