Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Duke & Duchess Of Cambridge tour … is it just me?

334 replies

PodgePie · 23/03/2022 21:25

I am a huge royalist (obviously not Andrew but definitely William and Kate). However, I am struggling with their current tour, in a time of war, of crippling price rises and also Covid, it seems tasteless to be parading around in the sunshine in a stream of hugely expensive outfits, each one more luxurious than the next. I understand why international tours take place - and agree they have an important role - but shouldn’t this have been postponed given the climate?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
5
meditrina · 25/03/2022 18:26

It's a bit of both.

Diplomats will,have let it be known that HJ would be interested in a representative touring to mark the Jubilee. Realms will be able to say yes or no. And indeed some realms would proactively invite. It's a conversation, and it stretches back months/years.

What they visitors do is largely up to the hosts, but OK'ed by the visitors.

Lilifer · 25/03/2022 16:00

@TheKeatingFive

Can you imagine putting together a state visit at a community center and how the kids would feel if she wandered in wearing a ratty old shirt and jogging pants?

I agree that this is one of the stupidest comments I've ever read on here. There's oceans of space between 'jogging pants' and wardrobes well into 5/6 figures.

She would look perfectly presentable in a £200 dress. She has done so in the past on many occasions.

I quite agree.

Talk about straw man argument 😐

Puzzledandpissedoff · 25/03/2022 15:49

Do you know that Jamaica invited them or did the RF instigate the visit? Because I don't know

I don't pretend to know either, kateemo. I'm aware that "inviting the RF" (or at least appearing to) is the usual thing to do, though it's also true the royals could have engineered this one

Of course the islands could always have said no, but then they really might have got the gunboat!! Wink Grin

Roussette · 25/03/2022 15:15

Do you know that Jamaica invited them or did the RF instigate the visit?

How weird. I just posted this on the other thread before I saw this! Great minds think alike

kateemo · 25/03/2022 15:11

@Puzzledandpissedoff "Royal tours can take up to a year to plan, and are either instigated by the U.K. government, or by an invitation from the host country. The itinerary is put together based on whatever matters of national importance the host government would like to draw attention to, while also incorporating some of the visiting royal's personal interests.. . .The theory goes that they have invited the royal party to visit, and the resulting publicity will showcase their country as a tourist destination and draw positive attention to causes and initiatives."

That's from Town and Country Magazine. Do you know that Jamaica invited them or did the RF instigate the visit? Because I don't know. The fact is that Jamaica has lost a lot of tourism revenue in the last two years because of Covid. The RF wanted this "charm offensive" to try and consolidate support in the Caribbean after Mia Mottley broke their heart and they lost Barbados, their "little England". It is probably as simple as that. Also, who doesn't love a show? As long as it's respectful. The couple can be respectful as people, but their gestures and what they represent are not and can never be.

kateemo · 25/03/2022 15:11

@Puzzledandpissedoff "Royal tours can take up to a year to plan, and are either instigated by the U.K. government, or by an invitation from the host country. The itinerary is put together based on whatever matters of national importance the host government would like to draw attention to, while also incorporating some of the visiting royal's personal interests.. . .The theory goes that they have invited the royal party to visit, and the resulting publicity will showcase their country as a tourist destination and draw positive attention to causes and initiatives."

That's from Town and Country Magazine. Do you know that Jamaica invited them or did the RF instigate the visit? Because I don't know. The fact is that Jamaica has lost a lot of tourism revenue in the last two years because of Covid. The RF wanted this "charm offensive" to try and consolidate support in the Caribbean after Mia Mottley broke their heart and they lost Barbados, their "little England". It is probably as simple as that. Also, who doesn't love a show? As long as it's respectful. The couple can be respectful as people, but their gestures and what they represent are not and can never be.

Walton45123 · 25/03/2022 13:17

I posted earlier on this thread defending the tour to a degree. However over last couple of days I’ve changed my mind. I don’t blame the duke and duchess in particular - I’m sure they’re doing their best and have little choice in it all. I also think cancelling it would have caused great offence.
However the whole concept of a royal tour seems so anachronistic. And I think Kate is wearing ludicrously, ludicrously expensive clothes. A few designer pieces yes, but what about high end high street, like jigsaw, me&em etc? Would look very nice (all her clothes are tailored anyway) and somehow less offensive than thousands of pounds on a suit or a cocktail dress.

