Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

I wonder how Leave voters feel about P&O Ferries.

212 replies

lecreusetpeppermill · 23/03/2022 15:12

I know many people voted one way or the other for different reasons, but those who were concerned about immigration 'swallowing jobs' or driving wages down.......how do they feel about this recent story?

Do they not feel lied to?

OP posts:
Newrumpus · 25/03/2022 22:48

BambinaJAS

There is your (and leavers) mistake.

You can't "move on" from Brexit.

The effects will be with us for the next 30 years.

Say hello to massive wage devaluation and falling living standards.

I would be very concerned if I was a leaver and was not very wealthy.

Do your forecasts only affect leavers who are not wealthy? Remainers are exempt from wage deflation and falling living standards then?

Polyanthus2 · 25/03/2022 18:58

But this is a different scenario than EU migrants and non-EU migrants - because we have strict immigration laws which wouldn't allow non-EU migrants to take jobs .... . . . .. . . except there is something to do with the merchant marine where they can live wherever because of where the ships are registered. (according to DH when I pointed out that the phillipino or indian staff won't be allowed to move to the UK)

jessycake · 25/03/2022 16:04

I voted Remain , but people's working conditions have been taking a dive for years .

BambinaJAS · 25/03/2022 14:00

@Polyanthus2

It's inevitable I fear - cheap labour moving into UK jobs. I read the front pages of foreign papers (in english) the same thing all over. I think it was a Brazilian paper that had a ranting headline about their IT graduates being poached abroad. People move to the best paying place or whatever - Uk residents have always moved abroad - the Middle East/ USA etc Indians/Phillipinos are moving here.
Brexit opened the floodgates for non-EU migration.

While EU migration nosedived after 2016, non-EU migration has materially increased since 2016.

UK is now replacing semi-skilled and non-skilled EU migrants with semi-skilled and non-skilled non-EU migrants.

This was explained many times to the pro-Brexit folks, who seriously thought Brits would take these jobs.

Note: the lack of undestanding of how the UK operates in geo and socio-economic terms from the UK natives was just amazing to me.

Brexit was always about accelerating a race to the bottom in terms of UK labour protections and wages by replacing EU labour with non-EU labour (lower wages and benefits).

MarshaBradyo · 25/03/2022 09:48

@Kendodd

If anything, remain voters are the ones who were happy with unlimited low skilled immigration which pushed down wages (mostly affecting the working class that they hate so much), to service their cheap takeaway coffees and push up their house prices/filled their buy-to-lets. I doubt that middle class remain voters care about low wages and competition as long as they get their cheap ferry ride to France.

Blaming Brexit on working class voters is nothing but a lie. Very comfortable home countries pensioners with big houses and fat pensions voted Leave in their droves.

I don’t think anyone should be blamed for how they choose to vote in a referendum but key trends have been recognised, including around income etc

JRF covers it well.

Papayamya · 25/03/2022 09:47

@StormzyinaTCup

Blaming Brexit on working class voters is nothing but a lie. Very comfortable home countries pensioners with big houses and fat pensions voted Leave in their droves.

I don't think that demographic fits with the well used 'Brexit voters have been hoodwinked by SM trolls and bots' narrative. I doubt you'd find droves of pensioners on Twitter/Facebook etc.

I think the bigger issue is assuming anyone who voted for it has no brainpower. Yes a lot of working class people did vote for it, but people are perhaps uncomfortable delving into why, and its not simply because omg immigrants.
SamphiretheStickerist · 25/03/2022 09:45

@BambinaJAS

There is your (and leavers) mistake.

You can't "move on" from Brexit.

The effects will be with us for the next 30 years.

Say hello to massive wage devaluation and falling living standards.

I would be very concerned if I was a leaver and was not very wealthy.

Take a look at what happened to New Zealand in the 1970s when they lost access to their primary market (UK).

Thats exactly what is going to happen to the UK now.

You voted for exactly this. Enjoy!

And a global pandemic has had absolutely no influence whastsoever?

It is only the UK/GB that is suffering an economic downturn, no other country at all?

No other country with fuel issues?

No?

Blame Brexit where such blame is due. But trying to tie in every ill ever, make it purely a UK problem, when the global issues are starkly apparent to everyone just makes your argument weak, ridiculous!

