Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to get obsessed with unfairness

57 replies

Ceci03 · 23/03/2022 23:56

so I'm tired of fighting for fairness. I asked my boss today if I could work 8am to 4pm (instead of 9am to 5pm), There are 6 of us in the team and 3 people already work 8-4, by request. I said I would only leave at 4 if there was someone in who is working til 5pm - i.e. I would be flexible and asked to just do it if there is someone there. I am often left on my own from 4pm to 5pm if I'm on the rota with the people who are working 8-4. I honestly didn't think it would be a problem. We have the use of a free car park for a few months - leftover from covid, - and I've been driving in, which is a lot quicker than public transport, and less chance of catching covid, but I do have to be in by 7.30am to get a space, so I've been wandering in, getting a coffee and starting work usually around 8.30, getting a headstart on the day, which is fine. Colleagues were saying to me I should just ask to leave at 4 as I'm in so early so today I bit the bullet and asked. And was immediately shut down. She referred me to my contract - from 2.5 years ago - which apparently says I have to work 9-5 (I checked it later and it doesnt mention this), she also said she has to put the 'business needs' of the team first, and I need to be there from 4-5. She said other things, like how I need to officially apply for flexible working. When I pointed out that in the policy it says that local managers have discretion for temporary arrangements, she said she had made her decision. I'm finding it really hard to let it go. Obsessing about why she is unfair. I need to just let it go and get over it, but I'm finding it really hard, especially as I get older, to let this kind of unfairness go. I need to though I know that. Life is unfair and that's life. It really bugs me that I take pride in my work, and even last week worked late when I got home, to meet a deadline, and had everythign ready to go on the Friday morning. no acknowledgement of that, or offer of time in lieu, or any mention of it at all. I know, I chose to do that, as I wanted to meet the deadline. But it's just hard when you ask for some flexibility in return, and it's immediately denied. WIsh I could switch off my brain now though.

OP posts:
vivainsomnia · 24/03/2022 08:55

Just to clarify the point she made about me being needed to cover my original colleagues hours does not make sense as she did the the same hours as me 9-5
It does make complete sense. You are both covering eachother. This means if she's not there, there is still someone to work until 5. Just like if someone on the 8 to 4 shift is off sick, someone can cover the 8am start.

4 vs 2, or 1 I'd one person is off long term at the moment doesn't work.

vivainsomnia · 24/03/2022 08:51

This thread really shows how clueless many people are about the operational requirements of services.

I'm assuming that you are customer focus and the business/service needs to run until 5pm. 3 staff on one shift means cover at all time, taking into account holidays and sickness.

Why dors everything has to be made personal and why this entitlement to your wishes taking over the needs of the service?

You agreed to work certain hours for over 2 years. You can't expect to change this just to suit you. And yes, this happened to me. I didn't like it but understood why I had to work those hours. It's life.

user1471457751 · 24/03/2022 08:44

Your manager not having kids has fuck all to do with this so no reason to mention it here - do you think that makes her inferior, or something?

You are still not getting the cover point. You provide extra resilience in the 9-5 shift which means you are also there when the other person can't be.

EarringsandLipstick · 24/03/2022 08:33

My question really is how do I get this woman out of my head

She's your manager, you can't.

Stop being childish & have an honest, factual conversation with her about the additional work. You mentioned one time working late - was it more than that?

About working early, don't.

Changing your hours - put in a request as she said. You say it'll be declined? It may be, but there are then rules around how this can be applied so you will have a further basis to discuss.

raspberrymuffin · 24/03/2022 08:30

@JovialNickname I find it strange when I encounter adults who know life is unfair and think that's fine and no need for anyone to try to do anything about it. Most of us can't do much about Russia (other than stop voting for people funded by Russian oligarchs) but we can look for a better job if our current employer is taking the piss.

OP there's probably nothing you can do about this awful manager but unless you are being paid a lot of money I would suggest you start looking for other jobs and in the meantime cut right back on the extra hours. Can you take yourself for a coffee or a nice walk after you've parked?

Ceci03 · 24/03/2022 08:21

I knew some of you would agree with my manager. Just to clarify the point she made about me being needed to cover my original colleagues hours does not make sense as she did the the same hours as me 9-5. We worked together for a year before she went on maternity and then sick leave.

My question really is how do I get this woman out of my head. I want to forget the whole thing and just move on. Anyone any advice on that.

OP posts:
JovialNickname · 24/03/2022 07:55

Whoever told you life was fair! Whatever you might think, you are not automatically entitled to fairness in life. Most of us learn this at a young age; it is a modern phenomenon that this sort of attitude persists into adulthood. Think of those being bombed in Ukraine, is that fair? Objectively, taking a step back, life and being alive is characterized by unfairness. To be human means dealing with life's inherent unfairness sometimes. I still find it really strange when I encounter adults that don't know this

Yummymummy2020 · 24/03/2022 07:55

I didn’t see a mention of it above, but are you in a union? I would formally apply for the flexible working regardless and somehow fit on the form that you are willing to stay if the only one left ect (to make you look extra reasonable when she refuses) then I would broach it with the union. I agree with not doing a thing extra for them though as it is unfair really.

