Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Chancellor’s spring statement

369 replies

Cheesecakeandwineinasuitcase · 23/03/2022 06:56

AIBU to think that today we are about to be hugely disappointed by what Rishi says in his spring statement and just to realise just how out of touch he is with the grim reality that normal people (I.e. not millionaire politicians) in the Uk face?

My prediction is that he won’t back down on the 1.25% increase in NI contributions that he is making people pay from April. There will be a paltry reduction in fuel duty (maybe a few pence if we are lucky - but that will easily be cancelled out within a few days as prices increase to compensate). Maybe he will reduce the duty on champagne this time or some other gimmicky sweetener (wasn’t it Prosecco last time?). He might raise the threshold from which people have to start paying tax but for most working families that won’t make a jot of difference.

So it feels like we are sitting ducks and that as time goes by more and more people end up really struggling.

OP posts:
daimbarsatemydogsbone · 23/03/2022 17:24

@Zilla1

Be realistic. Taxing wealth would hit key stakeholders and the rich would just leave. OK, their houses might stay and the companies that service the economy but apart from that, they would leave like Lloyd Webber after a Labour government. Cutting benefits and workers' wages in real terms and increasing taxes is the only way. No, it doesn't show where the real power lies, move along move along.
So rich tax-dodgers would fuck off to some shithole? Not seeing the downside yet.
fogglez · 23/03/2022 17:24

high tax & low growth & seeing your money actually not able to buy much is not good. Young people are going to emigrate & we need as many young people as possible!

Zilla1 · 23/03/2022 17:22

Be realistic. Taxing wealth would hit key stakeholders and the rich would just leave. OK, their houses might stay and the companies that service the economy but apart from that, they would leave like Lloyd Webber after a Labour government. Cutting benefits and workers' wages in real terms and increasing taxes is the only way. No, it doesn't show where the real power lies, move along move along.

Blossomtoes · 23/03/2022 17:18

@Ifeellikedancing

Sneakily reducing the chances of part time workers qualifying for full state pension. 🙄
Not true. People earning less than the threshold get credits.
lonelyapple · 23/03/2022 17:15

It's ridiculous that they are punishing work by making those on PAYE pay 1.25% more NI whilst benefits are going up by 3%. Hardly an incentive to work. They should be encouraging work, not making workers pay more for the privilege!

EthelTheAardvark · 23/03/2022 17:09

The Treasury is coining it in duty on higher petrol prices. The 5p cut is a drop in the ocean in comparison, especially as prices are rising so quickly that we will be back to current levels within a couple of weeks.

EthelTheAardvark · 23/03/2022 17:06

@fogglez

* What do you expect him to do. The UK has high levels of debt. There’s not a magic money tree. Printing more money = greater inflation (it’s already high).*

target wealth & not income

Plus: Do something sensible about tax avoidance. Take steps to recover those billions lost on furlough frauds. Stop throwing expensive government contracts at companies whose only qualification is that they're friendly with someone in the cabinet or that they make large donations to Tory funds.
fogglez · 23/03/2022 17:02
  • What do you expect him to do. The UK has high levels of debt. There’s not a magic money tree. Printing more money = greater inflation (it’s already high).*

target wealth & not income

fogglez · 23/03/2022 17:01

imo wage stagnation has impacted productivity & QE has deflated wages

fogglez · 23/03/2022 17:00

We need improved productivity. That's thw only way to raise living standards. If interest rates go up significantly businesses will be even less inclined to borrow to invest in productivity increases and technology.

Productivity is shocking but how can the gov improve it?

GiraffesInScarfs · 23/03/2022 16:49

[quote ThinkAboutItTomorrow]@GiraffesInScarfs do interest rates still impact sterling? I know they used to but not sure anymore.

Are the people advocating high interest rates looking to strengthen sterling as a cushion to the external price rises?

Beyond that I agree I don't see much point, in fact with high mortgage borrowing interest rates must surely drive up inflation.

I don't think it would drive house prices down that fast either as lenders have applied pretty strict tests of affordability. [/quote]
Yes, they will always impact a currency. However, so many other things do so (and have done so for years now) that Sterling is worth a fraction of what it was a decade ago, and a significant rise in interest rates would likely have a negligible effect on import costs etc, given the other much more significant factors driving the prices increases in those commodities globally.

It would however, bring business investment pretty much to a halt, result in negative equity for many people, and mean that many individuals, companies and indeed the Government itself struggle to refinance their high levels of debt at affordable rates. Which would mean even more tax rises/ less public spending. And less spending by consumers meaning further job losses meaning higher welfare bills and less productivity, etc. That way lies a vicious downwards spiral.

daimbarsatemydogsbone · 23/03/2022 16:46

@Whelmed

The thing is that if there was an election this summer the Tories would win, not because they've done a great job but because we're convinced that everyone else is worse. So they don't really need to try that hard at this point.
but because we're convinced that everyone else is worse. I'm not. But then I didn't vote for these cunts in the first place, along with a majority of those who bothered to vote, I voted for something else.
ThinkAboutItTomorrow · 23/03/2022 16:37

@GiraffesInScarfs do interest rates still impact sterling? I know they used to but not sure anymore.

Are the people advocating high interest rates looking to strengthen sterling as a cushion to the external price rises?

