Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To expect family money being passed on

390 replies

Soffana · 23/03/2022 11:21

Am I being AIBU if I think that parents that had an inheritance and profited on that when it comes to property investment should pass money on to the next generation and not spend it all?

That money should be passed on from generation to generation?

For example helping next generation buying property?

OP posts:
5128gap · 23/03/2022 12:36

@malificent7

One reason why i got on the property ladder was that dd would have something to inherit. I'm sure i can have fun in my latter years without spaffing all my money on crap. What parent dosn't want to provide for their kids?
I'm only 20 years older than my DD. If I take after some of my family members, she'll be 70 by the time she gets my house, with 50 years of providing for herself under her belt. My grandchildren will likely be heading for middle age and, I'd anticipate, also paying their own way by then.
godmum56 · 23/03/2022 12:35

@Soffana

Interesting. Just to make clear it is not about me, I am just making a philosophical and moral question.

I have inherited and am not spending it all as I want to help my children out. Just thinking what you are planning to do.

As I can read here you will all spend your money and not give anything to your children?

For me that would be morally wrong.

soooo funny.
Soffana · 23/03/2022 12:33

@EatSleepReplete

I agree OP. If people have benefited by being gifted or left money from the previous generation, I think that morally they should do their best to do the same for those who follow after them. Obviously, life sometimes dictates otherwise. But there's a vast difference between what's possible & what's reasonable in any particular situation.
I agree.
OP posts:
Blossomtoes · 23/03/2022 12:31

@HeadNorth

I live in Scotland, where you cannot disinherit your children - all offspring are entitled to a share of your moveable estate. So not your house, but if you have savings, flash cars, jewelry then any children are entitled to a third, by law, regardless of what your will may say. So it certain seems the settled will in Scotland, as reflected in statute, that family money should be passed down.
I think you’re missing the point. She’s not talking about disinheriting, she thinks if you inherit wealth you should pass it on, untouched, to future generations.
girlmom21 · 23/03/2022 12:31

If I inherit anything and I'm not expecting to get a single penny, I intend to hand it directly to my children, I dont think I would be able to help them with house deposits any other way

I think this is what anyone who agreed with the OP should do - or put it into an account if they're under 18.

If you're intending on passing it on and think it's morally wrong not to do so, this is the only way you can be certain of it.

thinking123 · 23/03/2022 12:30

I won't be getting any inheritance of any sort, but for years I worked in a building society, I met so many elderly people who where living on a shoe string so that they could leave the money in their savings to their children.

It was so sad to see, I'm sure most of their children would want them eating well and heating their homes and maybe having a holiday or two

Soffana · 23/03/2022 12:30

@Eeksteek

Probably.

I will definitely make sure some of the money I inherited goes to DD. Some if it I am ‘selfishly’ using myself now instead of working full time, so that she doesn’t have to be in childcare, and to give us different priorities. She isn’t involved in that decision, and nor should she be. As the adult, I am making a decision for the good of our family. Later, she will have more support than other children in my income bracket, and less than she might have had if I hadn’t used some while she was young. But who can say what effect that would have had on her childhood and my mental health and ability to parent well? I’m making the best decision I can with the information I have.

It’s a fine line, between helping out your children and passing on your good fortune, and raising entitled brats who think the world owes them a living. I’d rather err on the side of the former, as I feel it would make a child happier, more equipped to deal with life and better person who will make the world a better place. I also don’t want to live it up at the expense of my child’s struggles, or to pull the ladder up behind me. There are good arguments for both, I think.

With parents, well, I don’t know. But I’m inclined to say it’s up to them. You have to let people be wrong. Prolly makes the parents a bit grabby, but to call them out on it makes oneself a bit grabby. People can be right assholes, no question about it.

Interesting post that summarize how I am thinking. English is not my first language so I could not put it down like that.

If children see parents spending and not working hard, they can inherit that approach to money. If they see parents working hard and then inherit, I think they have respect for money and might be inclined to pass them on as well.

OP posts:
Change123today · 23/03/2022 12:30

I don’t have much of an inheritance coming my way - it doesn’t bother me it’s such as life.
But if my parents or in laws suddenly did I hope they would enjoy life to the full!!
Great believer in never expect anything and anything above that is a nice to have if it does!

Tigger85 · 23/03/2022 12:29

I don't think it should be an expectation to pass it on, some inheritances are only small. If I inherit anything and I'm not expecting to get a single penny, I intend to hand it directly to my children, I dont think I would be able to help them with house deposits any other way.

AnneKipankitoo · 23/03/2022 12:28

YABU
They can do what they wish with it. It’s theirs.

You might not do that @Soffana. That’s up to you. That’s your choice.

HeadNorth · 23/03/2022 12:28

I live in Scotland, where you cannot disinherit your children - all offspring are entitled to a share of your moveable estate. So not your house, but if you have savings, flash cars, jewelry then any children are entitled to a third, by law, regardless of what your will may say. So it certain seems the settled will in Scotland, as reflected in statute, that family money should be passed down.

