Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Duke & Duchess Of Cambridge tour … is it just me?

334 replies

PodgePie · 23/03/2022 21:25

I am a huge royalist (obviously not Andrew but definitely William and Kate). However, I am struggling with their current tour, in a time of war, of crippling price rises and also Covid, it seems tasteless to be parading around in the sunshine in a stream of hugely expensive outfits, each one more luxurious than the next. I understand why international tours take place - and agree they have an important role - but shouldn’t this have been postponed given the climate?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
5
FiddlefigOnTheRoof · 23/03/2022 22:51

The tour is fine, the PR is dreadful. Some nice outfits for formal events is all well and good. But they should have balanced that with practical stuff to meet every day people.

PodgePie · 23/03/2022 22:51

@IcedPurple

And you don’t think that the many charities & foundations supporting Ukraine can be classed as a campaign? What does constitute a campaign then?

You tell me. You used the expression.

Are you saying that most British people have roots in Africa?

I would have thought it was fairly obvious I was talking about people in the Caribbean.

Yes. I am writing from the UK, on a UK hosted platform so when I say ‘most’ I refer to the UK readership. Not host nations. It didn’t look like the Jamaicans were terribly happy to host so I would imagine they’d have been delighted if Ukraine had diverted The Duke & Duchess from attending.

There seems to have been a mixed reception to the visit. There were protests, and there were also crowds of people waiting to see them, as was no doubt expected.

However, cancelling a visit which will have been planned at a very high level for months or even years would have been very awkward diplomatically. As has been said repeatedly, wars have been pretty much a constant throughout the queen's reign, even if Sky News wasn't providing live updates or half of Twitter didn't add the country's flag to their profile. Nobody was demanding that royal tours or other soft diplomacy be suspended indefinitely, or that the money saved be donated to a 'campaign'.

However, your post misses the point that rising fuel & food costs make this seem all the more extravagant

I don't actually disagree with that. I think the tour is a bit cringey and seems like a relic from another age. However, it's a Jubilee year and these countries are for the time being at least, Commonwealth realms. So they couldn't really be left out. Going forward, more Commonwealth countries are likely to become republics and I doubt we'll see too many tours of this nature in the future.

No, it wasn’t obvious at all (to me). I don’t have an insight into the lives of people in the Caribbean - but what I do understand is that this trip is poorly timed. Had she worn a bunch of LK Bennett or even Zara then it wouldn’t be so irksome. But the fact she’s parading around in YSL when people are having to make decisions between fuel & food doesn’t seem right.
OP posts:
GreenLunchBox · 23/03/2022 22:50

The optics aren't great Confused

Duke & Duchess Of Cambridge tour … is it just me?
Manekinek0 · 23/03/2022 22:50

I don't know anyone, in real life, who cares or pays attention to any of this. Get rid of the lot of them.

Blossomtoes · 23/03/2022 22:49

@Alwaystheplusone

This tour is quite stunning in that it really feels like the beginning of the end for the monarchy. I think that William and Kate can feel it too. The meeting with the Jamaican prime minister was an absolute toe-curler.
You and all the other republicans wish.
IcedPurple · 23/03/2022 22:48

[quote Scandisaurus22]@IcedPurple there really is no comparison in the way they are expected to behave. If our royalty were to behave any different to us, they simply would not be popular by anyone. A couple of years ago I stopped by a very local gas station, and there was our King topping up his car. Saw later they had a sausage roll at the same petrol station.[/quote]
If you're talking about the Swedish king, he's not a role model for anyone to follow. Complete sleaze bag.

And he lives in a palace, is guarded round the clock and has a life of extreme unearned luxury. He is certainly not like everyone else.

Alwaystheplusone · 23/03/2022 22:46

This tour is quite stunning in that it really feels like the beginning of the end for the monarchy. I think that William and Kate can feel it too. The meeting with the Jamaican prime minister was an absolute toe-curler.