MarshaBradyo · 25/03/2022 09:38

This is a good article on demographics of vote

www.jrf.org.uk/report/brexit-vote-explained-poverty-low-skills-and-lack-opportunities

A few charts useful re income, attitudes and age

I wonder how Leave voters feel about P&O Ferries.
I wonder how Leave voters feel about P&O Ferries.
I wonder how Leave voters feel about P&O Ferries.
StormzyinaTCup · 25/03/2022 09:29

Blaming Brexit on working class voters is nothing but a lie. Very comfortable home countries pensioners with big houses and fat pensions voted Leave in their droves.

I don't think that demographic fits with the well used 'Brexit voters have been hoodwinked by SM trolls and bots' narrative. I doubt you'd find droves of pensioners on Twitter/Facebook etc.

Kendodd · 25/03/2022 09:02

If anything, remain voters are the ones who were happy with unlimited low skilled immigration which pushed down wages (mostly affecting the working class that they hate so much), to service their cheap takeaway coffees and push up their house prices/filled their buy-to-lets. I doubt that middle class remain voters care about low wages and competition as long as they get their cheap ferry ride to France.

Blaming Brexit on working class voters is nothing but a lie. Very comfortable home countries pensioners with big houses and fat pensions voted Leave in their droves.

lonelyapple · 25/03/2022 08:58

@lecreusetpeppermill

I know many people voted one way or the other for different reasons, but those who were concerned about immigration 'swallowing jobs' or driving wages down.......how do they feel about this recent story?

Do they not feel lied to?

If anything, remain voters are the ones who were happy with unlimited low skilled immigration which pushed down wages (mostly affecting the working class that they hate so much), to service their cheap takeaway coffees and push up their house prices/filled their buy-to-lets. I doubt that middle class remain voters care about low wages and competition as long as they get their cheap ferry ride to France.
Polyanthus2 · 25/03/2022 08:47

It's inevitable I fear - cheap labour moving into UK jobs.
I read the front pages of foreign papers (in english) the same thing all over. I think it was a Brazilian paper that had a ranting headline about their IT graduates being poached abroad.
People move to the best paying place or whatever - Uk residents have always moved abroad - the Middle East/ USA etc
Indians/Phillipinos are moving here.

Kendodd · 25/03/2022 08:19

Farage has a lot to answer for as well

I agree.
Last I heard from Putin's useful idiot was him flag waving for Russia. I suppose being against net zero is, again, doing Putin work for him.

Merrymouse · 25/03/2022 08:07

The reason why this is all connected to Brexit is because the leavers in the UK chose Boris. They knew full well at the time just how bad he was.

Is this completely true though?

Members of the Conservative Party chose Johnson, and the alternative to Johnson was Corbyn. I suspect that many right wing Remainers held their noses and ticked the blue box.

TebayOrNotTebay · 25/03/2022 08:00

@ChiswickFlo explained in the 7th post how this was an indirect consequence of Brexit. Other posters have pointed out the effect of Brexit on the land bridge.

Brexit isn’t the sole cause, but to say it is irrelevant is delusional

BambinaJAS · 25/03/2022 07:54

@Merrymouse

Where this does link to Brexit is that the ferries were just a smaller part of the package when Dubai bought Southampton and London Gateway ports, which are now a central part of the Freeports scheme.

Freeports are part of the ‘Singapore’ Brexit vision - low tax, low regulation. The government appears set to hand over large parts of this operation to the people they are now claiming they will punish for breaking regulations.

Whatever the ins and outs of Brexit, I thought most people voted for it under the impression that it would protect British jobs. However, what can the government do once Dubai has so much control of infrastructure?

I’m not making a point about leavers/Remainers here - just generally concerned about this government’s competence and honesty.

The reason why this is all connected to Brexit is because the leavers in the UK chose Boris. They knew full well at the time just how bad he was.

Boris then chose a cabinet full of incompetent Brexit rubber stampers.

Thats precisely why we are seeing so much corruption and incompetence right now in British politics.

None of these folks would have ever been near the corridors of influence or power without Brexit

Think about it....

Gavin Williamson?
Raab?
Patel?
Braverman?

These folks are far below the average.

BambinaJAS · 25/03/2022 07:49

@JackieWeaverHandforthCouncil

And Farages next publicity sucking bandwagon is ‘Net Zero’ where he’ll convince the 17.4 million that the economic pain they’re suffering isn’t anything to do with extreme right wing policies but the ‘green agenda’. They will then vote for their water to become more polluted and for more coal stations choking the air to get back at lefties and the ‘woke mob’.
Mostly agree with this.

