Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

"Selfish" to choose to have only one child?

116 replies

Ivegottagoforaliedown · 23/03/2022 08:14

Not my opinion! So less of an AIBU and more 'are they being unreasonable.

I recently had my first baby, he's lovely. My partner and I said we'd just have one, because:

  • We hope to have more time/resources to devote to him.
  • State of the world (we did discuss not having any due to this - whole other thread for that argument!
  • Hopefully less stress?!

However since he's been born I find myself thinking I could do this again (hormones maybe, he's only 6 months!). I wonder about him being lonely, or what will happen when his dad and I die. I wasn't close to my sister growing up but we are very close now and I'm so glad I have her. I was discussing this with her yesterday and she agrees, but went on to say she thinks it is selfish to choose to have only one child. She has none of her own yet but wants two.

I have a bit of time to decide, I'm early 30s and partner is mid 30s - although he reckons he will be too old for another in a few years time. I'm not sure what to think. There's no guarantee siblings would even like one another or get along as adults - I know plenty who don't. But I also know of some who are best of friends.

Of course there are very sensitive reasons why people may choose to stick with one - high risk pregnancies for instance. And of course there is secondary infertility. But in the case where the parents could provide for another child and would be happy with another - is it selfish not to for the sake of their first child?

OP posts:
bookworm14 · 10/05/2022 14:45

This thread, or a variation on it, crops up every bloody week at the moment. There are always people who say it’s fine to have one child and people who say it’s selfish and they’ll be miserable. No one ever changes their mind. What’s the point of endlessly rehashing it?

For what it’s worth I have one child and the only place I am made to feel guilty about this is on Mumsnet.

ColdColdColdColdCold · 10/05/2022 14:40

You can't have a child for someone else.

Having grown up with siblings, they've been the bane of my life and caused me so much trauma, sent me into therapy and triggered severe depression. I wish so much that I'd been an only child. I know in some cases it works out well and siblings can get along and be a net positive in one another's lives but there's really no way of knowing how it's going to go, so if the main driver is to provide a playmate/friend/companion for the existing child, that's a hell of a gamble.

BeccaGeej · 10/05/2022 14:33

Everyone's different. Thee's nothing selfish about either decision. As a mum of one, I would just say that when the time is right, if there is any part of you that wants another, then go for it. I dithered for ages until it was too late ( DH wasn't keen and there were a few reasons against) and I now regret it everyday. Yes, we can give DD, who's now 7, a lovely lifestyle, loads of attention etc but I feel guilty and sad everyday that we didn't have a second, both for her sake and mine. I can't see that feeling ever going away and will always live with that regret.

georgarina · 24/03/2022 20:11

I was an only child for most of my childhood and definitely didn't want that for my kids.

It was lonely, and there was the feeling that whenever my school friends fell out as they often do, the ones with siblings still had their siblings to play with, but I didn't so was more at the mercy of whatever was happening socially.

It was also not great from the perspective of my relationship with my parents. Lots of intense scrutiny and anxiety that I felt my friends with siblings were spared.

Of course if it's not a choice, that's fine and it will work out, but I would never choose that. Kind of like being a child of divorce - it's common and the kids usually grow up absolutely fine, but I wouldn't choose it.

MrsSkylerWhite · 24/03/2022 19:48

Comedycook

I had a blast with my sister growing up...I'd rather have had that relationship than more one on one time with my parents“

My brother abused me and beat me up on a regular basis.

PeterandSandy · 24/03/2022 15:04

of course its not.

Its selfish to have children and mistreat/abuse them though.

Comedycook · 23/03/2022 12:52

I had a blast with my sister growing up...I'd rather have had that relationship than more one on one time with my parents!

HoldingTheDoor · 23/03/2022 12:48

I never understand the focus on care because in my experience it tends to fall on one sibling anyway. There are exceptions but more often than not it tends to be one child who bears the brunt of it.(Usually female, lives closest or the eldest.) Besides even if you do have help, sometimes that can make it harder when you have very different ideas about how to care, e.g one thinks it's time for a care home and the other disagrees.

Not to mention that their sibling could be born with or develop disabilities that mean that they also require care. My Mother's 3 brothers all developed varying degrees of alcohol issues. She loved them a lot but they were also a huge source and stress and worry for her and weren't of any use with caring for her Mother.

I've cared for family members three times now and personally I found it much easier to make the decisions alone.

Darkstar4855 · 23/03/2022 12:44

Definitely not selfish. My son gets far more of my time and attention because we didn’t have a second. We’ll potentially be able to send him to private school.

HunterHearstHelmsley · 23/03/2022 12:42

For every person who thinks it's selfish to have only one child, there's another that thinks it's selfish to have more and then another who think it's selfish to have any at all.

I love my siblings. I'm the middle of three. I hate being the middle child so I'd say it's selfish to have an odd number... Which is clearly ridiculous.

Comedycook · 23/03/2022 12:42

She also has very close friends at school and wider family nearby

But if we all had just one child, eventually you'll reach a point where further generations won't have any wider family.

Ivegottagoforaliedown · 23/03/2022 12:40

Thanks everyone- wasn't expecting so many responses so apologies for not coming back sooner!! Very mixed I see, if only I could see into the future...

I'll have a proper read through soon (in the middle of cleaning my house for the landlord coming round!) But thanks so much for sharing your views and experiences

OP posts:
Chasingaftermidnight · 23/03/2022 12:39

I’m an only child and always hated it (although my parents would tell you I was a ‘perfectly happy only child’ who ‘never wanted a sibling’, but obviously they needed to believe that).

