Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Can't afford to fix fence

113 replies

mommaneedssleep · 22/03/2022 19:50

Been going through a tough time financially recently (like many people!). Our electricity bill has more than doubled, nursery and school club have both put their prices up. Basically we are being stretched further than we can manage. We've been trying to cut down where we can and have done some drastic measures to bring bills down such as getting rid of one car ect.
Our fence broke in the bad storms we had in February, we live in a long line of Victorian terraced houses and the fence that has broken is our responsibility. With everything else currently going on we just can't afford to get it iced. It requires 2 new fence panels and 3 of the posts. Neighbour has come round tonight asking when we are getting it fixed. I explained that at the moment we aren't able to but will try to do it over the summer. They said that as the weather is getting nicer they now need to paint their side and get their trellises planted ect so need it doing asap.
I understand that it must be annoying for them, but I really can't afford to do it at the moment. To be clear there is no gap or fallen fences ect, the fence is still standing but is just bowed (if that's the right word??) to one side.

OP posts:
AlecTrevelyan006 · 22/03/2022 22:25

@Blimecory

If it’s your fence, not only can they not attach trellis or anything to it, they can’t paint it either - because it’s yours.
This - make sure to tell them when you do put up your fence they can’t paint it
Againstmachine · 22/03/2022 22:25

I'd be weary of neighbours putting up another fence on their own land as some have recommended. Moving the boundary line can cause havoc when selling a property especially if the deeds are not amended and the fence is not erected on the original boundary division.

Anyone can out up a fence as long as it's not in your boundary it doesn't matter.

Philisophigal · 22/03/2022 22:17

This reply has been deleted

This has been withdrawn at the user's request.

longtompot · 22/03/2022 22:09

Repair g fence aside, your neighbour is being a cf thinking they can paint and attach things to your fence on their side! Have they even asked you if they can do this, or just told you?

"The most important part of the garden fence law is regarding who can change or paint an existing fence.[3] The answer is clear – only the fence’s owner is permitted to alter the fence in any way. While this may seem counterintuitive, you are not allowed to paint or stain the side of the fence that faces your garden without prior permission. You are also forbidden from allowing climbing plants to grow upon it without permission, as they can cause damage to the structure."

From here www.gardenbenches.com/blog/common-laws-around-trees-and-garden-boundaries/

If they want to do that then they can erect their own fence and paint and trellis away to their heart's content.

user1471538283 · 22/03/2022 21:57

I would point out to them that you will do it when you are able to. If they dont like that I would tell them that you are not obligated to have a fence at all, only a boundary, which could be a piece of string.

Change123today · 22/03/2022 21:53

We have recently been in this situation! We have a dog & they have a nervous 4 year old. So I was a little concerned if the wonky fence would then eventually go over & I wouldn’t want my dog to scare their daughter. I’m also aware that getting anyone in & the cost!! Together we fixed it very temporarily - offered to split the cost when it was time. They have managed to find a cheap way of doing it - short concrete post and existing post & panels stay. It’s worked - may not look great with a short post but it safe! & was a lot cheaper than a whole new fence!! Maybe look at other cheaper options?
I know it’s hard at the moment financially & getting trades people even in!

SixteenTwelve · 22/03/2022 21:35

Our fences totally shat the bed in storm Eunice. We have a gap on the right side where the whole panel just blew into next door’s garden and the rest of them are leaning and getting worse. All of the fences are ours because the house surrounding were built several years after our house. It is going to cost £4.5k to fix it and a bit of work on the retaining wall which has seen better days. We can afford it but I have had to say goodbye to my new bathroom I wanted this year.

Builders etc are really busy fixing everyone’s fences/roofs at the moment so even though we got our quote straight away we aren’t booked in until the 9th April.

YANBU

saleorbouy · 22/03/2022 21:25

I'd be weary of neighbours putting up another fence on their own land as some have recommended. Moving the boundary line can cause havoc when selling a property especially if the deeds are not amended and the fence is not erected on the original boundary division.
As a scenario, moaning neighbour erects fence on their property and puts up trellis but it is not legally recorded. OP removes their fences as it dilapidates. Over the years the boundary between the properties naturally moves to the new fence erected and owned by the neighbour. OP wants to sell but boundary line is not correct on the drawings, they also state that OP legally owns fence, not the neighbour. House sale flounders as boundary, land and ownership are not clearly defined. Solicitors make lots of money as boundary and fence ownership are contested.
Please ensure any boundary and fence, wall hedge ownership are correctly recorded.

