Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Duke & Duchess Of Cambridge tour … is it just me?

334 replies

PodgePie · 23/03/2022 21:25

I am a huge royalist (obviously not Andrew but definitely William and Kate). However, I am struggling with their current tour, in a time of war, of crippling price rises and also Covid, it seems tasteless to be parading around in the sunshine in a stream of hugely expensive outfits, each one more luxurious than the next. I understand why international tours take place - and agree they have an important role - but shouldn’t this have been postponed given the climate?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
5
romatheroamer · 24/03/2022 07:19

When I read this and other threads about the royal family, I always think of my uncle who always came to stay with us when there was a royal event like the Jubilee or a wedding so as to be near London and go and watch in person. And yet I heard him say more than once (and I'm talking quite a long time ago) that if there were a referendum the majority would vote to end the monarchy. I didn't really believe it then but I wonder now....

moonbedazzled · 24/03/2022 07:18

[quote HollowedOut]@Prescottdanni123 would they? I can’t think of the last time a royal went on a foreign tour and don’t recall any mention of racism because of that.

If they were actually able to read the room well enough to see that a lot of these commonwealth countries want out they wouldn’t be titting about over there. They’d arrange with the countries for some kind of referendum before turning up in thousand pound outfits, smiling benevolently and achieving the sum total of fuck all while pretending that it’s an actual job.[/quote]
Any country can leave the Commonwealth but even Barbados that just removed the Queen as head of state, hasn't left. And there are countries that were never even British colonies that have joined. I guess the royal family respect these countries enough to let them decide on and organise their own referendums. Clearly they think they are far more capable than you do, probably because they read the room.

moonbedazzled · 24/03/2022 07:10

It looks to me like they were well-received in both Belize and Jamaica. A few protesters but that happens when anyone goes anywhere. Happens in the UK to visiting heads of state too.
There have been ongoing wars throughout the Middle East for years. Should no heads of state have been allowed to leave their country and go on a state visit during those years? Were people appalled when Barak and Michelle Obama took their children on state visits while these wars were going on?

DowningStreetParty · 24/03/2022 07:06

Thanks EdithWeston that sounds good and appropriate. I just found a report on it. He had said as much as he could have in his position.
Boris Johnson (and all the PMs prior, it’s not a new question) have the power to decide on financial reparations for slavery, not the UK’s royal family. www.bbc.com/news/uk-60856763

derxa · 24/03/2022 07:03

it is so far removed from what is happening in the world right now. What's that?

intwrferingma · 24/03/2022 07:02

I am pretty neutral about the Royals and have just clocked the 'fence' pictures. I think if there hadn't been a whopping great war going on there would have been much more public comment about them.
And Kate is perfectly good at her job but I do think she gets up in the morning and slips into her pretty dresses singing "I feel pretty...' While William I imagine thinks 'Yah I've got my mate Raheem here, its all good..' And it's not really is it?

mumofEandE · 24/03/2022 07:00

@PodgePie

I am a huge royalist (obviously not Andrew but definitely William and Kate). However, I am struggling with their current tour, in a time of war, of crippling price rises and also Covid, it seems tasteless to be parading around in the sunshine in a stream of hugely expensive outfits, each one more luxurious than the next. I understand why international tours take place - and agree they have an important role - but shouldn’t this have been postponed given the climate?
I just had the same thought this morning - when I saw Kate in a (albeit beautiful) green ball gown - it is so far removed from what is happening in the world right now. And as for those photos of them shaking hands through a wired fence!
JemimaPiddleDick · 24/03/2022 06:59

YANBU
Parasites, every one of them.
Like tapeworms with tiaras.
I bear none of them personally any ill will and wish them no harm but this country’s obsession and obsequiousness towards people who are born into a particular family is puzzling

Tillymintpolo · 24/03/2022 06:57

It reeks of colonialism

Loopytiles · 24/03/2022 06:55

And what is the ‘important role’ royal visits play?

Loopytiles · 24/03/2022 06:54

Why are you a ‘huge royalist’

The reasons likely to be behind your discomfort with royal visits apply to many other, bigger aspects of the institution.

For example: the Queen being head of state for countries - direct continuation of imperialism. ‘Honours’ referring to the ‘British Empire’.

LabelMaker · 24/03/2022 06:54

Better than them saying sorry commonwealth we don't actually care about you right now. I disagree with the whole thing anyway but now seems a good a time as any.

Shiningpath · 24/03/2022 06:53

People do appreciate the outfits aren’t just a Duchess playing dress up right, they’re a showcase for British fashion and design around the world. You know, to increase business and support the economy.

EdithWeston · 24/03/2022 06:51

Apparently William has speeches to make as representative of the Queen where he’ll comment on the historical colonial relationships and presumably slavery so I’m interested to see how that is going to be handled

Done, and he expressed 'deep sorrow', saying slavery was abhorrent, "should never have happened" and "forever stains our history".

