Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

LGB vs LGBTQI etc

518 replies

Whoistheexpert · 22/03/2022 20:04

Why was the T (and others) ever added to the LGB acronym?

The T (trans) is surely related to gender and not ones sexual orientation?

Am I missing something 😵‍💫

OP posts:
Thread gallery
9
bellinisurge · 23/03/2022 08:05

The self-hate is so sad

Clymene · 23/03/2022 08:03

'Statistics don't do anything for me' is possibly one of the most idiotic things anyone has said since Layla Moran talked about being able to see people's souls.

bellinisurge · 23/03/2022 08:01

It really is, isn't it

Hasselhoffsheadband · 23/03/2022 08:01

Statistics don't really do anything for me. You can find a reason to exclude and be afraid of almost any group of people using clever statistics.

You don't need 'clever statistics' - 98% is not 'clever statistics'!

At what objective point of transition do transwomen come out of the high category of 'male'?

Annette32123 · 23/03/2022 08:01

@bellinisurge

"Most sexual assault carried out by women to other women is done by lesbians." Most sexual assault on women is carried out by men. Is there an outside possibility that a woman will assault me? Yes. But that is utterly unusual. And for you to suggest that lesbians uniquely follow male patterns of offending is disgusting.
It’s internalised homophobia.

Which is sad.

Ereshkigalangcleg · 23/03/2022 08:01

My point is that if TW are excluded from spaces then I ought to be too.

Its not a good point, it's a poor gotcha. There is literally no basis for this, because spaces for women are spaces for women. Lesbians, straights, bi women. Not male people. They are there for all women's privacy, dignity and safety. You think your friends' feelings are more important and dismiss accurate statistics on male violence. That's up to you. I don't.

Annette32123 · 23/03/2022 08:00

@Ijustreallywantacat

Talking about the tiny number of violent women is pure whataboutery. Odd behaviour for a lesbian.

My point is that if TW are excluded from spaces then I ought to be too. Is this about statistical threats? Most sexual assault carried out by women to other women is done by lesbians. Out they go.
Is it about feeling uncomfortable? Because plenty of women felt uncomfortable around me.

Statistics don't really do anything for me. You can find a reason to exclude and be afraid of almost any group of people using clever statistics. 99% of transwomen do not want to do anything but get on with their lives and do not wish to harrass or assault women. These people are not statistics, they are my friends and I will defend them.

Lesbians are not statistically as violent as men. That is twaddle.
bellinisurge · 23/03/2022 08:00

"Most sexual assault carried out by women to other women is done by lesbians." Most sexual assault on women is carried out by men.
Is there an outside possibility that a woman will assault me? Yes. But that is utterly unusual. And for you to suggest that lesbians uniquely follow male patterns of offending is disgusting.

Annette32123 · 23/03/2022 07:59

@Ijustreallywantacat

Your school handled it badly. The difference is, you were no threat to girls or women.

How did the school know that? Lesbians are, purely statistically, a bigger threat to straight women than other straight women.
They genuinely and sincerely believed I was a threat to them. Their first action wasn't assault, it was complaining that I had asked one of them out despite not knowing if she liked girls (true!) and that I was staring at them getting changed. (Not true, though difficult to permanently affixed to the wall.)

TW want to changed, or go pee.

A threat in what sense?

Teenage girls can be a nasty bunch. If it wasn’t you, they would have been saying the same about a female PE teacher. Every school has this nonsense and every school should handle it better than yours did.

That isn’t a reason to let men into women’s spaces.

Ereshkigalangcleg · 23/03/2022 07:57

It’s why lesbians are not an issue - because they are women - and we don’t let gay men in - because they are men.

Transwomen are just as likely to be violent as any other men.

Lesbians are just as likely not to be violent as any other women.

That’s it.

Exactly.

bellinisurge · 23/03/2022 07:57

Transwomen just going about their business in public spaces? Fine, no problem. You do you, hun and all that. When I'm in a vulnerable situation like a loo or a hospital ward? When I'm doing competitive sport? When I'm struggling to overturn male dominance in my chosen field of work? No. Keep out of my spaces.

Ijustreallywantacat · 23/03/2022 07:57

Talking about the tiny number of violent women is pure whataboutery. Odd behaviour for a lesbian.

My point is that if TW are excluded from spaces then I ought to be too. Is this about statistical threats? Most sexual assault carried out by women to other women is done by lesbians. Out they go.
Is it about feeling uncomfortable? Because plenty of women felt uncomfortable around me.

Statistics don't really do anything for me. You can find a reason to exclude and be afraid of almost any group of people using clever statistics. 99% of transwomen do not want to do anything but get on with their lives and do not wish to harrass or assault women. These people are not statistics, they are my friends and I will defend them.

Annette32123 · 23/03/2022 07:55

@Ijustreallywantacat

And yes, you are right, up until recently, women were generally 'ok' with a tiny number of genuinely dysphoric transsexuals, most of whom had had full SRS, using their facilities.

Untrue. Some feminist groups have historically opposed trans rights since at least the seventies. For example, Sandy Stone was a transwoman working at a lesbian record company. She and the natal women who defended her were threatened with guns and sent death threats. Pretending that transsexual women have always led a coy and quiet life, free from harassment, is niave and damaging.

