Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To expect family money being passed on

390 replies

Soffana · 23/03/2022 11:21

Am I being AIBU if I think that parents that had an inheritance and profited on that when it comes to property investment should pass money on to the next generation and not spend it all?

That money should be passed on from generation to generation?

For example helping next generation buying property?

OP posts:
HouseofGamers · 23/03/2022 13:32

I voted YABU but only because I think it shouldn’t be a given that inheritance is passed on. We have inherited on DH side, and have given a chunk to each child toward their deposit to get on the housing ladder.

We also give them a reasonable amount of cash yearly to spend as they want.

But a friend has parents who sold their own house and passed all of it to their son, to build a “granny annex”. The house and granny annex are all in the son’ s name. Dad is now in hospital bed blocking as he needs a care home space, but with no assets it has to be state funded and there are very few places, and no choice locally. Compared to DH dad who we sorted a lovely care home latterly, paid for out of his own money.

girlmom21 · 23/03/2022 13:31

@Pumperthepumper we didn't need two incomes. We happened to be a couple who wanted to buy together.
I've got friends on a lower income than mine do the exact same thing.

If you're working full time and living at home you should be able to save a lot a month. You can be angry about it but it's true. It's perfectly feasible to be able to buy a property in your mid-late 20s

The reason it's so hard for so many people is because they want the independence younger so choose to rent and then it's obviously much harder to save while you're supporting yourself financially.

The other thing lots of people do is get stupidly expensive cars on finance and then pay a shed load in insurance etc.

JudgeJ · 23/03/2022 13:30

If no-one passes it on, you included, it would be like a huge money snowball, rolling along getting bigger and bigger. I think the OP means that it should come to her to spend, not to pass on!

toomuchfruit · 23/03/2022 13:29

@HeadNorth

I live in Scotland, where you cannot disinherit your children - all offspring are entitled to a share of your moveable estate. So not your house, but if you have savings, flash cars, jewelry then any children are entitled to a third, by law, regardless of what your will may say. So it certain seems the settled will in Scotland, as reflected in statute, that family money should be passed down.
Wow I did not know this. How awful if someone’s children are complete arseholes to their parents but will still inherit money from them.
Soffana · 23/03/2022 13:26

@knittingaddict

Neither did they earn it. Their ancestors did.

Well that's obviously not true for everyone, not ny a long way.

We have had zero inheritance from grandparents or parents. My husband has a good job and we do ok. We have given our children some cash towards properties and weddings, but that was money that me could afford and had the free will to do that. The minute my children feel entitled to our money is the minute we start saying no.

That kind of money was not the money I was talking about. That is earned money.

I was talking about money that you inherited from past generations.

OP posts:
Pumperthepumper · 23/03/2022 13:26

I don't know why you're so angry about the suggestion that adults in their 30s still living at home should have enough saved for a deposit - obviously that excludes people who've moved back home after having moved out and ended up being screwed over financially - but someone who's never left home and is still there in their 30s with no savings is bad at managing money.

‘No savings’ is not the same as ‘not enough for a house deposit’. Owning a home is an option closed to the vast majority of people in their twenties - you needed two salaries for yours. It’s a market that has massively outstripped wages and has literally nothing to do with poor money management. Length of your mortgage? Under twenty five years?

JesusInTheCabbageVan · 23/03/2022 13:26

I will be looking to pass money on to my DS whether I inherit or not. I think that's the right thing for me to do, as I brought him into the world and (due to house prices, climate crisis etc) the prospects of living a comfortable life seem to reduce with each new generation.

However, I won't go without to the extent that my DS would be living a significantly more comfortable life than me. Equally, I wouldn't expect anyone to do that for me.

knittingaddict · 23/03/2022 13:23

Neither did they earn it. Their ancestors did.

Well that's obviously not true for everyone, not ny a long way.

We have had zero inheritance from grandparents or parents. My husband has a good job and we do ok. We have given our children some cash towards properties and weddings, but that was money that me could afford and had the free will to do that. The minute my children feel entitled to our money is the minute we start saying no.

Applesonthelawn · 23/03/2022 13:23

I think it's what a normal person might expect but I also think there's nothing you can or should do about it if your parents choose to behave differently.

girlmom21 · 23/03/2022 13:23

@Pumperthepumper

And *@girlmom21* if you wouldn’t mind, the length of your mortgage.

I’m going to guess: small non-commutable town either in the east of Scotland OR the north west of England. Family help to buy, 35 year mortgage. Your house is now worth 15k more than you paid for it. You earn approx 25k and your partner 30k ish.

Your assumptions are way off.

