Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Duke & Duchess Of Cambridge tour … is it just me?

334 replies

PodgePie · 23/03/2022 21:25

I am a huge royalist (obviously not Andrew but definitely William and Kate). However, I am struggling with their current tour, in a time of war, of crippling price rises and also Covid, it seems tasteless to be parading around in the sunshine in a stream of hugely expensive outfits, each one more luxurious than the next. I understand why international tours take place - and agree they have an important role - but shouldn’t this have been postponed given the climate?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
5
TatianaBis · 24/03/2022 14:41

And cash for honours has always been a thing. And where would a proportion of cash come from pre-abolition?

Gettingthingsdone777 · 24/03/2022 14:34

@BadgerB it’s a very good question, probably hard to answer with a hard numeric figure, I think the short answer is the royal family did gain a lot of wealth through slavery. And if you consider the wider British aristocratic system, which the royal family presided over and benefited from, it seems likely you could also track much of their wealth and the general current wealth of the state back to the time of industrial slavery too. The Guardian has a very brief overview of the basics here: www.theguardian.com/uk-news/2022/mar/23/british-royal-family-monarchy-historical-links-to-slavery

Of course the poorer people in Britain at the time we’re less likely to be benefiting quite so much from this industry and were probably horrifically exploited themselves (eg. Chimney sweeps) by the many of the same people. Though of course they certainly didn’t endure brutality and exploitation on the same level and scale as enslaved peoples.

mathanxiety · 24/03/2022 14:28

The whatabouttery isn't misplaced, but this tour will have been planned for years.

What is tone deaf about it is the blinkers wrt growing republicanism in the former Caribbean colonies, helped enormously by the Windrush debacle and the fact that people from Caribbean commonwealth countries have to apply for visas to visit the so called 'mother country'. They know when they're not wanted.

The tour is pretty cringe worthy in that context.

TatianaBis · 24/03/2022 14:20

Did the royal family make "massive wealth" from slavery?

Royal African Company for a start - set up by James II before he was king - shipped slaves from Africa to S.America and English colonies.

It wasn’t just private individuals who profited from slavery, the government, industries and public infrastructure did too. Until its abolition, the slave trade was protected by the royal family as well as the government.

ToMockAKillingBird · 24/03/2022 14:18

Is it true that the host country pays for the clothing expenses etc? I'm sure I read that somewhere.

Politics4me · 24/03/2022 14:05

Are we not in danger of getting things arse about face?
Jamaica INVITED them It was not their decision to go and lord it over them.
The itinerary was planned and agreed by both sides months ago, right down to the comfort breaks.
All kinds of discussions have taken place about events in the future.
Costs are planned to fall within their annual allowances.
Nobody has done anything on a whim.

Lilifer · 24/03/2022 14:01

@AnastasiaRomanov please don't even try to use covid for this. I have seen multiple photos of K&W even on this tour of them sitting close to and touching other people - if covid was that much of a concern they would either be wearing masks everywhere or not travelling in first place

Roussette · 24/03/2022 13:54

The woman that reached out was 'not just anyone'. It was the Minister for Culture who she had met and who was trying to guide her towards a position for a photo.

TatianaBis · 24/03/2022 13:53

Very good piece from Lisa Hanna.

BadgerB · 24/03/2022 13:53

@C8H10N4O2

William wants to profess is "profound sorrow" about slavery?

How about handing back the massive wealth his family built on the bodies of slaves, instead of performance sorrow wearing a designer suit at a banquet before popping off to his next expensive holiday.

Words are cheap.

Did the royal family make "massive wealth" from slavery? I thought it was the rising business & industrial classes of the 17th & 18th centuries.

As long as my taxes don't have to pay it. Am fairly confident that my ancestors were poor agricultural labourers. Not likely to benefit from slavery.

Anon778833 · 24/03/2022 13:49

@PodgePie

I am a huge royalist (obviously not Andrew but definitely William and Kate). However, I am struggling with their current tour, in a time of war, of crippling price rises and also Covid, it seems tasteless to be parading around in the sunshine in a stream of hugely expensive outfits, each one more luxurious than the next. I understand why international tours take place - and agree they have an important role - but shouldn’t this have been postponed given the climate?

Why are you a royalist if you can see how crass the whole thing is?

TheKeatingFive · 24/03/2022 13:49

The idea that the people of Jamaica would take offence if Kate toned down the designer labels is ... quite something really 😆

AnastasiaRomanov · 24/03/2022 13:47

@Lilifer

https://www.sheknows.com/entertainment/articles/2548744/kate-middleton-jamaica-minister-snub-racism/amp/

Has anyone seen this video where the Duchess of Cambridge appears to back away or recoil from Olivia grange (minister for culture) reaching out to her - it looks bad - it might not be what it looks like but it looks pretty bad.

Apparently the explanation is that no one is meant to touch Kate or William - I find that unconvincing as I have seen them get up close to people in other photos even in this trip and even if it is a rule it again speaks to the insufferable arrant nonsense of royalty being better than anyone else.

I don’t think it’s arrogance. It’s partly a security issue, partly a Covid issue and partly that if anyone who felt like it could reach out and touch the RF it would mess up timings and create all sorts of issues.
Lilifer · 24/03/2022 13:45

@CruCru

Kate has a really hard job. She must look glorious and never say anything stupid. If she wears something expensive she’s profligate. If she wears something from the high street it shows her commoner roots.

