Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Can't afford to fix fence

113 replies

mommaneedssleep · 22/03/2022 19:50

Been going through a tough time financially recently (like many people!). Our electricity bill has more than doubled, nursery and school club have both put their prices up. Basically we are being stretched further than we can manage. We've been trying to cut down where we can and have done some drastic measures to bring bills down such as getting rid of one car ect.
Our fence broke in the bad storms we had in February, we live in a long line of Victorian terraced houses and the fence that has broken is our responsibility. With everything else currently going on we just can't afford to get it iced. It requires 2 new fence panels and 3 of the posts. Neighbour has come round tonight asking when we are getting it fixed. I explained that at the moment we aren't able to but will try to do it over the summer. They said that as the weather is getting nicer they now need to paint their side and get their trellises planted ect so need it doing asap.
I understand that it must be annoying for them, but I really can't afford to do it at the moment. To be clear there is no gap or fallen fences ect, the fence is still standing but is just bowed (if that's the right word??) to one side.

OP posts:
Theimpossiblegirl · 22/03/2022 20:43

It might be worth asking your local church or men's shed group if they have anyone that could help. Not for your neighbours, for you. I would probably be using old doors just to piss them off.

EvilPea · 22/03/2022 20:36

@TibetanTerrah

Their attitude would seriously piss me off. Id be tempted to drop a note saying you will do it when you can but as they kindly pointed out, it is your fence so they are not permitted to paint it or attach anything to it. But they are of course welcome to put up their own fence and do as they please with it Wink
This is the attitude I’d have to be honest.

I rent and our neighbour moans and moans and moans about our fence Everytime I see her. I hide when i can. She does this “oh my god, look at that fence” in this dramatic way, like it’s a tragedy.

One of the panels blew down in the storms. We could have called the landlord, had them come round, scratch their heads, drunk our tea. Wait in for their workman to, come round, scratch their heads, drink our tea before coming back the next day to repair it.

Or, we could have fixed it ourselves. because she had moaned and moaned (and I’m really petty) we didn’t buy a new one, we repaired it ourselves just because we knew it would annoy her more.

CremeEggThief · 22/03/2022 20:36

Just stay calm and firm but in a polite way, as you have been doing. If you haven't got the money there's nothing they can do, simple as that.

Floralnomad · 22/03/2022 20:36

If they ask again just tell them it’s a low priority for you at present and will get done at some point in the future . Our neighbour wants us to replace a fence , it’s old but was perfectly ok until their dog started chewing great chunks out of it , we just patch as necessary as I have absolutely no intention of paying £thousands for their dog to ruin it .

FangsForTheMemory · 22/03/2022 20:34

I would tell them you're actually planning to plant a hedge as it's better for the environment and that if they specifically want a fence, they can put it in themselves.

Sparkle123r · 22/03/2022 20:32

As has been said already, I would be narked if a neighbour demanded a fence be fixed that is not their responsibility. I can understand a little if there was no fence at all, but you've explained that is not the case.

I'd let them know next time you see them that it's low priority and that when it is fixed they do not have permission to paint or fix anything to your fence.

EvilPea · 22/03/2022 20:31

@Curioushorse

I realise you've said money is tight....

....but fencing is one of those weird things in life where doing it yourself is wildly, wildly cheaper. The same thing happened with us a few years ago, and we simply couldn't afford it. However, we watched a clip on wickes (I think it was). And, honestly, it wasn't that hard- and I'm an absolute idiot. I feel like it came to a couple of hundred pounds instead of thousands. It might be cheaper because your fence panels might be reusable- it might just be the posts you need to replace.

This ^ More so if you have the fence posts they just slide into.

However. First problem most people have, is getting one. Not many cars fit a 6ft fence in.

TibetanTerrah · 22/03/2022 20:28

Their attitude would seriously piss me off. Id be tempted to drop a note saying you will do it when you can but as they kindly pointed out, it is your fence so they are not permitted to paint it or attach anything to it. But they are of course welcome to put up their own fence and do as they please with it Wink

Pissyduck · 22/03/2022 20:27

Tell them that you don't know when you will have the money to do it, so if they are that bothered about putting up trellises they will need to fix the fence themselves.

Curioushorse · 22/03/2022 20:24

I realise you've said money is tight....

....but fencing is one of those weird things in life where doing it yourself is wildly, wildly cheaper. The same thing happened with us a few years ago, and we simply couldn't afford it. However, we watched a clip on wickes (I think it was). And, honestly, it wasn't that hard- and I'm an absolute idiot. I feel like it came to a couple of hundred pounds instead of thousands. It might be cheaper because your fence panels might be reusable- it might just be the posts you need to replace.

