Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Inheritance query. Is sister being cheeky or is it me?

188 replies

IndeterminateCaptainNoises · 23/03/2022 22:52

Our lovely dm died some years ago. Everything spilt 50-50 between DSis and I. (Some money left directly to the grandchildren) . Recently we have been made aware of some more money (approx £800) coming through a policy that's matured. I was thinking even split but dsis wants to use it to buy things for the children. Aibu to say she can spend her half how she wants but I want my half?

OP posts:
eldora · 24/03/2022 14:19

@IndeterminateCaptainNoises

Our lovely dm died some years ago. Everything spilt 50-50 between DSis and I. (Some money left directly to the grandchildren) . Recently we have been made aware of some more money (approx £800) coming through a policy that's matured. I was thinking even split but dsis wants to use it to buy things for the children. Aibu to say she can spend her half how she wants but I want my half?
Why do you say ‘the children’, not ‘her’ children?

She is a CF. Any falling would be down to her greed, not you.

MimiSunshine · 24/03/2022 13:43

Just say sorry sis, DP have some expenses at the moment that this unexpected money will really help us out if a hole with so I can’t afford to give £400 to your children.

Spelling it out should make her see how unreasonable she’s being

WomanStanleyWoman · 24/03/2022 13:36

She probably just wants to make sure the money is used for something special with the money, rather than just getting absorbed into her household budget.

But the OP’s share was never going to get absorbed into her sister’s household budget, was it? So the sister doesn’t need to worry - she has £400 to spend on her children.

WickedStepmomNOT · 24/03/2022 13:30

f) £400 is a lot of money - I certainly don't have £400 spending money available every month! And hasn't the sister heard about the massive energy price hike next month?

WickedStepmomNOT · 24/03/2022 13:28

@MrsWinters
^Gosh people are funny when it comes to money and inheritance.
Of course the terms of the Will still apply, so it should be split 50:50 between the sisters by the sounds of it, but I don’t think your sister is being unreasonable or outrageous suggesting you use the money to treat the kids to something nice, particularly if she is unaware of your financial situation. She probably just wants to make sure the money is used for something special with the money, rather than just getting absorbed into her household budget.^
Split the money 50:50, but I would be prepared for her kids to accidentally drop in about a treat with grandma’s money at some point. You might want to do something little like buying some afternoon tea bits and going for a fun picnic or something so your kids think they’ve done something too.

You're ignoring the fact that
a) will said 50/50 split
b) OP doesn't have children
c) her sister's children already received individual bequests from their grandmother's estate
d) sister is being both unreasonable and outrageous to suggest OP gifts her share to her sister's children
e) it's not her sister's business to 'suggest' what OP does with her share.

dworky · 24/03/2022 12:59

@Cocomarine

What’s she actually said? If she’s just put forward an idea, it’s not cheeky at all. It’s just that - an idea.
Its still cheeky.
HomeHomeInTheRange · 24/03/2022 12:54

Who was the Executor?

Legally the executor HAS to distribute the ££ as in the Will, unless a beneficiary asks for a Deed of Variation to divert some or all of their inheritance to someone else. So the money needs to be paid to each of you, 50 /50. If it all goes to your DSis to spend in her kids, a solicitor would need to draw up a Deed for you to sign.

Otherwise the Executor could be in trouble.

VanGoghsDog · 24/03/2022 12:51

@TulaOfDarkWater

No no no so many wrong answers here! Not all policies will fall under the deceased person’s estate so no, the will may not apply! There are some polices that will not form part of the estate and will have a named beneficiary instead and in that case they get the lot; it really depends on the terms of the specific policy so no one can give you a definite answer here OP.
This is true, we don't know what this policy is.

Policies don't "mature" after someone dies, the provider needs to be told the date of death now that the policy had appeared and they can recalculate based on that. It might even be higher as it might have had a life assurance element. We just don't know.