IcedPurple · 23/03/2022 22:45

And you don’t think that the many charities & foundations supporting Ukraine can be classed as a campaign? What does constitute a campaign then?

You tell me. You used the expression.

Are you saying that most British people have roots in Africa?

I would have thought it was fairly obvious I was talking about people in the Caribbean.

Yes. I am writing from the UK, on a UK hosted platform so when I say ‘most’ I refer to the UK readership. Not host nations. It didn’t look like the Jamaicans were terribly happy to host so I would imagine they’d have been delighted if Ukraine had diverted The Duke & Duchess from attending.

There seems to have been a mixed reception to the visit. There were protests, and there were also crowds of people waiting to see them, as was no doubt expected.

However, cancelling a visit which will have been planned at a very high level for months or even years would have been very awkward diplomatically. As has been said repeatedly, wars have been pretty much a constant throughout the queen's reign, even if Sky News wasn't providing live updates or half of Twitter didn't add the country's flag to their profile. Nobody was demanding that royal tours or other soft diplomacy be suspended indefinitely, or that the money saved be donated to a 'campaign'.

However, your post misses the point that rising fuel & food costs make this seem all the more extravagant

I don't actually disagree with that. I think the tour is a bit cringey and seems like a relic from another age. However, it's a Jubilee year and these countries are for the time being at least, Commonwealth realms. So they couldn't really be left out. Going forward, more Commonwealth countries are likely to become republics and I doubt we'll see too many tours of this nature in the future.

TheKeatingFive · 23/03/2022 22:44

So, perhaps it's nice to see something else on the news and be able to admire (or not) the clothes, jewellery and pretty hair

See, there's tonnes of that shit on Instagram nowadays. No need to drop the hundreds of millions we spend on the royals so that Kate can delight us with a pretty frock.

PodgePie · 23/03/2022 22:44

@Blossomtoes

Are you saying that most British people have roots in Africa?

No, she’s saying most Caribbean people have roots in Africa. How much difference do you realistically think the cost of this tour would make if the funding was diverted? It’s a drop in the ocean.

Thanks for clarifying. Probably nothing but from the general feedback it doesn’t seem like anyone would have given a shit if it had been cancelled!
OP posts:
Scandisaurus22 · 23/03/2022 22:42

@IcedPurple there really is no comparison in the way they are expected to behave. If our royalty were to behave any different to us, they simply would not be popular by anyone. A couple of years ago I stopped by a very local gas station, and there was our King topping up his car. Saw later they had a sausage roll at the same petrol station.

Rosebel · 23/03/2022 22:39

Postpone it until when? Things aren't going to be any better re the Ukraine, Covid and high prices for years.
I don't think they are particularly enjoying it and possibly didn't want to do it but it wasn't their choice, it's part of their job.
I wouldn't say their outfits are flamboyant, expensive yes. That's not a new thing though, certainly not unique to Catherine.

Blossomtoes · 23/03/2022 22:38

Are you saying that most British people have roots in Africa?

No, she’s saying most Caribbean people have roots in Africa. How much difference do you realistically think the cost of this tour would make if the funding was diverted? It’s a drop in the ocean.

Scandisaurus22 · 23/03/2022 22:35

@IcedPurple you are right, but she also more often wears HM or similar to big events. When she’s out working, meeting people in all countries, she often looks like she could be anyone. I think it’s a better way to do it.

Jamoffmytoast · 23/03/2022 22:35

I don’t think that her wardrobe is any more expensive than any thing else she has ever worn, she looked amazing when she visited the US years ago. Why should she dress down for Belize and Jamaica, do they only rate dowdy old gardening clothes? Can you imagine putting together a state visit at a community center and how the kids would feel if she wandered in wearing a ratty old shirt and jogging pants? It would be offensive, like they weren’t worth dressing up for.

