Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Can't afford to fix fence

113 replies

mommaneedssleep · 22/03/2022 19:50

Been going through a tough time financially recently (like many people!). Our electricity bill has more than doubled, nursery and school club have both put their prices up. Basically we are being stretched further than we can manage. We've been trying to cut down where we can and have done some drastic measures to bring bills down such as getting rid of one car ect.
Our fence broke in the bad storms we had in February, we live in a long line of Victorian terraced houses and the fence that has broken is our responsibility. With everything else currently going on we just can't afford to get it iced. It requires 2 new fence panels and 3 of the posts. Neighbour has come round tonight asking when we are getting it fixed. I explained that at the moment we aren't able to but will try to do it over the summer. They said that as the weather is getting nicer they now need to paint their side and get their trellises planted ect so need it doing asap.
I understand that it must be annoying for them, but I really can't afford to do it at the moment. To be clear there is no gap or fallen fences ect, the fence is still standing but is just bowed (if that's the right word??) to one side.

OP posts:
PaperTyger · 23/03/2022 07:33

I would use the painting and trellis as leverage.

Be naive and innocent, say whilst you're fence actually don't need to put one up and Also it's criminal damage to paint it etc.
However you will let them paint it and put trellis up if they can wait polity or free to chip in

MayMorris · 23/03/2022 07:32

@TiddleTaddleTat

If you do end up budgeting to do this yourself I’ve found wickes best for this and will deliver. Still not cheap (ours is £500 for 5 panels, 6 posts, gravel boards and postcrete inc delivery) but much cheaper than getting fencers in.
Bloody hell, we just had 10 panels , concrete posts and concrete gravel posts replaced. Cost was double that. Including labour at a full day 2 blokes. I thought that was really high price due to stupid material prices. It was clearly a bargin 🤣🤣🥳 We got local timber guys to do that make their own panels so maybe that’s why…
gazprom · 23/03/2022 07:29

Are the posts intact, and is it just the lapped panels. You can easily get lap panels in Wickes for not much money and as long as you have another helper and can gain access to their garden (if it's a tricky access point) you can easily slot in (well 'easily' is moot, it can be a bugger) but is well inside the capabilities of most people and doesn't need specialist tools. If it is the posts, you can dig around the base and mix sand and cement or use Postfix products (google them to see which one). If there are holes anywhere you could even attach some feather edge board as a temporary fix.

www.wickes.co.uk/Wickes-Dip-Treated-Overlap-Fence-Panel---6-x-6ft/p/540053?gclid=CjwKCAjwiuuRBhBvEiwAFXKaNO2f9bNudfDRT1ISAyhpQejDVrPjx-sg7lfqE_ZF63hjSaO26gfEQxoCjSYQAvD_BwE&gclsrc=aw.ds

www.toolstation.com/drive-in-repair-spike/p80996?store=JQ&utm_source=googleshopping&utm_medium=feed&utm_campaign=googleshoppingfeed&mkwid=_dc&pcrid=560261087208&pkw=&pmt=&gclid=CjwKCAjwiuuRBhBvEiwAFXKaNOxBb01OndAG9V0_H6bbckyCmijNhapZi6VqilZawKrmaOf0uXlHlRoC-SoQAvD_BwE&gclsrc=aw.ds

MrsWinters · 23/03/2022 07:26

Others are right. Unless there’s something in the covenants attached to the property you don’t have to replace it at all. You can also refuse to allow them to paint it etc.
The only thing I would add- is you don’t have to have it fixed provided it’s isn’t dangerous- do if there are some collapsed or overhanging panels you might want to remove them entirely.

Personally, I’d remove it completely, sit tight and hope they knuckle under a pay. If they do- the new fence needs to be on their side- not the boundary line.

