Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask what you think of Kate Middleton?

637 replies

Teadrinker11 · 22/03/2022 20:27

Interested to hear some opinions. What do you think of her? I was just reading a Dailymail article where she and William are in Belize and people are complaining about them flaunting their lives and all that. People struggling and Ukraine on fire, etc and Kate and William are rubbing it in people's faces. What do you think? Yes, they definitely have it better than a lot of people but in one sense I also feel that she has to thread on eggshells being in the public eye so much. Say one thing she'll be crucified but if she says something else it will be the same, she can't win regardless of what she says or do. If she acknowledges and openly says that she's got it easy with her luxury lifestyle people will scream down her neck about that too. What do you think? What's your view on Kate?

OP posts:
anotherbloodyyearofcovid · 23/03/2022 10:52

@Brefugee

I love the Queen and I like having a monarchy. I don't want President Johnson or President Blair.

zzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzz
boring. Really. Idiotically boring. There are SO MANY other people who could be a president.

Trump, putin, Sarkozy, Clinton....
VanCleefArpels · 23/03/2022 10:51

@trailrunner85 we don’t KNOW that PW has had an affair. We KNOW that the media has speculated about it based on anonymous “sources”.

Frollop · 23/03/2022 10:43

Her parents must be proud of her. The education, her beauty and connections paid off.

TreatTrimTame · 23/03/2022 10:42

I think the Catherine we are shown is nice and fulfils the role. She is very vanilla, a good wife and mum and very amiable. She is what we needed. I like her.

trailrunner85 · 23/03/2022 10:36

Likewise, people seize eagerly on the idea that William has affairs . Because it can’t possibly be that they are actually in love and happy with each other can it?

But we know that he has. It genuinely surprises me that people aren't aware of this - when, thanks to the Internet, we can all read world media not under the scope of the injunctions in place here.

Our media had a lot of fun with it at the time but were very careful not to breach the law. The "rural rival" and "turnip toffs" stuff is all still there for all to read.

I'm ambivalent towards KM. I wouldn't want her life and wouldn't last 10 minutes in it,
but I think she does her "job" well.

reesewithoutaspoon · 23/03/2022 10:30

Yes the idea that they’ll bring a bit of sunshine into the lives of poor people just by being there is extremely patronising.

This is what I don't get. It's a really outdated concept. It might have been great last century when seeing royals bought a bit of glamour into people's otherwise grindingly hard and boring lives. When people were raised with stark class differences and 'knew their place' and were supposed to feel grateful that their betters would deign to come to see them and be waved and smiled at.
I just don't get how seeing very wealthy and privileged people is supposed to raise the morale of the country. Feels more like rubbing it on your face. Maybe that's why the backlash to these tours.

Brefugee · 23/03/2022 10:29

How do they behave? Catherine (her lack of a past is very telling, to me it all feeds into my belief that the Middletons really had a long-term game plan. I am sincerely in awe of them pulling it off) is very bland wears very bland clothes, has some interests (her photos aren't brilliant, they are competent given she has top of the range equipment i would expect nothing less) she seems to like shooting, is she any good at it? and did her duty by producing the heir and the spare (and another spare! go her)

But what did the others do? Meghan? I think she underestimated what she was marrying into (no idea how, given how much we hear about the family firm) and walked away from it? Who else? Diana? Well, poor ol' Di seemed to have been bred to marry Charles, then really didn't like it and wasn't supported in any meaningful way. Sophie Wessex? I quite like her, she does her thing quietly.

I do love things like Coronation Street and The Archers and i look on the British Royal Family in a similar way: if you look at it or listen to it for 5 minutes you want to know what happens next. Grin

Chely · 23/03/2022 10:28

Don't mind her. I think the royals should fizzle out though.

Classicblunder · 23/03/2022 10:25

Yes the idea that they’ll bring a bit of sunshine into the lives of poor people just by being there is extremely patronising.

I agree. William visited the children's hospital that my son was recovering from a major operation in. It actually made me quite angry that anyone could possibly think a privileged prince could actually make anyone there feel better.

95% of the parents on the ward opted out of interacting with him

Nicholethejewellery · 23/03/2022 10:23

I love Kate, she comes across as classy yet down to earth. Plus she's genuinely beautiful in a way that others who have married into the royal family are not (won't name names, but the big three others in the last 40 years).

Contrast her behaviour to how the others behaved (won't name names, but the big three others in the last 40 years) or are behaving, it's no wonder that people have a much fonder appreciation for Kate than they do for other royals. AFAIK she's not had an affair or set out to cause trouble unlike some others have done (won't name names, but the big three others in the last 40 years).

CounsellorTroi · 23/03/2022 10:19

@Jamoffmytoast

Don't see why she is being criticised when she's accompanying her husband there.

But I do think it seems very outdated, this tour, and also why are people meant to be pleased or interested when most peoples lives are pretty tough right now.

Yes the idea that they’ll bring a bit of sunshine into the lives of poor people just by being there is extremely patronising.
Elphame · 23/03/2022 10:18

No opinion really.

She knew what she was getting into. Hopefully the monarchy is now on its way out. The Commonwealth is crumbling about it. Maybe one day we'll be allowed to choose too.

SleepingStandingUp · 23/03/2022 10:10

As for Kate, there's so few stories about her I assume she has very loyal friends. That suggests she's a decent sort of person. Her family seem very close. She seems like a good Mom. If we bumped into ea h other in Starbucks in she we could have a perfectly nice chat about raising three kids albeit very differently and she's probably a laugh once she feels safe. But it must be quite isolating to know that any new friends have to prove their worth becks being trusted

spacehardware · 23/03/2022 10:10

Oh come on she had a poster on him on her wall as a teenager. They may never have thought they'd land the big one, but ma Middleton definitely intended her daughters to marry aristos/oligarchs/billionaires. For. Sure.

