Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

LGB vs LGBTQI etc

518 replies

Whoistheexpert · 22/03/2022 20:04

Why was the T (and others) ever added to the LGB acronym?

The T (trans) is surely related to gender and not ones sexual orientation?

Am I missing something 😵‍💫

OP posts:
Thread gallery
9
Ijustreallywantacat · 23/03/2022 07:40

And yes, you are right, up until recently, women were generally 'ok' with a tiny number of genuinely dysphoric transsexuals, most of whom had had full SRS, using their facilities.

Untrue. Some feminist groups have historically opposed trans rights since at least the seventies. For example, Sandy Stone was a transwoman working at a lesbian record company. She and the natal women who defended her were threatened with guns and sent death threats. Pretending that transsexual women have always led a coy and quiet life, free from harassment, is niave and damaging.

But I have felt threatened by and uncomfortable around transwomen. Is my experience less valid than yours?

No. Of course your experience is valid. But why does your experience in particular mean that people should be excluded? Why not lesbians from women's spaces? The women who assaulted me felt threatened and uncomfortable around me. I had asked one of them out was the crime. Who KNOWS what I could have done next. Lesbians have definitely assaulted people before. There are lesbians in prison right now because they have been predatory. What I take from all of these valid and real experiences is that;
a.you should not harass people in spaces where people may feel vulnerable.
b. Feeling uncomfortable around a person does not automatically mean that that group should be excluded from the space.
c. Any predatory behaviour should be dealt with promptly and seriously.

bellinisurge · 23/03/2022 07:29

I totally changed my position on this when I discovered that the overwhelming majority of transwomen, even those with a GRC, keep their penis.

As for the outrageous suggestion below that violent women are as prevalent as violent men - seriously have a word with yourself

Annette32123 · 23/03/2022 07:27

@Ijustreallywantacat

"No, never". Never been in a situation with someone with a penis (known or unknown) and worried about your safety? Not sure I believe that.

In the context of the discussion I thought you meant transwomen. Whom I have never felt threatened by or uncomfortable around. Not when using the bathroom, not when changing in a locker room, not when sharing a twin room in a hotel.

Have I felt threatened by men with penises? Yes. We've all been there. I've also felt threatened by straight women with vaginas (I assume) when getting changed, as I stated above.

But I have felt threatened by and uncomfortable around transwomen. Is my experience less valid than yours?
Theeyeballsinthefuckingsky · 23/03/2022 07:25

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk guidelines.

Clymene · 23/03/2022 07:24

@Ijustreallywantacat

"No, never". Never been in a situation with someone with a penis (known or unknown) and worried about your safety? Not sure I believe that.

In the context of the discussion I thought you meant transwomen. Whom I have never felt threatened by or uncomfortable around. Not when using the bathroom, not when changing in a locker room, not when sharing a twin room in a hotel.

Have I felt threatened by men with penises? Yes. We've all been there. I've also felt threatened by straight women with vaginas (I assume) when getting changed, as I stated above.

How can you tell the difference between a transwoman and any other person with a penis? Confused
Annette32123 · 23/03/2022 07:24

@Ijustreallywantacat

But I bet you have a moment of 'uh oh, what's the situation here?'' if there is a man there.

No, never. Pretty off that you think we talk about lipstick all day. Hiking, tattoos, weightlifting, sex, dinner, periods, tits, work, boxing, the women's FA cup... all topics of convo recently. Not lipstick so far but I'll keep you posted.

And I'm sure they do, but harassment and assault have always been unacceptable and will be shut down. We judge behaviour as we see it, and so far we haven't had a problem.

It all just reminds me of being assaulted and harassed at school for being gay and getting changed for PE. They'd complain to the teacher that I was staring at them, and I made them feel uncomfortable, before putting my uniform in the toilet or beating me up after school. I was eventually made to change in the toilets. Glad they no longer had to deal with me as a threat...

Your school handled it badly. The difference is, you were no threat to girls or women.

Males are a threat to girls and women.