If it is separate to the estate it goes to whoever she named, if she didn't name anyone (or if they pre deceased) then the trustees will decide and, to be honest, they usually just replicate the will if there was one.

If it was an endowment then it would have ended on her death. Of course, if the executors didn't know about it, they do now and need to inform the provider of all the details.

HomeHomeInTheRange · 24/03/2022 12:50

Your DSis is especially cheeky given that her kids have already had a set amount as specified in the Will, and if you want kids in the future yours will not benefit in the same way.

IF you are thinking of kids, and your DSis knows that, you could say that as the Will left your Mum’s estate 50 : 50 (after the bequests to the grandchildren) you would like to invest your half in savings / Premium Bonds for your hoped for children.

StrangeCondition · 24/03/2022 12:42

She's being a cheeky fucker whether the OP has kids or not!

Turningpurple · 24/03/2022 12:18

If you don't have kids then, yeah she is being cheeky.

If you both had kids and she simply suggested splitting between the kids instead, I wouldn't think it was a big deal.

Saying "I think you should give me it all to spend on my kids" is cheeky. Even if it's just a suggestion.

AryaStarkWolf · 24/03/2022 12:05

@IndeterminateCaptainNoises

All, thank you for the responses. I really don't want to fall out with DSis over this, which is why have not said anything yet. I just felt a bit aggrieved she had decided what to do with the money. To answer some queries I don't have children yet, we were both executors on the will. DSIs's children were all left an equal amount at the time. We are both in similar financial positions. Given the will was clear on the 50/50 as someone said may blame that.
So she's basically saying she wants ti rake all the money as you have no kids? Massive cheeky fucker, take your half
Lemonyfuckit · 24/03/2022 12:00

Oh so you don't actually have children? Then absolutely your sister is a CF, this should be a 50/50 split per the terms of your DM's will, and if she wants to spend her half on her children that's obviously her prerogative but how can she not see how completely unfair it would be if she took the lot for her children with nothing for you. As others have pointed out she's already had more for her children with the part that went directly to grandchildren, her children, as if you have children in the future they don't benefit. Stick to your guns OP, YADNBU.

HoldingTheDoor · 24/03/2022 11:55

You might want to do something little like buying some afternoon tea bits and going for a fun picnic or something so your kids think they’ve done something too.

MrsWinters
The OP doesn't have children yet.

Gilly12345 · 24/03/2022 11:18

If the will states 50/50 with sister then this additional money is surely a 50/50 with sister unless it is stipulated otherwise.

She can then spend her 50% as she wants.

MrsWinters · 24/03/2022 10:58

Gosh people are funny when it comes to money and inheritance.
Of course the terms of the Will still apply, so it should be split 50:50 between the sisters by the sounds of it, but I don’t think your sister is being unreasonable or outrageous suggesting you use the money to treat the kids to something nice, particularly if she is unaware of your financial situation. She probably just wants to make sure the money is used for something special with the money, rather than just getting absorbed into her household budget.
Split the money 50:50, but I would be prepared for her kids to accidentally drop in about a treat with grandma’s money at some point. You might want to do something little like buying some afternoon tea bits and going for a fun picnic or something so your kids think they’ve done something too.

WeBuiltThisBuffetOnSausageRoll · 24/03/2022 10:28

Try telling her that you were thinking of spending the whole £800 on paying off some of your debts or getting a new TV or something else equally selfish (not saying that it would be selfish at all to want to use your half on any of those).

The reaction she gives you is the exact same one that you need to double back on to her.

We all want the best for our kids, but they're OUR kids: we don't just expect other people to give things up or provide for them.

Itwasnotmeormydog · 24/03/2022 10:27

She can spend her half on the children or whatever she wants. You can spend your half on whatever you want. She can't spend your half for you unless you choose to gift it to her.

WeBuiltThisBuffetOnSausageRoll · 24/03/2022 10:24

Now we know the situation wrt kids, she has quite safely won the '100% CF Gold Award'. Talk about "Tell me you want me to give you £400 without actually asking me to give you £400".