I’m not sure whose at fault really, it anyone. I just think times have changed.

tiktokontheclock · 25/03/2022 12:47

@dictatorboss

I genuinely think that the argument that Kate was showcasing designer clothes to help the economy by advertising their clothes is not an argument. The average British person would never spend that kind of money on a dress ..not even as a one off ! I think that her outfits should have been smart/ lovely but with a price tag of £500 max .
Agree - I realise most poshos aspire to be her but that one is a bit far fetched
Roussette · 25/03/2022 12:44

Keating
Interesting piece from the BBC and quite fair I think.

It should be noted that it's not just some of us on this thread that considers the football picture bad. The article talks of the organisers sorely lacking experience and allowing this to happen, thereby overshadowing the hard work. Which is exactly what I and others have said on here.
Not W&K's fault, their team's fault yes.

dictatorboss · 25/03/2022 11:49

I genuinely think that the argument that Kate was showcasing designer clothes to help the economy by advertising their clothes is not an argument.
The average British person would never spend that kind of money on a dress ..not even as a one off !
I think that her outfits should have been smart/ lovely but with a price tag of £500 max .

clpsmum · 25/03/2022 11:40

I agree it's in very poor taste

TheKeatingFive · 25/03/2022 11:32

Here's the bbc take on it ...

Prince William and Kate: The PR missteps that overshadowed a royal tour www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-60870417

Onlyhuman123 · 25/03/2022 11:21

I agree. Nothing against the Royals doing 'their bit' but at a time like this?! really??! The press going mad and quoting the costs of Kate's outfits...really inappropriate but she can't do anything about what the press say/do can she? shrugs

Puzzledandpissedoff · 25/03/2022 10:54

You seem awfully intent on portraying the Jamaicans as unhappy hosts

Not sure if that was for me or the person I was replying to @kateemo, but far from suggesting most Jamaicans and others are unhappy about the visits, it's me who keeps asking why their governments would have invited W&K if that was the case - something which nobody's yet commented on

It's not for me to speak for others, but it all looks awfully like another of those instances where most are okay with it (or perhaps simply don't care) and a few noisy protesters are making the most of it

TheKeatingFive · 25/03/2022 08:47

Can you imagine putting together a state visit at a community center and how the kids would feel if she wandered in wearing a ratty old shirt and jogging pants?

I agree that this is one of the stupidest comments I've ever read on here. There's oceans of space between 'jogging pants' and wardrobes well into 5/6 figures.

She would look perfectly presentable in a £200 dress. She has done so in the past on many occasions.

littlefirecar · 25/03/2022 08:39

[quote Boxowine]@Podgepie this isn’t exactly the first time members of the RF have gone on progress to visit member nations of the Commonwealth, or do you not quite consider the Caribbean nations to be on an equal footing with, say, Canada or Australia?

Their visit has a slightly anachronistic feel about it but until any of these countries decide to go they have as much reason to be visited as Liverpool does.

I don’t think that her wardrobe is any more expensive than any thing else she has ever worn, she looked amazing when she visited the US years ago. Why should she dress down for Belize and Jamaica, do they only rate dowdy old gardening clothes? Can you imagine putting together a state visit at a community center and how the kids would feel if she wandered in wearing a ratty old shirt and jogging pants? It would be offensive, like they weren’t worth dressing up for.[/quote]
can you imagine how the kids would feel?

😂😂😂

I think this is one of the most out of touch and hilarious comments on MN

Like some disadvantaged children at a community centre would be in tears because Kate wasn't wearing designer!!!