That said, I still don’t think it’s a selfish decision to have an only child by choice because there are so many variables involved.

SVRT19674 · 23/03/2022 12:38

I thought we were supposed to be saving the planet by only having minimal kids or we were selfish? Now we are selfish if we only have one. Damned if we do, damned if we don´t. Having one suits our family, our logistics and our finances. So there it is. Having siblings is ok if you get on well, not guaranteed. Was just reading thread this morning where op was beyond distraught as her sister was blanking her. Both of my ex boyfriends did not get on well with their brothers. So, nothing guaranteed, we do what is right for us.

XmasElf10 · 23/03/2022 12:38

My DD is an only by choice and she’s 11. I don’t think she is spoiled although she does get a lot of my 1 on 1 attention. She isn’t lonely. She and I have a very close bond and both really enjoy hanging out together. She also has very close friends at school and wider family nearby.

I don’t know how it will go when I’m really old but I’d very much hope to look after myself, pay for carers etc..

Wishingthreestonesaway · 23/03/2022 12:33

I was an only child through my childhood years. I was lonely, shy, unable to share, etc. I needed a sibling to bring me some normality of family life. I needed the rivalry, the squabbles, to not be the sole focus of my mother's anxieties. Sadly she lost three boys after me. I'm sure they would have helped me be a more rounded individual. By the time I got a sibling, I was at secondary school and there just wasn't a sibling relationship. I have a DGS who is an only child and he's already struggling with adult life, as I did. When I see my DC and their great relationship I'm so glad I didn't have an only child.

theworstwife · 23/03/2022 12:33

Not selfish, just a choice to be made for the right reasons - you can’t guarantee siblings will get on so I wouldn’t have another for the sake of the first. I had a second child because I really wanted one, for now they get on and play together well, who knows what they will be like when they’re older.

I was an only child and really wanted a sibling, I felt being an only child made me stranger and more sheltered than I already was. My parents were unhappy in their marriage and I was the main focus constantly and the human sticking plaster. Now they are ageing and ill it seems a lot to manage alone.

HoldingTheDoor · 23/03/2022 12:24

Your sister was blunt, but also she was correct. Deliberately choosing to have a child with no siblings is selfish. You worry about the ‘state of the world’ - well you have a child now and whatever the state of the world is in future - war, climate change etc - looks like she’ll be facing it by herself. I’m sure she’d rather have a sibling! *

Utter Nonsense and personally I'd sooner have had a dose of The Clap than a sibling. I've always loved being an only child and the more I of many sibling relationships, the more I appreciate it as an adult.

dray9925 · 23/03/2022 12:22

I only have one they're 5
I've already left it too late to have children close in age. Last year my child became very unwell and needed a bone marrow transplant hours away from home. Thinking then and now I'm still caring for them I'm glad I didnt have other children to worry about.
When they're better I'm not sure if we will go for another I think maybe I'd like too but I worry the age gap would be too much there's 15 years between me and my youngest sibling and we aren't that close.
I think my child is happy on his own though and I don't think it's selfish to have only one

PineConesInTheSnow · 23/03/2022 12:14

@Furrybutts

I am an only child. I loved being so. I had no desire to have a sibling. I have 5 adult children. They are very close and have always really enjoyed spending time with each other. If I had my time over again I would just have one.
Same. I am and was quite happy being an only child. It was and is great!
RantyAunty · 23/03/2022 12:10

One is perfectly reasonable.

You're being considerate of the environment.
You DC will likely have a spouse, friends, and maybe DC of their own so they won't be alone.

deadlanguage · 23/03/2022 12:06

@Thewindwhispers I’m sorry that you’re struggling but I don’t think a sibling would have solved all of that for your daughter. I didn’t play with my sibling at all when we were children. We basically ignored each other/fought all the time and only developed a relationship as adults. I love her of course but I definitely don’t think my life would have been worse as an only child. DP likewise didn’t play much with his sister and they don’t really have a relationship now, so might as well have been an only child. In fact that would have been better for him as he wouldn’t have to worry about her going off the rails all the time.

konasana · 23/03/2022 11:54

My own mum did not cope well with two and I also know I would not handle the stress of two very well. Having a second would be selfish, in my case, as my first would suffer for it and I would resent the second child.

Tilltheend99 · 23/03/2022 11:53

I always think the state of the world is a good reason to bring up positive little humans and give them the opportunity to change things.

But how many children you have is your concern and doing something purely out of guilt is not a great reason to do anything.

Having more children should be based around what you want your family and it’s dynamic to be like. I don’t even believe that resources should be a factor as long as another child will be safe and loved. (Appreciate that means a lot to some)

If you care a lot about the state of the world/want your DC to have a variety of relationships you could always go down the foster route and help a child in a precarious situation.

Don’t forget, if your sister is able to have DCs and lives nearby then cousin relationships can be more like sibling ones!

suzysays · 23/03/2022 11:53

Only child here!

It's not selfish. I was perfectly happy and my mum and dad gave me a lot of attention (more than I am able to give my children) as there was only me! We have great relationships now and I have cousins/DHs family who's children I am Aunty too so I wouldn't say I'm lonely.

Just do whatever you feel is right, my mum and dad only wanted 1 and never regretted it.

Swipe left for the next trending thread