Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

LGB vs LGBTQI etc

518 replies

Whoistheexpert · 22/03/2022 20:04

Why was the T (and others) ever added to the LGB acronym?

The T (trans) is surely related to gender and not ones sexual orientation?

Am I missing something 😵‍💫

OP posts:
Thread gallery
9
housemaus · 22/03/2022 23:06

As a bi woman with a lot of lesbian friends - no, nobody I know feels sidelined. My friendship group and wider social circle is very supportive of trans people remaining included under the LGBT+ umbrella, including my oldest friend (who is a lesbian) working with young trans people in a local community support organisation (not 100% identifying info but if she's seeing this she'll know it's her and I know she has a stalk through MN occasionally... hello Grin).

Annette32123 · 22/03/2022 23:05

@Cheetocat

Why have you felt unsafe around men?

Do you think they are all attracted to you?

Do you think male violence towards women is about attraction rather than power?

How can I tell the difference between a man and a transwoman?

If you felt unsafe around men and I feel unsafe around men and I can discern no difference between men and transwomen, why is it unacceptable for me to feel unsafe around transwomen?

If the man you were scared of had told you he was a transwoman would your fear have disappeared?

If it did, would that have increased or decreased the likelihood of you being raped or murdered?

Lesbians won’t rape me even if they find me attractive and lesbians won’t rape me to exert their dominance over me. All men, including transwomen, are a potential threat to me on a way that no woman or transman is, lesbian or not.

littlbrowndog · 22/03/2022 22:56

When young girls and women arc having double mastectomies it must make all of us think what is going on

Girls as young as 13.

Why are girls doing this

It’s deeply troubling

10 or even 5 years ago this wasn’t happening

Why now

Girls and women mutilating their bodies in the hope of what ?

Ereshkigalangcleg · 22/03/2022 22:55

Yeah it is fairly recent, it kind of started when men began posting stuff on twitter like 'I'm a woman and if you don't think so you can suck my dick'....funny that isn't it?

YY. I'm not sure if this poster is being deliberately obtuse or is genuinely so.

jeaux90 · 22/03/2022 22:53

God I'm bored of this.

Men can't be women whatever special identities they may have.

T is an umbrella term which includes cross dressers. Let that sink in. Men who fetishise women.

I think some of you think it's about men with dysphoria who need to change their bodies. It isn't. Most of them keep their penis, and even if you are talking about a gay male who decides to transition surgically why does he need to be in womens spaces?

This is not about a community. It's turned into a cult.

It's not about inclusion.

It's turned into intrusion.

I will not stand by and watch lesbians bullied and coerced, our biological reality role played abs larped or our non conforming kids become life long medical patients.

The T has become a big male Tantrum, a mens rights movement, authoritarian and I'm saying no.

Ereshkigalangcleg · 22/03/2022 22:53

They still can't and I don't get why the existence of single gender spaces is such a big deal in the first place, are you worried trans women are going to take your partners?

Hilarious. No I promise you that is not something I worry about.

VivienneDelacroix · 22/03/2022 22:52

Also an lgbtq+ person here who is happy to have the T included, as are all my gay/lesvbian/bi friends. We understand what it is to be othered, to be attacked simply because of who we are, to be told we are a danger to children, to be called perverted, to be made to feel ashamed, to be closeted...we stand with our trans brothers and sisters.

Whatsnewpussyhat · 22/03/2022 22:52

I can go out in the world and be seen as a woman without being judged for it or feeling unsafe

Good for you. I've been judged for being a woman many times and have felt 'unsafe' because of men more times that I can remember.

Transwomen are the safest demographic in the UK. The least likely to be attacked or murdered yet we are constantly told they are the most 'unsafe' and 'vulnerable'. Utter bullshit.

Those that have severe dysphoria should get help for their mental health, but dysphoria doesn't mean you are the wrong sex. We don't 'affirm' people with anorexia by telling them they are fat and sending them off to get a gastric band.

Puberty blockers are a harmless pause button eh? More bullshit.

90%+ of all children with dysphoria grow out of it. (Proving that it isn't anything innate) Yet almost 100% of kids who start on blockers go on to cross sex hormones.

Hasselhoffsheadband · 22/03/2022 22:47

In that case, how do you know you wont realise you were wrong about this topic in a few years if things you're passionate about can suddenly change? You know this trend of women gathering together and acting victimised by all trans people is fairly recent?

Yeah it is fairly recent, it kind of started when men began posting stuff on twitter like 'I'm a woman and if you don't think so you can suck my dick'....funny that isn't it?

bellinisurge · 22/03/2022 22:47

"What's the worry then? That all transwomen are going to be attracted to you? I don't get it."
You trotted out this "are you scared you're going to lose your partner to a trans person ". Like all the shit photos on social media of transwomen saying "GC women hate me because im so pretty ".

Theluggage15 · 22/03/2022 22:46

You’re very subservient to men and their feelings cheet. You need to work on that inferiority complex.

TheKeatingFive · 22/03/2022 22:46

I have never actually been somewhere and thought "phew, there's only women here", it doesn't cross my mind

Sure. It doesn't affect you. I get that.

But what about women who've been taped or abused by men and may be triggered by a male body? Shouldn't they have the right (for example) to have counselling/therapy in a female only environment?

