Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

I wonder how Leave voters feel about P&O Ferries.

212 replies

lecreusetpeppermill · 23/03/2022 15:12

I know many people voted one way or the other for different reasons, but those who were concerned about immigration 'swallowing jobs' or driving wages down.......how do they feel about this recent story?

Do they not feel lied to?

OP posts:
Merrymouse · 24/03/2022 10:24

@DdraigGoch

Employment laws haven't changed - maritime workers always had very little protection.

What we can do now - which we couldn't do before - is exclude DP World from government contracts. Such action wasn't allowed under EU law.

Although apparently the government still want to go ahead and give them contract for Freeports?
ginghamstarfish · 24/03/2022 10:22

I imagine most people feel the same, as it's not connected with Brexit ... might be an idea to do a bit of research before trying to stir up anti-Brexit debate.

SeasonFinale · 24/03/2022 10:21

@Justcallmebebes

Nice try OP but this is a Dubai owned company so absolutely nothing to do with Brexit.
Except insofar as neatly explained by @ChiswickFlo
DdraigGoch · 24/03/2022 10:19

Employment laws haven't changed - maritime workers always had very little protection.

What we can do now - which we couldn't do before - is exclude DP World from government contracts. Such action wasn't allowed under EU law.

TheRealityCheque · 24/03/2022 10:12

@BambinaJAS

You won't get very far here.

People who voted Brexit do one of three things now:

  1. Pretend they never voted for Brexit
  2. Pretend the UK economy is roaring along
  3. Pretend they understood what they voted for

Nobody likes to be conned. My expectation is for them to double and triple down on their views.

Cost of living crisis however will definitely impact their views.

That may cause a change. Hopefully.

The same cost of living crisis that is also affecting EU countries?
BambinaJAS · 24/03/2022 00:31

You won't get very far here.

People who voted Brexit do one of three things now:

  1. Pretend they never voted for Brexit
  2. Pretend the UK economy is roaring along
  3. Pretend they understood what they voted for

Nobody likes to be conned. My expectation is for them to double and triple down on their views.

Cost of living crisis however will definitely impact their views.

That may cause a change. Hopefully.

Hopeforall · 23/03/2022 23:44

Op there’s a Brexit topic in Other Stuff - you will get more answers there.

Justanotherlurker · 23/03/2022 22:29

While we are at it, how about asking, how do lockdown enthusiasts feel about P&O. Almost all of the crises at the moment are down to the over zealous Covid restrictions. Struggling businesses, higher taxes, runaway inflation, the list goes on. Watching Netflix and baking banana bread while economy was shut down doesn’t feel like a good idea anymore, does it?

The obviouysly haven't been geen a narrative to post yet, OP wanted to come across as a critical thinker and knee jerk into an anti brexit narrative because they quickly posted something from twitter without really understanding anything of the situation that she openly admitted, the benefit of MN is that they can name change, memory hole this and start a thread somewhere down the line that is loosley related and pull the 'didn't know what they where voting for' card and fill up a thread, maybe even carry it on to multiple threads.

I shouldn't need to say this, but I am staunch remainer, but if there is one place where the narrative of people who voted remain are more intelligent or critical thinkers, MN isn't it

Clavinova · 23/03/2022 22:13

But surely its better that lorries don't use us as a land bridge? They filled up with petrol before coming here so the uk made no money out of that, they paid no road tax and they caused pollution. Surely having one fifth 20% fewer lorries on the road is a good thing?

I agree.

Longleggedgiraffe · 23/03/2022 22:11

@lecreusetpeppermill

Ah, I had a simplistic view of this, not too well up, sorry.

I think i was just curious about the double standard - people wishing to reduce immigration but accepting it if we can exploit them.

I see this is more complex.

It's P&O who are doing the exploiting. This is soley down to them, no Brexiteers involved.
Clavinova · 23/03/2022 22:08

For the record, French seafarers working for P&O have not been sacked.

How many French seafarers do they employ? Perhaps their French staff are all land based?

How did Irish Ferries do it in 2005, in that case?

And 2019?

Irish Ferries is being accused of using foreign crews to pay below the minimum wage.

SIPTU said the company's vessels fly foreign flags and it does not pay Irish minimum wage rates to foreign workers.

The Union will hold a protest later at Dublin Port later to highlight the issue.

www.irishexaminer.com/business/arid-30903078.html

sst1234 · 23/03/2022 22:01

While we are at it, how about asking, how do lockdown enthusiasts feel about P&O. Almost all of the crises at the moment are down to the over zealous Covid restrictions. Struggling businesses, higher taxes, runaway inflation, the list goes on. Watching Netflix and baking banana bread while economy was shut down doesn’t feel like a good idea anymore, does it?

