Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

People who dont smile at you when you smile

135 replies

PeterandSandy · 24/03/2022 14:40

Most people smile if you smile at them when out.

The other day i did and the person looked away without smiling.

Wonder what that was about?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
grapewines · 26/03/2022 12:52

@saveforthat

I can see that *@MurmuratingStarling has some issues and should probably stsy away from AIBU and seek some help irl so I will stop responding to her nonsense posts. Just for the rest of you (become she's ghosted me!) I am 100% woman and have never once dictated how women should behave, I just expect everyone male female and anything else they call themselves to have some basic human manners. @MedusasBadHairDay* has it exactly right.
She was right, and calling someone a miserable cow is not having manners or any high ground.
MurmuratingStarling · 25/03/2022 19:17

@ddl1 and @Butchyrestingface thank you. Flowers

Not content with hurling horrible misogynistic remarks at me, that poster (saveforthat,) has followed it up by saying I am not right in the head and need to see a therapist. She really is an insufferable and unpleasant person, and that is why I refuse to acknowledge her now.

Gone a bit quiet after being called out by you both though! Probably for the best. She really needs to stop posting on this thread now; she's embarrassing herself, and is making herself look like a very rude and unpleasant person. Ironic really, seeing as how she is presenting herself as Mrs Lovely-Smiley-Pants on this thread. LOL! Yeah right!!!

JesusSufferingFuck22 · 25/03/2022 15:07

I live in a small town and the vast majority when out walking/cycling/mobility scooter etc on paths will say hello or acknowledge you. Some don't, which is fine. They may avoid looking at me at all. Also fine. They may have anxiety or just not be in the mood to be friendly to a random stranger. What really annoys me is people who stare at me as if Ive got 3 heads when all I've done is given a little smile. I get paranoid they were staring at me because I'm on a mobility scooter.

MrsGHarrison87 · 25/03/2022 14:42

I usually do smile if I'm walking past someone and our eyes meet and they're smiling at me. But not everyone is the same, some people don't want to smile at random people and you never know what they're going through or what type of personality they have. So it's weird you think it strange that not everyone smiles at you.

SartresSoul · 25/03/2022 14:39

People are often in a world of their own so might not notice you smiling. They might look in your direction but not register the fact you’re trying to be friendly at all. It isn’t anything personal, people just have their own shit going on.

Noisyneighneigh · 25/03/2022 14:37

I smile at people a lot because of my children. They attract strangers' attention and they smile at the kids and me and I reciprocate. I do think it's a bit strange if someone smiles at you for no reason and would worry I had toothpaste on my face or something. I smile back but sometimes it feels uncomfortable and I am actually quite outgoing.

I was out a few weeks ago and someone said good morning to me, I responded of course but that's rare in an urban setting now. It's a bit sad I think.
Try not to sweat it OP, keep being friendly. It's not always about you.

Hbh17 · 25/03/2022 14:36

If I am out, then I just want to be in my own "headspace and enjoy some solitude. It doesn't make a person miserable if they don't want to interact with every passer-by. That's why living in a city is generally good, because you can just get on with your life without any interference from others. I do find it very odd if I visit a friend in a small town & she is saying 'hello' to complete strangers.
Also, I agree that it is very patronising to assume that older people welcome approaches from strangers - the older I get, the more the idea of being a recluse actually appeals! 😉

ddl1 · 25/03/2022 14:36

@saveforthat

I can see that *@MurmuratingStarling has some issues and should probably stsy away from AIBU and seek some help irl so I will stop responding to her nonsense posts. Just for the rest of you (become she's ghosted me!) I am 100% woman and have never once dictated how women should behave, I just expect everyone male female and anything else they call themselves to have some basic human manners. @MedusasBadHairDay* has it exactly right.
Calling someone a miserable cow is not good manners!
Noisyneighneigh · 25/03/2022 14:29

@TracyMosby

Because you dont deserve a smile back?

Because smiling at someone and expecting them to smile back is incredibly entitled.

Because women dont owe you pretty.

Oh ffs. 🤣
Butchyrestingface · 25/03/2022 14:16

@saveforthat

I can see that *@MurmuratingStarling has some issues and should probably stsy away from AIBU and seek some help irl so I will stop responding to her nonsense posts. Just for the rest of you (become she's ghosted me!) I am 100% woman and have never once dictated how women should behave, I just expect everyone male female and anything else they call themselves to have some basic human manners. @MedusasBadHairDay* has it exactly right.
Didn’t you call her a “miserable soulless joyless cow”? 😐

Where are YOUR ‘basic human manners’?

Butchyrestingface · 25/03/2022 14:16

@saveforthat

I can see that *@MurmuratingStarling has some issues and should probably stsy away from AIBU and seek some help irl so I will stop responding to her nonsense posts. Just for the rest of you (become she's ghosted me!) I am 100% woman and have never once dictated how women should behave, I just expect everyone male female and anything else they call themselves to have some basic human manners. @MedusasBadHairDay* has it exactly right.
Didn’t you call her a “miserable soulless joyless cow”? 😐

Where are YOUR ‘basic human manners’?

saveforthat · 25/03/2022 13:51

I can see that @MurmuratingStarling has some issues and should probably stsy away from AIBU and seek some help irl so I will stop responding to her nonsense posts. Just for the rest of you (become she's ghosted me!) I am 100% woman and have never once dictated how women should behave, I just expect everyone male female and anything else they call themselves to have some basic human manners. @MedusasBadHairDay has it exactly right.

Lottie2shoes · 25/03/2022 09:35

So this thread is getting weirder and aggressive on both sides of the camp.
Personally I am a smiler and I am the type to maybe say good morning and the like.

