Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To expect family money being passed on

390 replies

Soffana · 23/03/2022 11:21

Am I being AIBU if I think that parents that had an inheritance and profited on that when it comes to property investment should pass money on to the next generation and not spend it all?

That money should be passed on from generation to generation?

For example helping next generation buying property?

OP posts:
Soffana · 23/03/2022 12:55

@justanoldhack

I agree with you OP. And would think less of any parent that decided not to pass on the good fortune that they had enjoyed and benefited from to their own children (which presumably they had out of choice). Seems like we're in the minority though!
Looks like it, which is making me a bit surprised!
OP posts:
Soffana · 23/03/2022 12:55

@BeccaNotBecky

If I inherited I’d spend it on the house to improve it for my family and holidays and experiences for my children. Money is the cause of lots of problems in families so my kids will expect nothing but have had a great life growing up
I hear you, but if you could use the money to help them get on the property ladder instead of renting would you not consider that?
OP posts:
dentydown · 23/03/2022 12:54

My grandmother came into an inheritance recently and promptly shared it amongst the family. She gave her son a big chunk and me and my father smaller amounts for “helping her”

It all depends on the person.

2DogsOnMySofa · 23/03/2022 12:54

No I don't think so. Inheritance is a gift, not a given.

You should try, where ever possible, to be financially stable and ensure you have enough money pension wise without having to rely on inheritance.

I'm actively trying to convince my dad to enjoy his retirement and spend as much of his money before he pops his clogs. Mum died 4 years after retiring, what's the point in not enjoying life. Spend the money, you can't take it with you.

Pumperthepumper · 23/03/2022 12:53

If it is only a few thousand it could be spend for fun.

Surely then it would be better to spend it on them while you’re alive, on a holiday or something?

BadgeronaMoped · 23/03/2022 12:53

This is such a personal topic. I plan on helping my dc as much as I can financially, if I were ever to inherit any money. I wouldn't want them to struggle or be stuck renting till they're 40 (like me). I've been saving a deposit for years, and I'm nearly done retraining, so I can (hopefully) spend the next 25 years paying off a mortgage Grin

kittensinthekitchen · 23/03/2022 12:52

I've never known anyone but MNers to have this obsession with inheritance.

If the person is still alive, there's no inheritance. If they've got some and want you to have it when they die, grand. If not, make your own way in the world.

Pumperthepumper · 23/03/2022 12:52

If your daughter needed to stay at home into her 30s to be able to be able to get a mortgage I'd be wary of handing down a big inheritance that you're expecting her to be able to pass on because her money management can't be that great.

How much did you buy your first house for @girlmom21 and how old were you? Did you do it alone?

justanoldhack · 23/03/2022 12:51

I agree with you OP. And would think less of any parent that decided not to pass on the good fortune that they had enjoyed and benefited from to their own children (which presumably they had out of choice). Seems like we're in the minority though!

HeadNorth · 23/03/2022 12:51

@godmum56 - why would you want to 'make sure I had spent every penny' rather than have your children receive a share of your moveable estate? Bear in mind, if you spent it on cars and consumables, they could still get some of it - why does that bother you so?

Soffana · 23/03/2022 12:50

@Pumperthepumper

The value of money changes so quickly though, do you adjust for inflation? Also house prices have risen massively where wages haven’t, so do you take that into account too? Does it have to be a certain amount for it to be worthy enough?
It does have to be a certain amount.

If it is only a few thousand it could be spend for fun.

Inflation has to be considered. The inheritance could not of course be the same as you were given. Property values change. It is more of a mindset.

OP posts:
crepesncream · 23/03/2022 12:47

So who gets the joy of spending it then? If it just sits in the bank waiting to pass it on to the next generation....what then? Should the next generation miser it away to give to the following generation? Surely it has to be enjoyed.

Soffana · 23/03/2022 12:47

@thinking123

I won't be getting any inheritance of any sort, but for years I worked in a building society, I met so many elderly people who where living on a shoe string so that they could leave the money in their savings to their children. It was so sad to see, I'm sure most of their children would want them eating well and heating their homes and maybe having a holiday or two
That is very sad and not how it is meant to be.
OP posts:
BeccaNotBecky · 23/03/2022 12:46

If I inherited I’d spend it on the house to improve it for my family and holidays and experiences for my children. Money is the cause of lots of problems in families so my kids will expect nothing but have had a great life growing up

Soffana · 23/03/2022 12:45

@EmpressCixi

YANBU If a family has sufficient wealth to help grand parents, parents onto the property ladder, then yes money should be passed down generation to generation to also help today’s children onto the property ladder. Or to pay uni fees. Whatever seems to be family tradition.

Now it’s not unusual for someone in the family to inherit and break with family tradition. They may have had their schooling paid for and helped with buying their first home but choose not to pass this benefit on to their children. I think whether this is unethical or unfair on the next generation depends on the amount of money and whether there is realistically enough to help their children or not. If they are struggling with ill health and need the money to retire early and pay for added costs of care....then yes the children lose out, and it’s not fair but also the parent isn’t doing anything wrong they are simply unable to do the same financial boost for their children that they received from their parents.