That reminds me of the letter our DS came home from school with, once: the PTA were most definitely NOT asking parents to give them money, but rather (massive difference) simply to 'collect up their spare change over the next few weeks' and send it in (or preferably a cheque/banknotes to the equivalent value)....

By the sounds of it, OP, you are hoping to have your own children at some point: why should they end up missing out on money from their DGM, just because they haven't been born yet?

They've already missed out on direct bequests in the will that their older cousins will have benefited from - unless your sister is planning on evening that out by encouraging her children to retrospectively share their bequests from their DGM equally with ALL of the DGC she ends up having. I wonder if that's what she's dutifully planning Hmm

DorotheaHomeAlone · 24/03/2022 10:20

She wants the whole amount for her kids. No question at all that this CFery. Tell her you want your half and don’t even dignify her ridiculous suggestion with a response.

whynotwhatknot · 24/03/2022 10:16

No its 50/50 her kids have already been left an amount plus she can still buy gifts with 400

shes playing on your guilt because she has dc

WeBuiltThisBuffetOnSausageRoll · 24/03/2022 10:13

£400 each would go precisely nowhere in solicitor fees for a dispute, it would be used up on the first letter and response. Let's not pretend OP could buy a house with it while her sister wants to stick it all on roulette. In most of the country £400 is less than a month's rent or a week on holiday, which makes it a very small amount in terms of annual expenses.

We still don't know how many kids there are nor the proposal; say if they have 1 or 2 each or even one have 2 and the other 1, with sister suggesting a family holiday somewhere for the kids. Many people would spend £400 on that, even with low income, and would think that's a nice idea for an unexpected family windfall; exactly the type of thing a grandma would have wanted. OP can still just say "no thanks, I'm in too much debt and would rather use it for that", but the sister is perfectly reasonable to ask.

Where did the legal fees thing come from? Everybody knows how much legal fees can cost, which is why access to justice is very often only a privilege for the wealthy. Aston Martins cost a lot of money too, but OP isn't suggesting buying one of those either. Just because £400 would go nowhere towards buying a very expensive luxury, that doesn't mean that many people wouldn't find it a lifeline to meet basic essential costs. Also, you don't necessarily have to be in a lot of debt to not have money available to spend on luxuries - poor people are terrified of getting into debt in the first place, as they don't have the option of sticking it on a credit card and using some of their next executive Christmas bonus to clear it off.

Moreover, there's a wide spectrum of 'low income'. Some households can and do choose to budget very carefully and make sacrifices elsewhere to be able to go on a relatively cheap holiday; to others, no matter how much they cut back, even one of the Sun £10 holidays would never be within their reach.

I've been in the position where I didn't have 50p available for a loaf of bread. Thankfully, I'm not in that position now, but I hope I never lose perspective of what life is like for a great many poor - not just 'not particularly well-off' people.

Febrier · 24/03/2022 09:44

Tell her you agree, all the kids get equal shares and you're going to have five.

TulaOfDarkWater · 24/03/2022 09:36

But if this was the case, the beneficiary would have been informed.

Who knows, maybe the sister has been informed hence the plans to spend the money on her kids. OP hasn’t given enough information and only asked if the terms of the will apply and the correct answer to that is maybe or maybe not, it depends on the specific policy whether it forms part of the estate or not.

WomanStanleyWoman · 24/03/2022 09:32

Let's not pretend OP could buy a house with it while her sister wants to stick it all on roulette. In most of the country £400 is less than a month's rent or a week on holiday, which makes it a very small amount in terms of annual expenses.

It only takes the tiniest amount of common sense to realise that, if the rent is £500 and you struggle to make it every month, having 80% of it drop into your lap one month makes a massive difference. Or that if you’re paying off credit card debt, wiping out what could be a year’s worth of minimum payments means you reduce both the amount you’re paying interest on AND your monthly outgoings.

But no, £400 is a bag of Cadbury’s fucking buttons.