Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

"Selfish" to choose to have only one child?

116 replies

Ivegottagoforaliedown · 23/03/2022 08:14

Not my opinion! So less of an AIBU and more 'are they being unreasonable.

I recently had my first baby, he's lovely. My partner and I said we'd just have one, because:

  • We hope to have more time/resources to devote to him.
  • State of the world (we did discuss not having any due to this - whole other thread for that argument!
  • Hopefully less stress?!

However since he's been born I find myself thinking I could do this again (hormones maybe, he's only 6 months!). I wonder about him being lonely, or what will happen when his dad and I die. I wasn't close to my sister growing up but we are very close now and I'm so glad I have her. I was discussing this with her yesterday and she agrees, but went on to say she thinks it is selfish to choose to have only one child. She has none of her own yet but wants two.

I have a bit of time to decide, I'm early 30s and partner is mid 30s - although he reckons he will be too old for another in a few years time. I'm not sure what to think. There's no guarantee siblings would even like one another or get along as adults - I know plenty who don't. But I also know of some who are best of friends.

Of course there are very sensitive reasons why people may choose to stick with one - high risk pregnancies for instance. And of course there is secondary infertility. But in the case where the parents could provide for another child and would be happy with another - is it selfish not to for the sake of their first child?

OP posts:
ChiefAdjusterOfRubensShorts · 23/03/2022 11:49

I’m one of four and DH is one of three.

Our siblings are ok but we don’t have any kind of relationship with any of them beyond birthdays and Christmas.

DS is an only child, we only ever wanted one child as we wanted to give him all the opportunities and attention that DH & I lacked.

Plus we just didn’t want to be spending all our money on more children and their needs, so maybe we are selfish?

But, DS is perfectly happy, has lots of friends, great social life and often tells us that he likes being an only child.

SpringLobelia · 23/03/2022 11:47

I was having a very similar discussion with one of my friends recently. They have one child. he has autism and some other issues and the conscious decision to have one has meant they are financially able to pour alot of resources into him they could not otherwise- therapy- private school- trips away and extra curricular stuff designed to enrich his experiences and world view. She's quite open that if they had two, then they could not do any of that to the extent they can, and says openly that for them it is a blessing. But she is an only child so is also quite open that she does not know what a sibling relationship is like- although her DH has two siblings and they are extremely histile and estranged.

I think tbat what it boils down to is literally what suits your family best. Your situation best. It is not selfish to make conscious decisions about the size of your family. I would argue it is rather selfish to have more children than you can afford either emotionally or financially.

Raindancer411 · 23/03/2022 11:44

I had one at 31, and he was an only child for a long time. He didn't know any better but I was a twin, so don't know what it feels like to be an only child. It was hard on him lockdown but at school he is a social butterfly. He has cousins so wouldn't be exactly without any family.

Then when he was 7, I found out I was pregnant. When we told him he was so excited and burst into tears that he had always wanted a sibling.

My point there is you don't have to hurry into it, you have a while to change your mind. See how you feel...

I have to say I like the bigger age gap as he has me on his own, and now she has me on her own when he is at school.

AlternativePerspective · 23/03/2022 11:41

Your sister was blunt, but also she was correct. Deliberately choosing to have a child with no siblings is selfish. You worry about the ‘state of the world’ - well you have a child now and whatever the state of the world is in future - war, climate change etc - looks like she’ll be facing it by herself. I’m sure she’d rather have a sibling! what a load of bollocks.

Plenty of only children even on this thread who say they wouldn’t have wanted a sibling. So you saying that OP’s child would “rather have a sibling” is pure projection on your part.

AlternativePerspective · 23/03/2022 11:39

I think the magical sibling relationship is overstated massively. While many siblings do get on growing up, IME there are very few who have a really close relationship as they grow up and go on to have their own lives. And there are plenty who have no relationship at all.

In fact I think that a lot of siblings maintain a relationship purely because there is an expectation on them to do so.

Papayamya · 23/03/2022 11:31

@ElIie

I wouldn’t want just one.

Personal tragedy has taught me you need an heir and a spare.