SleepingStandingUp · 23/03/2022 10:08

@Gonnagetgoing

Kate loves William now - bBut ut when she met him at uni then of course she was after him because of his position in the RF. Of course she then had to spend time with him to see if she liked him.

Unless she's told you this herself because you're best friends, you have no idea whether she thought yeah I wanna be queen, I guess he'll have to do, Harry won't be got for a decade yet, or if she thought fuck, I actually really like him but his family are crazy and I don't want that life. Or if she thought he's hot, we can have fun and ill walk away then woke up one morning and realised she was in love. I know people are obsessed with the idea that Mama Middleton raised her girls to hook super rich men and that William basically had no chance to escape their calculated clutches. But at their age, its quite easy to fall in love and think the grown up stuff will never really happen. Dad v will reign until he's 100 and then we'll be in our 60s and that seems like a life too far away to be real

NellGwynne · 23/03/2022 09:59

@Gonnagetgoing

How on earth can you know what Kate felt? Are you saying it was impossible for her to have got to know him as a person and fallen in love with him? What a stupid thing to say. They shared a flat before becoming involved.

Brefugee · 23/03/2022 09:55

Bloody exhausting

Huzzah for the RF. Bunch of Stakhanovites, the lot of them. Hacking away at the coal face so the rest of us slackers can see what a good example they are of hardworking families who don't suckle at the teat of state benefits.

Sure. A couple of weeks a year it's meetings, dinners, boring small talk. Funnily enough that's how my working day is. For much shittier pay.

She chose the goldfish bowl for herself and her offspring and their offspring for generations to come. There must be a huge degree of understanding to take that on. Not "oh he's so hunky swoon i must marry him" stars in your eyes True Lurve.

Gonnagetgoing · 23/03/2022 09:41

@NellGwynne

I’m always astonished that so many people seem to assume Kate was calculating and only wanted to marry William for his position. Does it not occur to anybody that she may actually love him? Ther is this assumption that any woman marrying ‘up’ does it for position not love. We aren’t in a Jane Austen novel. Likewise, people seize eagerly on the idea that William has affairs . Because it can’t possibly be that they are actually in love and happy with each other can it?
@NellGwynne - Kate loves William now - bBut ut when she met him at uni then of course she was after him because of his position in the RF. Of course she then had to spend time with him to see if she liked him.

It's exactly the same with Meghan - she was in England, wanted to meet a suitable man and when Harry appeared she knew exactly who he was despite her pleas otherwise.

But liking and loving someone are different and can develop later on.

theworldhas · 23/03/2022 09:33

I’d personally hate for my children to grow up in a goldfish bowl which gets ever smaller and intrusive with each passing year. That’s one of the main reasons I don’t support the British Monarchy in its current form. It’s clearly a horrible environment in which to raise children - as attested to the fact that so many of the adult British Royals have had serious mental health issues/breakdowns etc despite every material privilege imaginable.

theworldhas · 23/03/2022 09:28

@NellGwynne
It could be both. We may be attracted to someone physically/their personality. But we also simultaneously weigh up their position/job/location etc.

She willingly gave up many of the pleasures/tribulations of a “normal” life for those of an “extraordinary” life in the public gaze. And not just for herself, but for her children. And not just for a year or two - but forever. That is no small thing. Pretending that love would have been the only factor in such a decision would be naive. Love fails all the time if and when the other stuff is insufficiently satisfactory according to our personal worldview/needs.

emuloc · 23/03/2022 09:27

@custardbear

I think she 'wears' her job well as Will's wife and a member of the RF. I doubt the trip was her idea it would be the Firm who sends them as ambassadors.

She's the opposite to her SIL, for which I am truly thankful - Megain's greedy, manipulative, bullying, oneupmanship behaviours made her a dreadful person let alone a representative of the UK, Kate comes across as sincere, kind, gentle and humble which is essential in such a role

Why are you truly thankful that in your opinion Kate is the opposite to Meghan? What difference does it make to your life? You know nothing about either women. Bonkers.
theworldhas · 23/03/2022 09:23

I thinks she’s totally fine. But for the above reason, I don’t think I’d have had much in common with her and I certainly don’t envy/admire her. I’d rather a weekend in Blackpool off my own endeavours than endless “work engagements” around the world where the most you ever get to cut loose is a quiet drink in a very high walled resort.

Blossomtoes · 23/03/2022 09:23

Use the money they eat up to solve the housing crisis in this country, and build more houses, the economy, NHS, etc.

How much money do you think they cost? It wouldn’t even make a dent in that lot.

NellGwynne · 23/03/2022 09:21

I’m always astonished that so many people seem to assume Kate was calculating and only wanted to marry William for his position. Does it not occur to anybody that she may actually love him?
Ther is this assumption that any woman marrying ‘up’ does it for position not love. We aren’t in a Jane Austen novel.
Likewise, people seize eagerly on the idea that William has affairs . Because it can’t possibly be that they are actually in love and happy with each other can it?

theworldhas · 23/03/2022 09:18

Nobody knows what’s she’s like. Her public role is just that - a role. She plays it well enough.

I guess you can certainly say that she is - or was - ambitious to take her job/role in the Royal Family. As marrying into a monarchy isn’t just a marriage it’s a high profile job/role.

But then it was an ambition of a very specific (arguably limited) sort. As for many ambitious women in their 20s, marrying into a position/role in which will never change or challenge them intellectually and in which they will never be anything more than a support act to their more important husband would be the antithesis of ambition.

Swipe left for the next trending thread