There is nothing that distinguishes a transwoman from a man, to a woman.

Ijustreallywantacat · 23/03/2022 07:21

"No, never". Never been in a situation with someone with a penis (known or unknown) and worried about your safety? Not sure I believe that.

In the context of the discussion I thought you meant transwomen. Whom I have never felt threatened by or uncomfortable around. Not when using the bathroom, not when changing in a locker room, not when sharing a twin room in a hotel.

Have I felt threatened by men with penises? Yes. We've all been there. I've also felt threatened by straight women with vaginas (I assume) when getting changed, as I stated above.

Annette32123 · 23/03/2022 07:20

@Ijustreallywantacat

Fine for you to not mind sharing a bathroom with males but it is not your place to suggest that all other women should be fine with this, too.

People have been sharing bathrooms with transwomen at least since forever. Part of the transition requirements even for old fashioned transsexual people was to live as the opposite sex for 2 years. That INCLUDES using the bathroom. Transwomen have always used womens bathrooms, as they should, and they always will. It has been bought up as an issue more recently because of the frothing about TW but it has always been the case. And as I said, you would not always know.

Part of the requirement was also extensive therapy to establish their mental state and address issues like women feeling threatened by their presence.

So not the same as now at all.

bellinisurge · 23/03/2022 07:08

"No, never". Never been in a situation with someone with a penis (known or unknown) and worried about your safety? Not sure I believe that.

Hasselhoffsheadband · 23/03/2022 07:05

@Ijustreallywantacat

Fine for you to not mind sharing a bathroom with males but it is not your place to suggest that all other women should be fine with this, too.

People have been sharing bathrooms with transwomen at least since forever. Part of the transition requirements even for old fashioned transsexual people was to live as the opposite sex for 2 years. That INCLUDES using the bathroom. Transwomen have always used womens bathrooms, as they should, and they always will. It has been bought up as an issue more recently because of the frothing about TW but it has always been the case. And as I said, you would not always know.

But what do you mean by 'transwomen' here? Because it now means 'any man who declares that he is a woman'. Do you believe there should be any gatekeeping to what constitutes a transwoman, or should it just be a free for all?

And yes, you are right, up until recently, women were generally 'ok' with a tiny number of genuinely dysphoric transsexuals, most of whom had had full SRS, using their facilities. But that was a courtesy, a privilege, because they are women's spaces. Those days are gone now, and I actually feel quite sorry for those people whose lives under the radar have been hijacked by a load of blokes who want to encroach on everything that women have. Now women are saying #nothankyou.

Whoistheexpert · 23/03/2022 06:59

@TheGrinchsDog

Oh sorry, my mistake!

'Hijacked' wasn't in the OP, it must have been one of the comments further down the page and it stuck because I feel it was hijacked.

Sorry @Ijustreallywantacat

OP here - I did use that term in my follow up post, so you remembered correctly ☺️
OP posts:
Ijustreallywantacat · 23/03/2022 06:57

But I bet you have a moment of 'uh oh, what's the situation here?'' if there is a man there.

No, never. Pretty off that you think we talk about lipstick all day. Hiking, tattoos, weightlifting, sex, dinner, periods, tits, work, boxing, the women's FA cup... all topics of convo recently. Not lipstick so far but I'll keep you posted.

And I'm sure they do, but harassment and assault have always been unacceptable and will be shut down. We judge behaviour as we see it, and so far we haven't had a problem.

It all just reminds me of being assaulted and harassed at school for being gay and getting changed for PE. They'd complain to the teacher that I was staring at them, and I made them feel uncomfortable, before putting my uniform in the toilet or beating me up after school. I was eventually made to change in the toilets. Glad they no longer had to deal with me as a threat...

Annette32123 · 23/03/2022 06:56

@Ijustreallywantacat

They are problematic in lesbian spaces and have been for a very long time. But they used to be small in number.

Never been a problem in my lesbian spaces. The women who try to tell lesbians how they should behave have been, but not transwomen. We've never had a problem talking about vaginas or periods or any of the stuff that's supposed to be a problem either.

