Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

LGB vs LGBTQI etc

518 replies

Whoistheexpert · 22/03/2022 20:04

Why was the T (and others) ever added to the LGB acronym?

The T (trans) is surely related to gender and not ones sexual orientation?

Am I missing something 😵‍💫

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Thread gallery
9
Whoistheexpert · 24/03/2022 21:11

@PenStation

I agree with your latest post *@Whoistheexpert*

I am old enough to campaign against Section 28. Gay, lesbian and bisexual people didn't disadvantage anyone else by campaigning for the rights to live their lives without prejudice, get support at school around their sexuality, marry the one they love and adopt children.

I'll defend the rights of disadvantaged people fiercely, but I won't be involved with a movement that seeks to advantage themselves by stamping on the rights of another disadvantaged group.

Yes - that is what it seems to be coming down to really, more fighting off mens entitlement to our bodies and now our minds and even our sex class.

It’s like a totalitarian patriarchy on steroids, with swathes of young people high on wokery and cancel culture.

It’s making me want Charlie Brooker to create a new episode of Black Mirror!

OP posts:
Whoistheexpert · 24/03/2022 20:59

[quote doublemonkey]This is the kind of crazy shit that is going on. Women and lesbians in particular getting discriminated against because someone doesn't like how they think..

[/quote] Good grief that is incredibly depressing.

It does illustrate the cancel culture / TRA wokery very well.

OP posts:
doublemonkey · 24/03/2022 20:26

This is the kind of crazy shit that is going on. Women and lesbians in particular getting discriminated against because someone doesn't like how they think..

PenStation · 24/03/2022 15:05

I agree with your latest post @Whoistheexpert

I am old enough to campaign against Section 28. Gay, lesbian and bisexual people didn't disadvantage anyone else by campaigning for the rights to live their lives without prejudice, get support at school around their sexuality, marry the one they love and adopt children.

I'll defend the rights of disadvantaged people fiercely, but I won't be involved with a movement that seeks to advantage themselves by stamping on the rights of another disadvantaged group.

Whoistheexpert · 24/03/2022 13:24

Indeed, I am not referring to myself as ‘cis’ - I am not a different category of woman. Woman IS the category.

OP posts:
Verv · 24/03/2022 12:56

@DuvetHugger

Why on earth do we have to describe ourselves as CIS women?
I don't and never will. I refuse to be a subset or a variant of my own sex class in order to show subservience to a lie.
DuvetHugger · 24/03/2022 12:43

Why on earth do we have to describe ourselves as CIS women?

Annette32123 · 24/03/2022 12:30

@nothingcomestonothing

And people who like Brie, don't be exclusionary!

I'm sorry Blush. I'm deeply ashamed, and I will educate myself, and do better. Of course all people who like brie are French, and I was wrong to imply otherwise.

Including Somerset Brie.

And anyone who likes scrumpy cider. Because that’s from Somerset too.

nothingcomestonothing · 24/03/2022 12:24

And people who like Brie, don't be exclusionary!

I'm sorry Blush. I'm deeply ashamed, and I will educate myself, and do better. Of course all people who like brie are French, and I was wrong to imply otherwise.

Annette32123 · 24/03/2022 12:07

I came out over 25 years ago and at the time was rather baffled by the T being in LGB spaces - but mostly the MtFs stayed in gay venues so I frequented lesbian spaces more. Transmen were never problematic in those spaces; no idea if they were also in gay venues. But those transwomen who did come into women only bars were intrusive and demanding, often laying guilt trips onto the women there about how vulnerable and in need of friendship they were and how awful their lives were.

Having just discovered lesbian spaces I was realising how much space men take up beyond their physical presence, in any place they occupy - and the same was true of transwomen in lesbian spaces. You could have been there for hours having a lovely time and within minutes of a transwoman arriving the atmosphere changed and they were demanding to be centred (overtly or covertly). At the time I was young and kind and felt bad at how many women would simply walk out when they arrived, but now I understand. And of course those spaces no longer exist, because they became more and more vocal and problematic until the lesbians stopped going there and the businesses went under.

I feel so sorry for young lesbians today.

mudgetastic · 24/03/2022 12:01

Begs the question about why women are so much more likely than men to have experienced trauma

mudgetastic · 24/03/2022 11:58

Are people bringing up the study that showed that ( post surgical , reggonised psychological disorder type ) transwomen brain scans showed evidence of trauma in their life , and because women are much more likely than men to have experienced trauma they also show evidence of that trauma in their brains at a greater rate than men hence the spurious suggestion that transwomen brains are like women

In fact transpeople brains were like both men and women brains where the people has experienced trauma

The link was the trauma and not the gender /sex

I Believe the authors had to issue a correction for clarity as it was being misrepresented so often

Annette32123 · 24/03/2022 11:57

@Ereshkigalangcleg

That's excellent, haven't seen that review. I still have concerns about relying on it due to its limitations and the fact that the population is likely to be a very different one now.
Yes it’s a useful unbiased summary.