Since she seems to wear a new expensive outfit every time she goes out, she must have plenty of clothes. Why not just wear them more than once Confused

OverByYer · 23/03/2022 22:35

I do like Kate and William but this tour just doesn’t sit right with me, seems so frivolous when we are all worried sick about the cost of living, war and Covid

Seema1234 · 23/03/2022 22:34

I find it embarassing and awkward to watch. W and K flying to Jamaica to swan about and be cooed over. The whole idea if it is outdated. The Queen is Head of State to a country where the slave trade took place and the UK benefitted. I wonder how much support there is in Jamaica for being a Republican .

montysma1 · 23/03/2022 22:34

What possible difference does it make to the residents, of a, country whether some rich woman dresses well? Could anything be less important?

PodgePie · 23/03/2022 22:33

@IcedPurple

I’m sure you understand what the ‘Ukrainian campaign’ is.

Well no, not really.

There are many charities assisting humanitarian efforts in Ukraine, just as there are in other conflict zones around the world, but no 'Ukrainian campaign'.

Absolutely true war didn’t start 4 weeks ago but this is the closest we have been to active fire for a very long time. It feels closer to home for most.

I presume you're suggesting the tour should have been cancelled? Unilaterally by the UK?

And by 'most', I'm assuming you're referring exclusively to British people, not those in the host nations? Given that most have roots in Africa, maybe the many wars in that continent felt 'closer to home' for them than a war in Eastern Europe? Why should Caribbean countries be especially concerned about the 'Ukrainian campaign'?

And you don’t think that the many charities & foundations supporting Ukraine can be classed as a campaign? What does constitute a campaign then? Are you saying that most British people have roots in Africa? Yes. I am writing from the UK, on a UK hosted platform so when I say ‘most’ I refer to the UK readership. Not host nations. It didn’t look like the Jamaicans were terribly happy to host so I would imagine they’d have been delighted if Ukraine had diverted The Duke & Duchess from attending.

However, your post misses the point that rising fuel & food costs make this seem all the more extravagant

OP posts:
GirlsTalk250 · 23/03/2022 22:30

Utterly cringing at the people saying the royal visit is irrelevant!

Our Queen is every bit as much the monarch of Belize and Jamaica and their Head of State, as she is of Britain. Obviously the Queen can no longer visit herself, so she has sent her representatives.

IcedPurple · 23/03/2022 22:28

@Scandisaurus22

Not in the UK, but love our Swedish princess Victoria turning up everywhere in HM clothing or just generally in jeans, shorts and hair in a messy bun, just like the people she meets. She is making a change, for real, and her children are brought up the same. The world needs real people.
Crown Princess Victoria definitely does not wear H&M 'everywhere'! She frequently wears designer clothing for big events.
Ionlydomassiveones · 23/03/2022 22:27

This reply has been withdrawn

This has been withdrawn at the poster's request.

Scandisaurus22 · 23/03/2022 22:25

Not in the UK, but love our Swedish princess Victoria turning up everywhere in HM clothing or just generally in jeans, shorts and hair in a messy bun, just like the people she meets. She is making a change, for real, and her children are brought up the same. The world needs real people.

IcedPurple · 23/03/2022 22:24

I’m sure you understand what the ‘Ukrainian campaign’ is.

Well no, not really.

There are many charities assisting humanitarian efforts in Ukraine, just as there are in other conflict zones around the world, but no 'Ukrainian campaign'.

Absolutely true war didn’t start 4 weeks ago but this is the closest we have been to active fire for a very long time. It feels closer to home for most.

I presume you're suggesting the tour should have been cancelled? Unilaterally by the UK?

And by 'most', I'm assuming you're referring exclusively to British people, not those in the host nations? Given that most have roots in Africa, maybe the many wars in that continent felt 'closer to home' for them than a war in Eastern Europe? Why should Caribbean countries be especially concerned about the 'Ukrainian campaign'?

Blossomtoes · 23/03/2022 22:24

Maybe some people would @Sweetchocolatecandy. Lots of others wouldn’t. And there’d have been wholesale whinging about putting themselves in danger and valuable resources being wasted on protecting them. Anyone else remember the stick Diana got for the land mine walk?