Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

LGB vs LGBTQI etc

518 replies

Whoistheexpert · 22/03/2022 20:04

Why was the T (and others) ever added to the LGB acronym?

The T (trans) is surely related to gender and not ones sexual orientation?

Am I missing something 😵‍💫

OP posts:
Thread gallery
9
Scout2016 · 23/03/2022 14:18

"There's a thread on feminism boards 'It will never happen', detailing crimes et by transwomen.
What if I were to start one about gay women?"

I haven't seen anyone on any thread deny that women sometimes harm other women. So there's no need to evidence it happens, as no one is arguing otherwise.

I have seen lots of posters say that no one would ever take advantage of self ID to harm others, or for any other ill intentioned reason. Which is why a thread providing evidence to the contrary exists.

Linning · 23/03/2022 14:18

I mean lesbian events often have gay men or a bisexual girl’s boyfriend or the straight best friends @BuffyFanForever , so like you say it’s maybe more than in general you don’t see as much exclusively lesbian parties and events but honestly I mind the straight girls coming for support at a lesbian party a bit more than I would ever trans women, and I also don’t think I would personally be comfortable attending lesbian parties that refused entry to trans women, and many of my lesbian friends wouldn’t either.

I prefer queer spaces to be inclusive personally rather than exclusive.

bellinisurge · 23/03/2022 14:14

@Skinnydogz another one who thinks that lesbians commit sexual violence at the same rate as men. You should be ashamed of being such a hand maiden

bellinisurge · 23/03/2022 14:13

So happy that you are happy. Thankfully, you don't get to decide what I consent to. "No" is a complete sentence.

Skinnydogz · 23/03/2022 14:12

And just to add, in my life I have experienced pushy, inappropriate behavior from lesbians- being cornered in toilets, not taking no thank you I'm not interested as an answer. Just my personal experience

BuffyFanForever · 23/03/2022 14:09

Totally get your point of view @Linning. Personally would prefer some lesbian only events but the wider issue is the lack of lesbian events sometimes too!

Linning · 23/03/2022 14:05

Whoops meant to quote @BuffyFanForever but didn’t work. My bad.

Linning · 23/03/2022 14:03

I am more than happy to have trans women at lesbian events. It is absolute a non-issue for me.

Skinnydogz · 23/03/2022 13:59

As a lesbian I'm totally happy with the T and I. No matter what a lot of people's opinions are trans people were some of the first to kick off the gay rights movement and I am thankful for that. Growing up I've met many trans people they have always been there, I don't feel hijacked or pressured to enter into relationships with the.

BuffyFanForever · 23/03/2022 13:54

@Linning

Didn’t read the full thread but as a lesbian no I don’t feel hijacked by the T at all and love the trans people are part of the community. I only feel sad on their behalf tbh that they still face so much discrimination at a scale I don’t feel I do anymore as a lesbian in a western country, I couldn’t imagine growing up trans personally so I am glad if a community I am a part of can provide them with support and relatable folks, especially as many trans people are queer so naturally fit irrelevant of gender identity.
Do you never feel like the women’s only nights are no more? Would you happily accept any male bodied person stating they are a woman to be included in an female activities? Not being rude just genuinely asking?
Lemonyfuckit · 23/03/2022 13:51

@flashbac

Transphobia is recycled homophobia now is it? What a lazy assertion with no critical thought behind it. If it's transphobic to believe sex is immutable how can you compare it to homophobia, which is based on moral disgust?
Exactly. It's so lazy to use this as the argument that GC people are just bigots just like homophobes and therefore shouldn't be listened to. It is just simply not the same at all. And obviously it's tedious repeating this ad nauseum because anyone who trots out that tired argument isn't interested in having a rational, fact-based discussion on the topic but here goes nothing: the GC arguments put forward by feminists are not transphobia. GC feminists don't hate or fear of trans people, or wish to 'erase' them or anything of the sort, there is simply a belief (one based on biological fact so knowledge in fact rather than belief) that sex matters, and women's sex-based rights should be protected and upheld, not trampled all over in the name of inclusivity and 'being kind'.
montysma1 · 23/03/2022 13:49