Interesting data on transmen and not what I would have expected.

But clearly women only spaces are needed as much as even and all men and transmen and transwomen should respect that. No woman would disregard the safety of other women so if “transwomen are women”, they should prove it by staying out of women only spaces. That’s what a woman would do.

Whoistheexpert · 24/03/2022 11:57

@nothingcomestonothing

Wow, we're on ladybrains being proved by science now Hmm

Back to the OPs question - how do TQI++ belong with LGB? Why is it transphobic for LGB to have separate organisations, lobby for different for different things, when sexuality and identity are different things?

It's like me starting an organisation for French nationals living in the UK, and then adding people who would like to be French, people who are thinking of a holiday in France, and people with a French-sounding last name. And then being called phobic for not centring Italians.

Thanks for bringing it back to the original questions.

Putting the debate regarding women’s safety aside just for the sake of the focus of this post - it appears there is a wide range of LGB posters here who are concerned or simply disappointed by the centralising of T within their communities.

In contrast, those who are unbothered or even supportive of T do tend to be speaking more from personal or anecdotal experience and less concerned about the wider concerns many have around female erasure and the loss of single sex spaces.

For me personally, I find the constant focus on T quite overshadowing of LGB which is all about sexuality and frankly nothing to do gender identity - certainly not in todays world.

Being shamed into accepting that male sex individuals are now female sex individuals, even if they have male genitalia feels like being part the Emperors New Clothes.

OP posts:
Verv · 24/03/2022 11:36

As far as I am concerned, LGB are all the letters.
They are based on same sex attraction.

TQA is unrelated and imo, completely damaging.

Ereshkigalangcleg · 24/03/2022 11:06

That's excellent, haven't seen that review. I still have concerns about relying on it due to its limitations and the fact that the population is likely to be a very different one now.

Annette32123 · 24/03/2022 10:43

This is a useful review

mbmpolicy.files.wordpress.com/2021/04/mbm-briefing-on-dhjene-et-al.-april-2021-1.pdf

Ereshkigalangcleg · 24/03/2022 10:24

And people who like Brie, don't be exclusionary!

nothingcomestonothing · 24/03/2022 10:07

Wow, we're on ladybrains being proved by science now Hmm

Back to the OPs question - how do TQI++ belong with LGB? Why is it transphobic for LGB to have separate organisations, lobby for different for different things, when sexuality and identity are different things?

It's like me starting an organisation for French nationals living in the UK, and then adding people who would like to be French, people who are thinking of a holiday in France, and people with a French-sounding last name. And then being called phobic for not centring Italians.

Cheeserton · 24/03/2022 09:30

Several gay friends reject the constant association with the T. They say they just don't identify with it and no, the issues aren't the same.

lifeturnsonadime · 24/03/2022 09:13

And yes of course people from all demographics commit violent crime but 98 % of sexual assault is committed by males. There is absolutely no good reason that we should give up single sex spaces on the basis that 2% of such crimes are committed by women.

There is no logic to arguments that men who identify as women are less likely to offend.

Women should not have to take a risk. This is not to mention the fact that certain sectors of women are excluded by the inclusion of males for religious or other reasons.

PenStation · 24/03/2022 09:10

I agree @lifeturnsonadime

It’s also awful for the trans community members who support proper safeguarding to be lumped together with these entitled misogynists who call themselves trans activists.

Whatsnewpussyhat · 24/03/2022 09:08

Back to the lady brain argument now?
A transwomen's brain cells will all contain male DNA. As will every other cell in their body.

Wishful thinking doesn't alter ones sexed body.

lifeturnsonadime · 24/03/2022 09:03

God this thread is depressing.

Women wanting to exclude males from single sex spaces to ensure safety and dignity are not transphobic.

It's no wonder misogynists object to threads such as the one FWR pointing out that that people are harmed by men who claim to be women. Women actually being harmed are just collateral damage. NOT ONE SINGLE incident should have happened in a safe space if the law were being upheld.

I'm sick of the male entitlement. These men might want to be women, some might think they are women but they sure as hell don't like or respect us. The ones that do know that this is not good enough.

RinklyRomaine · 24/03/2022 07:26

@Boredoutmymind

Maybe this will shut up the transphobic people on here, but I doubt it because they are so full of hate. www.sciencedaily.com/releases/2018/05/180524112351.html There was a study before where trans brains were compared to the brains of the bio sex post mortem. It found that trans women brains was the same as bio female brains and transmen brain was the same as bio male brains.

But some people are so full of hate they don't see that trans people are human and have to endure so much.
Children are not given gender reassignment surgery on the NHS. Children are not given replacement hormone therapy on the NHS. You have to be 18 to receive them.
You have to go through years of mental health assessments and other tests before you can have surgery or hormones.

Really! So there is, at last, a medical method to physically diagnose trans people? So we can check whether potential Karen Whites can be in womens prisons and hospital wards? Whether Irish surgeons should be making millions out of slicing the breasts off 13 year old girls? Hurrah! Why on EARTH is this not being done? Oh....