Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Is this amount of compensation for distress reasonable?

211 replies

Wotagain · 24/03/2022 15:00

My Darling husband died suddenly just over 5 weeks ago.
As the executor I had to contact our bank, First Direct about our joint accounts, and then of course send them the interim death certificate proving he had died. ( it’s an interim one as there will be an inquest).
This was all done within a few days and immediately after myself receiving the interim death certificate from the coroners office.
Two weeks later I received a letter from First Direct, addressed to the executor of Wotagain’s estate, sending their condolences on my death and asking for my death certificate.
To say I was upset is a complete understatement, I was devastated, tearful, shaking, and then really, really angry.
My view is the bereavement team at First Direct had one job, to get the name and details of the deceased person right first time, and not send such a letter to a widow numb with grief.

AIBU to ask for £500 as compensation for this distress?

First Direct have offered me £150 which amounts to just over 1p per day for the years that my husband and I banked with them.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
ReadyToMoveIt · 25/03/2022 10:40

@Pandypuff

I'm really sorry for your loss but this was just an error. Someone probably got fired or severely disciplined for this. I don't see how the name being wrong was particularly distressing for you, or how any money can change the fact that they got the name wrong. You're understandably devastated about your husband but, gently, this was just a mistake and it's really not a reasonable request to demand money for it. I'm shocked they're even offering £150 to be honest! I'd be offering an apology but don't consider money suitable or necessary. Sorry Blush
No one will have been fired, unless it was the latest of a series of performance issues for which disciplinary procedure has been followed.
Pandypuff · 25/03/2022 10:37

I'm really sorry for your loss but this was just an error. Someone probably got fired or severely disciplined for this. I don't see how the name being wrong was particularly distressing for you, or how any money can change the fact that they got the name wrong. You're understandably devastated about your husband but, gently, this was just a mistake and it's really not a reasonable request to demand money for it. I'm shocked they're even offering £150 to be honest! I'd be offering an apology but don't consider money suitable or necessary. Sorry Blush

GETTINGLIKEMYMOTHER · 25/03/2022 10:18

I’m so sorry for your loss.
It was a shocking mistake, and whoever is responsible ought to get a right royal bollocking - and I’d want to be assured that this had happened and that some extra training was going to take place ASAP - but TBH I’d have thought that £150 was enough.

ReadyToMoveIt · 25/03/2022 10:13

Obviously if the desire is simply to get £500 rather than £150, then by all means ask.

ReadyToMoveIt · 25/03/2022 10:11

@Branleuse

so what is peoples problem with it then, if OP feels that compensation is appropriate and its not going to be some poor old lady that has to give it out.

People in the UK are so weird about compensation

They have offered compensation… £150, which is consistent with the financial ombudsman guidelines for this sort of error. The OP is perfectly entitled to ask for more if she wants it, although it’s likely to be refused due to said guidelines. My point was just that asking for £500 won’t ‘hurt’ the organisation (or the employee who made the mistake) any more than the £150 would. So if the desire is to teach them a lesson for their mistake, asking for £500 won’t do that. They will just continue to follow their compensation procedures.
Branleuse · 25/03/2022 10:07

so what is peoples problem with it then, if OP feels that compensation is appropriate and its not going to be some poor old lady that has to give it out.

People in the UK are so weird about compensation

Everydaydayisaschoolday · 25/03/2022 10:06

I'm very sorry for your loss. Sorting out financial affairs is a nightmare at the best of times and I'm sure even more so when you are grieving.

I know when my dad died we had so many instances like this that we almost lost track in the end. Big companies should definitely put more effort and training so staff deal with these issues better.

That being said I think YABU making this about money. Let it go. Take the £150 and spend it on something your husband would like - a treat for yourself or a donation to a cause he supported. Don't let their mistake make your life any harder than it already is.

ReadyToMoveIt · 25/03/2022 10:04

@Branleuse

I think they should compensate you, and I dont think youre unreasonable at all. They should be acting with precision and with compassion in these circumstances. Maybe they need reminding that they are dealing with real people
They know they are dealing with real people. Mistakes still happen though, humans make errors in all professions. £500 won’t serve as any more of a ‘reminder’ to them than £150 will. It doesn’t come out of the pocket of the person who made the mistake, it comes from the coffers of a multi million pound organisation.
Branleuse · 25/03/2022 09:59

I think they should compensate you, and I dont think youre unreasonable at all. They should be acting with precision and with compassion in these circumstances. Maybe they need reminding that they are dealing with real people

Yants · 25/03/2022 09:08

You're obviously allowing your grief to overcome your judgment in this matter, which I suppose is understandable.

DogInATent · 25/03/2022 08:48

I'm hoping the OP has taken the advice given above and walked away from the thread.

But to the very few respondents that are saying that it's not just a simple mistake - the important detail here is that it's a joint account, that has both names attached. The bank is under pressure to not delay dealing with such matters so as not to be the ones holding up probate resulting in the accounts being frozen for longer than necessary. Some people may not realise this, but when someone dies all their accounts including joint accounts they are a signatory to are frozen until probate is concluded. This can be a major problem for couples that hold all their cash in joint accounts.

The compensation offered seems adequate to most respondents. To push for £500 you would need to be extremely confident that your instructions to the bank at a time of emotional stress were absolutely clear and unambiguous.

