Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To expect family money being passed on

390 replies

Soffana · 23/03/2022 11:21

Am I being AIBU if I think that parents that had an inheritance and profited on that when it comes to property investment should pass money on to the next generation and not spend it all?

That money should be passed on from generation to generation?

For example helping next generation buying property?

OP posts:
ancientgran · 24/03/2022 09:33

@Soffana

Interesting. Just to make clear it is not about me, I am just making a philosophical and moral question.

I have inherited and am not spending it all as I want to help my children out. Just thinking what you are planning to do.

As I can read here you will all spend your money and not give anything to your children?

For me that would be morally wrong.

No one in my family had any money for me to inherit so the money I have is all from my working life (don't want to get into a row about how house value has increased.) I can't imagine not wanting to pass most of it on, I do spend some on me. I've already given mine some help with uni/house/weddings.

So legally I agree I don't have to but morally I think I do and as a parent yes it makes me happy to be in a position to help.

Maybe it is easy for me as I don't have expensive taste, my last handbag cost £5 about 4 years ago, I've been debating with myself for weeks about buying a £150 handbag that is reduced to £60, by the time I decide there probably won't be any left.

Soffana · 24/03/2022 09:28

@Cheeserton

What a weird question. There are no such rules or expectations. You're making them up. People can do what they like with THEIR money.
I know there are no real rules. I mean more of a moral idea that pass on the help you got from past generation.
OP posts:
Cheeserton · 24/03/2022 09:21

What a weird question. There are no such rules or expectations. You're making them up. People can do what they like with THEIR money.

Briony123 · 24/03/2022 09:11

This is why the Royal family and eg. Duke of Westminster has clever tax schemes and avoid spending their own money wherever possible. Everyone else has to accept that most money runs out within 100 years.

Soffana · 24/03/2022 08:14

@Fr0thandBubble

Very surprised by the poll! I completely agree with you OP.

Surely at the very least you should give your children the same help you were given, especially because young people have it so much harder these days than we did.

I wasn't really given anything by my parents but I am saving and working like a dog so that I can buy my two DC their own flats one day. And then when I've done that I will keep working until I drop so that I have enough to pay for my future (fingers crossed!) DGC's education, and hopefully get them on the property ladder too.

I would get much more happiness from doing that than I would from spending the money on myself. Don't really understand people who don't feel the same way.

I am also very surprised!

That is my goal too, with the exception that I inherited money so I could get on the property ladder early.

Now my goal is to help my children do the same.

OP posts:
Basilthymerosemary · 24/03/2022 08:13

But life is very different now- they may need all their money to live comfortably when they retire (parents/grandparents) as life is more expensive. So there may not be much to give anyway.

Soffana · 24/03/2022 08:06

@Painiscrap

I agree with you OP, in that I want to help my own family, but it is up to the individual what they do.

When my dm died a few years ago, my siblings and I equally inherited her estate. I kept the money I inherited in a separate account, and when the time came, I used this money to gift each of my children enough to pay the deposit on a house (we live in a relatively cheap housing area). In fact I actually ended up using some of my own savings as well as there wasn’t enough in the account.

I know how hard it is to get on the property ladder, so it was important to me to help them out. My dh wasn’t best pleased, but it was my money, so he accepted that I could do what I wanted with it. I am now a widow so not really interested in spending money, so they will also receive an inheritance when I die. I have also opened accounts for my dgc, so they will receive some money too.

I’m not rolling in money, but I have an emergency pot and manage to live frugally and really don’t have anything much I want to spend money on!

That is how I would like to do it as well.

Why wasn't your husband well pleased?

OP posts:
Soffana · 24/03/2022 07:58

[quote LuckySantangelo35]@souffana
I didn’t inherit any money[/quote]
Well then, why reply to a question that is not aimed at you?

It is clearly stated in thread start that I am talking about inherited money.

OP posts:
Soffana · 24/03/2022 07:57

@MotherOfCrocodiles

YANBU especially if that's what the person leaving the money hopes will happen

My mum has been careful with money all her life and prioritised helping me and sibling buy homes. When I inherit her house, I'll be investing the money to help dc buy homes, in line with her expectations- not sloshing it on holidays DM would not have allowed herself, or donating it all to a cat sanctuary.

This is what I am talking about. Being careful to not waste to money you got from previous generation. Because they were careful and thinking about you.
OP posts:
bingoitsadingo · 23/03/2022 23:59

@Blossomtoes
Why? What’s so terrible about enjoying money? That’s what it’s for.
Well, the fact that you conflate “enjoying money” and “spend it all” is exactly what I dislike. You can enjoy money without consuming it all.

Also, I’m not that convinced that “enjoyment is what it’s for” is true. Personally I see it as a tool for security. If invested wisely, it can be both.