That's not without implications for the lives of the siblings left behind though. Sadly I know a few people who have lost siblings (when young ie before adulthood) and they all (wrongly) carry a sense of guilt and the burden of loss which massively affects their lives. I know this isn't the case for all, but personally what seems like an insurance policy of sorts still has downsides as well as advantages. Again, everyone feels differently but seems quite extreme to have another child just because of this.
Charette · 23/03/2022 11:30

@Thewindwhispers

I have an only child! Not by choice. She is so so lonely and bored of playing by herself, particularly on ‘family’ holidays. Lockdowns were hell: she didn’t speak to another child for half the year. I would never deliberately choose to do this to a child.

Once the toddler years are over, looking after one child is actually harder than looking after two, as they have no one to play with. You may be thinking that you’ll just do playdates, but this relies on other mums cooperating, which sadly isn’t usually the case. I try to do lots of playdates but so often people are busy doing family stuff. DD’s best friend isn’t even allowed to see us at weekends because they need her home playing with her own sister.

(Also my mum is an only child and all the burden and worry of what to do about her ill parents fell on her.)

Your sister was blunt, but also she was correct. Deliberately choosing to have a child with no siblings is selfish. You worry about the ‘state of the world’ - well you have a child now and whatever the state of the world is in future - war, climate change etc - looks like she’ll be facing it by herself. I’m sure she’d rather have a sibling!

With respect, I think the fact that you didn't have one child by choice is influencing you here, and you've been unfortunate in the people who are around your DD. DS (9) is pretty sociable, and has a good posse of friends, none of whom are only children, but the majority of whom have a significant age gap to the next youngest sibling in one case a full ten years, but in another four, and another five so they're not playing with them, anyway. He and his friends see one another a lot at weekends, and often play in the park after school, and do activities together in the evenings.

Two of his closest friends are twins, and while they are both lovely kids, they fight like cat and dog all the time, and are very much striving to distinguish themselves from one another. I think their parents do far more 'work' trying to sort out fights than I do amusing DS.

yellowsuninthesky · 23/03/2022 11:28

@ElIie

I wouldn’t want just one.

Personal tragedy has taught me you need an heir and a spare.

Seriously? If you take that view you'll need about six kids.
yellowsuninthesky · 23/03/2022 11:28

It's very selfish only to have one child. How dare you not want another pregnancy that might injure you or, in extreme cases, even kill you, therefore leaving the first child motherless. Or not want another child as a symbol of your partner's virility. Or want a child to split the inheritance of the first. Etc etc.

For the avoidance of doubt, I am being ironic. Ultimately any decisions relating to child-bearing are selfish, so do what's best for you and your family*

ToiletPoster · 23/03/2022 11:26

Having kids is inherently selfish and you've got no guarantees of an adult relationship. I've got 7 half siblings in total, 2 of whom I lived with for the entirety of my childhood. We're all barely in contact, not even due to any falling out, we just live separate lives.

Any inheritance not being split so many ways would be more useful than any emotional support that I would (not) get from them.

InglouriousBasterd · 23/03/2022 11:25

DD is an only and nearly all of my friends have also stopped at one. It seems to be far more common these days than when I was growing up!

I would have loved another but circumstances didn’t work out that way and I can’t see that changing. I love the relationship I have with DD and I wouldn’t change that for the world now.

deadlanguage · 23/03/2022 11:24

Any number is selfish in that it comes down to what you want. There’s no guarantee that siblings will get along so you can’t really say it’s for their benefit, and a 6mo hardly has an opinion on it. Having an only child is perfectly normal and increasingly common.

IDidntKnowItWasAParty · 23/03/2022 11:21

My only child used to want a sibling, but growing up she sees how badly her friends get on with their siblings, she now says she's glad not to have any! It can really go either way as to whether siblings get along as adults.

EvilPea · 23/03/2022 11:19

That’s a hell of alot of pressure and expectation for that (currently not existing) baby to carry.

ElIie · 23/03/2022 11:18

I wouldn’t want just one.

Personal tragedy has taught me you need an heir and a spare.

ImplementingTheDennisSystem · 23/03/2022 11:17

My only sibling lives abroad and has never brought me anything other than pain.

ExConstance · 23/03/2022 11:14

DH and I each have a brother, neither of us is close to them. Despite this I'm really pleased not to be an only child. As you get older the family decreases in size, parents, aunts and uncles and now cousins die off. I have children of my own but life has been enriched by having a niece and sisters-in-law. When my mother was very elderly the pressure to make decisions and find care did not all fall on me. DH and ;his brother had some very difficult decisions to make and it helped that there were two of them.
My two sons get on well, it is great when we all meet up together. One son is very creative and the other very academic all this greatly enhances our lives.
The main reason I had two was an irrational feeling that as i'd learned all the skills you need to look after a baby with a lot of trial and error it seemed a shame not to do it again. I'm really pleased I did.

