Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To blow a year's salary on on impractical car I don't need?

194 replies

Silverclocks · 23/03/2022 21:11

I have a sensible medium sized family hatchback, less than a year old.

Household is DS1 who has his own small hatchback (that was previously mine), DS2 18yo, not showing any interest in learning to drive but it's something I should insist he does, an important life skill, but hard atm because of lack of availability of tests and lessons.

I'm early 50s thinking about early retirement.

I've had a shocking time over the last 2 years, the kind of things that make you realise life is short and "the future" doesn't happen for everyone.

I've got some cash saved to finance the early retirement, thinking that for a few years I can live off capital rather than taking pensions early. I'm not desperate to leave work, but I'd like more free time/ freedom iyswim.

Anyway, I have this idea that I'd love a little 2 seater convertible. DS1 says I can't have a "middle aged mum car", which of course makes it all the more attractive. Grin

Realistically I need to keep the sensible car too, although I could share it with DS2 once he starts learning.

Spending the cash effectively delays retirement by a year....

I know it makes no sense but that's kind of why I'd like to do it! I've spent a lifetime being sensible - that's why I can afford to do it.

What do you think?

OP posts:
EatYourVegetables · 24/03/2022 09:45

I’m with your DS2. Have you heard of climate crisis? You want to have 3 or 4 cars in a 3 person household?

I’m… yeah. No. Buying stuff doesn’t make you happy, just ruins the environment.

ToxicBuns · 24/03/2022 09:42

You earned it, you spend it. I think it's a great idea. 👍

ASaucerfulOfSecrets · 24/03/2022 09:39

My beautiful, wonderful aunt had your dilemma some years ago. In the end she purchased a stunning British racing green sports car just after her 50th and she absolutely loved it.
That car made her so happy and I’m eternally grateful she bought it because she sadly developed cancer and died at 55.

Point is OP, life can be cruelly short so enjoy every moment of it whilst you can.

Politics4me · 24/03/2022 09:27

The modern answer to entry level of 'sports car' is still Mazda 5. They are reliable millions of them.
I was looking for a Jaguar saloon for £3000. amazing cars available, wonderful performance and comfort. Best pay a bit more though.
The anti car/anti fun/ lobby are making life more difficult for people to drive for enjoyment.
Buy now and get some memories before they put a tax on enjoying life in any way.

Tombero · 24/03/2022 09:12

Go for it. I loved my mx-5, had to sell it when the dc came along.

ceiliamary · 24/03/2022 08:54

You jolly well go and have some fun. If you like golf Buy good kit
If you like to drive buy a good car that you will enjoy.
Are you thinking of a classic type MGB, Jaguar or similar?

HomeHomeInTheRange · 24/03/2022 08:53

Personally, I wouldn’t do it.

Working for an extra year might feel different in a few years time to how it does now.

Because ‘things happen’ you never know. I was saving over a planned number of years, but the COVID zapped my job a couple of years earlier than planned, so I am living off the early retirement savings now.

I WOULD like to do something fun but not quite so profligate. Nee cars depreciate so fast in the first 2 years you might as well tip tenners down the drain in handfuls. Taxing, insuring more cars than necessary… But that’s just me.

I would do a nice holiday, and keep planning towards a fab early retirement with my choices still open.

bluetongue · 24/03/2022 08:44

Go for it OP. I’m considering buying my first brand new car ever at the age of 46. My family tend to be very tight with money and I can see from my parents that it’s possible to be too careful with money.

I’ve paid off a decent chunk of my mortgage and have no other debts so why the hell not.

Getoff · 24/03/2022 08:35

I got confused, I meant to say I could have ordered a right-hand-drive Golf in Germany.

Getoff · 24/03/2022 08:33

If you're near retirement, but willing to work a year extra to have the car, then it sounds like you've weighed up the cost reasonably. I wouldn't want to own two cars, I hardly do enough driving to justify one, but obviously your life is different.

At a similar age and financial position, having driven older used cars all my life, I set out to spend an "unlimited" amount on car. It turned out that my ideal car was a middle-of-the-range Golf (with lots of options) costing half my maximum budget. Still happy with it, several years later.

(The only thing I might have done better is buy it from Germany. Apparently in Germany you can choose from the same range of custom colours that in the UK are only offered on Audis, so I could have had it in purple or yellow. I read somewhere that I could have ordered a left-hand drive car from a German dealer. I think I also read somewhere that you could possibly order custom colours by contacting VW UK directly, the dealer ordering system here didn't allow it, but they could specify it on their computer systems.)

MoonbeamSprinkles · 24/03/2022 08:28

People on Mumsnet are weird about cars.

It’s like it’s a badge of honour to have the oldest car that you bought twenty years ago for 20p.
Then those people will give you advice about buying cars even though the last time they bought one was twenty years ago.

