Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Chancellor’s spring statement

369 replies

Cheesecakeandwineinasuitcase · 23/03/2022 06:56

AIBU to think that today we are about to be hugely disappointed by what Rishi says in his spring statement and just to realise just how out of touch he is with the grim reality that normal people (I.e. not millionaire politicians) in the Uk face?

My prediction is that he won’t back down on the 1.25% increase in NI contributions that he is making people pay from April. There will be a paltry reduction in fuel duty (maybe a few pence if we are lucky - but that will easily be cancelled out within a few days as prices increase to compensate). Maybe he will reduce the duty on champagne this time or some other gimmicky sweetener (wasn’t it Prosecco last time?). He might raise the threshold from which people have to start paying tax but for most working families that won’t make a jot of difference.

So it feels like we are sitting ducks and that as time goes by more and more people end up really struggling.

OP posts:
Becca19962014 · 24/03/2022 11:07

@Zilla1 I got it now. The missing link. All I need.

Gumption!

Now how could I have missed that!!

EvilPea · 24/03/2022 11:00

A lot of problems faced by ordinary people are Tory problems.

Council house sell off - and not replacement

Housing crisis anyone?

privatisation of utilities
Energy crisis anyone?

We are paying now for the 80’s recession and how Maggie got us out.

EvilPea · 24/03/2022 10:57

The £1 a poor person is given comes back in tax from the wages where they’ve spent it, and production of that item they’ve bought.

Zilla1 · 24/03/2022 10:50

Give a rich person £1, they earned it.

Give a poor person £1. Scounger. Or benefits. or benefit scrounger.

and we can't pay ourselves what we can't afford. Unless it's privatising the profits and socialising the losses because that's different.

daimbarsatemydogsbone · 24/03/2022 10:49

@Zilla1

But how on earth can wealth be expected to trickle down if it doesn't flood upwards in the first place? Basic economics. Keep up. The only reason the nation is in the state it is in is because of the contribution of oligarchs and corporates. They could just leave and then where would we be?
Grin Aye, the horror of life without them (the cunts) - it doesn't bear thinking about.
EvilPea · 24/03/2022 10:48

[quote deadlanguage]@worriedatthistime in the article I mentioned, it was people turning down potatoes from food banks because they couldn’t afford to cook them, so the cost of the potato is less relevant.[/quote]
This is genuinely one of the most depressing thing I’ve ever read.

EvilPea · 24/03/2022 10:47

Give a rich person £1 they save it

Give a poor person £1 they spend it, helping provide jobs and economic stimulation.

It’s really not rocket science is it

deadlanguage · 24/03/2022 10:43

@worriedatthistime in the article I mentioned, it was people turning down potatoes from food banks because they couldn’t afford to cook them, so the cost of the potato is less relevant.

Zilla1 · 24/03/2022 09:57

But how on earth can wealth be expected to trickle down if it doesn't flood upwards in the first place? Basic economics. Keep up. The only reason the nation is in the state it is in is because of the contribution of oligarchs and corporates. They could just leave and then where would we be?

daimbarsatemydogsbone · 24/03/2022 09:41

@Justanotherlurker

It's showing how many people are living on the edge and have accepted the 'ever rising house prices' narrative, the black swan was always around the corner as the world was at historically low interest rates, Covid was not a time to move house based on WFH and ignore the increase of interest rate we would need to pay back lock down, Russia has added to that, MN is going to become a lot more 'right wing' in the future when the belt fully tightens as a lot of people who don't understand the geopolitical situation try and paint it as a simple anti tory problem that can ve solved if x party come into power
A lot of problems faced by ordinary people are Tory problems. The geopolitical situation doesn't require us to steal from the poor and give to the rich continually - that's a Tory policy.
Zilla1 · 24/03/2022 09:36

It's just mean people who are observing that he made a ludicrously poor attempt at justifying and owning his decisions. It is unclear whether his constituency will see that as a defect or a feature for a new PM. No not his geographic constituency, the important constituency of Conservative MPs for the leadership contest and the constituency of donors and important stakeholders to that contest and the government in general.

EvilPea · 24/03/2022 09:29

I understand the ‘makings sure there’s money to invest in green energy pot’

However, why is that not coming from profits?
If a car manufacturer wants to carry on making cars they have to invest in new technology.

If an independent garage want to carry on trading they have to future proof the business by investing in new tools and computers.

Baker / food producer, keep up to date with new legislation, change ingredients if something becomes banned.

IT department, go on training courses and buy new equipment, upgrade cyber security. as technology and needs evolve

Every business has to invest to future proof themselves and ensure they can continue trading. Railways had to do it after steam. It comes from profits and outsourced investment, not solely the customer.

DuncinToffee · 24/03/2022 09:27

And the price of bread Zilla as everyone in his house houses eats different bread.

