Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

I wonder how Leave voters feel about P&O Ferries.

212 replies

lecreusetpeppermill · 23/03/2022 15:12

I know many people voted one way or the other for different reasons, but those who were concerned about immigration 'swallowing jobs' or driving wages down.......how do they feel about this recent story?

Do they not feel lied to?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
BambinaJAS · 31/03/2022 17:20

@Unphased

Alexandra2001 HK used to be under British rule, a few would count themselves as British and can come to GB under the handing over to China
BNO-type passports only allowed entry and not residence (I think it was a 6 month stay max for tourist purposes).

What they did is create a Visa for HK folks to aquire residency like EU folks & settled status.

Unphased · 31/03/2022 15:12

Alexandra2001
HK used to be under British rule, a few would count themselves as British and can come to GB under the handing over to China

Alexandra2001 · 31/03/2022 09:05

@Kendodd I believe the UK's reluctance to take in Ukrainian refugees, despite the rhetoric, is because they are european, the UK Govt has no problem getting 3000 per week from HK into the UK and what exactly are they fleeing?

Kendodd · 31/03/2022 09:01

Yep, in exactly the same way as when the EU implement laws that effect ALL 3rd countries, we get 'Express/Mail headlines stating "EU punishes Great Britain"
I know!
I know a Leave voter outraged and bewildered because they can't now retire to Spain as planned. Voted Leave because of 'too many immigrants ' and has now said that FoM should only apply one way, in that we should be able to move unhindered to the EU but EU citizens shouldn't be able to come here. Apparently her retirement plans in the bin are all the evil EU punishment for Brexit.

Alexandra2001 · 30/03/2022 09:13

@Kendodd

So anyway, I think even if Leave voters lose their livelihoods and homes as an absolutely unambiguous direct result of Brexit (not p&o) itll make no difference, they would vote exactly the same again, blame the EU for all their problems and become even more entrenched.
Yep, in exactly the same way as when the EU implement laws that effect ALL 3rd countries, we get 'Express/Mail headlines stating "EU punishes Great Britain"

Control the media and control the electorate, its how Putin could (in his early years) have relatively free elections but win on a landslide, despite some very awful decision making.

None of this has been lost on the Tory party.

Kendodd · 30/03/2022 08:47

So anyway, I think even if Leave voters lose their livelihoods and homes as an absolutely unambiguous direct result of Brexit (not p&o) itll make no difference, they would vote exactly the same again, blame the EU for all their problems and become even more entrenched.

Kendodd · 30/03/2022 08:42

Anyway, an example of how Leave voters are absolutely welded to Brexit no matter what the damage. Look at the DUP, their biggest fear is a United Ireland and yet all committed Leave voters, still. They must see that their vote has brought a United Ireland close than anything Sinn Féin has done, ever. My view is that they took a gamble thinking Brexit would deliver a hard 1980s style boarder between NI and ROI, it's looking like they lost and instead its delivered a sea boarder. Now instead of trying to row back and campaigning for SM and CU membership to solve all their problems, they want even more Brexit. Stupid!

Kendodd · 30/03/2022 08:32

P&O didn't follow the law on consultation
I'm surprised they didn't use the government own line in that meeting and say they broke the law... what was it? In a very specific and limited way?

Alexandra2001 · 30/03/2022 07:58

@daimbarsatemydogsbone

I predict that the government will puff and blow for a week or so, and then this will be allowed to quietly fade into the background I imagine you're right.

This kind of fire and replace has been going on for far longer than Brexit and the arguments around it though. As also mentioned on this thread it dates back way further - so people attributing it solely to Brexit are letting their prejudice cloud their judgement - it's complicated.

We are six years into Brexit, plenty of time for this "Change" we supposedly voted for to happen!!!

Huge problem with this desire for Change, is that the people who we entrust to do this, are the very same people who messed up the UK in the first place.

But once again, UK problems get blamed on EU/Labour/Ukraine/Covid or "No one told me!!"

P&O didn't follow the law on consultation, they appear to have done this with impunity & as i said earlier, EU workers of P&O not sacked, workers in the EU have far better protection rights.

Kendodd · 29/03/2022 21:48

The scales fell from my eyes on this ages ago. Leave voters will NEVER change their minds, never ever. Doesn't matter the costs for themselves or others, it make no difference, peace in NI doesn't matter, if Brexit broke up the UK, price worth paying. Nothing will make them reconsider, not even Putin personally thanking each and everyone of them for their vote.

BambinaJAS · 29/03/2022 21:28

UK is now about to delay import checks again from the EU. There is no real infratsructure at the border to do the import checks on July 1st

This has been delayed three times already since 2020.

It's time to pack it in an accept the following:

Leave voting folks in the UK need to accept that they were lied to and manipulated on a massive scale.

Russia (and Putin) financed the leave vote via Northern Ireland in order to destabilise the UK, as well as destabilise NATO.

It's over. The only future left for the UK is a materially poorer one if we continue with this charade.

BambinaJAS · 29/03/2022 18:31

@Kendodd

Is anyone attributing all poverty to Brexit? Brexit is one factor increasing poverty and division in the uk.
It is the main driver.

Covid and Ukraine War are only short term blips in the economic sense. They do not destroy our productive capacity. They cause economic disruption but can be adjusted for via Govt spending (furlough, covid loans, energy loans etc..)

Brexit destroyed our productive capacity. It is long-term and permanent. That capacity is never coming back.