HandlebarLadyTash · 22/03/2022 20:22

Make it clear that attaching trellis to your fence will be a big NO.

Tohaveandtohold · 22/03/2022 20:21

It’s your fence, you don’t have to fix it or let’s just say, you can fix it whenever it’s convenient.
And their excuse of wanting to paint your fence or attach trellis, if they are insisting it’s your fence and your responsibility then they have no right to paint or attach anything to it. Because if the things they do cause another damage to it, you’ll be responsible for fixing it. Tell them to buzz off

beautifullymad · 22/03/2022 20:21

@TheFlis12345

Unless there is a specific covenant you are not obligated to have a fence at all! And if you have one they have no legal right to paint it or attach trellis or anything else to it. If they are so bothered about it they can put a new fence up their side of the boundary.
This
IncompleteSenten · 22/03/2022 20:13

Stay firm.
I cannot afford it. I will be doing it if and when I can but my children have this nasty habit of needing food and they are a bit more important than a fence.

Firawla · 22/03/2022 20:12

It’s your fence, so you can decide whenever to sort it out. The husband coming round with the deeds to show they won’t be paying, yet demanding you sort it out asap would get my back up so I would purposely leave it longer.
I had similar with one of my neighbours, it is ridiculous - people can’t demand of you to spend your money just for their own whims. They either leave it and let you sort it on your own time and own way or they volunteer to pay it themselves if they are that bothered

Grapewrath · 22/03/2022 20:12

Honestly tell them to jog on, you aren’t responsible for their garden projects.

GabriellaMontez · 22/03/2022 20:12

clearly shows that fence is our responsibility so they weren't willing to pay anything.

Then it isn't theirs to paint or attach things to!

OK. So they're CF. As a pp said you'll have to be very firm. Don't give a date. Don't apologise.

Vallmo47 · 22/03/2022 20:10

We had a similar issue recently OP and I completely understand. In our case, our next door neighbour insisted he wanted to go half with us on cost (which is kind as it’s legally our side that we own). I took his word for it, he got a quote for £1800 (feather panels, the whole shebang). We couldn’t afford it and explained as much. He’s now in a right huff with us because we HAD to go for a cheaper option and refused to pay towards it. Fine as our fence, but he can’t get shitty with us for money that we didn’t have.
When money isn’t there, what on earth can you do.

Good luck, I feel your pain. Ours had completely come down though so we had to do something quickly. Glad that’s not the case for you.

Blimecory · 22/03/2022 20:08

If it’s your fence, not only can they not attach trellis or anything to it, they can’t paint it either - because it’s yours.

Whitefire · 22/03/2022 20:07

It took us about 8 weeks to get a fencer - I think he squeezed us in in the end as it was a relatively small job, as originally he said 12 weeks. I got it sorted after storm 1, will have been longer I guess for those after the next one's.

mommaneedssleep · 22/03/2022 20:06

@GabriellaMontez

Are they suggesting you share the cost?

Ignore them, you're under no obligation to fix it.

I did originally suggest we get a quote and jointly fix it as I wasn't sure whose responsibility it was and that is what we did with the neighbours on the other side when it broke last year. With that one there was never any debate about who paid we both just agreed to share it as we both use the fence. However when I suggested this her DH instantly came round with a copy of the deeds stating that they didn't need to pay anything as it clearly shows that fence is our responsibility so they weren't willing to pay anything. Which is fair enough but it's put my back up a bit that now they are demanding it is done so they can use it
OP posts:
carefullycourageous · 22/03/2022 20:05

You need to clarify who owns the fence and who is responsible for paying for the repairs - if it is your fence, you can usually do as you wish and as stated above the neighbour should not attach their trellis to the fence.

Do not be a doormat!

Whitefire · 22/03/2022 20:03

Fencing is fairly difficult to get hold of at the moment, it was difficult enough prior to the storms.

Leftbutcameback · 22/03/2022 20:03

Insurance basically never covers fences. Which is annoying. Around our way after the storms there is no fencing available and everyone is booked up for ages so you wouldn't be able to do it even if you could afford it. We're in a very similar situation but it's a joint fence.

Grapewrath · 22/03/2022 20:02

Take no notice. Tell them firmly you will fixit when you can. You have no obligation to do so and why should you put yourself in difficultly for their trellis ffs.