Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

LGB vs LGBTQI etc

518 replies

Whoistheexpert · 22/03/2022 20:04

Why was the T (and others) ever added to the LGB acronym?

The T (trans) is surely related to gender and not ones sexual orientation?

Am I missing something 😵‍💫

OP posts:
Thread gallery
9
Cheetocat · 22/03/2022 22:11

@Poomba

I’m not here to get involved in the trans discussion, I just have a question about words.

@bellinisurge can you please explain to me the peadophile background to cis?

I always thought cis was a Latin word meaning ‘same side of’ as opposed to trans. Like in chemistry you get cis isomers and trans isomers. Is this not where it come from???

Yes, it's just the opposite of trans.
Annette32123 · 22/03/2022 22:10

@LizDoingTheCanCan

For those of us who were around for Section 28, trans was nothing to do with us.

Who are 'us'? What right do you have to speak for others?

The LGB voice doesn’t belong to one person.

The ‘us’ is those in the gay community who agree with @LizDoingTheCanCan

You no doubt will find others who agree with your views.

Such is life. Both are valid positions. Both can speak for their own ‘us’.

Many trans people don’t agree with your views. What right do you have to speak for them?

suggestionsplease1 · 22/03/2022 22:06

@MangyInseam

Current gender ideology says being trans is not about dysphoria, you don't need it to be trans, just thought it was worth a mention.

Anyway - I think a lot of the posts are circling around the real question in the OP which is - why would T - gender - be part of the same lobby group as LGB, given that they represent totally different things?

And that makes perfect sense even if you totally accept the whole idea of gender identity. If it's not about same sex attraction, why would it get added into a group that lobbies about people with same sex attraction? Why would they have the same interests?

You could ask the same about the I for intersex and in fact groups representing people with DSDs have made it very clear they do not want to be part of the acronym.

We have different groups to represent people with something in common that means they might need to lobby as a block. SOmetimes you can group people a little - the disabled might include people with poor mobility, the blind, etc. But if they had some kind of disagreement about a way forward it would seem clear that such organizations would take a step back and they would have to speak through organizations that represented them separately.

Other than the fact that some trans people might also be attracted to people of the same sex, and are also LGB, just like a blind person might be LGB, why would they have a lobby organization in common?

Pasting this again:

The feminism boards here are generally pretty transphobic but even they note there can be crossover and a complex picture when they refer to detransitioning natal females who later feel that lesbian ID fits better for them than transman.

Kicking those people out of the community during the time they originally identified as trans would be deeply harmful for them.

Poomba · 22/03/2022 22:06

I’m not here to get involved in the trans discussion, I just have a question about words.

@bellinisurge can you please explain to me the peadophile background to cis?

I always thought cis was a Latin word meaning ‘same side of’ as opposed to trans. Like in chemistry you get cis isomers and trans isomers. Is this not where it come from???

PenStation · 22/03/2022 22:06

@bellinisurge

The sight of young lesbians butchering their bodies in service to this craze rather than being proud lesbians makes me weep
I agree. The sense of PRIDE in who we are, is something I would love to see return. A deep sense of worth that is not dependent on hormones or surgery.
Cheetocat · 22/03/2022 22:05

@Clymene

Do you feel #blessed for being white too *@Cheetocat* ?

What else do you feel privileged and guilty about? Being born relatively wealthy? Being educated? Having enough food to eat and a roof over your head?

How are you atoning for all those?

I'm not one but guilty but I'm empathetic and understanding of my privilege, I can go out in the world and be seen as a woman without being judged for it or feeling unsafe. I haven't had privilege in many other areas which is probably part of the reason I can put myself in other peoples shoes. I don't need to atone, I'm not hurting anyone.
suggestionsplease1 · 22/03/2022 22:03

@bellinisurge

The sight of young lesbians butchering their bodies in service to this craze rather than being proud lesbians makes me weep
But yet you'd like to alienate them by fostering divisions between LGB & T ?

That's not a good way forward.

MangyInseam · 22/03/2022 22:01

Current gender ideology says being trans is not about dysphoria, you don't need it to be trans, just thought it was worth a mention.

Anyway - I think a lot of the posts are circling around the real question in the OP which is - why would T - gender - be part of the same lobby group as LGB, given that they represent totally different things?

And that makes perfect sense even if you totally accept the whole idea of gender identity. If it's not about same sex attraction, why would it get added into a group that lobbies about people with same sex attraction? Why would they have the same interests?