The UK electorate is far too easily manipulated by the media.

Farage has a lot to answer for as well

Merrymouse · 25/03/2022 07:47

Where this does link to Brexit is that the ferries were just a smaller part of the package when Dubai bought Southampton and London Gateway ports, which are now a central part of the Freeports scheme.

Freeports are part of the ‘Singapore’ Brexit vision - low tax, low regulation. The government appears set to hand over large parts of this operation to the people they are now claiming they will punish for breaking regulations.

Whatever the ins and outs of Brexit, I thought most people voted for it under the impression that it would protect British jobs. However, what can the government do once Dubai has so much control of infrastructure?

I’m not making a point about leavers/Remainers here - just generally concerned about this government’s competence and honesty.

JackieWeaverHandforthCouncil · 25/03/2022 07:40

And Farages next publicity sucking bandwagon is ‘Net Zero’ where he’ll convince the 17.4 million that the economic pain they’re suffering isn’t anything to do with extreme right wing policies but the ‘green agenda’. They will then vote for their water to become more polluted and for more coal stations choking the air to get back at lefties and the ‘woke mob’.

sst1234 · 25/03/2022 07:39

@BambinaJAS

There is your (and leavers) mistake.

You can't "move on" from Brexit.

The effects will be with us for the next 30 years.

Say hello to massive wage devaluation and falling living standards.

I would be very concerned if I was a leaver and was not very wealthy.

Take a look at what happened to New Zealand in the 1970s when they lost access to their primary market (UK).

Thats exactly what is going to happen to the UK now.

You voted for exactly this. Enjoy!

Did you miss the bit where Covid destroyed businesses, which is what happened here.

Aside from that, your attitude is really weird. And immature. What do you mean ‘enjoy’. Some people voted differently to how some of us voted. Do you also say this to Tory voters and then feel good about ‘winning about the argument’ but never having your preferred party in power because they, like you, just insult prospective voters.

Finally, what do you propose to do if not ‘move on’? Can you change it? It’s obsessive and strange and irrational to not ‘move on’.

layladomino · 25/03/2022 07:39

*Honestly some people wont just leave it alone. Claiming that the Leave voters didnt know what they were voting for, stating that all of them secretly think this but wont admit it.

There was a Refendum. Leave won and Remain lost. Just accept it and move on.

I was grabbed when shopping and asked to sign for a people's vote presumably to get another answer. I pulled her arm off me and said there was a People's Vote. What next - best of three.*

This

The financial crisis we're in? So are EU countries (and much of the rest of the world).

There's been the small matter of a pandemic that's made sure of that.

If we're going to debate whether Brexit was the right decision in the short term / long term, fair enough (although I'll step out as I've moved on), but please let's have an informed debate that doesn't pick headlines to suit.

As for P&O. Disugusting behaviour that could have happened whether or not there was Brexit.

JackieWeaverHandforthCouncil · 25/03/2022 07:32

This has nothing to do with Brexit but it has a lot to do with the current Tory regime. They support firing and rehiring practices. Many of the Brittania Unchained are in top jobs. They believe the British are the ‘worst idlers in the world’. They love Ayn Rand survival of the fittest crap.

If you voted for Tory’s to cut ‘red tape’ then you voted for this. Red tape includes worker protections. P&O would never have attempted this under a different government. Mark my words other companies are watching to see the outcome to see if they can get away with this too.

Nevertheless, I’m certain many complaining about P&O today will vote Tory next time.

BambinaJAS · 25/03/2022 07:24

There is your (and leavers) mistake.

You can't "move on" from Brexit.

The effects will be with us for the next 30 years.

Say hello to massive wage devaluation and falling living standards.

I would be very concerned if I was a leaver and was not very wealthy.

Take a look at what happened to New Zealand in the 1970s when they lost access to their primary market (UK).

Thats exactly what is going to happen to the UK now.

You voted for exactly this. Enjoy!

Selma22 · 25/03/2022 07:08

@Chloemol

Oh go away with your Brexit rubbish

This has nothing to do with it

This! Anything to bring this up again.Its done and dusted and doesn't matter which side you are on as its not as if we can get it back.Move on
Selma22 · 25/03/2022 07:06

@lecreusetpeppermill

Ah, I had a simplistic view of this, not too well up, sorry.

I think i was just curious about the double standard - people wishing to reduce immigration but accepting it if we can exploit them.

I see this is more complex.

Surely it wasn't about stopping immigration but about controlling it?