IcedPurple · 23/03/2022 21:12

[quote futuremoneyinbank]@IcedPurple the fire and rehire law we have in UK (Tories have just not turned up to the Labour movement to abolish it). Yes, Irish have it too, but it can't happen in EU employment law.[/quote]
I don't understand.

If 'fire and rehire' happened in Ireland, which is an EU member, how can it not happen in 'EU employment law'? Isn't employment law, outside of a few basic regulations, at the discretion of individual member states, not the EU?

Merrymouse · 23/03/2022 21:04

French employment law was different to U.K. employment law before Brexit. It’s much more difficult to make somebody redundant in France.

Justanotherlurker · 23/03/2022 21:01

Why not be kind and explain to all those who had not a clue what they were voting for.

Ironic saying this because this could have happened even if the vote went to remain, so it looks like you are not aware of what you was voting for either...

Newrumpus · 23/03/2022 20:56

sadly no takers here 😀

Possibly because the question makes no sense

Parker231 · 23/03/2022 20:52

The P & O ships relating to the redundancies were registered in Cyprus and the Bahamas.

Justanotherlurker · 23/03/2022 20:33

The government recently snuck through a change in employment legislation for those employed on ships.
They are now governed by the employment legislation of the country to which the individual ships are registered. Ships are registered in countries throughout the world. In the case of P & O the ships were not registered in the U.K. so U.K. employment legislation does not apply. P & O have apparently filled the necessary paperwork regarding the redundancies with the different countries .

Yes, they 'snuck' in an EU directive in 2018...

Iflyaway · 23/03/2022 20:30

😂 wth are you even talking about OP, clueless.

Oh, o.k. so you know all there is to know everything there is to know about how Brexit works....

Why not be kind and explain to all those who had not a clue what they were voting for.

We are not all up on geopolitics.

As a single, working mum, taking care of elderly parents, and now a war going on, excuse me for being ignorant about some stuff happening in the world.

Parker231 · 23/03/2022 20:27

The government recently snuck through a change in employment legislation for those employed on ships.

They are now governed by the employment legislation of the country to which the individual ships are registered. Ships are registered in countries throughout the world. In the case of P & O the ships were not registered in the U.K. so U.K. employment legislation does not apply. P & O have apparently filled the necessary paperwork regarding the redundancies with the different countries .

Pixiedust1234 · 23/03/2022 20:19

@lecreusetpeppermill

Ah, I had a simplistic view of this, not too well up, sorry.

I think i was just curious about the double standard - people wishing to reduce immigration but accepting it if we can exploit them.

I see this is more complex.

You are indeed very confused. it is not complex at all. Let me try and break it down very simply:

People = Joe Public, the workers, wanting to reduce immigration so more jobs/better pay so they can eat/pay bills/roof over their head etc
Exploiters = business owners or companies with stakeholders using the excuse of too many workers and not enogh jobs means poor working conditions/low pay etc

Its not double standards when it isn't the same group of people. It is also nothing to do with brexit as its been a labour/tory thing for decades. Try learning history. HTH

futuremoneyinbank · 23/03/2022 19:57

@IcedPurple the fire and rehire law we have in UK (Tories have just not turned up to the Labour movement to abolish it). Yes, Irish have it too, but it can't happen in EU employment law.

StarlightLady · 23/03/2022 18:23

For the record, French seafarers working for P&O have not been sacked. Where as UK law is somewhat blurred (this will be one for the courts), French law is clearer. They are protected by “Code du Travail”. Redundancies have to take account of seniority and burden.

How French seafarers will work alongside their new workmates will remain to be seen.

But the ships are EU registered and it does somewhat explode the myth that the EU ruled over the UK; that was not so.

Smokeahontas · 23/03/2022 18:00

@futuremoneyinbank

However interesting that other EU workers kept their jobs (protected) as theirs (thanks to EU law) can't be loopholed by the unemployment law saying they can be made redundant and the job re-hashed and given to workers for a fraction of the pay.
ICYMI

m.independent.ie/irish-news/irish-ferries-will-abandon-routes-unless-staff-go-quietly-25967299.html

tttigress · 23/03/2022 17:48

Erm, Irish workers that live and work our of Ireland were also effected:

www.irishtimes.com/news/ireland/irish-news/union-says-60-irish-employees-among-the-800-crew-sacked-by-p-o-ferries-1.4831386P

It is nothing to do with Brexit.

Where do you get your news from?