I suspect that if she wore cheaper clothes to visit a country like Jamaica, people there may take offence. I’m sure her clothes are expensive but it isn’t as though she only wears them once. Even if she wore cheaper clothes, the actual cost would be a lot more than the hanger price - her clothes are adjusted for her and weights are sewn into the hem of her skirts.

The tour is a bit old fashioned. Presumably it was arranged quite a long time ago.

It doesn't matter how long ago it was arranged, anything can be cancelled if the prevailing circs require it as covid demonstrated.
Lilifer · 24/03/2022 13:44

www.sheknows.com/entertainment/articles/2548744/kate-middleton-jamaica-minister-snub-racism/amp/

Has anyone seen this video where the Duchess of Cambridge appears to back away or recoil from Olivia grange (minister for culture) reaching out to her - it looks bad - it might not be what it looks like but it looks pretty bad.

Apparently the explanation is that no one is meant to touch Kate or William - I find that unconvincing as I have seen them get up close to people in other photos even in this trip and even if it is a rule it again speaks to the insufferable arrant nonsense of royalty being better than anyone else.

CruCru · 24/03/2022 13:43

Kate has a really hard job. She must look glorious and never say anything stupid. If she wears something expensive she’s profligate. If she wears something from the high street it shows her commoner roots.

I suspect that if she wore cheaper clothes to visit a country like Jamaica, people there may take offence. I’m sure her clothes are expensive but it isn’t as though she only wears them once. Even if she wore cheaper clothes, the actual cost would be a lot more than the hanger price - her clothes are adjusted for her and weights are sewn into the hem of her skirts.

The tour is a bit old fashioned. Presumably it was arranged quite a long time ago.

TheKeatingFive · 24/03/2022 13:27

The only reason anyone is making anything else of this is because they want to make something of it.

But of course there are groups that want to make something of it. You can argue with their motives all you like, but they do exist.

It's really not very smart to hand these people ammunition. Especially given the many challenges the royals have been facing over the last few years. It's a huge PR mistake and I think it's a bit silly to deny that.

It's also quite an uncharacteristic mistake, which is why it's so glaring. Their team usually manage to avoid such pitfalls.

kateemo · 24/03/2022 13:13

To Jamaica, this visit is very relevant. Lisa Hanna said well what and how I feel. But without anything real to bring to the table, this is just a show.

https://www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2022/mar/24/snub-kate-middleton-jamaica-royal-slavery-prince-william-monarchy-reparations?CMP=ShareiOSAppp_Other

carefullycourageous · 24/03/2022 12:22

@TheKeatingFive

Just as, presumably, they wouldn't have the royal photo shoot beside a Troubles mural in NI, they should have planned this better to avoid the very unfortunate impression these pictures give.
I agree and can not understand why anyone is arguing with you about it - the photos look bad, they pay for PR staff to manage this stuff, those staff failed.
MangyInseam · 24/03/2022 12:20

@TheKeatingFive

Genuinely, do people think the removal of an existing fence would have been the right thing to do?

Who's talking about removing a fence? Confused.

Either plan the photo op somewhere else, don't invite the press to this venue, stage some shots with the public elsewhere. It's not particularly difficult, someone is employed to do this as their job.

I think this is really bordering on disingenuous.

We are not morons. We can see what is going on here, which is they are on a football field, and went over to say hi to the people watching.

The only reason anyone is making anything else of this is because they want to make something of it. They are using those people, who are real people who chose to come to that event and appear rather excited to say hello to Kate, as symbols of something for their own political ends. Yes, all black people are poor sods being subjugated by colonial forces and forced to come out to see the rf at the football pitch.

Right.

Roussette · 24/03/2022 12:18

ajandjjmum

I've said what I think previously. I can't keep repeating myself

Katya213 · 24/03/2022 12:14

@IcedPurple

Okay, removed the queen and became a republic now practically owned by China but smart enough to remain in the commonwealth.

How did removing the queen make Barbados 'practically owned by China'? She had only symbolic power as head of state. I don't think Justin Trudeau or Scott Morrison wait for HM's approval before making decisions, do they?

Go research it and you will see?
MangyInseam · 24/03/2022 12:12

@Loopytiles

Why are you a ‘huge royalist’

The reasons likely to be behind your discomfort with royal visits apply to many other, bigger aspects of the institution.

For example: the Queen being head of state for countries - direct continuation of imperialism. ‘Honours’ referring to the ‘British Empire’.

What is your point here?

You know that even if the UK decided to get rid of the monarchy, that does not mean that other countries would have to. They can, and some have, decided to become republics.

The extent to which people on this thread seem to think that other countries which have the same monarchy can't deal with their own affairs is pretty staggering. Who gives a shit if you think travel is |inappropriate" at this time? Why should the citizens of Jamaica care what a bunch of people in the UK think? Why would a bunch of British republicans think that they can tut tut the monarch of another country doing their jobs in that country?

It's really condescending.

ajandjjmum · 24/03/2022 11:35

@Roussette

I certainly haven't said the fence should be removed! As my last post has said! Nor has anyone else said that on here that I've seen?
But what was the option, if the fence in the photo was so offensive?

Kids had gathered there to see the visitors. Should they have been ignored then?

I get that the optics aren't great, but taken in context, there is no issue - although some people are trying to make it into one.

52andblue · 24/03/2022 11:32

I take your point. I don't believe that I was being xenophobic to say that the optics were still not great, esp added to the official Jamaican comments.
Many respect HMQ for her long reign & (perceived?) Duty. But once The Queen dies the RF is on a less sure footing I think. If William wishes to become King (in say 20 years time) it would be well to appear to be more aware of, and care more about the lives of ordinary people in the UK and around the globe.