MayMorris · 23/03/2022 07:25

@Whitefire

It took us about 8 weeks to get a fencer - I think he squeezed us in in the end as it was a relatively small job, as originally he said 12 weeks. I got it sorted after storm 1, will have been longer I guess for those after the next one's.
This. We had our fence finally mended yesterday. It’s taken 3 months for the contractors due to weather, materials etc and his work backlog due to previous weather and material availability

Plus the cost was frightening…he showed us on our outer how the cost per panel (concrete posts and wall boards) has gone up 50% in last 12 months

Tell your neighbours that unless it is actually down that you are not paying the stupid prices just now and you can’t just get someone to come round

Can you/they insert some sort of posts on relevant side to stop it bowing?

BornBlonde · 23/03/2022 07:16

@ASaucerfulOfSecrets

I remember a tale on a neighbourhood forum of a man who had twats for neighbours. He installed a lovely new fence at considerable expense and the following day the neighbour came out and painted ‘his side’ of it with a fence stain that then leeched through into fence owners side looking extremely unsightly.

‘‘Twas a glorious moment when fence owner lifted and rotated every panel so that newly stained side faced him.

So should you replace the fence I’d advise to wait until the NDN has painted it and turn the bugger round 😂

@ASaucerfulOfSecrets

This is brilliant!

RantyAunty · 23/03/2022 07:16

If the fence isn't required, I would just remove that part completely until you can afford to fix it.

They complain to you. Just say you've decided not to replace it.

Problem solved.

chaosrabbitland · 23/03/2022 07:10

my neighbours fence went over at least over a year ago and what with a huge loss to her family plus lack of money i assume the panel is still missing , shes put up a metal gate thing in place of it , but it doesnt bother me in the slightest , i mean it would be nice if she replaced it , but iv got used to it not being there

id just ignore it and next time he comes around knocking asking when its getting done , just briskly reply sorry we just dont have the money . it will get done when we can afford it , if he wants to get all shirty then just point out to him the facts that have already been laid out in all these replys , if they are that desperate they will have to pay themselves

TheRealityCheque · 23/03/2022 07:00

Write them a letter (and keep a copy) stating that you can't afford it at the moment AND that when you do install one you do not give permission for either painting or anything to be attached to it.

You will however be happy for them to erect a fence, that they own, should they wish to do this.

WutheringHeights66 · 23/03/2022 06:56

@ASaucerfulOfSecrets

I remember a tale on a neighbourhood forum of a man who had twats for neighbours. He installed a lovely new fence at considerable expense and the following day the neighbour came out and painted ‘his side’ of it with a fence stain that then leeched through into fence owners side looking extremely unsightly.

‘‘Twas a glorious moment when fence owner lifted and rotated every panel so that newly stained side faced him.

So should you replace the fence I’d advise to wait until the NDN has painted it and turn the bugger round 😂

That is brilliant 🤩
DobbyTheHouseElk · 23/03/2022 06:54

I had a similar issue with my Victorian terrace. I had a fence up half way along the garden at the front because I had nasty neighbours and it gave me privacy as they hurled abuse at me. (They were alcoholics)

When they left I didn’t take the half fence down. Then a new neighbour moved in and asked me to repair my fence as it was “missing” the end panel and their dog could escape.

I said that the fence was only ever two sections long and if they wanted to keep their dog in to build a fence. They told me it was my responsibility.

So I took the fence down completely. They soon put up a fence!!! Problem solved.

Tulipomania · 23/03/2022 06:53

OP, fencers are extremely busy at the moment.

We can't get ours fixed until July!

EveningOverRooftops · 23/03/2022 06:43

@Cakesnbiscuit

I’m petty, even when you have the money I wouldn’t fix it. I would wait a few more months just to annoy them. Technically you didn’t state which summer? And tradesman are hard to come by.
And cost of wood is through the roof too so it’s going to take a while for that cost to come down as well
foamflower · 23/03/2022 06:42

Put some chain link fence up yourself like our neighbours have done!

EveningOverRooftops · 23/03/2022 06:42

OP are the fence panels OK? As in could they be fixed to new posts?
Mug so I’d just replace the posts and reattach the panels and fuck em if they complain it looks tatty.