Beyond that I agree I don't see much point, in fact with high mortgage borrowing interest rates must surely drive up inflation.

I don't think it would drive house prices down that fast either as lenders have applied pretty strict tests of affordability.

Whelmed · 23/03/2022 16:37

The thing is that if there was an election this summer the Tories would win, not because they've done a great job but because we're convinced that everyone else is worse. So they don't really need to try that hard at this point.

GiraffesInScarfs · 23/03/2022 16:33

@Cheeseplease1976

The BOE need to raise interest rates to combat inflation but they know if they do it will collapse the housing Ponzi scheme. People are addicted to low interest rates - interest rates need to be around the same as inflation to get it under control but they know what will happen - black Wednesday all over again. The country is fucked until that happens!
The sources of inflation are largely external to the UK economy so raising rates will do very little to bring inflation down, and will probably actually make the economy worse overall.

We need improved productivity. That's thw only way to raise living standards. If interest rates go up significantly businesses will be even less inclined to borrow to invest in productivity increases and technology.

The measures that could mitigate the shorter-term impact on living costs are fiscal ones, not monetary ones.

Zilla1 · 23/03/2022 16:30

'working families' 'hard working' 'just about managing'. Don't be mean. Someone is paid to think this up.

Don't mention a majority of UC? recipients are in work and the low-wage economy scandalously subsidises employers. We need to demonise benefit recipients. They should work harder (even though some of the hardest working people I've met are on NMW so have to work long hours). Or been luckier about into which families they were born.

LizzieMacQueen · 23/03/2022 16:30

@RiverFlowers

So if you earn under £13k a year, will that mean you don't qualify for your "pension" stamps each year?
@RiverFlowers I asked that upthread and the answer is you'll be ok as there's no increase to the lower earnings level ( c £120 ) a week. So 'stamps' paid as before.
TimBoothseyes · 23/03/2022 16:25

I voted YABU just for the use of the term "working families".

Zilla1 · 23/03/2022 16:23

Indeed. People need to empathise more with the problems that others face I bet few on this thread have thought about the problems of a Chancellor who needs to face his billionaire chums and has job worries about where the votes will come from for his leadership challenge. Makes 'heat or eat' pale into insignificance. You all need to empathise more with the truly disadvantaged.

I am genuinely sorry about your post, OP. These are indeed hard times. If only it were the Roaring Twenties like F Scott Fitzgerald's Gatsby instead. Except for the end (spoilers).

Becca19962014 · 23/03/2022 16:15

@Zilla1 of course!! That’s it!!! I’m just being a meany, old miser. I’m disabled, how dare I expect any better. I’ve read dickens!

GiraffesInScarfs · 23/03/2022 16:15

@Lifeisaminestrone

What do you expect him to do. The UK has high levels of debt. There’s not a magic money tree. Printing more money = greater inflation (it’s already high).

The Government can’t afford to bail out people anymore. We generally had a good Keynesian approach during lockdowns, but it is unsustainable.

Do something to increase productivity?
Zilla1 · 23/03/2022 16:15

@lecreusetpeppermill putting aside Greensill, was it DC who imposed a housing cap for the benefit claimant's entire accommodation to rent that was less than the cost of the new kitchen in No 10 (or number 11, I know sometimes the PM lives in No 11 if they have children as it's bigger) that they had to have even though the last one was serviceable but not pretty?

Cheeseplease1976 · 23/03/2022 16:14

The BOE need to raise interest rates to combat inflation but they know if they do it will collapse the housing Ponzi scheme. People are addicted to low interest rates - interest rates need to be around the same as inflation to get it under control but they know what will happen - black Wednesday all over again. The country is fucked until that happens!

Zilla1 · 23/03/2022 16:12

@Becca19962014 I'm sorry to hear that. Life can be hard sometimes.

Zilla1 · 23/03/2022 16:11

You are almost all just mean people being mean. It's getting like a (family member of a) billionaire can't play to the gallery of his powerful stakeholders and build a reputation for fiscal conservatism with the constituency of electors for the next PM and schedule in a pre-election sweetener for the masses (well the masses who haven't starved or frozen before May 2024) without you all criticising him. So ungrateful. It's like the UK has stopped being a country for the hard-working, those who aspire to be billionaires. It's levelling up for the billionaires, not levelling down. The important people will leave for lower tax countries like LLoyd Weber threatened to do if Labour were elected. And then the lights will get turned off. Haven't you read Ayn Rand? And Rees-Mogg the elder?

And there's no such thing as a magic money tree. Unless a £bn or two need to be found when an election goes wrong. Or £10s of billions can be directed to the powerful during a pandemic. And don't say a nation's economy is fundamentally different to a household economy. You're right economically but even so. Mrs Thatcher was a grocers daughter so she knew about purses and how to cut benefits. Well, knew enough to marry a millionaire when a million was worth something.

Don't forget, it's been at least some time since tens of billions were channeled to donors during COVID and the important people have short memories so we need to keep them sweet. Pay peanuts and get monkeys. Like MPs with an extra £2500 and all the other revenue streams and the second jobs and the City. No, we don't need to pay the NHS and care workers more, though do it for claps. In that way they are like monkeys.

Tally Ho!

Swipe left for the next trending thread