Wavypurple · 24/03/2022 06:50

It’s not just the tour, it’s just all a bit odd. Kings and queens and princesses living in big pretty castles wearing tiaras and ball gowns.

StooOrangeyForCrows · 24/03/2022 06:49

I think it's OK but I do wish in general the RF would tone down the ostentatious wealth generally and have thought this from when Diana first starting wearing ridiculously expensive clothes. It's all too tone deaf for my liking.

I'm dreading when Charles becomes King George. He's just been too spineless and weak for me to have any respect for him. He has qualities I admire too but I do not think he will make a good king.

DowningStreetParty · 24/03/2022 06:44

Sorry but going out to an active war zone for a photo opportunity would be crass and cynical and do worse than nothing to help anyone whatsoever. The royals have donated money to Ukraine. It’s been reported.

Unless they speak Ukrainian or Russian, or have medical skills or practical experience in supporting refugees (they don’t) and could actually do a job (which they couldn’t for security and diplomacy reasons), then they would be a massive burden to the aid agencies trying to help people in agonising need and trauma.

And throwing Buckingham palace open to house European refugees when they did not take them from Syria, Afghanistan and the countless wars before those? When the security risks would be so high for the hosts and the refugees? How would that possibly work, or help anyone?

Being a royal may be financially cosseted and in lots of ways ‘luxurious’ but it is a job and looks hideously stressful and boring. It is lacking in any kind of personal choice whatsoever. Royalty really isn’t what it’s imagined to be in the princess movies. It’s not just being really rich and wearing clothes and being loved by everyone. They’re diplomats 24/7 of the most stressful kind. Yes there’s a million times worse situations to be in obviously, but I wouldn’t swop with them if I had the choice. The Commonwealth countries deserve to see a representative of their Head of the Commonwealth just as much as the UK deserves to. They’re just doing their job.

Petrol and food costs will be affecting the places they’re visiting too, as Covid will have done. They’re highlighting local products and how scenic the locations are and the what’s wrong with that.

Apparently William has speeches to make as representative of the Queen where he’ll comment on the historical colonial relationships and presumably slavery so I’m interested to see how that is going to be handled.

TabithaHazel · 24/03/2022 06:43

@Wartywart

Royal tours can do a lot for tourism, to look on the positive side. Belize certainly looks fabulous with the Mayan ruins etc.
Belize is insanely popular with American tourists, I don’t think it is struggling amor particularly needs the approval/publicity from the British RF.
DressingPafe · 24/03/2022 06:41

So if we got rid of the RF would that make BJ our president? No thanks. It’s a bit ironic talking about privilege when the people actually running our country and taking money from our pockets also had a very big advantage from being born into wealth and status. I’d rather see efforts go into getting more “common people” into the government, where it really matters. At least the RF do a lot for charity.

EdithWeston · 24/03/2022 06:40

but shouldn’t this have been postponed given the climate?

It's the Platinum Jubilee tour - so there wasn't that much choice of when.

And I don't think it would be right to just tell the countries that their Head of State visit was off (the Cambridges are formally representing the Queen). How patronising would that be?

It's up to the countries concerned whether they decide to change their head of state. Very condescending to be telling them they're doing it wrong.

Self determination is an important matter.

It's their choice, on their timing. Until they make that choice, then it is right for them to be able to celebrate the Platinum Jubilee with the Royal Tour they are hosting.

derxa · 24/03/2022 06:31

The money spent on the trip could have been donated to the Ukrainian campaign for one thing. Really?

Joystir59 · 24/03/2022 05:42

@FlowerArranger

I don't think William and Kate had any choice regarding the nature of the tour. However, I do wish she'd stop wearing such outrageously expensive clothes. Given how everyone has to tighten their belts, it is entirely inappropriate. There are plenty of labels that offer a choice of stylish dresses of the kind she seems to favour. There is no reason why she shouldn't wear dresses that are not unique.
She is the epitome of bland and wears the dowdiest expensive clothes. Which adds insult to injury.
NuNameNuMe · 24/03/2022 05:40

Our Queen is every bit as much the monarch of Belize and Jamaica and their Head of State, as she is of Britain

Except citizens of Belize, Barbados and Jamaica need visas to visit their head of state in her gaff. Not to mention the scandal of Windrush victims being jailed in some cases as HM's government destroyed proof they had the right to stay in the UK I have deep respect for the queen for her public service, but the monarchy is anachronistic, and cannot be based on personal charisma alone, as we've seen with this lot - cyphers.

MakingProgress2022 · 24/03/2022 05:28

Tone deaf and out of tune with modern politics.

Time for more countries to follow the lead of Barbados and become republics.

carefullycourageous · 24/03/2022 05:20

@Alwaystheplusone

This tour is quite stunning in that it really feels like the beginning of the end for the monarchy. I think that William and Kate can feel it too. The meeting with the Jamaican prime minister was an absolute toe-curler.
I agree with this, I think the royals have no idea what to do about succession.