Stating that sex is immutable is not transphobic. It is perhaps sciencedenial phobic.

mudgetastic · 23/03/2022 13:49

Rely on

1: if they could prove that transwomen didn't offend at the male rate it would be significant enough that it would be published /shouted from the rooftops

2: the Uk publishes data on the prison population which shows transpeople are overly represented as sex offenders ( note that you don't get counted for minor offences and the judiciary system may be biased against transwomen which makes this data ambiguous) ( apparently)

3 there was one peer reviewed paper - I remember it saying that transmen were more violent than women in general and that transwomen could not be distinguish from men

Linning · 23/03/2022 13:44

Didn’t read the full thread but as a lesbian no I don’t feel hijacked by the T at all and love the trans people are part of the community. I only feel sad on their behalf tbh that they still face so much discrimination at a scale I don’t feel I do anymore as a lesbian in a western country, I couldn’t imagine growing up trans personally so I am glad if a community I am a part of can provide them with support and relatable folks, especially as many trans people are queer so naturally fit irrelevant of gender identity.

VelvetChairGirl · 23/03/2022 13:40

@Whoistheexpert

Why was the T (and others) ever added to the LGB acronym?

The T (trans) is surely related to gender and not ones sexual orientation?

Am I missing something 😵‍💫

I thought it was because Stonewall won, they got what they wanted so as a lobby group rather then change themselves, they picked a new thing to lobby for and shoehorned that into their existing demographic to continue trying to justify their existence and the work they were doing.

this may get deleted for this but I strongly believe that if they achieve their aim of getting sex replaced in law by gender, the feelings in a man or womans head, they will start campaigning for pedophiles to be accepted, I think the point is to continue being a lobbyist and they honestly dont care about what they are lobbying for just so long as they can maintain relevance and funding as their core function as a lobby group.

purpleboy · 23/03/2022 13:39

I'm not a lesbian, but I do know a lot of them who feel they have been pushed out of their own space.
There is no tolerance from the TRAs as many of us know, many of the lesbians I have spoken to have received some form of abuse from the "community" because they don't want to date or engage in sexual relations with TW.
What I don't think anyone can deny is that there is a split within the community there are plenty of posters on this thread on both sides who give conflicting points of view, but what I find interesting is that those that fall on the GC side set up their own LGB group so they could advocate for themselves without the T, and the response to that has been shocking from the TRAs..... abuse, threats, violence etc....
Almost as if no one is allowed to have a different opinion from them, if certain LGB people feel LGBT+ groups no longer represent them, why should they be harassed for starting a new group that they feel represents them better?

Same with women.... women only groups, suddenly infiltrated by men or TW, women leave set up a new female only group, new group gets targeted for being non inclusive.

Same old fucking shit.

Ereshkigalangcleg · 23/03/2022 13:29

For people saying that transwomen offend at the same rate as men what studies are they relying on?

No one needs to rely on any studies to say that this group of males have not been shown to pose less risk to women than other males, nor is there a coherent definition of what constitutes a "transwoman".

We know that males commit most sexual crime and violent crime.

BuffyFanForever · 23/03/2022 13:26

The problem with these threads is that people always jump to the “anti trans” conclusion. Why isn’t it anti women to eradicate women’s spaces? Why isn’t is seen as homophobic to expect lesbian women to sleep with “male bodied people” - I genuinely don’t understand this. If people would like to sleep with/ have relationships with trans people that’s great for them, why should anyone expect people to have to be attracted to someone just because of something they say they feel they are? There are plenty of pan sexual people for whom the “bits and bobs” involved don’t matter so why is it only lesbians being told they should accept the T🤷‍♀️

BuffyFanForever · 23/03/2022 13:18

@Jumperlark

LGB people will claim to be more accepting of the T than they are, you're fucked if you don't and can lose your community. A lot of people are waiting for it to blow over.