whynotwhatknot · 22/03/2022 21:11

@totallybonafido

We just had exactly this, the neighbours were really peeing me off asking me about it constantly. Fortunately we could afford to fix it, and I'm glad it's done so that I don't have to see them casting their judgmental looks at me through the gap all the time. We both work full time and we have 2 kids - not top of my list really! Was tempted to just put a bit of string up to wind them up Grin. It took over a month to get anyone to even look at it and 3 people stood me up to even come and quote Angry
You know you didnt have to do anything
whynotwhatknot · 22/03/2022 21:09

Been through this its your fence you dont even have to hve one legally-if they want to paint a fenc tell them to put their own one up my neighbour did

you can take the whole thing down and nothing they can do

minieasteregg · 22/03/2022 21:03

Urgh my old neighbour died and their son came and did this to us because he wanted to sell his house he told us we were ruining his chances of a sale (the house was now empty). The fence had kept falling down because animals kept jumping over it so I'd given up and I'd never seen anyone in the garden so was waiting until the summer to sort it.

You don't have to put a fence up.
In the end I put a chair facing the gap and left it. Immature I know but he was annoying me because he was really rude about it and it was all to benefit him hurrying up the sale, when I finally did it, the house didn't sell for months anyway.

totallybonafido · 22/03/2022 21:00

We just had exactly this, the neighbours were really peeing me off asking me about it constantly. Fortunately we could afford to fix it, and I'm glad it's done so that I don't have to see them casting their judgmental looks at me through the gap all the time. We both work full time and we have 2 kids - not top of my list really! Was tempted to just put a bit of string up to wind them up Grin. It took over a month to get anyone to even look at it and 3 people stood me up to even come and quote Angry

Katya213 · 22/03/2022 20:58

If it bothers them so much, let them fix it.

TiddleTaddleTat · 22/03/2022 20:58

If you do end up budgeting to do this yourself I’ve found wickes best for this and will deliver. Still not cheap (ours is £500 for 5 panels, 6 posts, gravel boards and postcrete inc delivery) but much cheaper than getting fencers in.

SafelySoftly · 22/03/2022 20:58

Do you need to mend the whole thing, if it’s just a bit leaning can’t you just prop it up with some wood?

BulletTrain · 22/03/2022 20:53

Just repeat that you will fix it when able, fencers are booked up for weeks anyway, and if they really want one to paint and hang shit on they can put their own in on their side.

godmum56 · 22/03/2022 20:51

trellis and paint???????? cheeky sod!

FlamingoQueen · 22/03/2022 20:51

It is your fence so it’s up to you when you fix it. If they want it done sooner, they can pay! Decent neighbours would offer to pay half.

godmum56 · 22/03/2022 20:50

@TheFlis12345

Unless there is a specific covenant you are not obligated to have a fence at all! And if you have one they have no legal right to paint it or attach trellis or anything else to it. If they are so bothered about it they can put a new fence up their side of the boundary.
this absolutely. If the fence is actually dangerous and someone might be injured then you may HAVE to do something, but you can quite legitimately just remove what is unsafe and leave a gap. If there are animals or children then its the responsibility of the owner/keeper to keep them where they should be but unless there is a covenant in your deeds then you don't have to fence. Also (there are covenants in my deeds) even if there is a covenant, not just anyone can enforce it, it has to be the person who set up the covenant or their agent....so eg if the builder set up the covenant and they have gone out of business and not named an agent then no one can enforce it.
Againstmachine · 22/03/2022 20:48

Unless your covenant says you need a fence and mainly once the developer has left aren't enforceable, you can actually signify the boundary with a piece of string of you wish.

rwalker · 22/03/2022 20:48

Tell them you are doing without a fence and will be taking it down shortly

LightSpeeds · 22/03/2022 20:48

I'm pretty sure that, by law, there doesn't need to be a fence or any other thing separating gardens - so you do not have to fix the fence.

If they want a nice fence, they're entitled to erect their own fence on their own property!

I fell out with my neighbours at the back because they wanted the fence replaced with something better and wanted me to pay half. They said 'our dog keeps getting in your garden' (through a gap) but it's their responsibility to keep it off my property, not mine.

They'd already made me pay a lot of money to cut down a tree, weren't the slightest bit grateful and thought I had a never ending pot of money for all their garden whims! Hmm

LookMoreCloselier · 22/03/2022 20:48

If its just bowed over can you fix it yourself? Ours completely blew over and we needed 2 new posts but the panels could be reused.

OnlyFoolsnMothers · 22/03/2022 20:46

Oh well if they’re in a rush they can fix it- we don’t have the finances at the moment, have you heard of the cost of living crisis? Shut them up with that.

WiddlinDiddling · 22/03/2022 20:44

Yup id be round to thank them very kindly for putting you in the picture as to whose fence it is. As you are the sole owner of the fence, you'll be replacing the lot with a hedge - and as you own the remaining fence, they need to take down their trellis ASAP and stop painting it.