Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Inheritance query. Is sister being cheeky or is it me?

188 replies

IndeterminateCaptainNoises · 23/03/2022 22:52

Our lovely dm died some years ago. Everything spilt 50-50 between DSis and I. (Some money left directly to the grandchildren) . Recently we have been made aware of some more money (approx £800) coming through a policy that's matured. I was thinking even split but dsis wants to use it to buy things for the children. Aibu to say she can spend her half how she wants but I want my half?

OP posts:
Painiscrap · 25/03/2022 18:53

@IndeterminateCaptainNoises

All, thank you for the responses. I really don't want to fall out with DSis over this, which is why have not said anything yet. I just felt a bit aggrieved she had decided what to do with the money. To answer some queries I don't have children yet, we were both executors on the will. DSIs's children were all left an equal amount at the time. We are both in similar financial positions. Given the will was clear on the 50/50 as someone said may blame that.
She’s being a CF! Her dcs have already had a share from their dgm, but she wants them to get more. You haven’t got children yet, so any you have, will have missed out on getting anything from their dgm.

Perhaps say to your ds that you think it would be fair if you get all the money, in trust, for any children you may have in the future! After all, surely that would be fairer!!

WomanStanleyWoman · 25/03/2022 18:46

@Lizzy53

Need more info and if it's going to cause a rift is it worth it for £400? If she's desperate for this money can you be that person and let her have it?
I see a lot of comments like this and always wonder - why is it always the OP in these scenarios who has to ‘be the bigger person’? Why can’t the sister be the bigger person and decide that, given her children have already had an inheritance, the OP should be the one to get the whole £800? It would be interesting to see the sister’s reaction to that suggestion.

As for not causing a rift, I can only see one person causing a rift. I bet she’s not willing to give up her 400 quid to avoid it.

Dee00 · 25/03/2022 18:44

Is it possible when your sister said she wants to spend the money on the children, she means her half of the money?

If not I think you need to play dumb and bring it up again, ask her what she’s buying for them and then tell her what your planning to do with your half and how the money is coming at such a good time for you as you could really do with it!

Hopefully she will twig either way!

justasmalltownmum · 25/03/2022 18:39

Just saw your most recent update. She has kids and you don't.

CF. Should be 50:50

Lizzy53 · 25/03/2022 18:32

Need more info and if it's going to cause a rift is it worth it for £400? If she's desperate for this money can you be that person and let her have it?

Twitterwhooooo · 25/03/2022 18:27

As others have said, it's not up to you and your sister to make a decision, it comes down to the terms of the Will.

If it specified that assets should be split 50/50, then assets should be split 50/50.

doobyscoob · 25/03/2022 18:21

So she wants you to give your half to her kids!

Rather cheeky

LittleOwl153 · 25/03/2022 18:21

I would tell her you want to out it all in a bond for your future children as they missed out on any original inheritance - see what she has to say to that!

Newnamefor2022 · 25/03/2022 18:13

Surely if the will said a 50/50 split, that is what has to happen to this policy as well, by law? Wouldn't it need a formal deed of variation to change that?

Galdos · 25/03/2022 18:09

@65honeybee

If your mother's will stated that the inheritance is split 50/50 (apart from specific amounts for grandchildren) then it's absolutely not up to your sister to try to dictate anything else. She can do what she wants with her share and can butt out of what you do with yours
Exactly. If she gets more than her bequeathed half, it isn't your mother's bequest, it's a gift from you.
fuzzywuzzywombat · 25/03/2022 17:54

It's part of the 50/50 split inheritance. The kids have had theirs . End of

Mandyjack · 25/03/2022 17:50

I'd want to split it 50/50

Ddot · 25/03/2022 17:38

Tell her you need it all for the car, dog, fence, anything will do, then watch the penny drop

65honeybee · 25/03/2022 14:58

@cherryonthecakes like you I'm surprised by the posters who seem to think 'sorry but...' or some sort of explanation is required. A will is a legal document. The mother did the absolutely right and proper thing by dividing the estate equally between her children; the fact one adult child has already had her own kids is a total red herring. That's her choice. Anyway, the OP might have kids further down the line. But that's irrelevant too. It's quite simple- half the money belongs to the OP end of.

NeedleNoodle3 · 25/03/2022 10:55

Text saying please transfer my £400.

knowinglesseveryday · 25/03/2022 10:49

Just politely say you need your half for something else..Simple. You can't be responsible for other peoples reactions.

Kitkat151 · 24/03/2022 18:53

[quote girlmom21]@Kitkat151 if she wants to do a day trip with all the kids to somewhere they've been begging to go it might be reasonable.

If her husbands just left her and she can't afford to buy her kids new school shoes and OP's just got a bit promotion it might be reasonable.

It's not irrelevant. [/quote]
Of course it’s irrelevant🙄 .....the money was left 50/50 to the 2 DDs ....legally half the money Is OPs ....her sister can spend her half on her own kids if that’s what she wants.....so like I said irrelevant

LizzoBennett · 24/03/2022 18:49

What a CF! No way would I let my sister get away with that.

eldora · 24/03/2022 16:01

@WeBuiltThisBuffetOnSausageRoll

Why do you say ‘the children’, not ‘her’ children?