Gotajobthrunepotism · 23/03/2022 12:27

And personally I would rather my mum spent her money on herself

Gotajobthrunepotism · 23/03/2022 12:26

I think if the GP wanted to pass the money to grandchildren they should specify in the will (and perhaps make it a condition that they only get the money at a certain age or to buy property etx)

LindaEllen · 23/03/2022 12:26

Nobody owes anyone an inheritance. You only inherit once your parents die and that's only what they didn't spend. My partner's parents are loud and proud about going on multiple holidays a year to spend their savings, and we say bloody good on them.

Earn your own money.

Anything you inherit is great, but don't take it for granted, and never expect it as a given.

Pumperthepumper · 23/03/2022 12:26

The value of money changes so quickly though, do you adjust for inflation? Also house prices have risen massively where wages haven’t, so do you take that into account too? Does it have to be a certain amount for it to be worthy enough?

Soffana · 23/03/2022 12:25

@AnneLovesGilbert

Did you post about this with specifics a couple of days ago?
No.
OP posts:
CousinKrispy · 23/03/2022 12:25

I personally hope to pass what I'm able to on to my child, but I think it's mentally healthier for people to not expect to receive a substantial inheritance. Unless the child is disabled or has a similar reason for not being able to make their own way in the world, it's better to plan to stand on your own two feet so you don't feel resentment about a parent not passing down what you think they "should" have. I find this attitude goes a long way to maintaining family harmony and a positive mindset.

Soffana · 23/03/2022 12:25

@EatSleepReplete

I agree OP. If people have benefited by being gifted or left money from the previous generation, I think that morally they should do their best to do the same for those who follow after them. Obviously, life sometimes dictates otherwise. But there's a vast difference between what's possible & what's reasonable in any particular situation.
Yes, of course if you really need to spend it on care etc you should. And not live in poverty to pass on lots of money. But it should be a mindset.
OP posts:
ColgateGirl · 23/03/2022 12:25

I'd be in favour of 100% inheritance tax to be honest.

It seems unfair that person A gets an easier time/better start in life than person B purely because Person A's great granddad was a saver.

What about people who are brought up in care? Or where there is no money to be passed on?

Everydaydayisaschoolday · 23/03/2022 12:23

I'm going to have to disagree with you. DH and I have inherited money and chose to use it to help our DC but there is no "should' about it. If I had thought that the DC expected it or felt entitled to it they wouldn't have seen a penny of it.

If the relation who died wanted the money to skip a generation they would have written that into their will.

malificent7 · 23/03/2022 12:23

One reason why i got on the property ladder was that dd would have something to inherit. I'm sure i can have fun in my latter years without spaffing all my money on crap. What parent dosn't want to provide for their kids?

blisstwins · 23/03/2022 12:23

@Itloggedmeoutagain

YABU for thinking you have any say in how money that is not yours is spent
But I wasn’t their either. I inherited an income producing property. Friends are constantly telling me to sell and make my life easier, nicer. But the house saved me during hard times and was passed from my grandmother, who was a scrub woman and buying it was her life’s achievement, to my father, and. Ow to me. I benefit from it—but cashing out doesn’t feel right. I intend to pass it on.
Sally872 · 23/03/2022 12:22

Our children will inherit our house (unless something unforseen happens and we dont have it)

If my parents or PIL choose to spend all their money or give us money that makes no difference to my plans for our children's inheritance. I would hope they cover their funeral costs but other than that the money is theirs to spend or to leave. And it doesn't matter if they inherited from their parents or not either.

CatherinedeBourgh · 23/03/2022 12:22

@Skiptheheartsandflowers

We live in a different country from them and are not close. I used to do loads for them until I had my dc and realised that not only would they do nothing for us, they intended to sit and criticise everything we did.

Since then I decided to put in as much effort into our relationship as they did, which has resulted in my not having seen them for several years...

I really don't give a damn about money, for me it is just another way of helping each other within a family. When I had lots of money to spare I handed it out whenever someone needed it (including to pil). When I didn't, I didn't, but helped in whatever ways I did, provided I felt I could count on those people if I needed them (although most tell me I am terrible at asking for anything for myself). When I felt people were taking the piss or it was just a one way street I withdrew.

Over the years that has whittled down my relationships a fair bit...

EvelynBeatrice · 23/03/2022 12:22

I think each person can only speak for herself as it's so fact and people dependent. In my own case I look at the fact that earnings in my profession are lower in real terms for people starting out or climbing the pole than they were 'when I were a lad'!. This means that the reasonable expectation that you'd study at uni, work your butt off but be able to afford a nice house in the city I live in, car, holidays etc by your thirties isn't a given anymore. Given that's the case, I anticipate that my kids would benefit from a leg up in due course if we can manage it whether that's contribution to house deposit or whatever.

Swipe left for the next trending thread