EarringsandLipstick · 24/03/2022 07:50

I don't agree that it's unfair she denied your request; her response sounds valid to me, and she told you that you should make an official request. It doesn't sound reasonable that you should ask to change your hours in a casual way, and expect an immediate answer. I can see the problems that might arise in a few months when she may want you to go back to 9 - 5. Hence making an official request.

The way she handled it doesn't sound great, either though.

The issue of you doing additional work that isn't recognised is a separate one. You should let her know that, clearly and distinguish between you starting work early because you are in early, and the work that you did to get a task done.

Starting work early is your own decision. As a manager, I have to say sometimes to people 'you weren't asked to do that'.

However, if you worked late on a task, the reasons for that should be addressed, especially if it's more than once, and a good manager will do this.

I do get your frustration, but your posts sound a little immature to me.

GruntGruntSnifSnif · 24/03/2022 07:45

This sounds inflexible, is it a customer service type of job where you have to man a Helpdesk?

Flittingaboutagain · 24/03/2022 04:29

At a broader level the older I get the more I become aware how much unfairness there is in the world and how relationships are so influential in who has power. I am finding it harder to let things go.

I see that she said the needs of the business mean she needs to ensure there is always someone there until 5. Do your colleagues do the same role as you? If a client rang at 4.30 could any of them respond as you would?

If TOIL is used in your company then she could allow you to occasionally have an afternoon off for doing 8/8.30-5 if you absolutely have to be there until 5.

ThinWomansBrain · 24/03/2022 04:14

get in at 8.30 or whenever you need to park - and make it perfectly obvious that you are reading a book/newspaper/listening to a podcast on earphones/whatever and not starting work until 9am.

NumberTheory · 24/03/2022 03:12

It sounds like your manager is thinking about business needs - as she's supposed to. If you're frequently in the office on your own from 4 - 5 and the office needs coverage I can see why she doesn't want to adjust another employee's hours to lower coverage for that time frame. Having 4 people with official hours of 8 - 4 and 2 people on 9 - 5 would not be sensible. Even with other 8 - 4'ers offering to cover I can also see why she might not want to have a complicated rota of people subbing in for the last hour. It's not "unfair" for her to have given the 8 - 4 slots to the people who asked first. There are other ways she could have done it, but if more people want those hours than the others there's going to be someone disappointed. First ask isn't a terrible way to do that.

Have you tried asking for some other accomodation to make up for the lack of parking?

If you don't get anything, you should think about your needs and start looking for a job that pays more and has lower expenses. It's a job hunter's market at the moment. When you get an offer you can either try negotiating that into the hours you want (and a pay rise?) or take the new job.

BambinaJAS · 24/03/2022 00:56

@HeddaGarbled

She even started saying that I had been specifically appointed to cover another colleague's hours - wtf, this colleague has not been in work for over a year, on maternity and sick leave. Plus, this colleague worked 9-5, so I can't see any relevance? How was I 'covering her hours' when we worked the same hours? It's just excuses which don't even make sense

“Cover her hours” means work the hours she would have worked if she was there, so that bit makes sense. That’s what ‘cover’ is - a replacement for someone who is absent. Were you appointed to replace her while she was on maternity and sick leave?

"Cover her hours" is just her working hours.

Thats 8hrs/day with 1hr for lunch.

Nornal working hours are 9 - 5, but these are not set in stone in any contract that I have ever seen.

WickedWitchOfTheEast87 · 24/03/2022 00:55

@Ozanj

Don’t work a minute over your hours. Get in for 9 and leave at 5 on the dot. Don’t take on or fix the work of others just pass it to your manager to fix. If she can’t be flexible with you, just stop all flexibility with her.
@Ceci03 Ozanj has it right in a nutshell. If I were you I would also carry out any communication with your manager over email that way you have a paper trail and evidence of her being unfair and piss poor management skills. Also any meetings you have with her email a request for the minutes of that meeting and don't sign your name to anything you don't agree with. Any requests you make always email because your manager can deny anything that was said or agreed verbally. Don't do any favours for anyone and no more being flexible for your manager she needs to learn the lesson that when you take advantage and refuse to compromise and be flexible with your employees you can't expect them to do the same for you.
BambinaJAS · 24/03/2022 00:54

@Ozanj

Don’t work a minute over your hours. Get in for 9 and leave at 5 on the dot. Don’t take on or fix the work of others just pass it to your manager to fix. If she can’t be flexible with you, just stop all flexibility with her.
This is exactly what happens when poor managers clamp down ln reasonable requests.