TigerLilyTail · 23/03/2022 06:39

You could put up some tarpaulin or bamboo screening if there is a hole. Just so you don't have to look at each other all summer.

Bunnycat101 · 23/03/2022 06:35

It depends on the convenants as to whether you need to maintain a border. If there are no gaps the I wouldn’t rush but if there were whole panels down and no border id prioritise it more. They are being very cheeky to assume they can paint the fence/attach trellis.

mommaneedssleep · 23/03/2022 06:33

@Cakesnbiscuit

I’m petty, even when you have the money I wouldn’t fix it. I would wait a few more months just to annoy them. Technically you didn’t state which summer? And tradesman are hard to come by.
Yeh this is how I'm feeling at the moment! If they hadn't have said about replacing it quickly just so they can paint it I wouldn't have been as bothered but they have put my back up now.
OP posts:
Cakesnbiscuit · 23/03/2022 06:27

I’m petty, even when you have the money I wouldn’t fix it. I would wait a few more months just to annoy them. Technically you didn’t state which summer? And tradesman are hard to come by.

Raindancer411 · 23/03/2022 06:15

Do it when you are ready, if they come knocking again, politely say they are free to put a fence up within their boundary and paint and attach what they want to it. If you replace it you will need to say as it is your property, they are not allowed to paint or fix any trellis to it as if this damages if, they will be liable.

mommaneedssleep · 23/03/2022 05:49

@ASaucerfulOfSecrets

I remember a tale on a neighbourhood forum of a man who had twats for neighbours. He installed a lovely new fence at considerable expense and the following day the neighbour came out and painted ‘his side’ of it with a fence stain that then leeched through into fence owners side looking extremely unsightly.

‘‘Twas a glorious moment when fence owner lifted and rotated every panel so that newly stained side faced him.

So should you replace the fence I’d advise to wait until the NDN has painted it and turn the bugger round 😂

I love this suggestion! 😂
OP posts:
godmum56 · 22/03/2022 22:59

@saleorbouy

Againstmachine

I'd be weary of neighbours putting up another fence on their own land as some have recommended. Moving the boundary line can cause havoc when selling a property especially if the deeds are not amended and the fence is not erected on the original boundary division.

"Anyone can out up a fence as long as it's not in your boundary it doesn't matter."

Not disputing that anyone can erect a fence on their land, I'm pointing out that if it's on or new a boundary and not clearly defined and recorded it can cause disputes and issues when the "original" owners move on and clear definition of the boundary is required. During these disputes the deeds will be used and if they don't match this can cause protracted solicitor battles which cost time and money during conveyancing. It can put purchasers off.

if they put it on their land (which is all they can do) then they will lose land and the neighbour will gain!
saleorbouy · 22/03/2022 22:50

new = near

ASaucerfulOfSecrets · 22/03/2022 22:50

I remember a tale on a neighbourhood forum of a man who had twats for neighbours. He installed a lovely new fence at considerable expense and the following day the neighbour came out and painted ‘his side’ of it with a fence stain that then leeched through into fence owners side looking extremely unsightly.

‘‘Twas a glorious moment when fence owner lifted and rotated every panel so that newly stained side faced him.

So should you replace the fence I’d advise to wait until the NDN has painted it and turn the bugger round 😂

saleorbouy · 22/03/2022 22:49

Againstmachine

I'd be weary of neighbours putting up another fence on their own land as some have recommended. Moving the boundary line can cause havoc when selling a property especially if the deeds are not amended and the fence is not erected on the original boundary division.

"Anyone can out up a fence as long as it's not in your boundary it doesn't matter."

Not disputing that anyone can erect a fence on their land, I'm pointing out that if it's on or new a boundary and not clearly defined and recorded it can cause disputes and issues when the "original" owners move on and clear definition of the boundary is required. During these disputes the deeds will be used and if they don't match this can cause protracted solicitor battles which cost time and money during conveyancing. It can put purchasers off.