I presume that's how the sister framed it. Saying 'my children' from the outset gives the game away; but if you say 'the children' or 'her grandchildren', that gives you the deniability to play innocent as you 'realise' the 'surprising fact' that all of them happen to also be your children.

Ha, very true!
WeBuiltThisBuffetOnSausageRoll · 24/03/2022 15:57

Or she could just say the truth …. ‘Sorry sis, as per the will, this must be split 50/50.

I wouldn't bother with the 'sorry', tbh - just "No, Sis, we each get an equal inheritance, so that's £400 each. Obviously, it's entirely up to you how you choose to spend yours".

I'd also be inclined to ask (with a very quizzical look) why she didn't encourage her DC to spend their share on whatever it is she wants them to do/have (or spend some of her own earlier share on it) - and point out that they've already had provision made for them by your Mum, that any DC you have will never get.

It's the easiest thing in the world to use up your fair share of something and then demand/expect the other person to then split their fair share a second time with you, but most people over about 5yo will understand that this is terribly unfair.

The children - HER children are a red herring here - it's not like they're a neutral party to both of you. Does she expect you to contribute to the rest of their living costs, or does she somehow understand then that that is the parents' responsibility? She just fancies the whole lot for her family, which she's free to want, but.... altogether, now.... "I want doesn't get".

cherryonthecakes · 24/03/2022 15:53

Surprised by some of these answers. My thoughts

  1. Sister's kids received an inheritance so it's not necessary for OP to try and compensate for that. Sister plans to buy gifts rather than save it for their futures anyway.

2 Sister has kids while Op doesn't so sister is being a cf and spending OP's half for her. Op isn't required to spend her half on her nieces and nephews because some richer posters deem £400 as negligible.

  1. £400 is a lot for some. That's more than a week's full time wages for someone on minimum wage and would give someone on a low income some breathing room with inflation being crazy.
  1. If policy doesn't have a named beneficiary then 50/50 is fair as that's what the mum saw as fair when she was alive.
HoppingPavlova · 24/03/2022 14:52

Just say sorry sis, DP have some expenses at the moment that this unexpected money will really help us out if a hole with so I can’t afford to give £400 to your children.

Why would she even have to mention bills though? It’s not relevant. OP is perfectly entitled to spend that money on Smarties or crack if she wants, no one else’s business.

Namechangehereandnow · 24/03/2022 14:39

@MimiSunshine

Just say sorry sis, DP have some expenses at the moment that this unexpected money will really help us out if a hole with so I can’t afford to give £400 to your children.

Spelling it out should make her see how unreasonable she’s being

Or she could just say the truth …. ‘Sorry sis, as per the will, this must be split 50/50.
WeBuiltThisBuffetOnSausageRoll · 24/03/2022 14:35

Why do you say ‘the children’, not ‘her’ children?

I presume that's how the sister framed it. Saying 'my children' from the outset gives the game away; but if you say 'the children' or 'her grandchildren', that gives you the deniability to play innocent as you 'realise' the 'surprising fact' that all of them happen to also be your children.

WeBuiltThisBuffetOnSausageRoll · 24/03/2022 14:32

We are both in similar financial positions. Given the will was clear on the 50/50 as someone said may blame that.

Don't 'blame' it on that or even suggest that you are - she will (legally quite rightly) say that, after receiving your share, you could hand it straight back to her for her kids.

I really don't see why you feel ashamed to take your inheritance - the same amount that she is getting. Suppose you worked in an old-fashioned workplace where they handed out envelopes with cash in on payday - would you feel guilty or in need of justifying saying "No!" if the next person in the queue, doing the exact same job for the exact same pay as you, turned and asked if they could have yours as well?

Her family has already had more money than yours, plus all of the presents and treats for the children (and maybe free childcare) provided by their DGM that your (as yet non-existent) children obviously never will.

She has absolutely no reason or justification for having the money other than that 'she would quite like it' - well, wouldn't we all! If she thinks that £400 isn't much money, she's quite at liberty to double her half from her own money and spend the lot on something nice for her kids; if she does see £400 as a significant amount of money, why on earth does she think that you should just give it to her?!

Also, as per PP, don't ever have it referred to as 'Mum's money' - and correct her if she calls it that. Don't let her kid you (or herself) that you're letting her/her family have a greater (well, whole) share of 'Mum's money'. It was Mum's money, but now it's yours, having come to you legally and morally indisputably yours - one of two children receiving 50% - it's now YOUR money. She is asking YOU to give HER children £400 of YOUR OWN money.

If you were to succumb and pay her £400 of your own money, on the shaky grounds that it was your share of the inheritance, be prepared for her to maybe start looking back at the whole inheritance. She might use the direct gifts to her DC as leverage and suggest that, instead of you two both having received almost half each and her children a much smaller amount, it would have been 'fairer' really for ALL the money to be shared equally between you two and the DGC - 'all of DGM's offspring' - so you 'should really' e-split it and give their family 'back' what 'should have' been their 'fair' share or - if you don't have it to give them, you're the unreasonable one and YOU owe THEM!!!