Zilla1 · 24/03/2022 09:04

Having listened to the Chancellor, I'm even more convinced most of you are being mean. He said he simply can't be expected to take account of every single person's circumstances so his generous announcement is something or other. And no one can absolutely know the exact prices of energy over the next 6 months so he can't have done more, obviously. Everyone will benefit from the new price cap over the next 6 months anyway so it's not an issue, well except users of community heating, fuel oil and LPG. And car fuel. So that's why he can announce a tax cut just before the election because we understand the position in two years better than the next six months. How can he be expected to build an election war chest to chow prudence and tax cuts if we don't share the mild discomfort now? We're all in it together, remember. And something about more accessible toilets for wealthy people with mobility issues and those with the gumption not to freeze or starve. And no one should say he's got the tinnest ear in government, many in the Cabinet would fight for that. Of course he knows what it feels like, after all he has to think about rising energy costs in his 12? houses, well the ones that aren't let out.

He might be tied up in media training for the next few months so he is better positioned for the Conservative leadership contest.

Tally Ho!

gosensk · 24/03/2022 07:19

Covid was not a time to move house based on WFH and ignore the increase of interest rate we would need to pay back lock down,

Part of me feels I missed out not moving during lockdown. I know a few friends that did because the SD made it possible. They also got quite hefty reductions on what they bought. Prices have definitely increased where I was looking although I felt they were overvalued.

Justanotherlurker · 23/03/2022 23:14

It's showing how many people are living on the edge and have accepted the 'ever rising house prices' narrative, the black swan was always around the corner as the world was at historically low interest rates, Covid was not a time to move house based on WFH and ignore the increase of interest rate we would need to pay back lock down, Russia has added to that, MN is going to become a lot more 'right wing' in the future when the belt fully tightens as a lot of people who don't understand the geopolitical situation try and paint it as a simple anti tory problem that can ve solved if x party come into power

worriedatthistime · 23/03/2022 22:37

@deadlanguage it is if they can't afford that potato
Fuel prices affect us all thats just a simple fact and whilst I think 5 p considering how much its going up is pissing in the wind
I do think fuel cuts aren't just for those who have a car

deadlanguage · 23/03/2022 22:12

@worriedatthistime it’s not as acute of a problem as people not being able to afford to boil a potato.

worriedatthistime · 23/03/2022 22:01

@deadlanguage the fuel cost does affect all though , whether you have a car or not as your food comes by road and things you buy
When companies expenses go up such as fuel where do you think the prices get passed on to

Zilla1 · 23/03/2022 21:50

I think the issue with rate rises is that a significant proportion of mortgages were already precarious even at negligible interest rates with a relatively high percentage of monthly repayments being paid with the proceeds of unsecured borrowing. Significant interest rate rises will tip many into default as presumably will energy, car fuel and food price rises. A disaster for the home owners and families but any correction might help new buyers I suppose though I think house price uncertainty normally leads to a reduction in new mortgage writing by the lenders so if prices drop, new buyers struggle more to benefit.

That said, I think there is a relatively high proportion of houses owned outright without mortgages so presumably they are insulated from rate rises and may benefit from increase in savings rates. I suppose wealth is, like William Gibson's future, here already but unevenly distributed.

I think the wealthy don't rely on savings interest rates, rather from the healthy returns on property and financial assets and will have increased their wealth from the last twelve-odd years' QE. Oh to be wealthy and risk the moral corruption.

Alexandra2001 · 23/03/2022 21:34

@Whelmed

The thing is that if there was an election this summer the Tories would win, not because they've done a great job but because we're convinced that everyone else is worse. So they don't really need to try that hard at this point.
Labour, despite the Ukrainian war (which Johnson must have thanked his lucky stars for) are still 5pts ahead of the Tories.

Though judging by the comments on my MPs FB page, Labour might go further ahead.

We'd prob get another Coalition, funnily enough for Macron, he has seen his popularity sky rocket, the right wing contenders are nowhere.

ilovesooty · 23/03/2022 21:32

Of course this government couldn't care less about people struggling. They won't care if people lose their accommodation, become ill or die.

However if there were a GE tomorrow they'd probably still be in power. It's not rocket science to work out why.

LadyShatterly · 23/03/2022 21:24

I wish that interest rates would rise enough that I could get anything from my savings. Their value is being depleted by inflation and even £30 a month would pay a bill. Just one, but God, 5% was manageable for years and years and years - why do we have no wiggle room any more?

GiraffesInScarfs · 23/03/2022 20:45

[quote fogglez]@GiraffesInScarfs Those things are great & I would be happy for my taxes to be used for that but looking at the track record of the gov, it's not going to happen! [/quote]
I know. Sad

fogglez · 23/03/2022 20:36

@GiraffesInScarfs Those things are great & I would be happy for my taxes to be used for that but looking at the track record of the gov, it's not going to happen!