You could ask the same about the I for intersex and in fact groups representing people with DSDs have made it very clear they do not want to be part of the acronym.

We have different groups to represent people with something in common that means they might need to lobby as a block. SOmetimes you can group people a little - the disabled might include people with poor mobility, the blind, etc. But if they had some kind of disagreement about a way forward it would seem clear that such organizations would take a step back and they would have to speak through organizations that represented them separately.

Other than the fact that some trans people might also be attracted to people of the same sex, and are also LGB, just like a blind person might be LGB, why would they have a lobby organization in common?

bellinisurge · 22/03/2022 22:01

"Once they stop taking them they can have a perfectly natural and normal puberty. " - you know that's NOT what happens, right?

bellinisurge · 22/03/2022 22:00

The sight of young lesbians butchering their bodies in service to this craze rather than being proud lesbians makes me weep

Cheetocat · 22/03/2022 21:59

@gigglewater

Gender STEREOTYPE non conforming kids are given puberty blockers. some go on to have sex realignment surgery. These treatments makes those children sterile adults. This is eugenics, re marketed.
Tonnes of children take puberty blockers for many reasons, trans children are probably the smallest group who take them. Once they stop taking them they can have a perfectly natural and normal puberty. It's not scary at all. You have to be an adult to consent to surgery so if it was just a phase or whatever they'd be long done with the blockers before it got to that.
PenStation · 22/03/2022 21:58

Things have changed a lot. I am glad I’m not dating these days. I feel nostalgic for the lesbian bars and clubs of old!

PenStation · 22/03/2022 21:56

The T was added in the 90s if my recollection is accurate. There were quite a lot of effeminate gay men who wore womens clothes in my social circle. There were some beautiful butch lesbians who were proud to be lesbians, trans men were not really a thing. There were no openly straight people with different gender identities.

Clymene · 22/03/2022 21:55

Do you feel #blessed for being white too @Cheetocat ?

What else do you feel privileged and guilty about? Being born relatively wealthy? Being educated? Having enough food to eat and a roof over your head?

How are you atoning for all those?

bellinisurge · 22/03/2022 21:55

Also, given that the OP used the letters "Queer" is a vile insult. Intersex is an outdated term for a medical condition

bellinisurge · 22/03/2022 21:53

"No it's not, it's the opposite in fact, I'm confident in my identity". So confident that you think you are only a subset of woman.
I am very sorry for the suffering someone experiences with gender dysphoria. They deserve help and support and services to deal with it. It is not fair to make me give up single sex spaces or women only shortlists or a place in women's sport just to make them feel better.

Theluggage15 · 22/03/2022 21:48

There’s no such thing as cis! Thinking your born in the ‘wrong body’ is a mental illness. It has no effect on biological fact.

gigglewater · 22/03/2022 21:48

Book burning, no platforming, eugenics and people shouting at each other over their belief in souls floating about, souls which can land in the wrong bodies. In 2022. Progressive?

bellinisurge · 22/03/2022 21:48

There are a few trans voices who are brave enough to say they are still men (or women) - the sex they were OBSERVED as having at birth. But they are few and far between. It is the colonisers that are the loudest voices.

Eyesofdisarray · 22/03/2022 21:47

And 'assigned at birth'
FFS leave it out

AllThingsServeTheBeam · 22/03/2022 21:46

@Cheetocat you weren't assigned a gender at birth. That's total rot. You are a woman who is not a transwoman. So, a woman.

Cheetocat · 22/03/2022 21:46

@bellinisurge

Calling yourself "cis" is some serious handmaiden bullshit.
No it's not, it's the opposite in fact, I'm confident in my identity and I'm not threatened by other women trying to get on with their lives whether they're cisgender or transgender. I said previously that it's a privilege to be cis, nobody would choose to suffer from dysphoria.
BigHeartyTruffle · 22/03/2022 21:45

@Ijustreallywantacat this is exactly my experience too.

Furthermore all of the trans people I’ve spoken to are deeply uncomfortable with the term cotton ceiling, and the idea that people think they believe they are entitled to sex from anyone. This is reflected in my own and my community’s experience of trans people.

gigglewater · 22/03/2022 21:45

Gender STEREOTYPE non conforming kids are given puberty blockers. some go on to have sex realignment surgery. These treatments makes those children sterile adults. This is eugenics, re marketed.

bellinisurge · 22/03/2022 21:45

@Cheetocat . It is a dirty word. It offends me. A child rapist made it up.