Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To expect family money being passed on

390 replies

Soffana · 23/03/2022 11:21

Am I being AIBU if I think that parents that had an inheritance and profited on that when it comes to property investment should pass money on to the next generation and not spend it all?

That money should be passed on from generation to generation?

For example helping next generation buying property?

OP posts:
HomeHomeInTheRange · 23/03/2022 14:13

If I get any inheritance (may well do, a middling amount, but not counting chickens) I doubt I will be in a position to pass the whole lot down to my own Dc as I will be scraping through retirement fairly frugally.

But I will do what I reasonably can to be able to leave something from my entire estate, earned and inherited, rather than splash the lot on cruises and fast cars.

Soffana · 23/03/2022 14:11

@kungfupannda

There's no 'should' in this, as all circumstances are different. You're essentially saying that no-one who inherits money should ever enjoy it - it should always be passed on, presumably to another generation who, by that logic, shouldn't enjoy it either.

I have a close family member who has this mindset, and has spent the last 20 years tying himself up in ridiculous knots with his ever-changing will, in search of some non-existent method by which his children can inherit his (very modest) estate, use it to have lovely lives, and still somehow pass it on untouched to their own children, who will then be required to do the same thing.

An inheritance is only an inheritance for a very brief period between someone dying and the money arriving in someone else's bank account. Either side of that, it's just someone's money, and everyone should be left to make their own choices about how they manage their own money. Most people will probably choose to help their children if they can, but there's no reason why they should martyr themselves, acting like some sort of temporary custodian of a precious commodity that must be preserved for posterity.

The reality is that most people will inherit very modestly, if at all. Relatively few people will receive the kind of substantial sums that can be invested in property and increase in value. Most inheritance will be substantially eroded within a generation. Being in a position to ringfence and pass on inheritance is just as much of a privilege as receiving it in the first place.

I think you are making an interesting point.

It has to be a considerable amount of inheritance to be able to help future generations. But it doesn't have to be enormous. Help with down payment can enable children to invest in higher value property, and the same for next generation.

OP posts:
Lou98 · 23/03/2022 14:11

@Soffana but then like I said, surely that property is being passed on to someone

notanothertakeaway · 23/03/2022 14:10

@Ifailed

money should be passed on from generation to generation

What's the point of playing pass-the-parcel with money down the generations, no one gets any use of it?
I inherited some money when my Dad died, we spent it on improving our home. Should I've just left it lying around to pass it on (presumably split in half) to my two sons who presumably would be expected to do the same?

But people do get the benefit of the ££

My parents were in a position to lend me the deposit for my first house. This enabled me to buy, rather than rent

I think it's reasonable that I should try to do the same for my children, if I can

OP, in RL, I think most people wouldn't agree with you. On MN, not so much

Soffana · 23/03/2022 14:07

@Eeksteek

Good point. I would say I try to do both, use the money I earn for now. Invest the money I got in property for their future benefit.

OP posts:
Tubs11 · 23/03/2022 14:06

IMO, yes. I am someone who benefited from wise investments my parents made and I am now doing the same with the view to giving my children that same start in life. I suspect my siblings are doing the same for their kids. I believe most parents would do this their kids, how well it's excuted is another matter

Femalewoman · 23/03/2022 14:05

My partner's ex would suggest every penny he has is saved for their children who will do very well from inheritance from grandparents who have skipped a generation and from him and her anyway.

A balance I think, enjoy your one go at life and if you can help out the next generation.

EarlGreywithLemon · 23/03/2022 14:05

My grandparents helped my parents buy a house. My parents helped us. I feel morally obliged to do the same if I possibly can (and all going well). I’d feel horribly wrong if I could and didn’t.

yourestandingonmyneck · 23/03/2022 14:04

@Soffana

Interesting. Just to make clear it is not about me, I am just making a philosophical and moral question.

I have inherited and am not spending it all as I want to help my children out. Just thinking what you are planning to do.

As I can read here you will all spend your money and not give anything to your children?

For me that would be morally wrong.

Generally, in well off families it would be invested, as opposed to cash.

The parents (or whoever) would spend the income / dividends with the capital being passed onto the next generation.

HeadNorth · 23/03/2022 14:04

its not about me, its about the principle that BY LAW children must receive part of their parents' estate regardless of how the children have behaved to the parents. Its not a law or a principle that I support. Thankfully, I don't live in Scotland.

Interesting. As a Scot, I feel pretty comfortable with the Scottish approach. It seems a proportionate balance of free will with duty and responsibility - no child should be left destitute for the state to pick up the tab if their late parents died with money in the bank. I think Scottish civic society is more based on duty rather than being as strongly individualistic as England and this is reflected in our laws and customs - land reform, comprehensive school system etc. It is fascinating the different ways we navigate and perceive the world based on an often unconsidered cultural heritage.

mrsbitaly · 23/03/2022 14:03

I see what you are saying. My MIL has just helped us put a large deposit on a house. Something we would never have afforded for many many years. This is my husbands inheritance she would rather see us making use of it now then when she passes. Our main reasons for buying a property not only for a better home for our children is purely for their inheritance so we can help them buy a house when the time is right. Its not easy these days to get on the ladder.

workwoes123 · 23/03/2022 14:02

I don't disagree with you OP, but that's partly the way I was brought up.