Earnings are higher, no family help, equity is higher, really good transport links.

I don't know why you're so angry about the suggestion that adults in their 30s still living at home should have enough saved for a deposit - obviously that excludes people who've moved back home after having moved out and ended up being screwed over financially - but someone who's never left home and is still there in their 30s with no savings is bad at managing money.

bluebellsandcustard · 23/03/2022 13:22

Yes OP I agree with you.

If you're lucky enough to benefit you should try and benefit others in the same way. That's how a kinder, more thoughtful society works.

Soffana · 23/03/2022 13:22

@BigSkies22

Not a popular view on MN, where the wishes of the legator or testator are paramount, and to hell with family expectations, but the UK is, globally, a bit of an outlier when it comes to the requirements of a testator to make reasonable provision for their family out of whatever property is available at their death. Most jurisdictions restrict testamentary freedom to ensure that dependents' /descendants' interests aren't forgotten. Which seems reasonable to me.
So it seems. Perhaps I am not expressing my point as well as I could. More people might agree with me if I did.
OP posts:
Howareyouflower · 23/03/2022 13:21

When my parents died I received a share of their money. My children didn't expect me to hand any of it over. When I die it will be their turn to inherit. Though if any of them were to appear to think they were entitled to inherit my money, the local cats and dogs home might benefit from their share.

stairway · 23/03/2022 13:20

I agree with you, the younger generations have zero chance of achieving massive wealth from property rises. I hope that if I receive a massive inheritance I won’t spend it all on cruises and will help my children out too otherwise that would be terribly selfish.

Soffana · 23/03/2022 13:20

@girlmom21"That looks different for each person.

For lots of people, family holidays and experiences are a better investment of money than a house that could end up being a money pit in 50 years time."

I can definitly see your point.

OP posts:
Pumperthepumper · 23/03/2022 13:20

West Midlands! What a cross post!

Whatinthelord · 23/03/2022 13:20

I will want to pass inheritance to my children, as personally that’s what feels important. However no one is entitled to anything. I think the idea of inheritance being a moral idea is difficult. Really, morally, it’s not fair that some get no inheritance or while others get hundreds s of thousands is it??

I’ll get fuck all anyway….except a bill for a funeral….so I find it hard to understand the entitlement as I’ve always known I’ll get nothing.

GreenFingersWouldBeHandy · 23/03/2022 13:19

Nope. Earn your own money and stop feeling so entitled to someone else's hard work.

Soffana · 23/03/2022 13:19

@incognitoforthisone

Given that you're clearly certain you're right about this and will argue against any other opinion, I'm not really sure why you're asking if YABU.

However, YABU. Everyone's situation is different and there is no 'should' involved here.

Nobody in my family has inherited so much as a sack of beans in about 20 generations, but if my parents had inherited something, I would expect them to make their own lives better with it because it was given to them, not to me. I am not somehow more deserving of it than they are. I have a job and earn my own money.

I am quite certain about what I think and how I will do it. But I am interested in other peoples' opinions in this matter as I am in other things.

I also think there is a big difference in earned money and inherited money. Earned money - you've earned it, you can spend it. Inherited money - you didn't earn it yourself, let it be of happiness for yourself and future family.

OP posts:
knittingaddict · 23/03/2022 13:19

Also we sacrificed a certain quality of life in order to give our children some luxuries that enhanced their lives as dependants. You only get one life and why should we continue to do that forever? We intend to enjoy the small extras that we can afford and I would think we had failed as parents if our grown up children resented that.

Pumperthepumper · 23/03/2022 13:19

And @girlmom21 if you wouldn’t mind, the length of your mortgage.

I’m going to guess: small non-commutable town either in the east of Scotland OR the north west of England. Family help to buy, 35 year mortgage. Your house is now worth 15k more than you paid for it. You earn approx 25k and your partner 30k ish.

girlmom21 · 23/03/2022 13:18

@Pumperthepumper

No thanks.

Just a vague notion of where you (and your partner) bought this house for 150k four years ago with no help from anyone else.

West Midlands. It's not really a difficult concept to grasp that adults living at home can save a lot of money if they want to.
Alonelonelylonersbadidea · 23/03/2022 13:18

Hahahahaha nope

RealBecca · 23/03/2022 13:18

Morally, if its "only a few thousand" inherited then dont you have a moral obligation to gove that to someone for whom that would be life changing rather than fun?

Or is it only when it affects you?

Catlitterqueen · 23/03/2022 13:17

@Aroundtheworldin80moves

My parents had a big inheritance.

Honestly... I look at it and feel a massive relief that if it is necessary there is money there for a decent nursing home.

This !