At the minute because of the lead times on new cars you can get a really good deal for a new car and second hand cars are eye watering.
Also the dealers prefer PCP to cash so you can often get a better deal on PCP than if you bought cash.

If I were you I’d buy a brand new car on PCP and then if you don’t like it you’ve always got the option of giving it back in 3 years.

Also get the exact car you like not one a little but like it.

Life is for living!

Riseholme · 24/03/2022 08:27

Definitely go for it OP.

I’ve started treating myself more.
Only last week I spent time with dm and rather than go straight home afterwards I visited a beautiful city on my way home and stayed in a lovely hotel for the night.

konasana · 24/03/2022 08:25

Oh yes go for it! Get the car! Life is short and you will have sooo much fun driving it, it will be completely worth it. Or at least go for some test drives and see how you feel.

Silverclocks · 24/03/2022 08:08

Agree with regards to the sneery part. It's very fun watching people try to compute that the car is mine and not DH's.

This really gets on my nerves. People have always assumed our comfortable lifestyle was down to DH's income more than mine when in fact I was the (slightly) higher income and far better with money. Now I'm a comfortably placed widow they assume I'm living it up on the life insurance, when in fact I'm entirely supporting myself and saving everything else for DC. I don't suppose that perception will change if I buy a fancy car.

OP posts:
LadyFlumpalot · 24/03/2022 08:03

@Boood

I have an MX-5 roadster and I say do it! Driving home from work with the roof down goes a long way towards making commuting time your time rather than their time.

Also, occasionally you’ll meet someone sneery and disapproving about a middle aged woman having the audacity to drive a selfish car, and it’s really nice knowing you’ve pissed off the miserable twat.

Agree with regards to the sneery part. It's very fun watching people try to compute that the car is mine and not DH's.

OP, people are really weird about people having nice cars. Buy it. Enjoy it. Love it. Join owners clubs and find track days. If you end up with something Japanese then come along to days like Japfest at Silverstone or JDM at Combe. Immense fun.

alwayswrighty · 24/03/2022 07:52

I am with you @Silverclocks and reckon you should buy it. Like you said you probably will go part time and not completely retire anyway.

I went and looked at the Mercedes amg. I love them. Second hand they are more expensive than brand new currently so I'd definitely order new and wait.

Boood · 24/03/2022 07:51

I have an MX-5 roadster and I say do it! Driving home from work with the roof down goes a long way towards making commuting time your time rather than their time.

Also, occasionally you’ll meet someone sneery and disapproving about a middle aged woman having the audacity to drive a selfish car, and it’s really nice knowing you’ve pissed off the miserable twat.

LadyFlumpalot · 24/03/2022 07:46

Go for it. If you can afford it and it will bring you joy. I did, I love my car. I've made so many friends through track days, learnt how to service it and fix things that break and discovered a whole wonderful new hobby.

AutumnOrange · 24/03/2022 07:34

I am on the bones of my arse at the moment and I still say fucking do it!
And when you drive it have the biggest smile on your face whilst acknowledging you went through hard times to get there.

BritInUS1 · 24/03/2022 07:28

Go for it - you only live one x

PotBelliesGiveGoodLoving · 24/03/2022 07:01

Only if it's a Caterham.

liveforsummer · 24/03/2022 06:54

@enjoyingscience

Get a second hand one. Driving with the top down is fabulous fun, and will be fun every time you do it. You can’t see the reg plate from inside the car though - it surely doesn’t matter if it’s a few years old already? Spend the change on champagne.
Second had cars are so expensive atm that if you want one in new like condition inside and out then you're as well getting a new one. Just order it now OP as there can be a wait currently and you want it for the start of summer.
liveforsummer · 24/03/2022 06:52

@nocoolnamesleft

Read the room.
What room - everyone's circumstances are different. Personally I'm working 2 jobs sometimes 18 hours of the day just to put petrol in my 15 year old banger to get to said jobs and I say go for it. It's only a year. Can you go part time initially OP to have extra time but still earn? First thing I'd do if I won the lottery would be buy my dream car.
Silverclocks · 24/03/2022 06:47

[quote vipersnest1]@Silverclocks, I'm a bit confused by your comment 'I don't think you are' about my post?
Do whatever you fancy. That's what I did, and that was the point of my post. I was just trying to save you a few quid if that was possible.[/quote]
I understand that, but I don't think you can save much money by buying a nearly new car at the moment. Newish secondhand cars have become very expensive, in some cases more expensive than new cars because of the long wait times for new cars. I understand that's been the case in the past and I daresay will be again, but not at the moment.

OP posts:
XelaM · 24/03/2022 06:46

Buying a new car outright is a bit stupid as it depreciates in value the minute you drive off. New cars are usually bought on lease/finance so you can return them in a few years and get another new one