My parents come into a large amount of unearned wealth in their own lifetime. They are very keen to conserve 'enough' to pass on. Ideally, they want to conserve the capital (and some) while living on the income derived from the capital. They have paid off their mortgage on their very nice, large house. They have bought a second home in France, which the whole family has benefited from. They have gifted large lump sums to my sister and I which has helped us greatly at earlier stages in life. They live a very comfortable life.

They have zero desire whatsoever to spend the capital on 'treating themselves' just for the sake of spending the money because it's 'theirs': they'd see that as a waste. They don't see it as their money tbh, they see themselves as the custodians of what is really family money.

DH and I will be the same, I'm sure.

cptartapp · 23/03/2022 14:01

I inherited. It's all invested so I can retire early and holiday several times a year.
Not saying I won't help my DC out, but I certainly aren't saving any to 'pass on'.

Fretfulmum · 23/03/2022 13:59

I think money should be passed down generations eg if my parents inherited a large sum- for them to spend a big chunk on themselves but also help out their DC with housing costs etc. and then I would pass that saving down to my DC. This is how immigrant families often work in the UK and allows generational wealth to be passed on. I honestly don’t see the point of me splashing loads of cash on myself whilst DC struggle later in life

Soffana · 23/03/2022 13:58

@LuckySantangelo35

Oh we go. Another one bleating on about selfish bastard older people not sacrificing themselves for the poor hard done by younger generation. Maybe, just maybe your kids should work hard and make their own way in life! Start at the bottom of the ladder, work their way up, do things they don’t want to do, move around for work or placements, sacrifice things, live in the grotty houseshare, etc etc.
Let's say you inherited money so that you didn't have to start at the bottom of the ladder etc.

Would you not want the same for your children?

OP posts:
cptartapp · 23/03/2022 13:58

No. Ridiculous to pass it down the line indefinitely. Spend it and enjoy it.

James44 · 23/03/2022 13:58

There was another thread recently about this recently.
@Soffana makes a good point. Most of us help our children, most of us would like to do more than we do presently. We all go along with that sentiment.
Somehow when inheritance crops up, MN erupts as rabid left wingers declare that we shouldn't bother to help. All the goodwill is lost and words like grabby are used.
Should we really be islands?

godmum56 · 23/03/2022 13:55

[quote HeadNorth]@godmum56 - I asked why you were so keen your children didn't receive a penny from you, not about your relations, the truth of whose family relationships none of us can ever know, families are complex.

So why wouldn't you want your children to get a penny from you?[/quote]
its not about me, its about the principle that BY LAW children must receive part of their parents' estate regardless of how the children have behaved to the parents. Its not a law or a principle that I support. Thankfully, I don't live in Scotland.

PinkSparklyPussyCat · 23/03/2022 13:52

Not squirrel away untouched, I mean more in the line of buying bigger property or paying off morgage that then would benefit your children.

Whoever inherits from us will get a flat worth next to nothing due to it having a short lease. We don't want to move so I'm not spending £50K to extend a lease for nothing!

kittensinthekitchen · 23/03/2022 13:52

@girlmom21

You think that those young adults expected to contribute to their home is the exception? I'd be really interested in seeing the actual figures for that.

Getting to stay at the family home and retain your full, or even most of your salary is a massive privilege.

HeadNorth · 23/03/2022 13:49

@godmum56 - I asked why you were so keen your children didn't receive a penny from you, not about your relations, the truth of whose family relationships none of us can ever know, families are complex.

So why wouldn't you want your children to get a penny from you?

LuckySantangelo35 · 23/03/2022 13:48

Oh we go.
Another one bleating on about selfish bastard older people not sacrificing themselves for the poor hard done by younger generation.
Maybe, just maybe your kids should work hard and make their own way in life! Start at the bottom
of the ladder, work their way up, do things they don’t want to do, move around for work or placements, sacrifice things, live in the grotty houseshare, etc etc.

Pumperthepumper · 23/03/2022 13:45

Is it under 25 years Girlmom21?

girlmom21 · 23/03/2022 13:44

@Pumperthepumper

Also a 35 year mortgage is very poor financial management.
Are you still talking to me? I don't have a 35 year mortgage. HTH.
Sunnyday321 · 23/03/2022 13:44

@Soffana

You say you will keep some of your inheritance for your children to pass on. Best give it to them before you die , as care needs for your old age could be eat it up as well as the value of your home.
Give it at least 7 years before you pop off as well for tax reasons !
I'm sure you can see , it's not as cut and dry as you think.

Swipe left for the next trending thread