Hasselhoffsheadband · 22/03/2022 22:45

My son started using the gents age 8/9 - he wanted to.

bellinisurge · 22/03/2022 22:45

Anyone would think @Cheetocat that you realise that women and children shouldn't be near adult men they don't know when vulnerable

Cheetocat · 22/03/2022 22:44

@bellinisurge

"They still can't and I don't get why the existence of single gender spaces is such a big deal in the first place, are you worried trans women are going to take your partners? Have you been personally victimised by a trans person? I most certainly haven't. Plenty of cis men have made me feel unsafe though."

If my partner wants to sleep with a transwoman or trans man they are free to do so. As long as they end their relationship with me. Similarly another man or woman.
This "are you worried we're prettier than you" is just more tedious mean girls bullshit that I have no interest in.

What's the worry then? That all transwomen are going to be attracted to you? I don't get it.
Hasselhoffsheadband · 22/03/2022 22:44

I'll pee in a cubicle next to the hulk if it means people can identify as their preferred gender.

That's nice dear, but what about the women who don't feel the same as you? Or do they not matter 'as long as people (men) can identify as their preferred gender?

Theluggage15 · 22/03/2022 22:44

Single sex spaces not gender. You seem quite confused. And why would it be so terrible for little boys to go in the gents? Are you saying men can be dangerous.

titchy · 22/03/2022 22:43

Puberty can begin at age 9 in boys though, would you prefer them to go in the gents alone?

Bloody hell kids should be going to the appropriate loo for their sex well before the age of 9!!! Most us have plenty of experience of hovering outside the gents waiting for a six or seven year old ds shouting 'make sure you wash your hands'!

bellinisurge · 22/03/2022 22:43

As for 9 year old boys going through puberty in women's spaces. I'm not going to do a hormone check nor am I going to go a genital check. Nor is anyone else. It is for the responsible female adult they are with to judge whether it's still appropriate for them to be there.

RoseslnTheHospital · 22/03/2022 22:42

@Cheetocat I have a 9 year old DS, he goes to the mens on his own. I think that's a very normal behaviour for boys his age.

I find your comment about having "cis" privilege to be able to go about your life as a woman without being judged for it or feeling unsafe to be very naive. Do you think that women generally are able to go about their lives without being judged or feeling unsafe?? Just look at the numbers of women and girls who report being sexually harassed, at school, in the workplace, whilst out and about. That's before we get into the issue of levels of male violence against women. Or the girls that are killed in utero or at birth for being female, or sent to unsanitary and unsafe huts every month due to menstruating. Or subject to FGM. So many things. All such a "privilege".

bellinisurge · 22/03/2022 22:40

"They still can't and I don't get why the existence of single gender spaces is such a big deal in the first place, are you worried trans women are going to take your partners? Have you been personally victimised by a trans person? I most certainly haven't. Plenty of cis men have made me feel unsafe though."

If my partner wants to sleep with a transwoman or trans man they are free to do so. As long as they end their relationship with me. Similarly another man or woman.
This "are you worried we're prettier than you" is just more tedious mean girls bullshit that I have no interest in.

Cheetocat · 22/03/2022 22:40

@bellinisurge

"would you prefer them to go in the gents alone?" Why? What's wrong with the gents?
I don't like the thought of kids going into any closed off public space alone, that's all.
Cheetocat · 22/03/2022 22:37

@bellinisurge

"You know this trend of women gathering together and acting victimised by all trans people is fairly recent?" Because until recently, men couldn't insinuate themselves easily into women's spaces and call any woman who objected a bigot
They still can't and I don't get why the existence of single gender spaces is such a big deal in the first place, are you worried trans women are going to take your partners? Have you been personally victimised by a trans person? I most certainly haven't. Plenty of cis men have made me feel unsafe though.
suggestionsplease1 · 22/03/2022 22:36

@MangyInseam

Kicking those people out of the community during the time they originally identified as trans would be deeply harmful for them.

I'm not sure why you think this is relevant, no one is talking about this. Anytime a person changes their thoughts about who they are, it can mean a period where they do not fit totally in any clear place. This can happen with sexuality as well. That's ok, and in general people aren't looking to disown such people immediately, or they shouldn't be, though of course it can happen. In time it usually becomes clearer.

But that is not in any way related to what I asked, which is why you would include sexuality and gender identity within the same grouping, any more than you would consider being a woman and a black person as they same thing? They are different, why group them together? Why would they lobby together politically as a block?

This is entirely relevant.

It shows the one person can straddle 2 identities (or more) at different points in their lives.

According to the segregationist philosophy being touted here those people, at their most vulnerable points, should be made to feel unwelcome in their community.

You appear to want to 'ungroup' them at the time they are probably struggling the most.

You appear to want to pit them against their former or future identities.

If a person who previously identified as a transman now identifies as a lesbian do you think they suddenly care any less for other transmen and their rights? Or can only conceive that because they feel that a lesbian ID now fits them better that every transman out there is misguided?

Human groupings and their fights towards rights are not about reductive concepts but the varied and complex people that form them.

bellinisurge · 22/03/2022 22:36

"would you prefer them to go in the gents alone?"
Why? What's wrong with the gents?

Swipe left for the next trending thread