That 4% permanently smaller GDP due to Brexit translates into about £30 BILLION in lost tax revenue.

That is going to be extracted (using the current inflationary shock) from:

  1. Public sector employees
  2. People on benefits
  3. Students

That is what is going on right now.

ClareBlue · 29/03/2022 17:00

And the majority of employment protection law is domestic and not EU lead. Its debatable whether any EU Treaty even gives them a legal basis for legislation in this area. They actually use the freedom of labour movement and creating a level playing field as the basis for employment legislation, they have never been given explicit powers in this area. Though of course not having a legal basis for action has never held them back before and is unlikely to in the future.

ClareBlue · 29/03/2022 16:53

Irish Ferries did exact same a number of years ago and they operate under EU employment law.

daimbarsatemydogsbone · 29/03/2022 16:12

I predict that the government will puff and blow for a week or so, and then this will be allowed to quietly fade into the background
I imagine you're right.

This kind of fire and replace has been going on for far longer than Brexit and the arguments around it though. As also mentioned on this thread it dates back way further - so people attributing it solely to Brexit are letting their prejudice cloud their judgement - it's complicated.

daimbarsatemydogsbone · 29/03/2022 16:08

@Kendodd

Is anyone attributing all poverty to Brexit? Brexit is one factor increasing poverty and division in the uk.
@BambinaJAS seems to be.

I won't quarrel about it being divisive - the blame for that lies with David Cameron and his government in my estimation.

TebayOrNotTebay · 29/03/2022 16:03

@daimbarsatemydogsbone

Anyway, P&O CEO sticking to what they/he has done & redundancies will still take place c/w the NDA

That is a despicable act by P&O. It doesn't appear that it's directly related to Brexit however.

So, despite the pre brexit promise of change (for the better) we have none.
I'm not sure what promise you think hasn't been met exactly - do you mean you think there was a general promise of everything getting better if we voted Leave? If so I can see how that's never going to be realised.

And round and round we go.. The links between Brexit and Grayling's law/ the effect on the "land bridge" were explained on page 1 of this thread. "Directly" related - well it depends what you mean by "directly" - but certainly related. I predict that the government will puff and blow for a week or so, and then this will be allowed to quietly fade into the background...Britannia Unchained!
Teateaandmoretea · 29/03/2022 16:03

YABU

I wonder how long blaming everything on Brexit is going to go on for.

Kendodd · 29/03/2022 16:02

Is anyone attributing all poverty to Brexit? Brexit is one factor increasing poverty and division in the uk.

daimbarsatemydogsbone · 29/03/2022 15:01

@BambinaJAS
Yes, you are little confused. I have never voted Tory and consider it vanishingly unlikely I ever would.

Your apparent attribution of all poverty to the Brexit vote continues to be as humorous as your repeated claims to be better qualified than anyone else to have an opinion on anything, ever.

peachescariad · 29/03/2022 14:38

I think you're a bit confused love...

BambinaJAS · 29/03/2022 14:19

@daimbarsatemydogsbone

stating a statistic doesn't portray any innate superiority whatsoever.

I agree. Calling statistics facts doesn't either.

May I remind you these statisticians are the same ones who mostly predicted a narrow victory for remain in the referendum by using the same techniques.

Keep ignoring reality in favour of your ideology.

Let us know how well that turns out.

Do you know what happened to those Leave voters that were desperately voting for change?

They got a hell of a lot poorer.

Which is exactly what people with education and experience said would happen. Which is also precisely one of the drivers of why people voted remain.

Giving power to a Tory party that has treated the poor, low income, and disabled viciously going back decades had but only one expected result.

Absolutely none of this is hard to grasp or understand.

So no, no sympathy for them. Now they will suffer the full financial consequences of their vote.

Hopefully, that will teach them to never vote for the corrupt and incompetent Tories again.

daimbarsatemydogsbone · 29/03/2022 13:31

Anyway, P&O CEO sticking to what they/he has done & redundancies will still take place c/w the NDA

That is a despicable act by P&O. It doesn't appear that it's directly related to Brexit however.

So, despite the pre brexit promise of change (for the better) we have none.
I'm not sure what promise you think hasn't been met exactly - do you mean you think there was a general promise of everything getting better if we voted Leave? If so I can see how that's never going to be realised.

daimbarsatemydogsbone · 29/03/2022 13:23

stating a statistic doesn't portray any innate superiority whatsoever.

I agree. Calling statistics facts doesn't either.

May I remind you these statisticians are the same ones who mostly predicted a narrow victory for remain in the referendum by using the same techniques.

Alexandra2001 · 29/03/2022 12:09

@daimbarsatemydogsbone

I think a pp posted earlier on the educational breakdown of both leave and remain voters and the fact is, leave voters had, on average lower attainment

That isn't a fact. That's a statistical probability. They are not the same.

The fact that people quote these things as facts so often causes me to question whether the innate superiority they have conferred upon themselves has any actual value.

Rather uncalled for! stating a statistic doesn't portray any innate superiority whatsoever.

Plenty of post ref polling show this to be the case, same polling shows that plenty of farmers voted Remain, despite the common misconception that they all voted to Leave!

Or did you not see IDS's face light up when told (back in '16) that a particularly run down housing estate had a very high turn out, he knew what that meant for the Leave vote.

Anyway, P&O CEO sticking to what they/he has done & redundancies will still take place c/w the NDA

So, despite the pre brexit promise of change (for the better) we have none.