Pull yourself together @Boxowine! none of these parades of wealth and patronizing handshakes are necessary - be it the Carribean or Liverpool

kateemo · 25/03/2022 08:20

@Puzzledandpissedoff

The underlying fact - that it is Jamaica who has to initiate the (independence) process - remains They have been talking without action for at least a decade

However inconvenient that's very true - and after all the RF are hardly going to refuse independence and send a gunboat

As said, I'd much rather the RF's roles didn't exist at all and that therefore they wouldn't be there, but interestingly I've still seen nobody explain why Jamaica would invite W&K at all if so many really were against the visit

We have been independent since 1962. The government needs to hold a referendum in order to transition to Republican status. These are expensive and the country is not rich and has had other, more pressing concerns. This tour was billed as a "charm offensive" in the news, to guard against others doing what Barbados did. Because they now see that sentiment in the Caribbean is changing. This has become a pressing concern and polling suggests the vote may get over the line now.

You seem awfully intent on portraying the Jamaicans as unhappy hosts. Did you read the Lisa Hanna piece I posted earlier? She, a government minister, who was also portrayed as "snubbing" Kate, makes it clear they were welcome, but what they represent is not. In case you ask why, when David Cameron visited in 2015, he confidently addressed the Parliament and instructed them to "move on from slavery". Sure, he could. His family's wealth partially came from it, his country's wealth was made in the colonies. Jamaica and the Caribbean got Deforestation, a colonialist legacy, multigenerational poverty, and so on. Yet we are not entitled to be heard on the subject of reparations. We must just forget it all happened and move on. It is hurtful, and as Hanna said, not respectful.

So why are you heaping this unhappiness on Jamaica alone? They were hosted, they were given the royal treatment. They had a good time. Some people protested, others spoke out. All very normal. The RF and what they represent is not innocent, unless you believe in fairy tales.

AnastasiaRomanov · 25/03/2022 07:40

@ECN73

Having seen them on tour I’m convinced the Monarchy will end with them if not sooner. They seem like nice people but there is absolutely nothing interesting about either of them. They do not have the strength or charisma to hold this institution together. Which is a shame in a way - I am a bit of a traditionalist - but monarchy seems such an irrelevancy in today’s world. When our Queen is gone I think they should quietly call it a day and get day jobs.
It’s just not possible to quietly call it a day though is it? There’s a whole machine in operation which has been there for centuries.
carefullycourageous · 25/03/2022 05:16

As long as my taxes don't have to pay it. Am fairly confident that my ancestors were poor agricultural labourers. Not likely to benefit from slavery.

This is silly and based on an illogical view of tax. Your taxes have been paying compensation to the slave owners, if there were any further slavery-related payments they would come from taxation of course. That is how national finances work.

XDownwiththissortofthingX · 25/03/2022 02:40

Sausage roll?? Good grief, I don't want to see our Royals chowing down a sausage roll at a fuel station, whatever next....

I'd pay good money to watch them choke on a sausage roll at a fuel station. In fact, I'd even go as far as to pay for the sausage rolls.

testerwiki · 25/03/2022 01:41

Kate recoiling from the touch of one of the ministers the other day at a touchy-feely event says it all.

The whole thing looks stiff and forced to me. Her face screamed contempt. Stunning that's how the commoner behaved.

Simply awful

L0stinCyberspace · 24/03/2022 23:46

Ah yes @mathanxiety in the case of Ireland during Cromwellian times, it focused on landowners rather than "the hungry classes' as the period saw the transfer of 75% of Catholic-Irish owned land into the hands of English-Protestant.

mathanxiety · 24/03/2022 23:29

A great many English, Welsh and Scots also ended up in indentured servitude, though not for the reason the Irish did. The colonies were a handy destination for hundreds of thousands, perhaps millions of unfortunate British people. The deportation of British children to Australia continued well into the last century. For several hundred years the island of Great Britain was not a good place to live if you were a member of the hungry classes.

L0stinCyberspace · 24/03/2022 23:19

@mathanxiety not fleeing; 50,000 captured, deported and sold into indentured servitude in Barbados by Cromwellian forces in Ireland.

These are their descendants www.historyireland.com/the-redlegs-of-barbados/

ECN73 · 24/03/2022 23:09

Having seen them on tour I’m convinced the Monarchy will end with them if not sooner. They seem like nice people but there is absolutely nothing interesting about either of them. They do not have the strength or charisma to hold this institution together. Which is a shame in a way - I am a bit of a traditionalist - but monarchy seems such an irrelevancy in today’s world. When our Queen is gone I think they should quietly call it a day and get day jobs.

Swipe left for the next trending thread