I am a lesbian and have many lesbian friends, it's half and half who is actively GC, however the 'accepting' ones in reality neither date nor socialise with transwomen. They're in fact many times for likely to date transmen. Make of that what you will.

This is my experience also.
bellinisurge · 23/03/2022 12:48

Nope. Not sure that helps you. Do you believe in "acceptable rape statistics ". Do you know who Karen White is? Without gender woo he wouldn't have had access to women to rape them.

suggestionsplease1 · 23/03/2022 12:26

For people saying that transwomen offend at the same rate as men what studies are they relying on?

It's usually this one that's referred to, right?:

www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC3043071/

One of the lead authors has commented further on their findings:

Cecilia Djehne. In the interview, she notes that in
fact:
“The study as a whole covers the period between 1973 and 2003. If one divides the
cohort into two groups, 1973 to 1988 and 1989 to 2003, one observes that for the latter
group (1989 – 2003), differences in mortality, suicide attempts, and crime disappear.
This means that for the 1989 to 2003 group, we did not find a male pattern of criminality.
As to the criminality metric itself, we were measuring and comparing the total number of
convictions, not conviction type. We were not saying that cisgender males are convicted
of crimes associated with marginalization and poverty. We didn’t control for that and we
were certainly not saying that we found that trans women were a rape risk. What we
were saying was that for the 1973 to 1988 cohort group and the cisgender male group,
both experienced similar rates of convictions. As I said, this pattern is not observed in
the 1989 to 2003 cohort group.
The difference we observed between the 1989 to 2003 cohort and the control group is
that the trans cohort group accessed more mental health care, which is appropriate
given the level of ongoing discrimination the group faces. What the data tells us is that
things are getting measurably better and the issues we found affecting the 1973 to 1988
cohort group likely reflects a time when trans health and psychological care was less
effective and social stigma was far worse.”

Jumperlark · 23/03/2022 12:22

LGB people will claim to be more accepting of the T than they are, you're fucked if you don't and can lose your community. A lot of people are waiting for it to blow over.

I am a lesbian and have many lesbian friends, it's half and half who is actively GC, however the 'accepting' ones in reality neither date nor socialise with transwomen. They're in fact many times for likely to date transmen. Make of that what you will.

bellinisurge · 23/03/2022 12:08

And that's 80% with a GRC. No evidence that those without a GRC ever do

bellinisurge · 23/03/2022 12:07

Define "lots" when you say lots of them don't. 80% keep their cock and balls.

AhhhHereItGoes · 23/03/2022 12:05

Sigh. 1. Lots of them don't 2. Why must we reduce everyone to their genitals all the time

Because that's what defines whether you're a man or woman to the outside world.

TheXX and XY chromosome will tell you in your DNA but without that your genitalia shows what sex you were born.

I'm happy for a fully transitioned, non penis having transwoman to come into the ladies - she's at least made an effort towards her goal to be more woman like.

But if you really hate being a man why would you keep the offending part?

I find it hard to take someone seriously saying they want to be a woman and yet don't do any physical body changes. Why not just dress how you like and use the toilets assigned to your sex?

Why not focus so much on 'I was born in the wrong body as I don't look female but wish to act female' and instead focus on being an individual who likes painting their nails, weightlifting etc.

I've been sexually assaulted by females and males but oh boy is the majority of predators male.

Do you think that changes simply by wearing a dress?

Even if non intentional what if a woman who has been sexually traumatised sees a trans woman's penis and it triggers her. Should she not feel that the ladies is a space she can escape men and mens bodies?

Most transpeople I know wouldn't do have the crap done in the media do anyway. Many use the disabled loos, dress like a non dragged up version of their preferred gender (ex: transwoman friend will either wear a skirt and a normal top or joggers and a t shirt).

Swipe left for the next trending thread