People will stop going the extra mile. They will come in at 9 on the dot, and leave at 5 on the dot.

In the end, its the company that loses out.

HeddaGarbled · 24/03/2022 00:52

She even started saying that I had been specifically appointed to cover another colleague's hours - wtf, this colleague has not been in work for over a year, on maternity and sick leave. Plus, this colleague worked 9-5, so I can't see any relevance? How was I 'covering her hours' when we worked the same hours? It's just excuses which don't even make sense

“Cover her hours” means work the hours she would have worked if she was there, so that bit makes sense. That’s what ‘cover’ is - a replacement for someone who is absent. Were you appointed to replace her while she was on maternity and sick leave?

Ozanj · 24/03/2022 00:46

Don’t work a minute over your hours. Get in for 9 and leave at 5 on the dot. Don’t take on or fix the work of others just pass it to your manager to fix. If she can’t be flexible with you, just stop all flexibility with her.

Ceci03 · 24/03/2022 00:46

@WickedWitchOfTheEast87 thanks I don't know why I am so f trusting and gullible at my age. I just trust that people are "good" underneath, but so many aren't. I gave this manager so many chances in my head, when she said inappropriate things, and yes Bambina, she really does need some training in people management. There is a lot of resentment in the team, but the others hide it well - they are probably wise, they know that ultimately she has power, so they keep her sweet. I find it so hard to be fake. I can't hide my feelings which has gotten me into trouble in work situations. I just want to find a 'nice' job with decent people. Keep coming across these petty people who have some kind of power complex though.

OP posts:
BambinaJAS · 24/03/2022 00:37

Age and management experience matter in these situations. Lack of flexibility and micro-managing are red flags of poor training.

Ultimately, what are your core hours?

Never heard of them being 9 - 5.

Usually its something like 10 - 2 (or similar)

Its very odd not to accomodate such an request (from 9 - 5 to 8 - 4)

This does not require a flexible work request.

That is more along the lines of working 4 days for 9 hrs/day instead of 5 days at 7hrs/day. Thats a material change for the business (usually).

Sounds like a manager with poor skills to be perfectly honest.

WickedWitchOfTheEast87 · 24/03/2022 00:36

@Ceci03 don't trust that colleague she sounds two faced and like she's shit stirring, actually I wouldn't be surprised if she's been telling your manager you've been slagging her off to get some special treatment and maybe thats why your manager is being petty and unfair because she's probably been told you were saying it. Next time your colleague slags your manager off say to her "I'm really not interested in what you think of her if it bothers you that much go and say it to her face" she'll soon backtrack when she sees her manipulative tactics aren't working.

Ceci03 · 24/03/2022 00:34

In fact 2 out of 3 (obviously not herself, as she works 8-4 and will never stay until 5pm) have offered to take turns with me, as they feel bad that they are allowed to leave at 4 if they come in at 8, but I'm not. I said no to them, that I wouldn't even expect that, only if there were people there anyway until 5, which would allow me to leave at 4 IUKWIM

OP posts:
Ceci03 · 24/03/2022 00:31

@HeddaGarbled

6 on the team, 3 work 8-4, 3 work 9-5.

That’s sensible, isn’t it?

yeah but why cant she be a teeny bit flexible for me? the others don't have a problem with it, they feel it's unfair to me. We're facing the worst cost of living crisis in my lifetime, and if I can save a few pounds on parking/travelling to work, for a few months, and it doesnt affect anyone, could she not just say "ok". Plus how come they all get to work 8-4 - is that fair? Just cos they asked first? And I'm not even asking anyone to change their hours, I will cover for them if I'm the only person on 9-5 that day, but is there a need for all 3 of us, or 2 of us to be there from 4-5 when I'm often left on my own for that hour? Is that not petty?
OP posts:
Ceci03 · 24/03/2022 00:27

thanks @WickedWitchOfTheEast87. I keep having these convos in my head where I have great one-liners and finally put her in her place.

She's about 45 - married no kids, if it makes any difference.

She even started saying that I had been specifically appointed to cover another colleague's hours - wtf, this colleague has not been in work for over a year, on maternity and sick leave. Plus, this colleague worked 9-5, so I can't see any relevance? How was I 'covering her hours' when we worked the same hours? It's just excuses which don't even make sense.

Another thing bugging me, is my immediate colleague - also under this manager - is always sucking up to her. She works part-time but always ends up working from home on her 'days off'. She doesnt like the manager, and feels resentful, but is so nice to her face and sucks up to her so much, nobody would ever know how she really feels. I don't know why she does it. She sympathises with me, and was the one egging me on to ask her could I do 8-4 but then is best pals with the manager, even though she heard what she said to me. I wish I could put on as good an act as she does.

OP posts:
HeddaGarbled · 24/03/2022 00:21

6 on the team, 3 work 8-4, 3 work 9-5.

That’s sensible, isn’t it?