I understand not everyone is like that so if someone didn't reciprocate, I would just not bother next time. No overthinking or wondering.
Im from up north if that makes a difference.
I believe a smile can make the day a bit brighter for some people, not all. So always make an effort just in case.
Most people do usually smile back or answer. Like I said it would not bother me either way if they didn't.

Although there is 1 woman ive come across, who glares back when ive smiled (twice) which I think is downright rude. I avoid her now.
Makes me wonder if she is islamophobic as I am Muslim. Which is a shame.

Musicaltheatremum · 25/03/2022 08:29

@Wingedharpy I fully agree. 10 years since I lost my husband and the guy at the checkout said to me "cheer up, it may never happen" I was buying vases for all the flowers that were arriving the day after my husband died so I told him. He was very sorry. Don't know how I held it all together.

MedusasBadHairDay · 25/03/2022 07:16

If you read this thread without the OP and just going by some of the reactions you could almost believe the OP was asking why people didn't like it when she grabbed people (who she knew were grieving/ having an awful day) while leering at them and yelling "cheer up love". 😂

MurmuratingStarling · 24/03/2022 22:55

[quote saveforthat]@MurmuratingStarling My post was aimed at the op. I don't believe I have the authority to tell anyone to do anything. You sound like great fun. You have the right to carry on being a miserable soulless joyless cow and I will carry on saying good morning[/quote]
@saveforthat you sound utterly insufferable, and the kind of person I actively avoid in real life!

You have totally lost the argument by insulting me and calling me a miserable soulless joyless COW. What the actual FUCK?! Miserable cow? Just because I don't fall in with YOUR idea of how women should behave...? So I must say 'good morning' and 'good afternoon' to every person I encounter, and grin and simper at everyone when I leave the house? Lest I get accused of being a MISERABLE COW? Fuck me. Could you BE more misogynistic?

I reserve the right to not smile at, or speak to every fucking person I meet, and whether I speak or not is MY choice and is fuckall to do with you, or anyone else, and I DON'T have to explain myself.

As many posters have said, women don't HAVE to do anything they don't want to do, and don't deserve misogynistic vile remarks like 'you're a miserable COW' if they don't kow-tow to the way YOU think they should behave.

Your posts are shameful. Disgraceful and misogynistic. You HAVE to be a man. Because only a MAN would call a woman a miserable cow for having the TEMERITY to say she doesn't feel the need to smile back at a stranger smiling at them. If I don't feel like smiling, there is probably a reason for that, or maybe I just don't want to.. That is MY RIGHT.

But you are too busy hurling insults to even take that into account. Your rude small-minded insults are a disgrace and I shall do what I do to people like you in real life, and ghost you.

Don't talk to me again.

Darkstar4855 · 24/03/2022 20:19

YABVU. Nobody owes you a smile. Smile because you want to, not because you expect something in return.

NowEvenBetter · 24/03/2022 19:51

@PeterandSandy
Nope. When I’m out I’m minding my own business, my own thoughts, not looking at people, hoping to avoid human contact, it’s not something I’m interested in when I’m going about my day. And I don’t subscribe to the ‘women must smile’ inflicted on us from infancy.

Rosesandthistles · 24/03/2022 19:36

I've suffered from depression and over time I've lost the semi-automatic smiling whenever someone smiles at you thing- someone could easily smile at me and by the time I've noticed and thought about smiling they'd have walked past me! maybe it's just something like that.

BitOutOfPractice · 24/03/2022 19:35

@WetLookKnitwear

It means nothing so don’t be an arse to them.

They might have been thinking about something else and totally on autopilot when you looked at them. Or maybe they didn’t have their glasses on and couldn’t see that you were looking at them specifically. The list goes on

Where does it say she was an arse to them?
WetLookKnitwear · 24/03/2022 19:28

It means nothing so don’t be an arse to them.

They might have been thinking about something else and totally on autopilot when you looked at them. Or maybe they didn’t have their glasses on and couldn’t see that you were looking at them specifically. The list goes on

CaptainThe95thRifles · 24/03/2022 19:21

Out here in the sticks, it's pretty unusual, though not outright weird, not to smile or acknowledge people you pass in the road or on a path, whether you know them or not. When I worked in London, smiling at random people could've been a very different game Grin

I'd always rather be polite and friendly, but sometimes I'm on another planet in busy places and don't register people are making eye contact or attempting to exchange pleasantries. It's different in a rural community where you tend to have more time to process what's happening.

BitOutOfPractice · 24/03/2022 19:11

@Chocolateteabag I understand totally. But if we are going to play “what if…” about people’s lives when they smile / don’t smile, what if the person who smiled at you is sad and lovely, hadn’t had a human interaction all day and is desperate for that tiny connection? So, on balance, I prefer to try and meet kindness with kindness no matter what’s going on in my life.

diamondpony80 · 24/03/2022 19:09

A friend told me once that he came across me walking down the street and smiled and said hi. Apparently I blanked him and kept on walking. A while after he asked me why I didn’t even acknowledge him - he thought I wasn’t talking to him or something. I can honestly say hand on heart I never even saw him. Despite the fact that apparently I looked straight at him. I was obviously just in a world of my own walking down the street.

BitOutOfPractice · 24/03/2022 19:08

@MurmuratingStarling much better. You’re pretty when you smile you know (you know I’m joking right?!)

I totally understand and agree with what you’re saying about women being expected to be pleasers and look pretty and smile. It’s really ducking annoying.

But the whole “fuck off you weirdo who are you smiling at” as a reaction to a smile is equally depressing.

I usually smile at other women. I find when approaching men in the street I’m too busy practising my favourite game of refusing to alter my course for a man and enjoying their reactions which are usually shock or anger when they realise they don’t actually own the space and have to step around me. It pleases and amuses me and usually makes me smile.