VeryMuchFlaggingMinty · 23/03/2022 11:11

I'm an only child and I have an only child...both of us perfectly happy and well adjusted.

I'll admit I've struggled in the last few years dealing with elderly/unwell parents with no family backup, but tbh I know plenty of people who have siblings in that situation and it either gets left entirely to one, or there is so much fighting and aggro it doesn't make it any easier.

As for she thinks it is selfish to choose to have only one child. She has none of her own yet but wants two...Grin...I was adamant I wanted four until I had my DD!

Thursday37 · 23/03/2022 11:08

We are having only 1, it’s in part financial and in part age. But also I now actually feel we are complete as we are. There is no-one missing here and a second child needs to be wanted for themselves, not as a sibling “for” the existing child.

@Ivegottagoforaliedown I felt horribly broody again between 6 months and 18 months but now not at all. We had a pregnancy scare fairly recently and whilst we would’ve continued the pregnancy we were both crying in a not good way and felt enormous relief when I wasn’t pregnant. So that cemented it for us.

Your sister is an arse-people with no children spout all sorts of nonsense about what they will or won’t do and frequently change their tune when they actually have their own.

OnlyFoolsnMothers · 23/03/2022 11:07

Thewindwhispers so glad someone else said it- it’s so hard to have one- you see it every school hols all the only child parents request play dates- and yes we do play dates but I don’t wNt to do one every day

Gilly12345 · 23/03/2022 11:07

I have a sister and we weren’t close when young and lived with our parents and we definitely aren’t close now, haven’t fallen out but have our own friends and interests.

If you can afford to have a second child then good.

I know plenty of siblings who are close and socialise together and to be honest I am a little envious of them.

Luredbyapomegranate · 23/03/2022 11:06

No - of course not, it’s about what’s right for your family. Many adults will tell you they enjoyed or felt entirely neutral about not having siblings. I know a fair few adult only children and I can’t think of one who has any huge issue with it.

As a very very broad rule, I think having siblings is usually preferable as another layer to your life. But that’s only overall - individually it depends on your circumstances.

Thewindwhispers · 23/03/2022 11:04

@OnlyFoolsnMothers

It’s not selfish- however I would say it’s actually much harder to have one child than two. I love my eldest but if she didn’t have a sister I’d feel obliged to eat every meal with her, play with her, go on every play date- and quite honestly I couldn’t do it.
Right?! This is me!! We eat every meal together when she’s not at school, she follows me around non-stop complaining she’s bored, I play computer games with her, read with her, run around the garden with her, even sleep in her room at the moment because she’s scared of the dark and doesn’t want to wake alone. Parenting an only child is intense!!! I’m tired.
Thewindwhispers · 23/03/2022 11:02

I have an only child! Not by choice. She is so so lonely and bored of playing by herself, particularly on ‘family’ holidays. Lockdowns were hell: she didn’t speak to another child for half the year. I would never deliberately choose to do this to a child.

Once the toddler years are over, looking after one child is actually harder than looking after two, as they have no one to play with. You may be thinking that you’ll just do playdates, but this relies on other mums cooperating, which sadly isn’t usually the case. I try to do lots of playdates but so often people are busy doing family stuff. DD’s best friend isn’t even allowed to see us at weekends because they need her home playing with her own sister.

(Also my mum is an only child and all the burden and worry of what to do about her ill parents fell on her.)

Your sister was blunt, but also she was correct. Deliberately choosing to have a child with no siblings is selfish. You worry about the ‘state of the world’ - well you have a child now and whatever the state of the world is in future - war, climate change etc - looks like she’ll be facing it by herself. I’m sure she’d rather have a sibling!

OnlyFoolsnMothers · 23/03/2022 11:00

It’s not selfish- however I would say it’s actually much harder to have one child than two. I love my eldest but if she didn’t have a sister I’d feel obliged to eat every meal with her, play with her, go on every play date- and quite honestly I couldn’t do it.

Swipe left for the next trending thread