I mean as far as I'm concerned people can knock themselves out pigeonholing themselves into ever increasingly-policed identities - to my mind the people who are attracted to that are not the sort of group that many others would want to belong to, so it's really no loss to people they want to exclude.
You've avoided teh question again. How is gender identity the same thing, with identical interests, as sexuality.
No one minded, in the days of GBL or even GL, if lesbians had a group just for lesbians, a woman only festval, a group for gay male AIDS patients. Those are interest groups, not "smaller and smaller" subgroups.
You know what you get when you don't have any "sub-groups"? You just have everyone. SW then would represent everyone, including the straightest manly man you could find.
Unfortunately of course these exclusionary groups do tend to operate with animosity in mind of the people they are trying to exclude; they perceive them as an outgroup and devalue them accordingly - just have a ready about ingroup / outgroup psychology
That's BS. If it were true, and group for transpersons, Stonewall, groups for the disabled, ant-racism groups, the WI, would all be about othering and exclusion. All you are arguing for here is that no group should have any criteria for membership at all.
Are you really prepared to say that a group for people of black African descent to lobby about political issues should include white people? Well then how is a group that exists to lobby on issues around sexuality "othering" and exclusionary if it doesn't include gender identity?
And I will just point out that a transman could joing a lesbian group, generally speaking, if said transman is attracted to women. By virtue of being a lesbian. If that was felt to be undesirable by said person, that's ok too.