But I have felt threatened by and uncomfortable around transwomen. Is my experience less valid than yours?

No. Of course your experience is valid. But why does your experience in particular mean that people should be excluded? Why not lesbians from women's spaces? The women who assaulted me felt threatened and uncomfortable around me. I had asked one of them out was the crime. Who KNOWS what I could have done next. Lesbians have definitely assaulted people before. There are lesbians in prison right now because they have been predatory. What I take from all of these valid and real experiences is that;
a.you should not harass people in spaces where people may feel vulnerable.
b. Feeling uncomfortable around a person does not automatically mean that that group should be excluded from the space.
c. Any predatory behaviour should be dealt with promptly and seriously.

Because women only spaces are about male violence not sexuality.

Women are far less likely to be violent.

It’s why lesbians are not an issue - because they are women - and we don’t let gay men in - because they are men.

Transwomen are just as likely to be violent as any other men.

Lesbians are just as likely not to be violent as any other women.

That’s it.

No transwomen should be in any women only spaces.

Hasselhoffsheadband · 23/03/2022 07:53

The idea that lesbian rights to access women's spaces is somehow conditional because they're less justified to be there than other women is homophobic.

Yes it's incredibly homophobic to say that lesbians being allowed in female spaces should be as conditional as males being allowed in. Lesbians are women, they arenjust as much women as any other woman.

Ereshkigalangcleg · 23/03/2022 07:53

Mixed sex spaces are more risky for women as well as violating our privacy and dignity. Because your personal experience of assault aside, males statistically commit 98-99% of sex crime. It's male pattern violence.

bellinisurge · 23/03/2022 07:53

Even more importantly, how can my teenage daughter, who is bombarded with messages that transwomen are women and therefore should be afforded the same assumption that they are safe to be around when vulnerable.

bellinisurge · 23/03/2022 07:50

Please explain how I can tell that an unknown transwomen (and, yes, they rarely "pass") is actually a transwomen who just wants to pee and not a sexual predator.

Ereshkigalangcleg · 23/03/2022 07:49

Why not lesbians from women's spaces?

Because lesbians are women, and women's spaces aren't "straight woman spaces". Lesbians have exactly the same right to use women's spaces as any other woman. I'm very sorry for your experience but most people don't want mixed sex spaces. Male people are the opposite sex, they do not have the right to use women's spaces.

The idea that lesbian rights to access women's spaces is somehow conditional because they're less justified to be there than other women is homophobic.

Hasselhoffsheadband · 23/03/2022 07:49

TW want to changed, or go pee.

So they can do it in the men's can't they? If a crime does occur then they can report it to the police. That's women are told isn't it, when they say they don't want males in their spaces? (In fact I think it's been said on this very thread!)

Clymene · 23/03/2022 07:47

Men - however they identify - commit NINETY EIGHT PERCENT of sexual assaults. They are responsible for nearly all violent crime.

Talking about the tiny number of violent women is pure whataboutery. Odd behaviour for a lesbian.

Ijustreallywantacat · 23/03/2022 07:46

Your school handled it badly. The difference is, you were no threat to girls or women.

How did the school know that? Lesbians are, purely statistically, a bigger threat to straight women than other straight women.
They genuinely and sincerely believed I was a threat to them. Their first action wasn't assault, it was complaining that I had asked one of them out despite not knowing if she liked girls (true!) and that I was staring at them getting changed. (Not true, though difficult to permanently affixed to the wall.)

TW want to changed, or go pee.

Theeyeballsinthefuckingsky · 23/03/2022 07:46

Ah I see I can cross predatory and violent lesbians off my bingo card too

Hasselhoffsheadband · 23/03/2022 07:45

Why not lesbians from women's spaces? The women who assaulted me felt threatened and uncomfortable around me. I had asked one of them out was the crime. Who KNOWS what I could have done next. Lesbians have definitely assaulted people before. There are lesbians in prison right now because they have been predatory.

This again?

98% of sexual crime is carried out by males. That is a huge, huge percentage. Yes, there is a very small number of women who are dangerous, but as a class, males are much much higher risk than females. Which is why we have certain sex segregsted provision, it's based on that risk assessment. Transwomen are in that high risk class. At what point do they come out of it?

Moodycow78 · 23/03/2022 07:42

@SevenWaystoLeave

Because trans people have always historically been part of gay spaces and part of the gay liberation movement.
If that were true that T+ would always have been there not added a couple years ago 🙄
Hasselhoffsheadband · 23/03/2022 07:42

@Ijustreallywantacat

"No, never". Never been in a situation with someone with a penis (known or unknown) and worried about your safety? Not sure I believe that.

In the context of the discussion I thought you meant transwomen. Whom I have never felt threatened by or uncomfortable around. Not when using the bathroom, not when changing in a locker room, not when sharing a twin room in a hotel.

Have I felt threatened by men with penises? Yes. We've all been there. I've also felt threatened by straight women with vaginas (I assume) when getting changed, as I stated above.

What is the difference between them? Nearly all still have a penis, a minority of those transwomen use their penis to harm others. How can you tell which ones are 'safe? How come you feel safe around transwomen but not around men? Do you have a cut off point for which transwomen you would feel safe around, ie. Do they have to be wearing a dress, a wig, have had breast implants, or is their declaration of womanhood simply enough for you to feel safe around them compared to men?