There's a reason that it's advised to think very carefully before appointing a spouse or partner as sole executor. It's not something I would choose to put upon my spouse.

Suzi888 · 25/03/2022 07:55

@AlmostAJillSandwich

I'm so sorry you're hurting, but someone has made a mistake, i don't think it warrants giving you any money at all. Their offer of £150 sounds very generous to me, why do people expect money for nothing these days?
^ Agree with this. YABU

I’m sorry for your loss Flowers

Soontobe60 · 25/03/2022 07:54

@Wheniruletheworld

Dear *@Wotagain*, please step away from here for a while. I've read 8 pages of comments, most of which think you are in the wrong. Clearly these are upsetting you as your responses show; you are grieving, you are trying to deal with an appalling and unexpected experience, but asking the question you did in such a forum was perhaps a mistake at this time. People may have been more sympathetic if you had done this in a few months, a common point being that it's too soon to be considering compo. We all grieve, we all focus on something to help us grieve, be it rational, irrational, or weird to those not grieving; one would hope others would understand that, but some responses here prove that is not the case, and this is fuelling your anger and grief. Step away from AIBU...
Perfectly put
HappyMiddleChild · 25/03/2022 06:53

How would £150 or £500 alleviate the distress caused? Why do you feel a monetary award is necessary? A reassurance that the person making the error had been reprimanded and a procedure being implemented so it doesn’t happen again would make more sense.

cptartapp · 25/03/2022 06:45

When my DM was killed suddenly in an accident I was executor of her estate, and there were 'admin' errors by large institutions along the way.
The horror and trauma of her death made me feel the opposite, and I found that in perspective, we are all fallable and in the scheme of things I became far more tolerant and felt that some things just don't really matter.

Workinghardeveryday · 25/03/2022 06:33

I am so sorry for your loss xxx

Meandthesky · 25/03/2022 06:26

YABU

£500 in FOS guidelines would be for a serious, ongoing issue causing significant distress. Obviously you are significantly distressed but that’s due to your grief more than the one error that they have presumably corrected as part of resolving your complaint. £150 is reasonable in this situation.

Wheniruletheworld · 25/03/2022 06:26

Dear @Wotagain, please step away from here for a while. I've read 8 pages of comments, most of which think you are in the wrong. Clearly these are upsetting you as your responses show; you are grieving, you are trying to deal with an appalling and unexpected experience, but asking the question you did in such a forum was perhaps a mistake at this time. People may have been more sympathetic if you had done this in a few months, a common point being that it's too soon to be considering compo.
We all grieve, we all focus on something to help us grieve, be it rational, irrational, or weird to those not grieving; one would hope others would understand that, but some responses here prove that is not the case, and this is fuelling your anger and grief.
Step away from AIBU...

Mabelface · 25/03/2022 06:20

I deal with complaints for an insurer. £500 is definitely in the bracket of compensation for an error like this.

Carpy899 · 25/03/2022 06:20

Is 500 quid really going to make you feel any better about it? Probably not. Mistakes happen and this happened to you at an unfortunate time but it wasn't done with any malice.

MMAMPWGHAP · 25/03/2022 05:51

I’m no expert here but have been dealing with my elderly parents finances for a couple of years with numerous financial institutions.
I’ve had a wide variety of errors happen.
After my Dad died I received a letter similar to yours stating effectively that my brother had died.
The magic words in any of these cases are ‘I wish to register a formal complaint’.
If the company does not deal with it to your satisfaction and you take it to the next level (ie to the ombudsman) it is my understanding that IT WILL COST THEM £750 (that’s how the Ombudsman service is funded). Far more than you have been offered.
I now always raise errors as complaints and will be asking for higher amounts than the £100 I received only yesterday for the latest cock up.

Zingy123 · 25/03/2022 05:43

£150 is more than generous of them. It was a simple mistake. Why do you feel you should be compensated with £500 for a simple error? It's just greed.

Planetbippop · 25/03/2022 05:28

I'm genuinely shocked that bereavement teams regularly make monumental errors like this & that people are so accepting of it as a simple 'admin error'.

They are called a bereavement teams for a reason. Their training, processes etc, should be robust in ensuring basic checks like who has died & who the executor is, are of paramount importance. It's sloppy & shows a complete lack of respect & attention to detail. Quite frankly, if they can't accurately identify the deceased, I'd be bloody doubtful anything else they did was accurate.

Clearly the bereavement team at First Direct, don't understand what bereavement is, how the bereavement process affects those left behind having to deal with these matters or the profound effect these 'simple errors' errors can have on someone.

@Wotagain I'm so sorry for your loss & that this has happened. The bank needs a rocket up it's backside, I'm glad you've felt able to launch it! 🫖🍰🍸

wombat1a · 25/03/2022 05:20

Sorry for your loss,

500 YABU, take the 150 with good grace.

Loginmystery · 25/03/2022 04:16

I honestly cannot believe how many posters here think the OP is asking for a lot! 500 is completely reasonable and it is not ok to say that it’s a simple clerical error. This should not be happening- time and again by the sounds of some of you here- it’s unacceptable and 500 is absolutely reasonable to ask for. Bloody hell you lot.
I’m with you OP. Sorry once again.