Different people, different experiences. Many lesbians don’t want to be hit on by males in lesbian bars.
EishetChayil · 23/03/2022 06:52

I feel a mixture of sadness and anger that so many of my fellow lesbian and bisexual woman can't see the harm in the Stonewall-led shift from same-sex attraction to same-gender. I'm sorry, but you've been well and truly hoodwinked by what is essentially a men's rights movement. Wake the fuck up.

bellinisurge · 23/03/2022 06:46

Haven't not having

MagpiePi · 23/03/2022 06:46

I have never actually been somewhere and thought "phew, there's only women here", it doesn't cross my mind

But I bet you have a moment of 'uh oh, what's the situation here?'' if there is a man there.

(I didn't realise I did this until recently, it is such an automatic response)

Obviously, if it is a transwoman then your Handmaid brain will shut down that automatic reaction and you will obviously be perfectly safe and have a nice chat about lipstick. Because no man would pretend to be a transwoman just to be able to take advantage of a woman, would they?

bellinisurge · 23/03/2022 06:46

Pretty sure transsexual MtF having been taking photos of themselves wanking in wonen's toilets for ever. Nor have they been in women's sports. Or winning "woman of the year" awards.
So, no, they haven't been doing this forever.

Clymene · 23/03/2022 06:45

@Ijustreallywantacat

They are problematic in lesbian spaces and have been for a very long time. But they used to be small in number.

Never been a problem in my lesbian spaces. The women who try to tell lesbians how they should behave have been, but not transwomen. We've never had a problem talking about vaginas or periods or any of the stuff that's supposed to be a problem either.

You're not a lesbian if you have sex with transwomen. The word lesbian means exclusively same sex attracted. So you and your mates can include them in your dating pool if you choose but please don't call yourself lesbians.
Ijustreallywantacat · 23/03/2022 06:43

It's alright Grinchy, I feel bad for being so defensive! Sorry!

Ijustreallywantacat · 23/03/2022 06:43

They are problematic in lesbian spaces and have been for a very long time. But they used to be small in number.

Never been a problem in my lesbian spaces. The women who try to tell lesbians how they should behave have been, but not transwomen. We've never had a problem talking about vaginas or periods or any of the stuff that's supposed to be a problem either.

TheGrinchsDog · 23/03/2022 06:40

Oh sorry, my mistake!

'Hijacked' wasn't in the OP, it must have been one of the comments further down the page and it stuck because I feel it was hijacked.

Sorry @Ijustreallywantacat

TheGrinchsDog · 23/03/2022 06:37

@Ijustreallywantacat

Hijacked by what, *@TheGrinchsDog*? Explain what you mean.
I was answering the OP, I assumed that was clear even though the thread has moved on.

Yes I feel the LGB has been hijacked.

Other, far more articulate posters have already explained why I feel that way so I don't think I need to 'explain' anything, that came across pretty rudely btw.

Annette32123 · 23/03/2022 06:32

@HoveringDonkeyofKnock

T has only been part of the LGB community if the trans person was gay.

A lot of the gay clubs and bars going back to the 90s and earlier had a sprinking of both drag queens and straight male cross dressers, some of whom went on to become transsexuals. Very often it was those places that they would first come out and make new friends and allies.

And back when lesbian bars existed a small number of straight males would turn up - usually wearing pink - claiming to be lesbians and trying to guilt women into dating them or going on girly shopping trips with them. They didn’t behave like lesbians. They didn’t behave like women. Many lesbians would immediately leave the venue when they arrived because they were clearly males invading women’s spaces.
Annette32123 · 23/03/2022 06:27

@Superhanz
The punching gave him away. Transwomen generally don’t chop their cocks off, particularly the ones who want to fuck lesbians.

@Beancounter1
They are problematic in lesbian spaces and have been for a very long time. But they used to be small in number.

Ijustreallywantacat · 23/03/2022 06:25

Hijacked by what, @TheGrinchsDog? Explain what you mean.

Swipe left for the next trending thread