But if the parent inheriting just wants to spend it on holidays, flash cars, or expensive hobbies, then YANBU to be critical of them for pulling the ladder up behind them and not helping their children get a good start in life.

Agree.

Obviously is a mindset, if I get sick or unemployed and have to sell my house to survive I could not help that.

It is a matter of mindset and an obligation to future generations, a matter to respect former generation.

OP posts:
Riseholme · 23/03/2022 12:45

My siblings and I have never been left money.
However we all give money, in proportion to what we can each afford, to our dc because we recognise that it’s hard for young adults to get on the property ladder now.
My dc don’t expect money and don’t ask but are very grateful for any help.
As for leaving money to charity I won’t be doing that.
Charities are like terriers at the sniff of a legacy.
My friend was executor of a relatives will and two charities were left money. She informed them of the fact.
For the next few months they badgered her for the money even though everything had to go through probate. Not a line of sympathy was given for the loss of her relative just where’s our money on a constant loop.
I prefer to give donations whilst I’m alive and can control them.
My dc will always be my beneficiaries.

girlmom21 · 23/03/2022 12:44

@chaosrabbitland

i agree , it wouldnt occur to me to spend the money if i could help my daughter buy herself a house to live in . id not watch her having to stay at home with me until she was in her bloody thirties because its so hard for them to get a mortgage these days if i could help her out , cant understand anyone wanting to spend it and not help their child out if they needed it to be honest
If your daughter needed to stay at home into her 30s to be able to be able to get a mortgage I'd be wary of handing down a big inheritance that you're expecting her to be able to pass on because her money management can't be that great.
Meandthesky · 23/03/2022 12:44

YABU

No one has a right to an inheritance. If you get one you’re just lucky, it’s not because you inherently deserve it.

Pumperthepumper · 23/03/2022 12:43

What happens if you pass on the inheritance and they piss it up the wall?

NoddyMcdoddy · 23/03/2022 12:42

I’m due an inheritance this week, a sizeable sum.

Adult DD, who is at university will get a few quid to treat herself. She will inherit from us, her parents upon our deaths which hopefully will not be for a couple of decades and I would anticipate she will inherit a significant amount more than I have inherited from my parents so I do not see the need to pass on my inheritance from my parents to her.

DogInATent · 23/03/2022 12:41

Whenever the discussion of inheritance arises the debate seems to be generally rooted in attitudes to wealth, life expectancy, economic prosperity, and family size from 50+ years ago.

There are a lot of families where the potential significant inherited wealth only arose in the 1980s (or later) and the property/capital involved is still supporting a generation now in their 70s/80s with 10-20 years further life expectancy. The following generation are very likely going to be at or around retirement age before inheritance becomes a factor, and there's potentially two further extant generations waiting behind them.

With the complexity of over-lapping generations that's now commonplace, attitudes and approaches to inherited/accumulated family wealth may need to be adjusted to reflect need rather than entitlement. Particularly if resentment is to be avoided about changing political priorities that might be interpreted as older generations lifting up the ladder behind them in terms of access to education, healthcare and opportunity.

chaosrabbitland · 23/03/2022 12:40

i agree , it wouldnt occur to me to spend the money if i could help my daughter buy herself a house to live in . id not watch her having to stay at home with me until she was in her bloody thirties because its so hard for them to get a mortgage these days if i could help her out ,
cant understand anyone wanting to spend it and not help their child out if they needed it to be honest

thegreylady · 23/03/2022 12:40

If I had money surplus to requirements of course I would share with my dc. I come from family who worked hard, earned little and died young so no major inheritance. When we go there will be a modest house, paid up funeral and no debts. All of our dc are financially better off than us and we are proud of them. They would help us if we needed help and we have, in the past, helped them. In a close family money shouldn’t be a bone of contention.

Cakesnbiscuit · 23/03/2022 12:38

I think I’m different to most on mumsnet and think yes it should. If someone has done something nice for you it’s nice to do something in turn.

I don’t think people should expect inheritance however I don’t get why you wouldn’t want to help set your children up for life.

I think most people in real life / in person would get some funny looks if they said screw my kids I’m spending all my money and not giving them any. However MN is a different place and it’s very acceptable.

I have already started bank accounts and putting what we can aside for my children in hope one day it might help them buy a car / deposit for a house etc. why wouldn’t I want the best for my kids?

godmum56 · 23/03/2022 12:37

@HeadNorth

I live in Scotland, where you cannot disinherit your children - all offspring are entitled to a share of your moveable estate. So not your house, but if you have savings, flash cars, jewelry then any children are entitled to a third, by law, regardless of what your will may say. So it certain seems the settled will in Scotland, as reflected in statute, that family money should be passed down.
I would make sure I had spent every penny.
Swipe left for the next trending thread