Choccorocco · 23/03/2022 23:28

I did too - voted yabu despite spending mine on my kids’ education. No one ‘should’ do as op suggested but if they wish to - that’s a different matter

entropynow · 23/03/2022 23:18

@DaisyDeli

I voted YABU because noone has the 'right' to inheritance that was left for someone else, however, I shared my inheritance with my DC (deposits) because I wanted to share, it wasn't expected.
Same. There is a middle ground between "should" and "no way".
Fr0thandBubble · 23/03/2022 23:14

Very surprised by the poll! I completely agree with you OP.

Surely at the very least you should give your children the same help you were given, especially because young people have it so much harder these days than we did.

I wasn't really given anything by my parents but I am saving and working like a dog so that I can buy my two DC their own flats one day. And then when I've done that I will keep working until I drop so that I have enough to pay for my future (fingers crossed!) DGC's education, and hopefully get them on the property ladder too.

I would get much more happiness from doing that than I would from spending the money on myself. Don't really understand people who don't feel the same way.

Blossomtoes · 23/03/2022 22:54

Personally I find the attitude of “I hope they spend it all” pretty awful

Why? What’s so terrible about enjoying money? That’s what it’s for.

bingoitsadingo · 23/03/2022 22:39

What’s the point in people just hoarding money and passing it on and no one ever really feeling the benefit of it?! Does it just keep going until it’s passed onto someone who doesn’t have kids and then they can just go wild and enjoy themselves?!

Only if you view money as something you consume. If you view it as something to invest (in property or other assets) then it can benefit generation after generation.
Also, even if it literally is passing down savings, the psychological benefit of a financial safety net is incredible. It lets you take risks, or make decisions that might not pay off financially for a while.

Personally I find the attitude of “I hope they spend it all” pretty awful

sorrygross · 23/03/2022 21:52

My parents helped me loads . I'll do same with my kids xx

Redgeret · 23/03/2022 20:00

I wouldn't expect anything but I can't help but be irritated by my inlaws. They have made it their mission in life to ignore relatives until they're at deaths door then gone to great lengths to ensure they grab as much from them yet happy, almost gleefully to tell us we're not getting anything when we haven't even asked! We've never had a penny off them and they had lots of help from their own parents.

Before anyone tells me 'But but but they deserve every penny they grab', these are people happy to go on big game hunting holidays in Africa, paying a fortune to bring back the dead carcasses yet can't be bothered to remember their grandchildrens birthdays.

MajorCarolDanvers · 23/03/2022 19:03

I would rather my parents spent their money on themselves having an enjoyable retirement than leaving it to us.

In turn I hope that my I bring my children up with similar values.

PurpleCarpets · 23/03/2022 19:01

That is a really good point. I’ve never understood the outrage at people selling their home to fund moving to a care home. If they are moving out of their house it seems entirely reasonable that they sell it to fund their new home, whether that is a bungalow, sheltered housing or a care home.
There's a definite income/capital confusion going on here!

Does anyone on this thread think it is unreasonable for people to sell their property to fund moving to care home?
How can it possibly be unreasonable? They don't need it any more. And they need money to pay their fees. They don't have any choice.

Blossomtoes · 23/03/2022 18:58

Does anyone on this thread think it is unreasonable for people to sell their property to fund moving to care home?

I don’t but I’m a member of a very tiny minority.

HeadNorth · 23/03/2022 18:53

@HelenWick

This thread is hilarious when you consider the rabid response to the 'dementia tax'. So those that inherit should spend it, unless it is on their own care when they are elderly, in which case the state should fund it so their kids can get their inheritance. Ok then.
That is a really good point. I’ve never understood the outrage at people selling their home to fund moving to a care home. If they are moving out of their house it seems entirely reasonable that they sell it to fund their new home, whether that is a bungalow, sheltered housing or a care home.

Does anyone on this thread think it is unreasonable for people to sell their property to fund moving to care home?

HeckyPeck · 23/03/2022 18:52

A friend of mine's parents inherited a substantial sum from their parents and had also been gifted money to buy a property when they were alive.

They then gloated about how they were planning to spend it all on themselves and that my friend should work hard for her own money like they did and not expect a penny. My friend hadn't even brought it up an certainly isn't grabby.

Everyone I know thinks they are utterly selfish, hypocritical dickheads.

My friend's grandparents were the nicest, most generous people and would be horrified at how their child and their partner are behaving.

HelenWick · 23/03/2022 18:37

This thread is hilarious when you consider the rabid response to the 'dementia tax'. So those that inherit should spend it, unless it is on their own care when they are elderly, in which case the state should fund it so their kids can get their inheritance. Ok then.

PurpleCarpets · 23/03/2022 18:04

Don't live off capital. Inheritances definitely count as transfer of capital from one generation to the next. Invest it, buy assets with it, use it to improve our maintain assets. Spend the income generated. In accounting terms keep it on the family balance sheet.

RantyAunty · 23/03/2022 17:32

@kittensinthekitchen

I've never known anyone but MNers to have this obsession with inheritance.

If the person is still alive, there's no inheritance. If they've got some and want you to have it when they die, grand. If not, make your own way in the world.

I never knew anyone who got an inheritance. When my parents passed, there was enough to bury them. That was it. Working class, poor don't have inheritances.
Swipe left for the next trending thread